I picked up an ARC of this middle-grade novel at the Public Library Association conference a few weeks ago. I was hoping to find something my niece would like. She’s nine, and I’ve found that so many books aimed at middle schoolers deal with content that’s too mature for her—going through puberty and crushes, or the death of a parent or someone close to you. This was a refreshing discovery, as it seems perfectly aimed at readers who have outgrown the early chapter books, but is still appropriate for a kid (9-11) rather than a pre-teen/young teen.
The first thing that drew me to this novel was the cover. My niece, nephew and I used to love playing the crane game at the arcade that allows you to win little rubber ducks—we usually left with a pile of them, and I’d often find a random stray duck buried in my purse weeks later. This is a contemporary novel (they text emojis), but it reminded me a little of the kid detective novels I grew up with in the 1980s. It centers on three kids who just finished fifth grade. Paul is the narrator, he loves solving mysteries and his family owns the local hardware store. He has a club with his two best friends—a short and fearless girl nicknamed Shanks who, like Paul, loves mysteries, and a tall boy nicknamed Peephole who has a photographic memory.
Their summer, and the novel, begins with a mystery—a huge number of rubber ducks appear one summer morning in the backyard of the reigning champion of the town’s annual bratwurst festival. What makes it feel a bit old-fashioned is that it’s set in a safe small town, where they have the freedom to ride their bikes wherever they want, and know most of the people, including adults, by name. Their parents are present and caring, but there’s still plenty of opportunity for kid adventure that’s fun without ever feeling scary—they're never in danger, though they do break some rules. I don’t think kids today have that level of freedom like I did growing up, but I do think that at that age, you want to read a novel about kids who have adventures and autonomy, without worrying about real world dangers. Delightfully, there’s also a map of the town at the beginning of the novel (I loved those as a kid, and still do).
The author is a teacher, and the novel has a humorous tone, making me chuckle several times. It’s clear he understands kids, and he even throws in a Poe reference and there’s a hidden reference to a line from Shakespeare. I’ll admit, I figured out almost the whole mystery before I was halfway through, but I’m not the target audience and I’ve read a lot of mysteries. I can also appreciate that the author played fair by laying out all the clues, some of which the characters don’t pick up on but the reader might. So a smart reader can figure it out, unlike those mysteries where it’s impossible because key facts are withheld until the end.
The end sets up the potential for this to be a series, though there’s no mention of a book 2. Cornett does a good job of creating a world and characters readers will want to return to, and I look forward to sharing this with my niece.