One Language, Two Scripts: The Hindi Movement in Nineteenth Century North India

by Christopher R. King

The Hindi movement in nineteenth century north India provides an excellent example of the relationships between language, religion and nationalism, and several scholars have dealt with various aspects of these relationships. This study differs form previous ones in examining not only the political, but also the social and cultural aspects of the Hindi movement, particularly on the local and provincial levels. Moreover, it is based on extensive use of both Hindi and English sources, including a thorough research of official rcords such as education reports, publication statistics and the like. Finally, it stresses the importance of voluntary language associations which both reflected and intensified the Hindi movement. After an introduction which provides the theoretical, historical, linguistic and social background, and a review of previous studies, the author traces certain aspects of the history of Hindi and Urdu literature from the late eighteenth to the early twentieth century and the development and expansion of the printing of books and periodicals in these languages. This is followed by an outline of the essential features of the government's language policy and its important though contradictary role in shaping the Hindi movement, and an analysis of both indigenous and governmental educational systems in terms of languages studied, the social background of the students, and the relationship of education to employment, especially government employment. One chapter is devoted to the history of the Hindi movement, from the initial controversies of the 1860s to the government decision of 1900 favouring Hindi and the Nagari script. The organization of the study is both chronological and topical, each succeeding chapter beginning its narrative and analysis at a later date than the preceeding chapter and dealing with a different aspect of the subject. The principal thesis of this book is that the Hindi movement of the nineteenth century expressed a Hindu nationalism whose essence lay in the denial of existing assimilation to cultural traditions associated with Muslim rule and the affirmation of potential differentiation from these traditions. In other words, one can view the Hindi movement as part of a process of multi-symbol congruence in which Hindu supporters of Hindi strove to transform the existing equations on Urdu = Muslim + Hindu and Hindi = Hindu + Muslim into Urdu + Muslim and Hindi = Hindu. Competing and overlapping loyalties and traditions, the crystallization of cultural identities into communal ones - these are issues which are still with us today and which admit to no easy solution. this book goes a long way towards filling a gap in our understanding of the role that language has played on the history and politics of modern India.

Genres: History, India, Language

246 pages, Paperback

First published March 23, 1995

Reviews

[ناسازگار · Rating 5 out of 5]

What brilliant research. Many of my relatively simplistic ideas of identity politics around language in colonial UP were rewired by this book. Loved the chapters on language policy in education and civil services, and the brilliant use of statistics on readership, publication and literacy across scripts divided by region, community and language.

[Daud Khan · Rating 4 out of 5]

A fine review of the Hindi-Urdu battles between the 1860s and the (very) early 20th century.