For years, when my wife asked me what I wanted for my birthday or Christmas, I would jokingly say, "The first or fourth edition of Johnson's Dictionary." She never came through, and I don't know why - those editions only cost around $10,000 U.S. Over the years I've toyed with buying a facsimile edition or a CD-ROM edition, but even those are priced in the hundreds of dollars.
But lo and behold, there is now a cheap Kindle version. And while it's not perfect, I'm pretty thrilled to be able to carry Johnson's Dictionary around with me. The Kindle version is based on the fourth edition, the last edition to which Johnson made significant additions and corrections. But when an entry appeared only in the first edition, it's also included.
Johnson's Dictionary is more than just a book; it's a monument in the history of English literature. Warts and all, it was the standard English dictionary for at least a hundred years. As Henry Hitchings points out in his book about the Dictionary, Johnson's use of quotes to illustrate the meanings of words makes the Dictionary an anthology of English writing up to Johnson's time. Johnson's definitions range from on-point to humorous to off-base to just odd, but the passages he chooses to quote are fascinating. Up to now I've only had access to selections from Johnson's Dictionary, and didn't realize that there were so many illustrative passages - the quotes take up much more room than the definitions.
I've marked this as "read," which, of course, is just ridiculous; I just didn't want it to show in my "currently reading" list for the rest of my life. Although a few notable figures (like Nathaniel Hawthorne) read it from cover to cover, this is a book to skip around and get lost in. I'll find myself curious about what Johnson has to say about a certain word, but before I get to that word, I'll get sidetracked a dozen times.
My rating of four, rather than five stars is a reflection of the weaknesses of the Kindle edition. The line breaks in the quotations are sometimes weird, but it's not really too hard to figure out what was intended. And navigation is not as awkward as you might expect in a work like this, but it's still not always easy, depending on what word you want to look up. There are many "jumping off" points marked in the table of contents, but if you pick a word halfway between two of those points, you may have a lot of scrolling to do.
It's amazing to think that this mammoth achievement was the work of one man. It's flawed, incomplete, and dated, but still amazing.