Reviewed by Toby's Nerd-Cave Library.
.
Josephine is a 17 year old writer living with her parents and four sisters, but she is very much different from them. She hears thoughts and can see things others can’t. Her abilities have been kept a secret from them and the rest of the world her whole life, and even she doesn't know the extent of her own abilities, but she has developed various methods to keep her and her family safe from herself. Then they unexpectedly inherit an old house belonging to her Fathers never before heard of Great Aunt Mercy. The house is full of shadows and whispers and too-good-to-be-true bedrooms and pantries filled with to-good-to-be-real food, and things start to get a bit wonky with their memories, and only Josie sees the patterns of forgetting, and the ancient ghost of the Evil Witch who lured the family to Vermont and intends to use them to resurrect herself.
I’m really enjoying this book so far, it would also make a really great horror movie. Usually YA horror is too cheesy and predictable, with a few jump scares and insipid teen banter, but this was one of the best ones I’ve read in a good long while. The writing style is unique and almost poetic, and just flows, and has on occasion some delightfully vulgar dialog, and I was immediately sucked into the story. The author does a really good job of setting up the characters and backstory in Part 1. And in Part 2 & 3, the level of suspense and tension just keeps rising chapter after chapter, revealing just a hint more of the history behind the Witch’s ghost and the mysterious house, leaving the reader gripping the book with white knuckles desperate to find out what happens next.
It's so hard for the reader to tell what's “real” and what's in Josie's head that it just adds to the mystery and suspense. As the book concludes in Part 4, we get a more detailed view of what's going on ‘behind the curtains’ so to speak, and we learn more of the background and motivations of the main characters, as well as the Witch, Dorcas. It all starts coming together with some questions answered, and earlier foreshadowing clues become more apparent, with all the details seeming to click flawlessly into place, and the reader is definitely ready to have the big Explanations. The big twists at the end aren't overly predictable in my opinion, and went very well with the overall themes of the story.
I like how the climax scenes are so much more gory than I was expecting from a YA book; the partial cannibalism, the physical and mental tortures endured by both child and adult, the sheer amount of evil you feel from the witch is apparent in every way the author describes her movements and mannerisms. The ending was definitely different than I was expecting, and the author left it wide open for a sequel, which I really hope will happen. Overall this was a fantastically dark YA Horror novel, and I’d recommend it to anyone who likes this genre.
Thank you to the Librarything Early Reviewers Club, the Publishers, Tundra Books, and the Author, Joel A. Sutherland, for providing me with a free copy in exchange for an honest review.