Rating: plus 2 on a scale of minus 15 to plus 5.
Before I begin I need to visit the YouTube. This made possible by Doctor Who/They Break My Heart, NCMI, The New Enlightenment with Ashley, Munecat, Mia Mulder, Puddles Pity Party, Silicon Curtain, Lily Simpson, Terrible Writing Advice, Girls Rock Asia, JohnTheDuncan, Kyiv Independent, The Ritual Kitchen with Laura, Kat Blacque, A Lil Bit Mads, The MechWest Show, Reads With Rachel,
Grace McGuire, Just in Time Worldbuilding, Wes O'Donnell, Cappy Army, Ship Happens, Northern Narrowboaters, Dr Fatima, Dominic Noble, JuLingo, Linguoer Mechanic, Belinda Strnad, Kazachka, Annamarie Forcino, Bitchuation Room, Belle of the Ranch, Welcome to Ukraine, A Sunny Book Nook, The Cosy Creative, RFU News,
Anthony Gramuglia, Ministry of Miniatures, Horses, Matriarchetype, One Drum One Stick, Dungeons and Discourse, Hoots, Raw News and Politics, According to Alina, Hetty and the Jazzalato Band, Anna from Ukraine, Delamer, Bluedotdweller, Octopus Lady, Bobbing Along, Gutsick Gibbon, Ben G Thomas, Megalithhunter, Planarwalker, May,
Engineering with Rosie, Chris and Shell, Ben and Emily, ThePrimeChronus, Russian Media Monitor, RevolutionarythOt, LuckyBlackCat, History with Kayleigh, Miniminuteman, League of STEAM, Hat Historian, Evie Lupine, Shannon Makes, Abby Cox, Bernadette Banner, Xiran Jay Zhao, Unlearning Economics, Cruising Alba, AllShorts, NFKRZ, Cruising the Cut, Wednesday -Paint it Black, Philosophy Tube, Gary's Economics.
I recently saw a member of the Village Idiot Party, who whilst insulting an essayist, complain to her that I list other trans creators. The Snowflake (ill-mannered, useless US baby-man) epidemic continues. A Trigger Warning is needed.
The channels which I list include archaeologist, lesbian, Canadian, military historian, science educator, Canadian, cis, older, linguist, miniatures builder, cosplayer, asexual, blond, sewist, farmer, economist, trans, psychologist, socialist, Norwegian, boater, intersex, physicist, redhaired, queer, WOC, model painter, musician, het, marine biologist, paleontologist, tall, architect, asexual, Swedish, fashion historian, engineer and other creators known as Women.
Other channels almost as threatening include pensioner, other LGBTQI+, logician, Ugandan, anarchist, younger, primatologist, philosopher, ginger, neurodivergent, other fashion historian, military boardgamer, mathematician, Ukrainian, wood worker, other BIPOC, miniature landscape builder, reenactor, chemist, archaeologist, game historian, tailor, political commentator, German, communist, anthropologist, wood worker and other creators known (outside the US) as Human Beings.
Should the voices persist, seek emergency pastoral counselling and/or repeat several times daily "Today do not be a bellend" and/or develop a new skill, such as reading.
My feelings towards the brain dead, are similar to that of the 13 Ukrainian marines defending Snake Island, when their surrender was demanded. Their famous response was "Russian warship, go f@ck yourself". Glory to Ukraine. Glory to the Heroes. Crimea is Ukraine.
I originally wrote that this was a good book. The writer tells that he put in a lot of research. Keeping any time travel story straight is a challenge. I love Doctor Who but having a clear timeline free of contradictions is not a strong point of the programme. This writer does a good job writing multiple time loops and presents them clearly enough that it was no trouble following the story.
The characters are clear and act in character. There are not any superpower granting artefacts. The main character considering the mundane uses of his discovery in his head for a few moments was realistic. It is what a real person would do and then back to the reasons for his being in the altered reality. Those touches, the odd relationships and other real world phenomenon generated a realistic backdrop.
The effects of science on characters were worth following. It was fun to be caught up in a story even when I did not fully understand the underpinning.
I enjoyed the representation of women as human beings, with a variety of life experiences that make them relatable individuals. The characters in general are not the quickest, most moral or even decisive but they all seem to do the best that they can. There are clues that not all the villains have been identified or are human.
Well crafted, well plotted (even before I considered time travel challenges), good characters (well described, some well developed), scenes described well enough that they seemed to me realistic. The book generally felt well researched.
I do not remember the book but I read it several years ago. The hundreds of Kindle loans were so badly written that they probably have overwritten my memory of a number of titles.
Consider treating this as a hostile site. 🤔
Goodreads discourse does not exist. As example, this last review was a short one of Powers of the Earth written by Travis Corcoran.
He self-described as libertarian (now anarcho capitalist without millions), veteran, advocate for the return of chattel slavery (popular opinion in the US with prison labour being supplemented by new forced labour prisons for the homeless, van, RV residents without outrage), employee of an unnamed US agency and admirer of Putin (popular US stance among the deluded working class and silly billionaire).
My communist judgement was that the book's glorification of the overthrow of the US government by a newly rich twat with the aid of the military in order that he not pay taxes, while a popular Kindle trope was dangerous, unhealthy and now prophetic.
This opinion incensed the writer and six fellow patriots, who spent pages and most of a year demanding my engagement with increasingly anti-socialist, varieties of racist, sexist and white supremacist assertions but no mention of the book.
I had hoped to see in that flood, an answer to the question of Mycenaean culture post Bronze Age Collapse. I was disappointed.
I was surprised by the levels of irony, until I began to understand US culture, politics and the snowflake (cowardly, insecure, poorly educated US man-baby of a certain political bent).
The last comment received was from Claes Rees Jr aka cgr710 now ka Clayton R Jesse Jr, who seems to no longer identify as Nazi.
He referred to the contents of my last message exchange with a Goodreads friend, then declared that They had "won" (?).
It seems that these animals and their friends deluged every female creator I mentioned with sexual, racist and similar comments for a year at that point and it continues still.
The physicist, political scientist, literature critic, boater and other female creators were not impressed.
Despite that failure, the world's overabundance of ugliness was increased and an accurate self-portrait of the Snowflake (arrogant, mental US man-child) was delivered to a multinational audience.
Surely that was Victory. Goodreads discourse is fascinating. Fortunately there are BookTubers to direct the reader to safer, saner, more useful reader forums.
Have earned a stepaway to the YouTube. This next is made possible by Doctor Who/Never Cruel or Cowardly, MarineMumbles, Dapper Dads, Rooted Way, FirstPost, Nicole Rudolph, Nature Lost Vault, Octopus Lady, Genre Books, Life Take Two, Gary's Stuff, Learn Hittite, Keith Edwards, Politics Girl, Naughty Nana DUZ,
Tabithaspeakspolitics, Willow Talks Books, FAFO, Inside Russia, aidan knight, Justin Taylor, Farm to Taber, Warships and Warriors, Giant Freakin Robot, Pollito Realities, ScaredKetchup, Failsafe, Council of Geeks, Morgan Hill Farms, Planet D, Red Glasgow, Some More News, Ashley Adamson, Writing with Claire Fraise,
Farming While Beige, Kristal Bell, Jay Reed, Lurie Daniel Favors, Julie's Vintage Love, Vintage Space, Strict Scrutiny podcast, Glory to Ukraine, Gina Lucia Reads, Golden Salt, Sarah Spaceman, Ana Marie Cox, Dana Howl, The Humanist Report, Vibewithmommy, SchizoKitzo, Seizure Girl, Science Insanity, Let's Talk Tabletop, Legendary Tactics.
Given population size in comparison to the rest of the Anglophone world, US readers should be the dominant Goodreads demographic.
The US population have 52 or 54% (between ages 16 and 74) who read BELOW the sixth (11 or 12 years old) grade level.
The average US Fantasy/Romantasy/Romance title is written at the sixth grade level. Mass US science fiction is currently written at the fourth or fifth grade (9 or 10 year old) level. 20% of US citizens are illiterate and content with that condition.
It no longer surprises that certain Goodreads members take umbrage with criticism of racist, sexist, ableist, anti-LGBTQ and generally anti-human themes, representation and embedded author opinions in both Fantasy/Romantasy/Romance and Science fiction generally in their comments.
These Goodreads members wish to decide not only what is popular but what is good. They also are determined to enforce that understanding and silence dissent.
I need another break before continuing. This next is courtesy of YouTube Doctor Who/Without Reward, Leah Nicole, Keffals, Summer Gayle, FAFO, Jake Broe, The Page Perspective, Kyiv Independent, JimmyTheGiant, The Orbital Array, Truth to Power, Hej Sokoly, JingXuan, Oceanliner Designs, Not Even Emily, Read Rant Review, Coffee and Tales, Natasha's Adventures, Raya, Anda Kent,
A Day of Small Things, Amanda the Jedi, The Kavernacle, Amadeus Quartet, Stephanie Bookish, Nikki Hawkes, Swoop, Inka Gold, Jemi, Books and Borders, Jenny Gillblad, Truth to Power, Caelan Conrad, Anka Daily News, Reading Wryly, Michael Lambert, The Gaze, Fantasy and World Music by the Fletchers, Riverboat Jack, Rowan Ellis, The Researcher, PageMelt, Abby Cox, The Pioneer, Lisandra Vazquez,
ScaredKetchup, Karolina Zebrowska, Tanya Fiona, Roughest Drafts, Fusion Fighters, Tale Foundry, Jess Owens, Christy Anne Jones, Fundie Fridays, One Drum One Stick, Drama Kween, Joe Blogs, Not Even Emily, Lives and Histories, Read Rant Review, Read and Knit with Cheryl, Professor Gerdes Explains, Made U Book,
The Juice Media, Postmodern Jukebox, Swell Entertainment, Books with Emily Fox, RobWords, Fraser Cain, Erutan, Queen Penguin, Mercado Media, Demebi Lea, Asturia Quartet, Ponderful, Gingers are Black, Jess of the Shire, Sumatha Reads.
I also watched House Husbands, Doc Martin, Workin Moms, Bodkin, Dark Winds, Landscape with Invisible Hand (an insightful depiction of NeoColonialism), Kim's Convenience.
Ominous music begins. 😊 The comment gangs do not limit themselves to nasty comments but have branched out to doxxing, stalking, threatening, backing attempt and beyond. Expect no relief from Amazon, which have never to my knowledge acknowledged an incident. Neither have They disciplined insane members, punished writers who encourage Them nor dismissed mad employees who enable either.
My own meagre message history was given over to that mob, which resulted in a request from Pine Gap Centre of Australian Intelligence to interrogate the one friend whom I occasionally messaged.
The attempt at my personal history failed. Amazon was unconcerned until we began to publicise this event. At that point Amazon returned my page format and options to normal, masked all comments, Lurkers whom I'd not been permitted to remove were disappeared and even Kindle service disruption ended.
Reads with Rachel wrote a Goodreads review commenting on a book's problematic elements (ableist or racist, if I remember correctly), which Goodreads deleted as "hate speech" with threat of eliminating her account.
A very Amazon definition of hate speech. She uploaded the review to YouTube where a Goodreads commenter declared that she "should die".
Fit Danielle Reads filed a double billing complaint with Amazon. Her customer service experience was horrible, her access to her Kindle library blocked and a second payment source demanded. A very Amazon response.
A seventh ex-employee of EBay was sentenced for the harassment of a couple whose small ecommerce channel was deemed unkind to EBay. The couple were awarded millions and the ex-employee had been EBay Chief of Global Security or some such.
With the new protections afforded US data firms, these are things to consider.
With discourse not on the cards, courtesy and social skills not evidenced, limited opinions, lack of critical judgements of titles and my having no desire for friends to join the site, am now only on the site to rewrite my reviews.
US science fiction are boom-boom spacey-space books so far removed from the genre's roots as to be some new dreadful category. They seem harbingers of the death of the US portion of the genre. In addition they are celebrations of an undeserved, glorious US military tradition carried forward to the future.
They are a sad monument to a dying empire's self-delusion. It feels appropriate to a dying site complicit in destroying a number of genres. Sales are supreme.
I suggest several precautions. Remove all personal information from Goodreads profile and avoid messaging. Remove the lurkers, those friends who never post. They are likely monitors for gangs or employee dummies, not admirers.
Given the Goodreads penchant for Altering customer pages, screenshots of the odd, ugly and threatening are invaluable. Those should suffice.
Kindle are a different matter. Do Not use Kindle Files, Calendar, Email or Contacts. Email are read by Amazon employees without permission or notice. Make of that what you will.
Do Not purchase KIndle ebooks as you own only the device (if Kindle that seems conditional), not your "purchases". Amazon may delete your books at whim. There are BooKTubers to direct the reader to alternative ebook or tablet vendors and options to ebook purchase altogether.
Silk searches should be innocuous and non-critical.
Emotionally damaged employees and members are not to be underestimated. They are devoid of non-Randian morality or healthy socialisation but are proud US patriots with all that implies. Ominous music ends. 😊
Be safe and may we all enjoy good reading. 🤗
Some of my favourite channels.
NCMI, Russian Media Monitor, Bobbing Along, UATV, Biz, British Museum, Munecat, Raw News and Politics, Tom Nicholas, DUST, Randy Rainbow, AllShorts, Reese Waters, Fun Size Reader, Cambrian Chronicles, Ben and Emily, J Draper, Lady Knight the Brave, Horses, Sabine Hossenfelder, Prime of Midlife, No Justice, Verilybitchie,
Dark Brandon, Cindys Villa, Oceanliner Designs, Novara Media, Well Deck Diaries, Cruising Crafts, Broken Peach, Riverboat Jack, Travelling K, OrangeRiver, Petrik Leo, Anton Petrov, Military History Visualised, Books and Lala, TVP News, Alice Cappelle, Cappy Army, Don't F@ck with Ukraine, Sarah Z, Grace McGuire, The Gaze, Patrick is a Navajo, Liene's LIbrary,
The Shades of Orange, Mrs Betty Bowers, Shar Henley, NITV, Omeleto, DW News, What Vivi did next, Book Lover Laura, DankyJabo, SamAtEverySize, LeeReads, Li Speaks, Squire, TIKHistory, Invicta, Kings and Generals, HBomberGuy, Veritas et Caritas, The Confused Adipose, Leena Norms, Yarmak, Ellbat, LydLoves, Olive's Book Nook, Patrick is a Navajo, Dr Becky, Don't Fret,
Female Warriors - Teresatessa, Words in Time, France 24, The Great War, Sara Elisabeth, Gracey D, Tanya Fiona, Atun Shei Films, The Bands of HM Royal Marines, Up and Atom, Physics Girl, Renegade Cut, Media Death Cult, Alizee, Crow Caller, Tale Foundry, Amie's Literary Empire,
Haropones, Talking Story, Deerstalker Pictures, Stephanie Bookish, Ember Green, Secret Sauce of StoryCraft, SciFi Odyssey, Jay Exci, Keffals, Inside Russia,
Interesting Times, Sunny Book Nook, The Yankee Farm Wife, Central Crossing, Fundie Fridays, Julie Nolke, Madysin, Leena Norms, Haropones, IL Neige, Viv's Little Library, Amodelwhosread, Tiff Reads Books, Jabzy, Liz Webster, NerdForge, Listen2Kristen, JammiDodger, Fran Blanche, The Leftist Cooks,
The Welsh Viking, Book Furnace, It's Black Friday, Cover in French, Library of a Viking, Cossack and Caucasus Sword Dance, Living Anachronism, Reads with Rachel, Mynameismarines, Reads With Cindy, Caspian Report, Real Time History, TIKHistory, TVP News, The Great War, Then & Now, Vlad Vexler, Jessie Gender, Viva La Dirt League, Brandon Fisichella, Julie Nolke, Eileen, Nomadic Crobot, Skip Intro, Discourse Minis,
The Friendly Atheist, Anark, Engineering Knits, Historical Fashion, Just in Time Worldbuilding, Philosophy Tube, LeeReads, Reedsy, Emma Thorne, Lynn Saga, Mom on the Spectrum, It ain't half hot mum, Guard the Leaf, Scallydandling About the Books.
May you have a glorious morning, a pleasant afternoon, an exciting evening, a splendid night and may we all continue learning.
A bird does not sing because it has an answer but because it has a song.
Taiwanese proverb