Not the best, but not totally terrible either.
I am kind of on the fence with this one. I was hot then cold, in then out, up then down. Why? Because this story fluctuated between good and bad; boring and exciting; and at times, not just the story, but the characters seemed sophomoric.
This story started out interesting. There's some not very pleasant history between the H and h back in their high school days. So when he turns up in her life again, a few years later, you're expecting a lot of antagonism initially and a slow, not so easy, fall into love, but that's not the case. All too quickly, their bad history is resolved and it turns sickeningly sweet. Sickeningly because at this point you're only maybe a little over a quarter into this story and you wonder...is this all i'm going to get? You feel like you're getting their HEA and you're not even half way through it. I got bored, put it aside and read another book.
I really hate having unfinished books on my kindle (it's an OCD thing), so it was either finish it or delete it. I decided to give it another chance and, fortunately, it wasn't long before an new development occurred that made it interesting again. Unfortunately, it's also where I found the characters, particularly the h, acting 'out of character'. What I mean is, considering her past history (not just the one with the H), some of her actions/comments just didn't fit...didn't seem plausible or real. Then there were times when the characters seemed like mature young adults (they were in their early 20's) and others when they acted like teenage high schoolers. And the sexual encounters between the Hand h were sometimes lacking too. There seemed to be a disconnect making the whole thing seem contrived. It was basically he did this, she did that, he did this and we came. There was no flow to the actions, no real feelings or emotions given during.
In the end, it wasn't a bad storyline, it just wasn't executed well enough. The characters were likeable but inconsistent and often one dimensional. Basically, the heart and soul was missing and I was unable to connect with the characters and their story.