What do you think?
Rate this book
Für einen Sommer
***THE FEEL-GOOD, UPLIFTING NOVEL EVERYONE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT IN 2019***You never know what life will throw at you. You just need to know who to turn to for help.One morning in early summer, a man and woman wait to board a flight to Italy. Allie has lived a careful, focused existence. But now she has unexpectedly taken leave from her job as an academic research scientist to fly to a place she only recently heard about in a letter. Her father, Joe, doesn’t know the reason for her trip, and Allie can’t bring herself to tell him that she’s flying to Italy to unpick the truth about what her mother did all those years ago.Beside her is her best friend since schooldays, Ed. He has just shocked everyone with a sudden separation from his wife, Julia. Allie hopes that a break will help him open up.But the secrets that emerge as the sun beats down on Lake Garda and Liguria don’t merely concern her family’s tangled past. And the two friends are forced to confront questions about their own life-long relationship that are impossible to resolve.The dazzling new novel from Richard & Judy book club author Catherine Isaac, Messy, Wonderful Us is a story about the transforming power of love, as one woman journeys to uncover the past and reshape her future.Praise for You Me Everything'You broke my heart AND made it soar! Isabelle Broom'Packed with twists and surprises' Good Housekeeping'A heart-wrenching story which explores the lengths we’re willing to go to for those we love' Cosmopolitan'Beautiful' Closer'Will stay with you' Marie Claire US'A heart-breakingly real story and poignant story of love, regret and second chances. This is one of the books that everyone will be talking about' Heat'Destined for big things' Red'An ideal holiday read' Sunday Mirror'One of the summer's big hitters' Fabulous'Must read' New York Post‘What a gorgeous book. A sensitive subject, beautifully handled. Loved it’ Jill Mansell'Heartwarming, thoughtful and very special' Jenny Colgan'Reminiscent of One Day' Sarah Vaughan
Paperback
First published November 28, 2019
315 people are currently reading
4030 people want to read
About the author
Catherine Isaac
17 books542 followersI’m the internationally bestselling author of 15 novels, ten of which have been published under the name ‘Jane Costello'’. My novels have been translated into 26 languages, selected by the Richard & Judy Book Club and I’ve been honoured to win a Romantic Novelists’ Award - twice! I was born in Liverpool, where I still live with my husband and three sons. When I’m not writing, you’ll usually find me on the tennis court, wishing I’d started to play about 25 years before I did.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 379 reviews
December 10, 2019
Messy, Wonderful Us.. what a delightful story. It is not all sunshine and roses, this one is an emotional roller coaster for the characters and the reader. Mostly set in beautiful parts of Italy with 2 main characters that are likeable and easy to care about. I was hoping it was all going to work out for both of them.
Allie is the sensible, research assistant who finds a letter in her grandmothers room that rocks her world. Suddenly there is a secret from her mother’s past that she needs to know more about. Her mother passed away when she was young and her grandmother refuses to talk about it. Her best friend is Ed and he has suddenly left his wife of 2 years, seemingly out of the blue. Together they travel to Italy in search of answers. Allie wants to know more about this man from her mother’s past and Ed needs to sort his head out and decide where his life is going. They both get a lot more than they bargain for.
Thanks to Simon and Schuster and NetGalley for my advanced copy of this book to read. All opinions are my own and are in no way biased
Allie is the sensible, research assistant who finds a letter in her grandmothers room that rocks her world. Suddenly there is a secret from her mother’s past that she needs to know more about. Her mother passed away when she was young and her grandmother refuses to talk about it. Her best friend is Ed and he has suddenly left his wife of 2 years, seemingly out of the blue. Together they travel to Italy in search of answers. Allie wants to know more about this man from her mother’s past and Ed needs to sort his head out and decide where his life is going. They both get a lot more than they bargain for.
Thanks to Simon and Schuster and NetGalley for my advanced copy of this book to read. All opinions are my own and are in no way biased
August 2, 2019
Three and a half stars.
Allie’s life is dramatically changed when she finds a photograph and a letter tucked away in her grandmother’s drawer. It seems to undermine all she knows about her family. Worse, still her grandmother shuts down any attempts to discuss the matter at all. Determined not to be put off Allie set off to try and track down the truth in Italy. With Allie is Ed, who has been her best friend since school days. Married to Julia, Ed is having his own issues and he has a critical decision to make. As Allie’s quest for the truth goes on, secrets about relationships that have been long hidden are brought to light. Secrets that could drastically change things.
One thing I really liked was the way the author brought to light an issue we often hear about yet succeeded in turning it on its head and giving a different perspective. The characters come across as flawed but real. Interestingly my favourite three characters were all men, Gerald, Allie’s grandfather, Joe, Allie’s father and Ed, her best friend.
Reading this book was rather like watching a soap opera. At more than one stage I could see where it was heading before it got there. Didn’t stop me reading though. Like the best soap operas it did get me in. Not enough to be emotionally involved with the characters, but certainly enough to keep reading. I didn’t ‘love it’ as the cover assured me I would or my money back. Since mine was sent to me free of charge from Simon and Schuster this was a moot point anyway. My thanks go to Simon and Schuster for my copy to read and review. I was pleased to have read it. While I didn’t love it, I did enjoy it. If you like feel good reads and family stories, you may well enjoy this one.
Allie’s life is dramatically changed when she finds a photograph and a letter tucked away in her grandmother’s drawer. It seems to undermine all she knows about her family. Worse, still her grandmother shuts down any attempts to discuss the matter at all. Determined not to be put off Allie set off to try and track down the truth in Italy. With Allie is Ed, who has been her best friend since school days. Married to Julia, Ed is having his own issues and he has a critical decision to make. As Allie’s quest for the truth goes on, secrets about relationships that have been long hidden are brought to light. Secrets that could drastically change things.
One thing I really liked was the way the author brought to light an issue we often hear about yet succeeded in turning it on its head and giving a different perspective. The characters come across as flawed but real. Interestingly my favourite three characters were all men, Gerald, Allie’s grandfather, Joe, Allie’s father and Ed, her best friend.
Reading this book was rather like watching a soap opera. At more than one stage I could see where it was heading before it got there. Didn’t stop me reading though. Like the best soap operas it did get me in. Not enough to be emotionally involved with the characters, but certainly enough to keep reading. I didn’t ‘love it’ as the cover assured me I would or my money back. Since mine was sent to me free of charge from Simon and Schuster this was a moot point anyway. My thanks go to Simon and Schuster for my copy to read and review. I was pleased to have read it. While I didn’t love it, I did enjoy it. If you like feel good reads and family stories, you may well enjoy this one.
October 7, 2019
Messy Wonderful Us is the second novel by British author, Catherine Isaac. Best friends Allie Culpepper and Ed Holt have gone to Verona. She’s looking for the man who might be her father; he’s trying to work out if his marriage to Julia can be saved, or if he even wants to do that.
Allie accidentally found a letter and a newspaper clipping that seems to indicate that Joe Hudson, the man she has known as her father for thirty-three years, might be that in name only. Well, and actions: he raised her alone after her mother died of cancer. Her Grandma Peggy has strictly forbidden her to pursue this, but she has to know. Stefano McCourt is in Italy; Allie can’t ask her mum, so she will ask Stefano. If she can find him.
Julia Holt rings Allie the day before she’s due to depart: Ed is talking about leaving her. Can Allie please talk sense into him? Allie is concerned about her friend’s state of mind, and he decides to accompany her, reasoning that he can translate for her while taking a break to sort himself out. But Ed has not shared everything about his marriage…
Three narrators tell the story: Allie and Ed relate events of the present day, with dips into their shared history; an (initially unnamed) narrator gives the perspective of a young woman who cannot resist having a one-night stand with a charismatic man, knowing he will be leaving the country. She, of course, falls pregnant.
Isaac’s characters are quite credible and their interactions can be both delightful and frustrating: Allie’s singlemindedness comes across as a bit selfish. Isaac gives marvellous examples of the extremes of father-daughter relationships, and her depiction of the psychopath is excellent. She explores forced adoptions and domestic violence with insight and sensitivity.
As is often the case, some of the problems between the characters stem from a lack of communication, although they can hardly be blamed for avoiding painful memories or not revealing certain details that embarrass them. There are some excellent twists and several red herrings, although the drama in the latter half of the story feels a tiny bit contrived. A moving and thought-provoking read.
This unbiased review is from a copy provided by Simon & Schuster Australia.
Allie accidentally found a letter and a newspaper clipping that seems to indicate that Joe Hudson, the man she has known as her father for thirty-three years, might be that in name only. Well, and actions: he raised her alone after her mother died of cancer. Her Grandma Peggy has strictly forbidden her to pursue this, but she has to know. Stefano McCourt is in Italy; Allie can’t ask her mum, so she will ask Stefano. If she can find him.
Julia Holt rings Allie the day before she’s due to depart: Ed is talking about leaving her. Can Allie please talk sense into him? Allie is concerned about her friend’s state of mind, and he decides to accompany her, reasoning that he can translate for her while taking a break to sort himself out. But Ed has not shared everything about his marriage…
Three narrators tell the story: Allie and Ed relate events of the present day, with dips into their shared history; an (initially unnamed) narrator gives the perspective of a young woman who cannot resist having a one-night stand with a charismatic man, knowing he will be leaving the country. She, of course, falls pregnant.
Isaac’s characters are quite credible and their interactions can be both delightful and frustrating: Allie’s singlemindedness comes across as a bit selfish. Isaac gives marvellous examples of the extremes of father-daughter relationships, and her depiction of the psychopath is excellent. She explores forced adoptions and domestic violence with insight and sensitivity.
As is often the case, some of the problems between the characters stem from a lack of communication, although they can hardly be blamed for avoiding painful memories or not revealing certain details that embarrass them. There are some excellent twists and several red herrings, although the drama in the latter half of the story feels a tiny bit contrived. A moving and thought-provoking read.
This unbiased review is from a copy provided by Simon & Schuster Australia.
January 5, 2020
I’m hovering between 3-4 stars for this book but rounded it up. I really did enjoy the ups and downs of Allie and Ed and the will they, won’t they storyline. It was predictable in places and I did guess some parts of it, but I just loved the way the story flowed.
July 7, 2019
Messy, Wonderful Us
I was surprised at how much I adored this story.
The story revolves around Allie a research scientist and her unexpected journey to Northern Italy to uncover the secrets of her family’s past. Allie can’t bring herself to tell her family the truth about where she is heading off to and they believe she’s gone on a singles holiday to Portugal.
I found Allie to be a likeable character along with her best friend Ed, a successful business owner who decides to join Allie on her quest.
From start to finish the story intrigued me and had me completely hooked. There is a thread of mystery and many twists and turns in the plot that hit you unexpectedly. There’s also no shortage of relationship drama to entertain and keep you wondering.
A great holiday read and a constant page turner for those that love a touch of romance and drama.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster for an ARC of this book
I was surprised at how much I adored this story.
The story revolves around Allie a research scientist and her unexpected journey to Northern Italy to uncover the secrets of her family’s past. Allie can’t bring herself to tell her family the truth about where she is heading off to and they believe she’s gone on a singles holiday to Portugal.
I found Allie to be a likeable character along with her best friend Ed, a successful business owner who decides to join Allie on her quest.
From start to finish the story intrigued me and had me completely hooked. There is a thread of mystery and many twists and turns in the plot that hit you unexpectedly. There’s also no shortage of relationship drama to entertain and keep you wondering.
A great holiday read and a constant page turner for those that love a touch of romance and drama.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster for an ARC of this book
October 7, 2022
הכריכה והשם קצת הרתיעו אותי, אבל למרבה ההפתעה זה היה ספר מקסים, וקריאה נהדרת ליום כיפור.
אלי מגלה במקרה מכתב בשידה בחדר של סבתה, שגורם לה לחשוד שאביה אינו באמת אביה הביולוגי. בעקבות המכתב היא יוצאת לאיטליה לחפש את האיש המוזכר במכתב. לטיול שלה מתלווה אד, ידיד קרוב של אלי עוד מהימים שלמדו יחד בתיכון. אד נמצא בעיצומו של משבר זוגי, לאחר שהחליט לעזוב את אשתו.
אני מאוד אוהבת ספרים על סודות משפחתיים שנחשפים ועל גאולה עצמית של אנשים לאחר מסע משנה חיים. וזה בדיוק הספר הזה.
הספר כתוב (ומתורגם) נהדר. הסוף קצת ביאס אותי ולכן 4 כוכבים ולא 5. אבל בהחלט ספר מומלץ.
אלי מגלה במקרה מכתב בשידה בחדר של סבתה, שגורם לה לחשוד שאביה אינו באמת אביה הביולוגי. בעקבות המכתב היא יוצאת לאיטליה לחפש את האיש המוזכר במכתב. לטיול שלה מתלווה אד, ידיד קרוב של אלי עוד מהימים שלמדו יחד בתיכון. אד נמצא בעיצומו של משבר זוגי, לאחר שהחליט לעזוב את אשתו.
אני מאוד אוהבת ספרים על סודות משפחתיים שנחשפים ועל גאולה עצמית של אנשים לאחר מסע משנה חיים. וזה בדיוק הספר הזה.
הספר כתוב (ומתורגם) נהדר. הסוף קצת ביאס אותי ולכן 4 כוכבים ולא 5. אבל בהחלט ספר מומלץ.
May 31, 2020
Having loved her previous book and giving it five stars I was very much looking forward to reading this one. I did enjoy it however I was a little underwhelmed when comparing it to her last book.
I liked the main characters, the story had a good plot and had a few twists and turns which I guessed. It was a nice enough story but it wasn’t anything unique and I found it very predictable.
I liked the main characters, the story had a good plot and had a few twists and turns which I guessed. It was a nice enough story but it wasn’t anything unique and I found it very predictable.
October 22, 2020
3 stars.
i thought it would be one of those books that i'd read in a day or two, but i just could not get into it.
Not bad story line, but a bit overdone at times.
i thought it would be one of those books that i'd read in a day or two, but i just could not get into it.
Not bad story line, but a bit overdone at times.
January 28, 2020
2.5★
I was expecting to like this, and once I started, I thought that I was really going to enjoy this. But it quite quickly descended into sentimentality and eye-rolling predictability. Ed really irritated me, with his "poor me" attitude hidden behind a facade of stoicism, and the more I found out about Peggy, the more she irritated me too. Allie felt like she was alternating between naïvete and romantic soppiness. I liked her Dad the best of all the characters, I think.
But perhaps the fault was in how I read it - I didn't get many extended times of reading when I started it, so I was reading a chapter here and a couple of chapters there.
Despite the fact that I wasn't overly impressed, thank you to Simon & Schuster for my copy to read and review.
I was expecting to like this, and once I started, I thought that I was really going to enjoy this. But it quite quickly descended into sentimentality and eye-rolling predictability. Ed really irritated me, with his "poor me" attitude hidden behind a facade of stoicism, and the more I found out about Peggy, the more she irritated me too. Allie felt like she was alternating between naïvete and romantic soppiness. I liked her Dad the best of all the characters, I think.
But perhaps the fault was in how I read it - I didn't get many extended times of reading when I started it, so I was reading a chapter here and a couple of chapters there.
Despite the fact that I wasn't overly impressed, thank you to Simon & Schuster for my copy to read and review.
June 13, 2021
Reading this was a little bittersweet. Lake Garda was one of the last places I visited before the pandemic hit and would have loved to spend more time exploring it. So, in a way it was nice to be transported back there with this book and getting to know the places a bit better.
As a story this is about just as predictable as you'd expect - and that's fine, because sometimes you need something that you know will end in a certain way. There are two main storylines and I think especially the historical one actually sheds light on how much things have changed in just a few decades, for the better. I also liked that this deals with some heavy issues but with tables turned and does it pretty well. As a whole this is well-written, has some substance and is a perfect escape from reality.
As a story this is about just as predictable as you'd expect - and that's fine, because sometimes you need something that you know will end in a certain way. There are two main storylines and I think especially the historical one actually sheds light on how much things have changed in just a few decades, for the better. I also liked that this deals with some heavy issues but with tables turned and does it pretty well. As a whole this is well-written, has some substance and is a perfect escape from reality.
March 10, 2021
This was a very easy book to read - a classic summer, beach read.
Whilst I didn’t find there was much ‘depth’ to the book (the characters, the plot line etc) I wasn’t reading it for a heavy read and it was exactly what I wanted and expected it to be. I liked the Italian elements of the plot - I was reading during the cold winter days in England, so losing myself in sunny Italy was very welcome!
There was a slight twist about 2/3rds of the way through the book which I didn’t expect and I enjoyed this element, often in ‘chick lit’ style books the novel is predictable from start to finish and this was a pleasant surprise.
For an easy, relaxing read I would recommend.
Whilst I didn’t find there was much ‘depth’ to the book (the characters, the plot line etc) I wasn’t reading it for a heavy read and it was exactly what I wanted and expected it to be. I liked the Italian elements of the plot - I was reading during the cold winter days in England, so losing myself in sunny Italy was very welcome!
There was a slight twist about 2/3rds of the way through the book which I didn’t expect and I enjoyed this element, often in ‘chick lit’ style books the novel is predictable from start to finish and this was a pleasant surprise.
For an easy, relaxing read I would recommend.
November 28, 2019
*Book provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review*
I can't even describe how excited I was for this book. Ever since Catherine Isaac published You Me Everything last year, I wanted more. And she topped it with this!!!
We follow Allie in this story, who is an academic research scientist and has always been careful and organized in her life.
Well, she finds a letter in grandmother's things, talking about a possible boyfriend her mother had, when she was young, namely 9 months before Allie was born. She can't ask her mother, because she died when she was six years old. Her grandmother didn't want to talk about the topic, so Allie decides to go to Italy and find out herself.
Always by her side is her best friend Ed. They have been best friends since childhood. Ed is married to Julia, but things aren't easy. Him going away with Allie doesn't help.
Well, their path leads them and us readers on a journey through Italy. The way of finding Stefano isn't easy, they are not successful everywhere. Of course, they spend a lot of time together and one thing kind of leads to another.
When they eventually find Stefano, things also turn out to be a bit different than expected.
The great thing about this story: we can read it from different perspectives: Allie, Ed and also the grandmother, which means we learn a lot about her past as well as Allie's mum's past.
I loved seeing Italy through their eyes and I think Catherine Isaac captured all their feelings beautifully, it was very touching and emotional. A roller-coaster ride with ups and downs and the ending, omg, quite something.
I can't even describe how excited I was for this book. Ever since Catherine Isaac published You Me Everything last year, I wanted more. And she topped it with this!!!
We follow Allie in this story, who is an academic research scientist and has always been careful and organized in her life.
Well, she finds a letter in grandmother's things, talking about a possible boyfriend her mother had, when she was young, namely 9 months before Allie was born. She can't ask her mother, because she died when she was six years old. Her grandmother didn't want to talk about the topic, so Allie decides to go to Italy and find out herself.
Always by her side is her best friend Ed. They have been best friends since childhood. Ed is married to Julia, but things aren't easy. Him going away with Allie doesn't help.
Well, their path leads them and us readers on a journey through Italy. The way of finding Stefano isn't easy, they are not successful everywhere. Of course, they spend a lot of time together and one thing kind of leads to another.
When they eventually find Stefano, things also turn out to be a bit different than expected.
The great thing about this story: we can read it from different perspectives: Allie, Ed and also the grandmother, which means we learn a lot about her past as well as Allie's mum's past.
I loved seeing Italy through their eyes and I think Catherine Isaac captured all their feelings beautifully, it was very touching and emotional. A roller-coaster ride with ups and downs and the ending, omg, quite something.
August 7, 2023
Notă: 4.5⭐/5
Gen: Contemporary Romance
•
🍋 A fost o lectură ușor diferită față de ce citesc de obicei, dar asta poate doar să mă bucure. Aveam nevoie de o gură de aer proaspăt. Inițial, am crezut că va fi o poveste drăguță romance și cam atât. Am fost surprinsă să descopăr că nu este cazul. Pe parcursul acestei cărți putem urmări diferite fire narative, astfel aflând povestea mai multor personaje.
•
🍋 Mi-au plăcut subiectele abordate, poveștile de viață ale personajelor și stilul de scriere. Cartea aceasta a reușit să mă emoționeze și să-mi stârnească întrebări. Nu pot să dau mai multe din casă, dar un lucru e cert – a fost o lectură de 4.5 steluțe.
•
🍋 Dacă sunteți în căutarea unui roman cu un stil alert și cu multe întâmplări pe parcurs nu vi-l recomand neapărat pe acesta, deoarece s-ar putea să vă plictisească.
Messy Wonderful Us este o înțesare de povești ale mai multor personaje, cu scop mediativ.
Gen: Contemporary Romance
•
🍋 A fost o lectură ușor diferită față de ce citesc de obicei, dar asta poate doar să mă bucure. Aveam nevoie de o gură de aer proaspăt. Inițial, am crezut că va fi o poveste drăguță romance și cam atât. Am fost surprinsă să descopăr că nu este cazul. Pe parcursul acestei cărți putem urmări diferite fire narative, astfel aflând povestea mai multor personaje.
•
🍋 Mi-au plăcut subiectele abordate, poveștile de viață ale personajelor și stilul de scriere. Cartea aceasta a reușit să mă emoționeze și să-mi stârnească întrebări. Nu pot să dau mai multe din casă, dar un lucru e cert – a fost o lectură de 4.5 steluțe.
•
🍋 Dacă sunteți în căutarea unui roman cu un stil alert și cu multe întâmplări pe parcurs nu vi-l recomand neapărat pe acesta, deoarece s-ar putea să vă plictisească.
Messy Wonderful Us este o înțesare de povești ale mai multor personaje, cu scop mediativ.
December 27, 2020
WOW... Really, W.O.W.
1. Top book dad - CHECK
2. Top top book grandparents (how many of those exist?) - CHECK
3. Healthy family dynamics - CHECK
3. A protagonist who didn't make stupid decisions - CHECK
4. Mesmerising locations - CHECK
5. Wonderful book cover - CHECK.
This book checked so many boxes for me. Reducing one star for the mild infodump that I had to speed through, but that was inconsequential in the grand scheme of things .
Allie Culpepper finds a strange photograph in her grandmother's dresser drawer during a Christmas dinner, which leads her to question her entire existence. She begins a journey to find some answers and uncover secrets of her past with the help of her best friend, Ed Holt, who himself is not having the best time in his marriage. Will Allie learn the truth about herself? Will she like the things she learns after all these years of familial harmony?
Allie is a rather likeable protagonist, even if she comes across as dense sometimes . She is pretty level-headed, incredibly smart (PhD Dr. ooo la la), and has been taught to take life as it comes. Her family consists of her father and maternal grandparents who love her to death and want to always protect her (even at thirty-three). I love these healthy family dynamics, where folks look out for each other and the amount of drama is minimal so as to not stray from the main plot line. She has a close-knit group of friends and then her best friend Ed, with whom she embarks on a journey of self-discovery (in which he is sooooo supportive of her). I wouldn't say this book is 100% romance, although love is a major contributor to the plot and character agency, which sits well with me - but this essentially fits better as women's fiction (the case in most of my recent romance reads).
Reading about sunny Italy, Lake Garda and Portofino and the vineyards, made me want to pack my bags and jet set (damn you, COVID)! Contrast that with the dreary and wet Liverpool, I couldn't have asked for more setting-wise in a book. A blend of science, entrepreneurship, family, life, love, and friendship in the various sub plots made for wholesome reading. Isaac is definitely an author I'm going to keep an eye out for.
1. Top book dad - CHECK
2. Top top book grandparents (how many of those exist?) - CHECK
3. Healthy family dynamics - CHECK
3. A protagonist who didn't make stupid decisions - CHECK
4. Mesmerising locations - CHECK
5. Wonderful book cover - CHECK.
This book checked so many boxes for me. Reducing one star for the mild infodump that I had to speed through, but that was inconsequential in the grand scheme of things .
Allie Culpepper finds a strange photograph in her grandmother's dresser drawer during a Christmas dinner, which leads her to question her entire existence. She begins a journey to find some answers and uncover secrets of her past with the help of her best friend, Ed Holt, who himself is not having the best time in his marriage. Will Allie learn the truth about herself? Will she like the things she learns after all these years of familial harmony?
Allie is a rather likeable protagonist, even if she comes across as dense sometimes . She is pretty level-headed, incredibly smart (PhD Dr. ooo la la), and has been taught to take life as it comes. Her family consists of her father and maternal grandparents who love her to death and want to always protect her (even at thirty-three). I love these healthy family dynamics, where folks look out for each other and the amount of drama is minimal so as to not stray from the main plot line. She has a close-knit group of friends and then her best friend Ed, with whom she embarks on a journey of self-discovery (in which he is sooooo supportive of her). I wouldn't say this book is 100% romance, although love is a major contributor to the plot and character agency, which sits well with me - but this essentially fits better as women's fiction (the case in most of my recent romance reads).
Reading about sunny Italy, Lake Garda and Portofino and the vineyards, made me want to pack my bags and jet set (damn you, COVID)! Contrast that with the dreary and wet Liverpool, I couldn't have asked for more setting-wise in a book. A blend of science, entrepreneurship, family, life, love, and friendship in the various sub plots made for wholesome reading. Isaac is definitely an author I'm going to keep an eye out for.
May 7, 2021
Povestea iubirii noastre este o poveste de dragoste călduță, exact ca o zi de primăvară însorită, cu raze care te mângâie blând pe față. Nu este povestea aia memorabilă, care să te impresioneze până la lacrimi. E mai aproape de normalitate, de banalitate. Allie și Ed sunt personaje cu care te poți identifica ușor, iar călătoria pe care o fac împreună e revelatoare din multe puncte de vedere.
Pornind în căutarea adevărului, Allie dezgroapă secrete dureroase, îngropate cu mult timp în urmă; secrete care redeschid răni mai vechi, dar care readuc înapoi speranța – speranța că nu e prea târziu. Nici să ierți, nici să iubești.
Citește toată recenzia ⬇️
http://momenteinviata.ro/povestea-iub...
Pornind în căutarea adevărului, Allie dezgroapă secrete dureroase, îngropate cu mult timp în urmă; secrete care redeschid răni mai vechi, dar care readuc înapoi speranța – speranța că nu e prea târziu. Nici să ierți, nici să iubești.
Citește toată recenzia ⬇️
http://momenteinviata.ro/povestea-iub...
January 25, 2024
4.25/5. This is not a romance novel. Instead it is about Allie's quest for the truth about her roots and the woman who has some of the answers to Allie's questions, but whose own trauma prevents her from divulging the secrets of the past. And there are secrets upon secrets, more than most families have in their closet. There is a romantic side story but it did not dominate the book, which is fine, because Allie's slow unveiling of her past is quite fascinating. The author knows how to keep us guessing and captivated. I will be back for more.
Excellent nararation
Excellent nararation
March 10, 2020
Allie’s world is one filled with love and family. But when she accidentally opens an envelope in her Grandmothers drawer, her whole safe world begins to crumble.
I fell in love with Catherine Isaac’s writing style. It is beautiful, well-paced not to heavy on mushy emotion but just the right amount for you to connect and care about the characters. A terrific story weaver, tentatively giving you the bits of the puzzle to fit together and just when you think you have it solved whooshing you off with a new twist.
At the heart of the book is the affect secrets have on our lives. How many times do we not cause a scene or express our feelings because we wouldn’t want to make a scene or create a fuss? How many opportunities are missed in life because we are taught to have that wall of the face we put out to the world? In the book as well as secrets in her family, Allie has them too. But the angst it brought me as I read the book wondering what would happen was incredible. I could see and feel everything as it played out.
Italy plays a key character in the book and the descriptions were so perfect. Garda is an area I have visited and Catherine Isaac captures it perfectly.
My absolute favourite character was Granny Peggy. It was nice to see the history of the older characters in the book as well as following the younger Allie and Ed on their mission. Seeing life through Peggy in the ’60s was fascinating and heartbreaking.
The copy I read was the paperback edition and it is so fresh and lemony looking. The light sage green and the lemons on the front is a gorgeous and beautiful addition to my bookcase.
Catherine Isaac is a new firm favourite of my must-buy authors.
A talented storyteller with a knack for pulling on the heartstrings.
Kelly Lacey
I fell in love with Catherine Isaac’s writing style. It is beautiful, well-paced not to heavy on mushy emotion but just the right amount for you to connect and care about the characters. A terrific story weaver, tentatively giving you the bits of the puzzle to fit together and just when you think you have it solved whooshing you off with a new twist.
At the heart of the book is the affect secrets have on our lives. How many times do we not cause a scene or express our feelings because we wouldn’t want to make a scene or create a fuss? How many opportunities are missed in life because we are taught to have that wall of the face we put out to the world? In the book as well as secrets in her family, Allie has them too. But the angst it brought me as I read the book wondering what would happen was incredible. I could see and feel everything as it played out.
Italy plays a key character in the book and the descriptions were so perfect. Garda is an area I have visited and Catherine Isaac captures it perfectly.
My absolute favourite character was Granny Peggy. It was nice to see the history of the older characters in the book as well as following the younger Allie and Ed on their mission. Seeing life through Peggy in the ’60s was fascinating and heartbreaking.
The copy I read was the paperback edition and it is so fresh and lemony looking. The light sage green and the lemons on the front is a gorgeous and beautiful addition to my bookcase.
Catherine Isaac is a new firm favourite of my must-buy authors.
A talented storyteller with a knack for pulling on the heartstrings.
Kelly Lacey
March 28, 2020
What if loving someone means keeping a secret that will break your heart?
In 1983, Northern Italy, a letter is written and sent. Its recipient hides it away as it contains shocking and unthinkable secrets. Many years later, academic research scientist Allison (Allie) Culpepper finds a photograph along with the hidden letter amongst her gran's possessions. She tries to discuss the revealing contents with her Grandma Peggy, but her Gran refuses to open up to her about it. So Allie decides to take matters into her own hands and takes a trip to Italy, along with her close school friend Ed, to discover the disturbing truth for herself...
Messy, Wonderful Us is a complex story of love, relationships, self discovery, loyalties and responsibilities. Catherine Isaac has made a great job of seamlessly weaving together three timelines to tell the story; Allie's and Ed's in the present day told by each of them; flashback snippets from their friendship over the years; and someone in the past from an (at first) unnamed narrator.
Set against the backdrop of Northern Italy, the author's descriptions of all the places Allie and Ed visited were so vivid that it almost felt that I was there alongside them, while they explored and took in the sights around them. The characterisation by Catherine Isaac was truly masterful and was particularly entranced by Ed's story, although I was still interested in learning more about Allie and the anonymous narrator's past.
Everything was solidly wrapped up in the poignant and believable denouement and I highly recommend this bittersweet tale about the messier side of love and relationships. The richness in detail together with a large smattering of Italian goodness elicit this affecting and riveting read.
I received a complimentary digital copy of this novel at my request, from Simon and Schuster UK via NetGalley. This review is my own unbiased opinion.
In 1983, Northern Italy, a letter is written and sent. Its recipient hides it away as it contains shocking and unthinkable secrets. Many years later, academic research scientist Allison (Allie) Culpepper finds a photograph along with the hidden letter amongst her gran's possessions. She tries to discuss the revealing contents with her Grandma Peggy, but her Gran refuses to open up to her about it. So Allie decides to take matters into her own hands and takes a trip to Italy, along with her close school friend Ed, to discover the disturbing truth for herself...
Messy, Wonderful Us is a complex story of love, relationships, self discovery, loyalties and responsibilities. Catherine Isaac has made a great job of seamlessly weaving together three timelines to tell the story; Allie's and Ed's in the present day told by each of them; flashback snippets from their friendship over the years; and someone in the past from an (at first) unnamed narrator.
Set against the backdrop of Northern Italy, the author's descriptions of all the places Allie and Ed visited were so vivid that it almost felt that I was there alongside them, while they explored and took in the sights around them. The characterisation by Catherine Isaac was truly masterful and was particularly entranced by Ed's story, although I was still interested in learning more about Allie and the anonymous narrator's past.
Everything was solidly wrapped up in the poignant and believable denouement and I highly recommend this bittersweet tale about the messier side of love and relationships. The richness in detail together with a large smattering of Italian goodness elicit this affecting and riveting read.
I received a complimentary digital copy of this novel at my request, from Simon and Schuster UK via NetGalley. This review is my own unbiased opinion.
May 29, 2019
Unfolding from the viewpoints of Allie, Ed and an unnamed girl, (whose chapters are italicised) that is speaking of the past, as the present, Messy, Wonderful Us is a touching tale of friendship, love, regret, and second chances.
Allie and Ed have been friends since adolescence, and remain so in their early thirties, despite periods of both physical and emotional distance.
Allie, an academic research scientist, who lost her mother as a young girl to cancer, is devastated when she finds a photograph that seems to suggest her beloved Dad, Joe, may not be her father. When Allie’s grandmother refuses to assuage her suspicions, Allie decides to find answers for herself, arranging a trip to Italy in search of the man who shares the gap between her front teeth.
Ed, a successful business owner, shocks everyone when he leaves his wife of two years, offering nothing but the vaguest of explanations. Julia, unwilling to accept her husband’s decision, begs Allie for her help, and so Allie allows Ed to join her on her quest.
As Allie, urged on by Ed, crisscrosses Italy in search of answers about her past, the pair are forced to face some uncomfortable truths and make some difficult decisions.
Ed and Julia’s supposedly blissful marriage is not what it seems, exactly why, he is reluctant to admit. Isaac treats the secret with sensitivity, and I thought the reversal of perspective of an oft used trope was examined in a thought-provoking manner.
Allie is rocked by the answer to her questions, but it’s the time spent with Ed that has the greatest effect on her life. To be honest, I found Allie a little insipid, she’s generally not very decisive and I have to admit I was disappointed somewhat by one element of the ending. Perhaps it’s petty of me, but I didn’t feel Allie, and therefore Isaac, made the right decision.
That said, I do like Ed and Allie together, though their situation is messy, Issac hits the right notes with their relationship, making it seem genuine. I also really appreciated the epilogue of sorts.
Messy, Wonderful Us is a likeable novel, and though I wasn’t wowed by it, I did find aspects of it thought provoking and engaging.
Allie and Ed have been friends since adolescence, and remain so in their early thirties, despite periods of both physical and emotional distance.
Allie, an academic research scientist, who lost her mother as a young girl to cancer, is devastated when she finds a photograph that seems to suggest her beloved Dad, Joe, may not be her father. When Allie’s grandmother refuses to assuage her suspicions, Allie decides to find answers for herself, arranging a trip to Italy in search of the man who shares the gap between her front teeth.
Ed, a successful business owner, shocks everyone when he leaves his wife of two years, offering nothing but the vaguest of explanations. Julia, unwilling to accept her husband’s decision, begs Allie for her help, and so Allie allows Ed to join her on her quest.
As Allie, urged on by Ed, crisscrosses Italy in search of answers about her past, the pair are forced to face some uncomfortable truths and make some difficult decisions.
Ed and Julia’s supposedly blissful marriage is not what it seems, exactly why, he is reluctant to admit. Isaac treats the secret with sensitivity, and I thought the reversal of perspective of an oft used trope was examined in a thought-provoking manner.
Allie is rocked by the answer to her questions, but it’s the time spent with Ed that has the greatest effect on her life. To be honest, I found Allie a little insipid, she’s generally not very decisive and I have to admit I was disappointed somewhat by one element of the ending. Perhaps it’s petty of me, but I didn’t feel Allie, and therefore Isaac, made the right decision.
That said, I do like Ed and Allie together, though their situation is messy, Issac hits the right notes with their relationship, making it seem genuine. I also really appreciated the epilogue of sorts.
Messy, Wonderful Us is a likeable novel, and though I wasn’t wowed by it, I did find aspects of it thought provoking and engaging.
August 21, 2020
When Allie unearths an old letter hidden away in her grandmother's drawer it opens up a Pandora's box of family secrets. Determined to find out the truth Allie hires a private detective, which leads her on a journey to Italy to piece together her past. Accompanying her is Ed, her best friend since childhood. Ed is going through a tough patch in his marriage and needs some space and time to himself. Will Allie and Ed find what they are seeking in Italy, and how will their time away shape both their futures?
I have always enjoyed this author's works as Jane Costello, and also liked her last book, You, Me Everything, which took a turn away from her usual romantic comedies, and was impressed by her handling of more complex issues. In this book, Isaac once again chooses to handle some more weighty issues, the tone of the story more mature than in her work as Jane Costello. Unfortunately, for me personally I didn't think this book worked as well as her last, although that being said I did find it for the most part a pleasant read.
The story is told at quite a slow pace, which in many ways suits the tone, as it is quite introspective and reflective, matching the mindsets of both Allie and Ed. That said, I found the beginning especially slow and even later there were many chapters when not much at all seemed to happen. I certainly preferred the parts of the story set in Italy, and thought Isaac did a good job of capturing the atmosphere and settings, and indeed the book would probably make for a good holiday read.
There are quite a few sub-plots within the book, including Allie's search into her family's past, Ed's marriage struggles, as well as flashback chapters that detail Allie and Ed's relationship over the years, and chapters from an initially unnamed narrator set in the past. To Isaac's credit, it was quite easy to navigate the book despite the switches in time frame and narrator, and she did have some surprises in store and twists that I wasn't expecting at the start. Indeed, if you think you've guessed it all at the start of the story, most likely you haven't, in which case I would stick with it, as the truth unravels slowly. This mystery aspect of the book was actually one if its strengths I thought.
Allie as the central character is generally likable. She's a studious, work-centered character, who has been through some difficult periods in her life, having lost her mother when she was young. I could certainly appreciate the emotional turmoil she must have been going through along her search in Italy, and liked the quiet dignity with which she always carried herself. At times she could perhaps be a little passive, and also a little shut off, certainly she's not the sort of character one would likely turn to when needing a shoulder to cry on, and at times I thought she shut down Ed when he was trying to open up to her.
Ed, I did also like, though it takes a little while to understand what is going on in his life. I think Isaac deserves credit for highlighting and raising more awareness of the issues that Ed was facing, however, I'm not sure I liked her depiction of his wife, Julia. Whilst her portrayal for most of the book was alright for me, towards the end it just steered completely into mental bunny-boiler mode, which I wasn't too keen on. In fact I wasn't really too keen on the last 20% of the book at all, as things just got very melodramatic, which wasn't I felt in keeping with the tone of the book up to that point.
I liked Allie and Eds relationship, especially the flashback chapters, and just how comfortable they were with each other. However at times I thought Isaac handled their interactions a little stiffly, they spoke very formally to each other at times, which didn't necessarily feel like the way two people who knew each other so well would talk to each other in real life.
At times I almost felt as though Isaac was trying too hard to write something more 'mature' or 'weighty'. For instance I thought she went into unnecessary detail with regards to Allie's job as a researcher into Cystic Fibrosis, and sometimes the characters came across as too serious. The book is described as escapist and feel good, but I'm not sure I'd quite agree with that, as parts of it were rather depressing. It also lacked a bit in humour, which whilst I appreciate she is moving away from her previous romantic comedies, I liked the balance she achieved in You, Me Everything, which handled more mature issues, whilst at the same time had zest and humour in it, a bit like Jojo Moyes' books. This one in comparison felt a bit forced and dry.
I have always enjoyed this author's works as Jane Costello, and also liked her last book, You, Me Everything, which took a turn away from her usual romantic comedies, and was impressed by her handling of more complex issues. In this book, Isaac once again chooses to handle some more weighty issues, the tone of the story more mature than in her work as Jane Costello. Unfortunately, for me personally I didn't think this book worked as well as her last, although that being said I did find it for the most part a pleasant read.
The story is told at quite a slow pace, which in many ways suits the tone, as it is quite introspective and reflective, matching the mindsets of both Allie and Ed. That said, I found the beginning especially slow and even later there were many chapters when not much at all seemed to happen. I certainly preferred the parts of the story set in Italy, and thought Isaac did a good job of capturing the atmosphere and settings, and indeed the book would probably make for a good holiday read.
There are quite a few sub-plots within the book, including Allie's search into her family's past, Ed's marriage struggles, as well as flashback chapters that detail Allie and Ed's relationship over the years, and chapters from an initially unnamed narrator set in the past. To Isaac's credit, it was quite easy to navigate the book despite the switches in time frame and narrator, and she did have some surprises in store and twists that I wasn't expecting at the start. Indeed, if you think you've guessed it all at the start of the story, most likely you haven't, in which case I would stick with it, as the truth unravels slowly. This mystery aspect of the book was actually one if its strengths I thought.
Allie as the central character is generally likable. She's a studious, work-centered character, who has been through some difficult periods in her life, having lost her mother when she was young. I could certainly appreciate the emotional turmoil she must have been going through along her search in Italy, and liked the quiet dignity with which she always carried herself. At times she could perhaps be a little passive, and also a little shut off, certainly she's not the sort of character one would likely turn to when needing a shoulder to cry on, and at times I thought she shut down Ed when he was trying to open up to her.
Ed, I did also like, though it takes a little while to understand what is going on in his life. I think Isaac deserves credit for highlighting and raising more awareness of the issues that Ed was facing, however, I'm not sure I liked her depiction of his wife, Julia. Whilst her portrayal for most of the book was alright for me, towards the end it just steered completely into mental bunny-boiler mode, which I wasn't too keen on. In fact I wasn't really too keen on the last 20% of the book at all, as things just got very melodramatic, which wasn't I felt in keeping with the tone of the book up to that point.
I liked Allie and Eds relationship, especially the flashback chapters, and just how comfortable they were with each other. However at times I thought Isaac handled their interactions a little stiffly, they spoke very formally to each other at times, which didn't necessarily feel like the way two people who knew each other so well would talk to each other in real life.
At times I almost felt as though Isaac was trying too hard to write something more 'mature' or 'weighty'. For instance I thought she went into unnecessary detail with regards to Allie's job as a researcher into Cystic Fibrosis, and sometimes the characters came across as too serious. The book is described as escapist and feel good, but I'm not sure I'd quite agree with that, as parts of it were rather depressing. It also lacked a bit in humour, which whilst I appreciate she is moving away from her previous romantic comedies, I liked the balance she achieved in You, Me Everything, which handled more mature issues, whilst at the same time had zest and humour in it, a bit like Jojo Moyes' books. This one in comparison felt a bit forced and dry.
January 21, 2020
The thing that intrigued me most while reading, were the different POV's and the time jumps. Apart from our main characters' perspectives - Ed and Allie - we also get glimpses of the past, before Allie was born. Those had me hooked, I tell you. They were full of information, but you had to figure out for yourself how it'd fit into the story. Trying to puzzle it all together really was half the fun!
Basically, there's the past before Allie's birth, the past where we see her budding friendship with Ed and then the present. Those three keep switching throughout the book, making it a wonderful ride in which you see a lot of events and evolution happening.
The emotions! This truly was one hectic ride. There's hope, love and family. There's loss, grief, unanswered questions. There's this undertone of something darker going on, of secrets better kept secrets and.. the combination of all those things had me hooked. I kept wanting to find out what was really going on, how it was all going to fit together. Not to mention what role certain side characters would get in the long run!
Talking about characters.. Although Allie left for Italy in order to find out more about her family, I found it frustrating how she would be there and.. avoid the whole ordeal? I can see how you'd still want to enjoy the country and all, but the avoidance was real and it got on my nerves at times. I felt like it should've been balanced out a bit more. It sometimes took away from the story in a completely unnecessary way.
3.5 / 5
Messy, Wonderful Us is a hectic ride with a lot of emotions, a lot of hard topics and a wonderful story. Although Allie's focus could've been a bit more on getting answers, I did still enjoy reading and couldn't stop turning [digital] pages. An intriguing read that got wrapped up nicely - albeit with a bit of a bang!
Basically, there's the past before Allie's birth, the past where we see her budding friendship with Ed and then the present. Those three keep switching throughout the book, making it a wonderful ride in which you see a lot of events and evolution happening.
The emotions! This truly was one hectic ride. There's hope, love and family. There's loss, grief, unanswered questions. There's this undertone of something darker going on, of secrets better kept secrets and.. the combination of all those things had me hooked. I kept wanting to find out what was really going on, how it was all going to fit together. Not to mention what role certain side characters would get in the long run!
When does fine ever really mean fine?
Talking about characters.. Although Allie left for Italy in order to find out more about her family, I found it frustrating how she would be there and.. avoid the whole ordeal? I can see how you'd still want to enjoy the country and all, but the avoidance was real and it got on my nerves at times. I felt like it should've been balanced out a bit more. It sometimes took away from the story in a completely unnecessary way.
3.5 / 5
Messy, Wonderful Us is a hectic ride with a lot of emotions, a lot of hard topics and a wonderful story. Although Allie's focus could've been a bit more on getting answers, I did still enjoy reading and couldn't stop turning [digital] pages. An intriguing read that got wrapped up nicely - albeit with a bit of a bang!
November 25, 2019
Book reviews on www.snazzybooks.com
Messy, Wonderful Us is the best kind of contemporary romantic fiction – it manages to be sweet without being cloying, romantic without being cheesy, and although you can predict some of what’s going to happen, it still serves up plenty of surprises.
I love the characters in this novel – Allie and Ed are just brilliant, and feel convincing to read about too. It addresses various topics and issues, one of which I won’t say here because it will give away part of the plot, but it’s an issue that isn’t often addressed in books I’ve read about when it’s this way round.
The plot is brilliant; it has various elements – the main one being Allie’s quest to find out who her father is, and what happened all those years ago between her parents. Alongside this is her friendship with Ed, and his relationship with his wife Julia; it all combines to make a really entrancing, interesting read with – warning! – some really sad parts (I was really crying at times) and some more humorous parts too. There’s plenty of gorgeous-sounding travel to Italy (always makes me immediately want to book a trip there) and mysterious parts that have you wondering what really happened years ago…
I’d highly recommend this book, especially to people – like me – who feel that this genre is often too cheesy and overdramatic – this one absolutely isn’t. It’s a wonderful read!
Many thanks to Simon & Schuster for providing a copy of this novel, on which I chose to write an honest and unbiased review.
Messy, Wonderful Us is the best kind of contemporary romantic fiction – it manages to be sweet without being cloying, romantic without being cheesy, and although you can predict some of what’s going to happen, it still serves up plenty of surprises.
I love the characters in this novel – Allie and Ed are just brilliant, and feel convincing to read about too. It addresses various topics and issues, one of which I won’t say here because it will give away part of the plot, but it’s an issue that isn’t often addressed in books I’ve read about when it’s this way round.
The plot is brilliant; it has various elements – the main one being Allie’s quest to find out who her father is, and what happened all those years ago between her parents. Alongside this is her friendship with Ed, and his relationship with his wife Julia; it all combines to make a really entrancing, interesting read with – warning! – some really sad parts (I was really crying at times) and some more humorous parts too. There’s plenty of gorgeous-sounding travel to Italy (always makes me immediately want to book a trip there) and mysterious parts that have you wondering what really happened years ago…
I’d highly recommend this book, especially to people – like me – who feel that this genre is often too cheesy and overdramatic – this one absolutely isn’t. It’s a wonderful read!
Many thanks to Simon & Schuster for providing a copy of this novel, on which I chose to write an honest and unbiased review.
October 3, 2019
This is one of those books that will leave you with a heart-warming smile on your face.
It's a slow-burning story, paced over a short period of time, but with all the memories from the past mixed in with the current events, it makes absolutely perfect and addicting read.
All those unfolding secrets and twists in this book kept me on the edge and made me yearn for more. Lovable characters, beautiful writing style and ability to "show" rather than only "tell" the story makes this book that bit more special and I really recommend you to pick it up and read it.
Allie is off to Italy to find some answers to the questions she can't get from anyone at home. The last-minute, her childhood friend Ed joins her on this trip and together they embark on this journey that will change their and their loved ones lives forever.
This is a story about self-discovery, family relationships, loyalties, support, understanding, commitment, grief and second chances.
It's a slow-burning story, paced over a short period of time, but with all the memories from the past mixed in with the current events, it makes absolutely perfect and addicting read.
All those unfolding secrets and twists in this book kept me on the edge and made me yearn for more. Lovable characters, beautiful writing style and ability to "show" rather than only "tell" the story makes this book that bit more special and I really recommend you to pick it up and read it.
Allie is off to Italy to find some answers to the questions she can't get from anyone at home. The last-minute, her childhood friend Ed joins her on this trip and together they embark on this journey that will change their and their loved ones lives forever.
This is a story about self-discovery, family relationships, loyalties, support, understanding, commitment, grief and second chances.
April 4, 2020
My favourite book I have ever read. After reading this book I definitely want to read more books from this author. At first it appears as though this book is a romantic read but as the story unfolds it's more than just romance as it becomes a family drama. It demonstrates how burying your emotions and lying can have disastrous consequences. I love the relationship between Allie and Ed and desperately want them to become a couple from the start but everytime you think it's about to happen it doesn't. That's what I love about this book, expect the unexpected. It made my heart race, gave me butterflies, made me gasp with shock and almost cry, all the emotions you would experience in a romantic relationship. If that's what you like in a book I would definitely recommend.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 6, 2025
it’s 4am but i’ve just finished the book and ruined my sleeping schedule. I’d say it was a nice book, it was okay.
3 because I felt like it dragged on at certain points. I think the overall plot was interesting. It got me every time with the plot twists. It was interesting seeing Peggy’s (Grandma’s) story and I really felt for her but sometimes her chapters came up at points I did not care to read like after that car crash scene.
Was hoping to see more of what Ed and Allie’s love story would be like after everything so that was kind of underwhelming. HATED Allie’s inability to speak about emotions.
Decent book. Plot was interesting and I was hooked on the last 150 pages but the last chapter underwhelmed me big time after all that.
3 because I felt like it dragged on at certain points. I think the overall plot was interesting. It got me every time with the plot twists. It was interesting seeing Peggy’s (Grandma’s) story and I really felt for her but sometimes her chapters came up at points I did not care to read like after that car crash scene.
Was hoping to see more of what Ed and Allie’s love story would be like after everything so that was kind of underwhelming. HATED Allie’s inability to speak about emotions.
Decent book. Plot was interesting and I was hooked on the last 150 pages but the last chapter underwhelmed me big time after all that.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 17, 2020
Noe av det var intressant, men av og til føltes historien all over the place. Det var mye som ble puttet inn som ikke trengte å være der, som ikke "hjalp" historien videre. Jeg var ikke alltid sikker på hvor gammel karakteren var eller hvor vi "var" før jeg hadde lest en stund. Jeg skulle ønske det kunne vært en liten info ved kapittelene så det ikke ble så forvirrende. Men en god historie, uansett.
August 19, 2019
Highly recommended read, I adored this, such a moving story about family, grief, loss, friendship and seeing beyond friendship. Wonderful twists and turns, amazing writing that makes you want to keep reading after the book ends. A completely unpredictable read for me, nothing predictable at all which I loved.
Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for a free copy for an honest opinion
Thanks to netgalley and the publisher for a free copy for an honest opinion
January 10, 2021
I loved this tale of friendship, romance, the complexities of families and their secrets. The beautiful depiction of Italy made me yearn it; to revisit Verona, discover Porta Fino and all its charms ( not to mention the icecream!). A thoroughly lovely read, a perfect pick me up for beating January blues.
March 29, 2019
At first, I didn't enjoy this book, but as Ed and Allie went off to Italy together, it got so much better.
I didn't expect everything that happened to happen, it was such an emotional rollercoaster.
I will definitely be reading more written by Catherine Isaac!
I didn't expect everything that happened to happen, it was such an emotional rollercoaster.
I will definitely be reading more written by Catherine Isaac!
June 20, 2022
Lovely 'Holiday Read'... I now want to go to Italy
Displaying 1 - 30 of 379 reviews