This, the last novel written by my favourite author, William Peter Blatty, was not a love-at-first-sight experience, like his penultimate The Exorcist was. When I first purchased this book, I was only a year or two into being a constant reader (one of the best decisions I ever made). I had only recently read The Exorcist (absolutely loved it!), my interested were almost completely confined to horror fiction, and I had only barely ceased being a teenager.
So when I excitedly purchased this book solely for the author's name on the cover, I didn't know what to make of it. It is indeed an odd book, a far cry from The Exorcist and, to a lesser degree, some of Blatty's other works as well. It was not well received by most readers, despite it being the author's "most personally important book" of his career. Even now, it seems the inevitable promotions that associate it with Blatty's most famous novel are absolutely detrimental in positioning readers to enjoy it. This is partly a detective mystery, and it is deeply infused with Blatty's (maybe Maronite?) Catholicism, but here the similarities to The Exorcist end. Dimiter is a strange, enigmatic story that is often hard to follow. I also would not deny, as a fan of the novel, that Blatty may be guilty of employing certain machinations to hold the plot that could be considered as a form of cheating. Here, I mainly refer to his tendency to have many, very short and vaguely relevant chapters, with finally a transcript of certain characters talking, just to straight-up tell the reader exactly what the hell has actually been going on.
One of the things I loved about Blatty from the very start was his writing style. He's not everyone cup of tea, but I personally think his authorial voice is one of the most beautiful in popular fiction. But of course, Dimiter isn't popular fiction. This one is a slow-burner, despite being fairly short. Its style is much more literary, more idiosyncratic on Blatty's part, and so I cannot imagine many readers are who only fans of The Exorcist to go for this. You need to be a fan of Blatty's more generally, in my opinion. Furthermore, as someone else on Goodreads very correctly pointed out, Dimiter is a book that needs to be read twice.
I came away disliking it the first time. I was not mature enough to appreciate the nuances of the story, and nor was I as fervent a Catholic myself at the time. (This book is steeped in references to the Gospels, and not just a knowledge of, but a love for those texts is quite vital). After getting older, becoming much more religious and finding a deeper relationship with Christ in my own life, I enjoyed this book significantly more when I read it again in 2019. Indeed, I liked it so much that, just two years, I asked my wife if she would read it with me again.
This time around, probably because I also read it with the added desire of my wife enjoying it (for her it was that challenging first time), I did not enjoy the story quite as much. But all the same, I still did enjoy it quite a lot. Therefore it shall keep all four of its stars. The first half - not just the excellent first section in Albania - is remarkable, and for me it actually managed to glimpse, here and there, at a potential five stars. But the second half just gets too bogged down in random, seemingly pointless little scenes that don't really connect until the somewhat convoluted, somewhat disappointing climax.