I really had to write this review, when I saw that all GR reviews of the book are 2- or 3-starred. So, I want to set the record straight. This short story collection is a jewel, a masterpiece. I read it first as a teenager in a partial Italian translation titled "La banda di Barnaby Sheen" and immediately loved it. And did it for over thirty years.
Why should you read this book?
First, you really have to meet Barnaby Sheen and his motley crew. Not all their stories are included here, but some of the best are.
Second, honestly, how many stories do you remember after reading a collection? In this case, you will remember a lot of them, considering that the ideas behind them are too smart and funny to forget: forgotten seasons (Brain Fever Season and Days of Grass Days of Straw), the compression of time in memory (And Read the Flesh Between the Lines), the subjective view of history (Rivers of Damascus), the literally creative nature of art (Dorg), infinity (Been a Long Long Time)... and so on.
Of course, I concede that Lafferty is not for everybody: if you try the book, you might adore it, but you might also hate it. That's a risk. I also concede that Lafferty is not always at his best. Sometimes, his stories are not smart funny but become a little self-serving weird funny and it is difficult to get the point. Well, nobody is perfect. This is why I gave 5 stars to this book. Otherwise, the stars would have been 6.