What do you think?
Rate this book
An Extra Knot Part I
Small changes - screwing an extra knot out of a warship's engines or a petty functionary insisting a family sell a wedding clock before they can get unemployment benefit - small changes which can nevertheless lead to a different world war than the one we know explored from the viewpoint of Republican Spaniards, committed Nazis, British parliamentarians and Royal Naval officers to name but a few in this stunning fictional alternative history.
- GenresAlternate History
180 pages, Hardcover
Published March 19, 2022
47 people are currently reading
10 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
November 28, 2019
A different cup of tea
In this novel a real accident which took place during the Spanish Civil War takes places a little differently resulting in a ship being damaged more severely than it was historically. As a result of the accident and skilled political actions by a politician who was a minor player at the time historically the ship repairs are done in her parliamentary district setting off ripple effects. She becomes a more significant MP years earlier than took place historically and her influence shifts a number of other events in the lead up to world war two. I am sure this will have a significant effect as later novels continue the story.
In this novel a real accident which took place during the Spanish Civil War takes places a little differently resulting in a ship being damaged more severely than it was historically. As a result of the accident and skilled political actions by a politician who was a minor player at the time historically the ship repairs are done in her parliamentary district setting off ripple effects. She becomes a more significant MP years earlier than took place historically and her influence shifts a number of other events in the lead up to world war two. I am sure this will have a significant effect as later novels continue the story.
February 28, 2020
So a tiny change in the speed of a boat changes history. From Jarrow to Asturias there are ripples when the ship HMS Hood moves at an extra knot, long before the war breaks out.
And this is interesting. But for me it is not enough. The tale moves slowly, I know too little about the actual events in this obscure run up to war. What is new? What is unchanged? The characters are many and so each relatively shallow.
This book will be great for some, just not quite for me. I don't think I'll finish the series, though I'm not sad to have read it.
And this is interesting. But for me it is not enough. The tale moves slowly, I know too little about the actual events in this obscure run up to war. What is new? What is unchanged? The characters are many and so each relatively shallow.
This book will be great for some, just not quite for me. I don't think I'll finish the series, though I'm not sad to have read it.
August 5, 2019
Interesting
An alternative history with tiny butterfly effects. Not a bad read but a tendency to lapse into purple prose that doesn’t seem to fit. Long drawn out at times with only occasional action. I reached the end but skimmed at times to get there. Needs to be much likelier.
An alternative history with tiny butterfly effects. Not a bad read but a tendency to lapse into purple prose that doesn’t seem to fit. Long drawn out at times with only occasional action. I reached the end but skimmed at times to get there. Needs to be much likelier.
Read
April 26, 2019Really good a different way of telling alternative history
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews