What do you think?
Rate this book


208 pages, Paperback
Published March 15, 2022
Irish people go to funerals. They circle the wagons, count the survivors. Everyone could still hug and kiss, wipe away the tears and snot, shake hands with her husband, her family, her kids. Nobody knew it then, but this would be the last good funeral of the year.
He told himself this from the start: this wasn’t just about Charlotte. It was about him suddenly being faced with facts he’d been ignoring — that he was getting old, that he wasn’t what he used to be, that his imagination, always overactive, had at some point reversed its direction, switching production from dreams to regrets. Anyone could see the gears turning, the facile clockwork. It was selfish and dishonest. And worse, it was dull.
he said to his wife once he said if I ever start writing about being a writer or about a fictional writer who is writing a book get a five-pound steel lump hammer and strike me repeatedly on the back of the head
an artist friend once told him that he thought writing was the purest art because you can’t hide behind the form and when you’re writing you always have to try to find something new and he said that for example someone had told him about a recent American novel that was only one long sentence and it had won experimental prizes and wasn’t that an interesting idea and he told his artist friend that in the past five years not one but two novels that were only one long sentence had won the big English prize for experimental fiction and that Joyce first ran that experiment a century before and his artist friend laughed
So now he had, after all, a photograph of himself with Charlotte, from their short time together, a long time ago. It hurt now to think of them all, happy there together, but here was the evidence, a last-minute twist. But what did it prove? We were. That’s all. It was good. And some of us continue. Could any true story end any other way?
…now that he thought back, he had another good reason for missing Charlotte McDonald. She alone from that time had offered some forgiveness. He didn’t realize it until it was too late, but she had been his last link, though half-forgotten, in the background, to some other not-quite-finished business. He had just lost his only friendly witness.This memoir shouldn’t have hit me as hard as it did, but there you go, it knocked me into a long conversation with the me of about 40 years ago. All my witnesses are gone too, all my friends who would have remembered me then and even earlier, and this is the single most painful symptom of growing older. The author delves into his feelings around a number of events, especially his friend's death and that of his younger brother, and explains in a roundabout way why this book is written in the third person:
…He should have kept a diary, even a superficial one. I he had, he could have turned it into some sort of book, the sort of book that reporters write. But to write that book, a non-fiction one, in the first person, he would have had to find a theme for it, and he would have had to be part of that theme. And he didn’t interest himself enough to want to use himself as a character. So he stuck to the sugar rush of other people’s stories…Ah but it isn’t all grief (or commas although they grow like tiny irritating whiskers everywhere) or pain. There are also some very funny lines and delicious turns of phrase scattered throughout, like “failure continues to evade him” and “not being Irish, Jeroen is seeing a psychiatrist.” The whole book deserves close reading, and will be on my gift list for a number of people this year. 4 1/2 stars.
…all this was fine, no problem at all, just doing the job - until twenty years later, when his kids wanted a ghost story, and he realized, as he told it, the he was now one of its ghosts.