I am getting super frustrated with the Christian and Inspirational books I am reading. I started reading these books because they were well written, not always full of doom and gloom, and because they -at least the first dozen or so-showed people working at , and through their problems, in a deep and conscientious manner. All I seem to find now is people behaving abominably, saying God forgives me so you must to-and Fast, and taking virtually no personal responsibility for their actions ,nor the ramifications that follow.
This book is well written, and I certainly got engrossed in the story and the characters, but the plot line of Madge and Russell defied all reason and turned what could have been a 4 star experience into a one [I averaged it out a bit for the star part of the review.]
The author missed a HUGE opportunity to develop this story in a more realistic way. I am very disappointed, especially because she writes well and had interesting story lines for the other two sisters.
SPOILERS AHEAD.
I can accept that Madge decided to stay in the marriage, and forgive her husband, as well as raise his ' love child'. I cannot , for the life of me, accept that she treated his ongoing ,3 plus years ,actions as if they were a 'mistake' that needed forgiveness.
The fact that she didn't express any emotion about hubby carrying on with another wife for 36 months plus; living with another woman;sleeping with another woman;even getting a pet for his love child when he wouldn't let his 'real' sons have one!! Nothing Nada-nope, let's just let it all skate by-because I took vows. Well those vows say 'for better or worse'. They Don't say: be a doormat; let your spouse walk all over you; allow your spouse to persuade you to lie to your adult children. I mean, isn't lying a sin? Or lying about something that the other person had a moral right to know-oh, like "hey sons, you have a sister"?
He MARRIED the other woman, lived with her as a husband, raised the little girl as a bio father, and spent just as much time with the 'second' wife as he did Madge. There is NO WAY that that is 'just a mistake', and absolutely no way that any self respecting woman would gloss over an entire alternate life. I mean , that is waaaay beyond betrayal. The fact that Russell basically said 'oops, sorry, it's all on you' about his other family and divorce, is even ,more offensive. He had an entire second life for at least 3 years. What woman wouldn't be seriously emotionally wounded by the thought of her husband having regular sex And an emotional commitment to another woman? Forgive all you want, but you don't forget, and that seems to be what Madge did-and what Russell expected. It's as if Madge had an emotional lobotomy, one that had Russell's approval. Then on top of that he forces her to maintain his lie and not inform their adult children of Daddy's duplicity. Oh, and her sisters encouraged her to keep all the lies juggling in her life.
I honestly do not 'get' this idea that I find in more and more Christian novels, that actions have no real consequences, that the characters in these books tend to be far from sincerely remorseful, instead they, and their pastors tell the betrayed one " you must forgive" and that , as far as sneaky, cheating hubby's think, is the end of it.
It is well written, but I am truly disappointed.