What do you think?
Rate this book
Under the Earth, Over the Sky
In the woods where human lands meet fae, an ancient king born before the history of men finds a dying baby. Iohmar will take in the child and care for him until a suitable home in the human realm is found. But best laid plans often go awry in the lands of Látwill, where winds carry fae across the star-strewn sky, the woods ensnare the weak-minded with their sinister song, and even Iohmar, King Beneath the Earth, is susceptible to the will of the immortal mountains. Magic long tethered to Iohmar's soul will crumble. Unknown shadows and monsters of mirrored glass will encroach upon the borders of their land. And memories thousands of years lost will unravel as Iohmar struggles not only to properly rule his fair folk, but protect the fragile human son he never should have saved in the first place.
352 pages, Paperback
Published November 8, 2022
236 people are currently reading
9422 people want to read
About the author
Emily McCosh
44 books222 followersEmily McCosh is a graphic designer, writer of strange things, and daydreamer extraordinaire. She currently lives in California with her two parents, two dogs, one fish, one tree swing, and innumerable characters who need to learn some manners. Her fiction has appeared in Beneath Ceaseless Skies, Shimmer Magazine, Galaxy’s Edge, Flash Fiction Online, Nature: Futures, and elsewhere.
Find her online on her writing and bookish YouTube channel, website where she sometimes blogs, and Instagram full of sappy poetry.
YouTube: Emily McCosh
TikTok: emilymccosh
Instagram: emily_mccosh
Blog: oceansinthesky.com
Facebook & Twitter: @wordweaveremily
Find her online on her writing and bookish YouTube channel, website where she sometimes blogs, and Instagram full of sappy poetry.
YouTube: Emily McCosh
TikTok: emilymccosh
Instagram: emily_mccosh
Blog: oceansinthesky.com
Facebook & Twitter: @wordweaveremily
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 269 reviews
August 23, 2023
Alright! I managed to get an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review and I am so glad I did! As you can see this got 5 stars, so I would like to mention that I am a rather tough rater who rates based on both enjoyment and a more analytic view, and so I don’t really give out many of these. But this book deserved it for sure because it was a masterpiece. I will be recommending Under the Earth, Over the Sky to everyone from now on and it is definitely going on my favorites shelf for rereads. It did however take me longer to read than I would like to admit but that's because I was super busy and I can promise you almost ever spare second I had was spent reading this amazing book.
The story starts with Iohmar, the fae king, finding a human baby in his woods. The baby’s mother has just died and this basically ageless fae has no idea what to do—he can’t take the child because he would be breaking his own laws, but then he also feels he can’t leave it. In the end after seeing that the baby’s father is a horrible man, Iohmar decides to take the child home to his Fair Halls until he can find him a suitable home. Of course then he gets attached and decides to keep it and hides him in his chambers. But this human child is sickly and dying and Iohmar has no idea what to do about it but he knows he can’t just let this child die because it seems wrong and he really is starting to get attached and protective, so he goes searching for someone to help this human child. Thus begins a search deep into his mountains, one that will cost Iohmar a part of himself, a part willingly given in order to save this human child he has taken in as his own. But this isn't the only thing that plagues his land, shadowy figures that only appear to him and don't seem to be able to speak have started haunting his steps, old enemies long since seen are pressing against their borders and a strange sickness begins to affect Iohmar that doesn't have any known cure or cause.
Okay so not only did this book have chapter titles! But it also had a table of contents! Sorted into SEASONS! I literally opened it and just stared for a few minutes because I couldn’t get over it. Then when I got over it enough to move onto the next page there was a Lord of the Rings quote and a map so I got amazed all over again. Then! Yes there’s more! The different seasons where separated into sections and the beginning of each new season had a beautiful piece of artwork in these really bright and vibrant colors (artwork done by the author btw). I just loved it! So A+ on overwhelming the reader with your awesomeness in the first five pages.
Probably the two biggest things that really stood out to me and made this book so great was how the world was portrayed and the relationships between the characters. I’ll start with the latter.
~ The most focused on is the father-son relationship between Iohmar and the child (who he does name earlier on but I’ll leave that for you to find out when you read this book so I’m just going to call him the child). It made me cry it was just so sweet and wholesome that it made me (who never really cry's about stuff like this btw) start randomly bawling my eyes out because it was such a beautiful relationship. The nicknames were adorable too, like he called him “the grub” a few times in the beginning which was funny but then he called him “his little boy”, *sniffles* his little boy. Then later there were a few more that were just as adorable but I’ll leave you to find out what they were. My heart simply melted over this super sweet and wholesome relationship. In fact it touched me so much that I ranted about it to my mother and probably overwhelmed her but I literally cannot stress enough how adorable their relationship is and we need more healthy father-son relationships in literature.
~ Then there was the relationship between Iohmar and Galen which I also loved but in a more amused way. It was a mentor/caretaker and his charge sort of thing but their relationship was really wholesome and good too. It was funny how Galen would scold Iohmar, this millennia old fae king, and Iohmar would actually feel bad. Like he would act like a child who was being told off by his mother for sneaking candy. It also said at one point that the younger fae would come to him for advice and stuff and that he was like the father figure of the whole Hall, so that made me like Galen’s character even more. And the way his disapproving looks are described from Iohmar’s POV just made everything better because you can literally picture it.
~ There was Iohmar and Rúnda too which ended up being really sweet and cute. I was expecting to be disappointed because everything was going too well, I hadn’t found anything I didn’t like yet and I was bracing myself for the worst. I was very pleasantly surprised with this super cute couple I could ship without feeling guilty about it. I was nervous for Rúnda to be introduced because I had no idea what to expect and I felt like everything was going too smoothly and so figured something was going to go wrong. But things went great and I immediately fell in love her character. She was playful and free spirited and just kind of cute (so basically I adored all these characters) And get this, no smut. Like THANK YOU!
Just as there was no smut there was no cursing! This book was very clean, especially compared to some others I won’t name, particularly for a fae centered book which are honestly disgusting and toxic for the most part now days. But I just really appreciated that. There were a few very subtle mentions of ‘making love’ mostly in past tense, but honestly I barely noticed and they were just very brief unimportant mentions. Which again is much appreciated!
Another thing I really liked that I would like to mention before moving on to the world was that Iohmar was a kind and just king unlike a lot of the fae kings out there who are seductive and cruel and rather toxic and have little to no morals, so that was a really nice change. You could really tell he cared about his people and Rúnda and her people and the child and just everything really, he was clearly very caring and kind in general. But the awesome thing is, not only could you tell from his thoughts but also through his actions. He was always showing his loving and caring nature, whether to the child, Galen, his kingsguard, Rúnda or just to a random faerie that comes up to him. But one thing I really liked was how he mourns. For his parents, for lost friends, for his people, for a human woman he didn’t even know, even for his lost memories. So instead of becoming distant and viewing life as short and meaningless for others, he became more compassionate in his however many millennia and it taught him to view life in a different (very beautiful) way. That just really touched me. As you go through the book more of his character and backstory is revealed and it was done perfectly making me fall in love with his character and this story even more. So yeah I really enjoyed reading this book from his point of view.
Now on to the world. It was absolutely beautiful. The way that McCosh explains it via her poetic writing style had all the whimsy of a cozy fantasy. It felt like walking through an enchanted forest and I adored every bit of it. As someone who prefers a more poetic style this really hit the spot for me and I truly think Under the Earth, Over the Sky was a masterpiece simply for how well McCosh portrayed the beautiful and whimsical yet somehow melancholy picture that makes this book so magical and infinite feelings. Like she actually managed to create the feeling of infinity through Iohmar! Something similar that really stood out to me was the way that time passed. It was incredibly intriguing and original. Since the book was from Iohmar’s POV the way time passed was how he saw it and being several millennia old made it different from how you and I see it. Honestly for me, who has a very open and curious way of looking at the universe and time, this element of the story really stuck with me and I thought it was portrayed rather well for such a difficult topic. So it was just overall very intriguing and I absolutely loved it!
The side characters, and really all the characters in general, were very well written. They had a unique life of their own that made them memorable and separate because they didn’t necessarily exist to further the main characters story, even if they only had one line they still stuck with you.
The storyline itself was amazing too considering it was slow but still held my attention till the end. There was a clear goal in mind but then it didn't solely revolve around that goal, there were other smaller things and day to day life weaves in instead of one driven purpose. The whole ending and reason for the shadows was a bit predictable but I don't think I would have been able to guess correctly if I didn't write myself and so look at books with the analytic view of a writer. It was very nicely foreshadowed and didn't have any gaps or plot holes though which is impressive.
Literally the one and only thing I didn't like about this book was that now that I'm finished it's over. I want to know more! See the child growing up more and see all the other events long term affects! Learn more about the characters and the world and the past. Don't get me wrong, the book was a perfect length, not too long or short. It's just that I, as a reader, don't want to leave this magical world that Miss Emily has crafted yet.
Overall, if you love a well thought out book with meaningful relationships, a beautiful world and don’t mind a slower pace, then this book is for you.
The story starts with Iohmar, the fae king, finding a human baby in his woods. The baby’s mother has just died and this basically ageless fae has no idea what to do—he can’t take the child because he would be breaking his own laws, but then he also feels he can’t leave it. In the end after seeing that the baby’s father is a horrible man, Iohmar decides to take the child home to his Fair Halls until he can find him a suitable home. Of course then he gets attached and decides to keep it and hides him in his chambers. But this human child is sickly and dying and Iohmar has no idea what to do about it but he knows he can’t just let this child die because it seems wrong and he really is starting to get attached and protective, so he goes searching for someone to help this human child. Thus begins a search deep into his mountains, one that will cost Iohmar a part of himself, a part willingly given in order to save this human child he has taken in as his own. But this isn't the only thing that plagues his land, shadowy figures that only appear to him and don't seem to be able to speak have started haunting his steps, old enemies long since seen are pressing against their borders and a strange sickness begins to affect Iohmar that doesn't have any known cure or cause.
Okay so not only did this book have chapter titles! But it also had a table of contents! Sorted into SEASONS! I literally opened it and just stared for a few minutes because I couldn’t get over it. Then when I got over it enough to move onto the next page there was a Lord of the Rings quote and a map so I got amazed all over again. Then! Yes there’s more! The different seasons where separated into sections and the beginning of each new season had a beautiful piece of artwork in these really bright and vibrant colors (artwork done by the author btw). I just loved it! So A+ on overwhelming the reader with your awesomeness in the first five pages.
Probably the two biggest things that really stood out to me and made this book so great was how the world was portrayed and the relationships between the characters. I’ll start with the latter.
~ The most focused on is the father-son relationship between Iohmar and the child (who he does name earlier on but I’ll leave that for you to find out when you read this book so I’m just going to call him the child). It made me cry it was just so sweet and wholesome that it made me (who never really cry's about stuff like this btw) start randomly bawling my eyes out because it was such a beautiful relationship. The nicknames were adorable too, like he called him “the grub” a few times in the beginning which was funny but then he called him “his little boy”, *sniffles* his little boy. Then later there were a few more that were just as adorable but I’ll leave you to find out what they were. My heart simply melted over this super sweet and wholesome relationship. In fact it touched me so much that I ranted about it to my mother and probably overwhelmed her but I literally cannot stress enough how adorable their relationship is and we need more healthy father-son relationships in literature.
~ Then there was the relationship between Iohmar and Galen which I also loved but in a more amused way. It was a mentor/caretaker and his charge sort of thing but their relationship was really wholesome and good too. It was funny how Galen would scold Iohmar, this millennia old fae king, and Iohmar would actually feel bad. Like he would act like a child who was being told off by his mother for sneaking candy. It also said at one point that the younger fae would come to him for advice and stuff and that he was like the father figure of the whole Hall, so that made me like Galen’s character even more. And the way his disapproving looks are described from Iohmar’s POV just made everything better because you can literally picture it.
~ There was Iohmar and Rúnda too which ended up being really sweet and cute. I was expecting to be disappointed because everything was going too well, I hadn’t found anything I didn’t like yet and I was bracing myself for the worst. I was very pleasantly surprised with this super cute couple I could ship without feeling guilty about it. I was nervous for Rúnda to be introduced because I had no idea what to expect and I felt like everything was going too smoothly and so figured something was going to go wrong. But things went great and I immediately fell in love her character. She was playful and free spirited and just kind of cute (so basically I adored all these characters) And get this, no smut. Like THANK YOU!
Just as there was no smut there was no cursing! This book was very clean, especially compared to some others I won’t name, particularly for a fae centered book which are honestly disgusting and toxic for the most part now days. But I just really appreciated that. There were a few very subtle mentions of ‘making love’ mostly in past tense, but honestly I barely noticed and they were just very brief unimportant mentions. Which again is much appreciated!
Another thing I really liked that I would like to mention before moving on to the world was that Iohmar was a kind and just king unlike a lot of the fae kings out there who are seductive and cruel and rather toxic and have little to no morals, so that was a really nice change. You could really tell he cared about his people and Rúnda and her people and the child and just everything really, he was clearly very caring and kind in general. But the awesome thing is, not only could you tell from his thoughts but also through his actions. He was always showing his loving and caring nature, whether to the child, Galen, his kingsguard, Rúnda or just to a random faerie that comes up to him. But one thing I really liked was how he mourns. For his parents, for lost friends, for his people, for a human woman he didn’t even know, even for his lost memories. So instead of becoming distant and viewing life as short and meaningless for others, he became more compassionate in his however many millennia and it taught him to view life in a different (very beautiful) way. That just really touched me. As you go through the book more of his character and backstory is revealed and it was done perfectly making me fall in love with his character and this story even more. So yeah I really enjoyed reading this book from his point of view.
Now on to the world. It was absolutely beautiful. The way that McCosh explains it via her poetic writing style had all the whimsy of a cozy fantasy. It felt like walking through an enchanted forest and I adored every bit of it. As someone who prefers a more poetic style this really hit the spot for me and I truly think Under the Earth, Over the Sky was a masterpiece simply for how well McCosh portrayed the beautiful and whimsical yet somehow melancholy picture that makes this book so magical and infinite feelings. Like she actually managed to create the feeling of infinity through Iohmar! Something similar that really stood out to me was the way that time passed. It was incredibly intriguing and original. Since the book was from Iohmar’s POV the way time passed was how he saw it and being several millennia old made it different from how you and I see it. Honestly for me, who has a very open and curious way of looking at the universe and time, this element of the story really stuck with me and I thought it was portrayed rather well for such a difficult topic. So it was just overall very intriguing and I absolutely loved it!
The side characters, and really all the characters in general, were very well written. They had a unique life of their own that made them memorable and separate because they didn’t necessarily exist to further the main characters story, even if they only had one line they still stuck with you.
The storyline itself was amazing too considering it was slow but still held my attention till the end. There was a clear goal in mind but then it didn't solely revolve around that goal, there were other smaller things and day to day life weaves in instead of one driven purpose. The whole ending and reason for the shadows was a bit predictable but I don't think I would have been able to guess correctly if I didn't write myself and so look at books with the analytic view of a writer. It was very nicely foreshadowed and didn't have any gaps or plot holes though which is impressive.
Literally the one and only thing I didn't like about this book was that now that I'm finished it's over. I want to know more! See the child growing up more and see all the other events long term affects! Learn more about the characters and the world and the past. Don't get me wrong, the book was a perfect length, not too long or short. It's just that I, as a reader, don't want to leave this magical world that Miss Emily has crafted yet.
Overall, if you love a well thought out book with meaningful relationships, a beautiful world and don’t mind a slower pace, then this book is for you.
January 8, 2025
THIS BOOK SERVED! IT SERVED SO GOOD I’M CRYING
THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE COZY FANTASY. WHY IS THERE PAIN?!!😭😭😭
THIS IS SUPPOSED TO BE COZY FANTASY. WHY IS THERE PAIN?!!😭😭😭
November 16, 2022
Under the Earth, Over the Sky reads like a dream perfectly articulated in story form. Very rarely can a book with such entrancing cover art live up to its promise with a matching narrative. The pacing drifts slowly, like a stroll in the woods, with some action sprinkled along the way to offer breaks in the doldrums. I absolutely loved the McCosh's debut and did not mind the slow pacing at all, as it wasn’t so much an issue with a certain part of the story but an overall mood framing it. This book deals elegantly in subtlety. The forest setting lends itself well to the pacing, and even many of the characters with which Iohmar interacts transition in and out seamlessly, leaving the reader to wonder if the interaction was a figment of the imagination.
See my full review on my blog!
Blog / Instagram / Literal / BookBub
See my full review on my blog!
Blog / Instagram / Literal / BookBub
February 27, 2023
4.5 ⭐️
Beautifully written with captivating characters that I’ll forever love. Beware, the pacing is slow. However, it’s such a rich whimsical story, I couldn’t put it down. The relationship between father and child (Iohmar and Lor) was too sweet and at the center of it all. Definitely will read again some day. It made me feel warm.
Beautifully written with captivating characters that I’ll forever love. Beware, the pacing is slow. However, it’s such a rich whimsical story, I couldn’t put it down. The relationship between father and child (Iohmar and Lor) was too sweet and at the center of it all. Definitely will read again some day. It made me feel warm.
January 8, 2024
I received an eARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
3.5 stars rounded down to 3
Let's get the obvious out of the way. The artwork is stunning. McCosh deserves all the credit for capturing the essence of her book so beautifully, and that the artwork is her own is even more impressive. I was sold on the images alone and it was that and the author's presence online that made me curious to try out the book.
The story focuses on the Fae King Iohmar, King Beneath the Earth, and follows him as he develops a relationship with his adopted son, interacts with his subjects and his world, and deals with a past he would rather forget.
McCosh’s writing style is poetic and descriptive. She uses this to her advantage in describing her story world, evoking the feeling of walking through magic forests, of feeling the lived experience of Fae thousands of years old, and of an intimate connectedness with both magic and the natural world.
As someone who doesn’t often read such descriptive prose, the flowery language took a little getting used to. But once I got used to it, the story flowed, and the writing style made the ethereal world come to life.
Now to some aspects of the story that didn’t gel with me.
My reading tastes lean towards quick-paced SFF rooted in a few characters. This could explain why for the majority of the story, it feels as if the plot meanders without a clear sense of direction, leaving the story feeling slow paced and lacking the tension that pulls the reader through. This is further exacerbated by the characters not really having any goals or desires beyond the immediate moment. Things sort of happen to Iohmar. This shifts drastically in the last 20% of the story, leaving the overall pacing feeling uneven and jarring.
While I haven't read much from Brandon Sanderson, he has this framework for plotting that I think best describes why the plot of the story didn’t really work for me. He talks about the three P’s: Promise, Progress and Payoff. The Promise the author makes at the start of the story sets the readers expectations. The sense of narrative momentum comes about with the Progress of the story, leading towards the Payoff at the end. While I think there might have been problems with all three aspects in UtEOtS, most problematic was the lack of progress (clear line of cause and effect) in the middle chunk of the book which leads to a lack of narrative momentum. After a strong first 20% of the story, the slow pace and lack of conflict after that point meant that every time I put the story down, there wasn’t anything really drawing me to pick it back up.
Which brings us to the characters.
The cast of the story is small (always my preference), but I was a little disappointed that we never really get the depth of relationship that a small cast allows. We hear very similar things about the relationships (how there is love and respect and care), but instead of deepening, growing more complex, we get a repetition of feelings throughout the story – something that made me think this would have worked better as a short story. This could very easily be attributed to these relationships simply being too mature for any genuine conflict, but without tension in the world, or the plot, it leaves a very flat (albeit beautifully described) story.
By far the most interesting scenes were between Iohmar and the humans where the otherworldliness of Iohmar comes out deliciously in contrast to both how humans perceive time, and their inherent wariness of the fae. I really wish we could have spent more time with this contradiction.
Lastly, there were some minor writing issues, head-hopping in the beginning, some overly convoluted descriptions that lose the meaning they’re trying to impart, the use of synonyms that don’t make sense (when something feels wrong, and the author uses feels incorrect instead) but they are easy to ignore in an otherwise gorgeously painted world.
Some parting thoughts about what I appreciated about the story:
1. The world McCosh creates in fascinating, and I love the mystery that exists within it.
2. I appreciate the strangeness of the Fae and Iohmar that really sells the idea that we’re visiting a strange place and people.
3. I was sold on the relationships between these characters, could believe they cared for one another, and loved that the heart of the story sat with a father and son.
Overall, while the story didn't elicit strong emotions from me, it was a pleasant reading experience.
It sort of feels like a boat ride down a gentle river. Very little happens but the view is beautiful.
I would recommend this story for readers who really appreciate the journey of reading more than an ending with spectacle. If you go in with those expectations, I'm sure you'll be pleasantly surprised by this debut novel by Emily McCosh.
3.5 stars rounded down to 3
Let's get the obvious out of the way. The artwork is stunning. McCosh deserves all the credit for capturing the essence of her book so beautifully, and that the artwork is her own is even more impressive. I was sold on the images alone and it was that and the author's presence online that made me curious to try out the book.
The story focuses on the Fae King Iohmar, King Beneath the Earth, and follows him as he develops a relationship with his adopted son, interacts with his subjects and his world, and deals with a past he would rather forget.
McCosh’s writing style is poetic and descriptive. She uses this to her advantage in describing her story world, evoking the feeling of walking through magic forests, of feeling the lived experience of Fae thousands of years old, and of an intimate connectedness with both magic and the natural world.
As someone who doesn’t often read such descriptive prose, the flowery language took a little getting used to. But once I got used to it, the story flowed, and the writing style made the ethereal world come to life.
Now to some aspects of the story that didn’t gel with me.
My reading tastes lean towards quick-paced SFF rooted in a few characters. This could explain why for the majority of the story, it feels as if the plot meanders without a clear sense of direction, leaving the story feeling slow paced and lacking the tension that pulls the reader through. This is further exacerbated by the characters not really having any goals or desires beyond the immediate moment. Things sort of happen to Iohmar. This shifts drastically in the last 20% of the story, leaving the overall pacing feeling uneven and jarring.
While I haven't read much from Brandon Sanderson, he has this framework for plotting that I think best describes why the plot of the story didn’t really work for me. He talks about the three P’s: Promise, Progress and Payoff. The Promise the author makes at the start of the story sets the readers expectations. The sense of narrative momentum comes about with the Progress of the story, leading towards the Payoff at the end. While I think there might have been problems with all three aspects in UtEOtS, most problematic was the lack of progress (clear line of cause and effect) in the middle chunk of the book which leads to a lack of narrative momentum. After a strong first 20% of the story, the slow pace and lack of conflict after that point meant that every time I put the story down, there wasn’t anything really drawing me to pick it back up.
Which brings us to the characters.
The cast of the story is small (always my preference), but I was a little disappointed that we never really get the depth of relationship that a small cast allows. We hear very similar things about the relationships (how there is love and respect and care), but instead of deepening, growing more complex, we get a repetition of feelings throughout the story – something that made me think this would have worked better as a short story. This could very easily be attributed to these relationships simply being too mature for any genuine conflict, but without tension in the world, or the plot, it leaves a very flat (albeit beautifully described) story.
By far the most interesting scenes were between Iohmar and the humans where the otherworldliness of Iohmar comes out deliciously in contrast to both how humans perceive time, and their inherent wariness of the fae. I really wish we could have spent more time with this contradiction.
Lastly, there were some minor writing issues, head-hopping in the beginning, some overly convoluted descriptions that lose the meaning they’re trying to impart, the use of synonyms that don’t make sense (when something feels wrong, and the author uses feels incorrect instead) but they are easy to ignore in an otherwise gorgeously painted world.
Some parting thoughts about what I appreciated about the story:
1. The world McCosh creates in fascinating, and I love the mystery that exists within it.
2. I appreciate the strangeness of the Fae and Iohmar that really sells the idea that we’re visiting a strange place and people.
3. I was sold on the relationships between these characters, could believe they cared for one another, and loved that the heart of the story sat with a father and son.
Overall, while the story didn't elicit strong emotions from me, it was a pleasant reading experience.
It sort of feels like a boat ride down a gentle river. Very little happens but the view is beautiful.
I would recommend this story for readers who really appreciate the journey of reading more than an ending with spectacle. If you go in with those expectations, I'm sure you'll be pleasantly surprised by this debut novel by Emily McCosh.
September 1, 2024
the ending saved this from being a flat 3 star. closer to a 3.5 for me but have a 4.
September 27, 2022
I am so excited that I finally got to read this bc I have been waiting for what feels like forever since I saw a single video of this on TikTok and was instantly hooked.
Going into this I was scared I may have set my expectations too high simply bc of the long wait but oh boy I was not disappointed in the slightest at all.
I have been struggling with reading and finishing books lately and could feel the reading slump coming but I could not put this book down.
It honestly has been a while since I have been this enamored with a book and its world. I love the way different authors interpret fae lore and this was simply perfect.
I could read thousands and thousands pages about this world and its characters and never tire of it. The way the author describes the world is so visual and vibrant and as a reader i couldn’t help but be sucked into it.
More than that though all the characters stuck with me. Not only the main characters but also every side character felt so alive and I couldn’t help but want more of them. The author could give me a novel with literally any character and I would read it.
However, getting to know Iohmar was such a personal thing to me. I was instantly hooked on him and the more I got to know him the less did i want to let go of him.
Learning about him, his insecurities and issues hit very close and i just had to fall in love with him.
More so by how he is defined through his relationships that told us so much about his character and made me love him even more.
Iohmar as a friend, a lover, a king and most importantly a father meant so much to me and with every page i was reading, I was also dreading losing him when the book ends.
I cannot stress enough how much I love this book that made me want to devour it but also not bc I knew that the more I read the closer to the end I got.
And while I truly loved the ending, I cannot help but wish I could have kept reading the story of these characters and this world that really sucked me in.
Going into this I was scared I may have set my expectations too high simply bc of the long wait but oh boy I was not disappointed in the slightest at all.
I have been struggling with reading and finishing books lately and could feel the reading slump coming but I could not put this book down.
It honestly has been a while since I have been this enamored with a book and its world. I love the way different authors interpret fae lore and this was simply perfect.
I could read thousands and thousands pages about this world and its characters and never tire of it. The way the author describes the world is so visual and vibrant and as a reader i couldn’t help but be sucked into it.
More than that though all the characters stuck with me. Not only the main characters but also every side character felt so alive and I couldn’t help but want more of them. The author could give me a novel with literally any character and I would read it.
However, getting to know Iohmar was such a personal thing to me. I was instantly hooked on him and the more I got to know him the less did i want to let go of him.
Learning about him, his insecurities and issues hit very close and i just had to fall in love with him.
More so by how he is defined through his relationships that told us so much about his character and made me love him even more.
Iohmar as a friend, a lover, a king and most importantly a father meant so much to me and with every page i was reading, I was also dreading losing him when the book ends.
I cannot stress enough how much I love this book that made me want to devour it but also not bc I knew that the more I read the closer to the end I got.
And while I truly loved the ending, I cannot help but wish I could have kept reading the story of these characters and this world that really sucked me in.
October 8, 2023
No Plot, All vibes, and I absolutely loved it.
Under the Earth, Over the Sky has my heart. It's so perfect for fall, and I swear my anxiety melted away as I read this book.
Iomhar and Lor were so cute, I never thought I would like a book about a Fae king and a baby this much. Honestly, it lowkey gave me baby fever, but like I'm too young to have a baby :((. This book was exactly what I needed, I'm so sad it ended. I will be recommending this book to everyone I know because it's perfect and magical and the best thing ever, and everyone needs to read it.
Under the Earth, Over the Sky has my heart. It's so perfect for fall, and I swear my anxiety melted away as I read this book.
Iomhar and Lor were so cute, I never thought I would like a book about a Fae king and a baby this much. Honestly, it lowkey gave me baby fever, but like I'm too young to have a baby :((. This book was exactly what I needed, I'm so sad it ended. I will be recommending this book to everyone I know because it's perfect and magical and the best thing ever, and everyone needs to read it.
August 19, 2022
I beta read this in exchange for an honest review.
Now you real that, then see the five stars, and are maybe struck witb a bit of confusion. Don't worry though, I'm not that nice of friend.
UteOts immediately sets the tone and atmosphere with stellar prose and description, perfectly pacing the reader's way.
McCosh has a way with setting a scene that is refreshing in fae-based storytelling, allowing us to understand and relate to Iohmae that isn't either an entitled or angsty feeling. He soon finds himself in a situation he never saw coming and make drastic sacrifices all in the sake of fatherly love.
As a parent myself, this struck home. The relationship between the characters is wonderfully done. Not only the father/son relatiomship, but all of them.
The way time passes and the seasons change add to atmosphere. The way mysteries unfold kept me intrigued and wanting more. And the payoff for those mysteries was top tier storytelling.
It's clear McCosh put a lot of heart and soul into this story. Amd that's from my experience as a beta. I can't wait to read the polished and proofed version.
Now you real that, then see the five stars, and are maybe struck witb a bit of confusion. Don't worry though, I'm not that nice of friend.
UteOts immediately sets the tone and atmosphere with stellar prose and description, perfectly pacing the reader's way.
McCosh has a way with setting a scene that is refreshing in fae-based storytelling, allowing us to understand and relate to Iohmae that isn't either an entitled or angsty feeling. He soon finds himself in a situation he never saw coming and make drastic sacrifices all in the sake of fatherly love.
As a parent myself, this struck home. The relationship between the characters is wonderfully done. Not only the father/son relatiomship, but all of them.
The way time passes and the seasons change add to atmosphere. The way mysteries unfold kept me intrigued and wanting more. And the payoff for those mysteries was top tier storytelling.
It's clear McCosh put a lot of heart and soul into this story. Amd that's from my experience as a beta. I can't wait to read the polished and proofed version.
December 28, 2023
4.5
This was a beautiful and whimsical tale about a dark and serious fae king taking in a helpless human newborn. The writing was magical and descriptive. The story itself was simple and heartwarming.
It’s not usually what I go for when reading a book- as I go for more action packed, plot twisty, and complicated novels. This novel is definitely not that and its plot is simple- more of a cozy read. However, it was interesting enough for me to flow through the book.
I only wish there was more depth to characters and the plot- but other than that it was a wonderful tale and I would recommend this talented author to my friends.
I’m excited to see how this author grows and I will check out her other books.
This was a beautiful and whimsical tale about a dark and serious fae king taking in a helpless human newborn. The writing was magical and descriptive. The story itself was simple and heartwarming.
It’s not usually what I go for when reading a book- as I go for more action packed, plot twisty, and complicated novels. This novel is definitely not that and its plot is simple- more of a cozy read. However, it was interesting enough for me to flow through the book.
I only wish there was more depth to characters and the plot- but other than that it was a wonderful tale and I would recommend this talented author to my friends.
I’m excited to see how this author grows and I will check out her other books.
September 12, 2024
The warm feeling is everyting. The fae king and his adopt son is so adorable, the way Iohmar loves his little Wip made my heart truly happy. He struggles a lot because of his past, his afraid that can not protect he. But the fae king have an kind heart, really love his people and the human.
The book do not have most action, is mostly about Iohmar learning to raise the child that he found in the human realm. Also have a little mystery involved shadows and magic.
The book do not have most action, is mostly about Iohmar learning to raise the child that he found in the human realm. Also have a little mystery involved shadows and magic.
January 19, 2025
The prose is so beautiful 🫶
January 30, 2024
If you are looking for something beautiful and lyrical, this is the book for you. If you would like to read a novel about a fae lord’s devotion to a human son, this is the novel for you. If you want something that makes you want to close your eyes and follow the gentle river of the story, this is the story for you.
It’s greatest strength is also it’s greatest weakness. This is a gentle story; it won’t raise your heart rate.
If you’re interested, support an indie author and pick up this beautiful book.
It’s greatest strength is also it’s greatest weakness. This is a gentle story; it won’t raise your heart rate.
If you’re interested, support an indie author and pick up this beautiful book.
September 3, 2023
Best book I've read this year so far 🩷
August 2, 2023
4.5 stars
Yes to this cozy, standalone high fantasy! This slow burn tale of a gentle fae king stumbling upon a human child who he takes in as his own will melt your heart. The world is so atmospheric, almost melancholic in its quiet beauty that I can see myself reading this when I just want some comforting, quiet time.
Yes to this cozy, standalone high fantasy! This slow burn tale of a gentle fae king stumbling upon a human child who he takes in as his own will melt your heart. The world is so atmospheric, almost melancholic in its quiet beauty that I can see myself reading this when I just want some comforting, quiet time.
March 29, 2023
Love it🥹 such a kind and lovely story💘
June 7, 2025
Oh dear my heart wasn't ready for such loving story.
I've had my eyes on this book a good while, and I'm so happy I finally read it. The premise had piqued my interest and it was an instant love. From the simple yet effective tale to the lyrical writing, Under the Earth, Over the Sky is a strong book on all fronts.
The story was incredibly refreshing, not only within the fantasy genre but also what themes it handles and how the story progresses. No big battles or grand actions typically actions take place. Instead, we're presented with grief, trauma, acceptance, found family and healthy relationships. The love Iohmar has for Lor had me so often in tears, every interaction, however small it may be, so soft and sweet. This is their story, while life continues to happen around them.
It's a story that requests you take time to read and experiece. Time works differently in the fae realm (compared to the human one), and McCosh did an incredible job making you feel that throughout the story. As the fae have no clear grasp of time passing, so doesn't the reader and it doesn't matter. What happens, happens when it does.
In a society where everything has to happen quick and the pressure to be "productive" is ever present, this book comes as a little blessing in disguise requesting you take some time for yourself, some time to breath. There may happen very little in a chapter, but the writing is so rich it's request of you to engulf yourself within this richness. I may not have clearly been able to visualize every description, but the mood and atmosphere was palpable.
I've previously mentionned that the book handles the subject of grief. I hadn't expected it to take such a big part of the story, but I'm glad it did. Sure, it's a fae king who griefs, but I think we can find comfort in this character. McCosh depicts grief in different ways in the book. How it affects beings and how they each react differently, and the time it takes to heal. But most importantly, she lets us know; grief can stay. It doesn't always fade, and it's okay. We may feel the sadness, be vulnerable as some pains can never be overcome. We are allowed to feel, and can seek support from the ones we love and trust.
Talking about love and trust, I was soooo pleasantly surprised with the romantic relationship in the book. It's simple, not at the forefront of the story, but present enough for us to understand the dynamic within the relationship. It's so loving, patient and understanding. The communication between the two is so healthy. It just felt really nice to see a couple just be happy and healthy with all the messy tropes that invades fantasy/romantasy nowadays :')
For a while I didn't know where the story was going, but at the end of the day, it didn't truly matter. Sure I had expectations, but I was more concerned about the character's wellbeing than the need of a grand plotdriven story. It felt nice to mainly feel for once while reading. There are many elements mentioned, that may give you ideas where the story might lead to, but I still felt slightly surprised by the turns the story took. It truly is a story that ties up loose ends from the past History of that universe, while weaving in Lor's tale at the same time. But never are you lost, as everything is beautifully crafted so you know in time, what happened and why the now is.
I'm going to stop here, otherwise I'll just keep repeating myself how much I loved the story and enjoyed my reading. The review is already long enough haha. I highly recommend this book if you need a boost of feelgood and want to feel healed. Can't encourage anyone enough that enjoys fantasy to give this one a try, whether it's your cup or tea or something new~
Thank you to those who read until the end, may this book bring you as much joy and softness as it did to me ^^
I've had my eyes on this book a good while, and I'm so happy I finally read it. The premise had piqued my interest and it was an instant love. From the simple yet effective tale to the lyrical writing, Under the Earth, Over the Sky is a strong book on all fronts.
The story was incredibly refreshing, not only within the fantasy genre but also what themes it handles and how the story progresses. No big battles or grand actions typically actions take place. Instead, we're presented with grief, trauma, acceptance, found family and healthy relationships. The love Iohmar has for Lor had me so often in tears, every interaction, however small it may be, so soft and sweet. This is their story, while life continues to happen around them.
It's a story that requests you take time to read and experiece. Time works differently in the fae realm (compared to the human one), and McCosh did an incredible job making you feel that throughout the story. As the fae have no clear grasp of time passing, so doesn't the reader and it doesn't matter. What happens, happens when it does.
In a society where everything has to happen quick and the pressure to be "productive" is ever present, this book comes as a little blessing in disguise requesting you take some time for yourself, some time to breath. There may happen very little in a chapter, but the writing is so rich it's request of you to engulf yourself within this richness. I may not have clearly been able to visualize every description, but the mood and atmosphere was palpable.
I've previously mentionned that the book handles the subject of grief. I hadn't expected it to take such a big part of the story, but I'm glad it did. Sure, it's a fae king who griefs, but I think we can find comfort in this character. McCosh depicts grief in different ways in the book. How it affects beings and how they each react differently, and the time it takes to heal. But most importantly, she lets us know; grief can stay. It doesn't always fade, and it's okay. We may feel the sadness, be vulnerable as some pains can never be overcome. We are allowed to feel, and can seek support from the ones we love and trust.
Talking about love and trust, I was soooo pleasantly surprised with the romantic relationship in the book. It's simple, not at the forefront of the story, but present enough for us to understand the dynamic within the relationship. It's so loving, patient and understanding. The communication between the two is so healthy. It just felt really nice to see a couple just be happy and healthy with all the messy tropes that invades fantasy/romantasy nowadays :')
For a while I didn't know where the story was going, but at the end of the day, it didn't truly matter. Sure I had expectations, but I was more concerned about the character's wellbeing than the need of a grand plotdriven story. It felt nice to mainly feel for once while reading. There are many elements mentioned, that may give you ideas where the story might lead to, but I still felt slightly surprised by the turns the story took. It truly is a story that ties up loose ends from the past History of that universe, while weaving in Lor's tale at the same time. But never are you lost, as everything is beautifully crafted so you know in time, what happened and why the now is.
I'm going to stop here, otherwise I'll just keep repeating myself how much I loved the story and enjoyed my reading. The review is already long enough haha. I highly recommend this book if you need a boost of feelgood and want to feel healed. Can't encourage anyone enough that enjoys fantasy to give this one a try, whether it's your cup or tea or something new~
Thank you to those who read until the end, may this book bring you as much joy and softness as it did to me ^^
March 17, 2023
I have many thoughts on this book upon finishing it only to release them just as quickly. Whatever my opinions on plot, character, and redundancies…this book was written for vibes and feels—and for that, it is beautiful. I enjoyed the whimsy of it, and only grew frustrated with the very same in the last 75%.
This book feels like a long, held sigh.
And I didn’t hate that about it.
The writing was beautiful, and that’s what brought it to 4 stars.
This book feels like a long, held sigh.
And I didn’t hate that about it.
The writing was beautiful, and that’s what brought it to 4 stars.
February 26, 2023
This book distinctly reminded me of some of the books of my childhood— of the magical forests and endless seas of Narnia and dragon bones living under mountains. It reminded me of one of my favorite books- a house overlooking a glittering sea that housed a makeshift family of oddities where traumatized men adopt neglected children and claim them as their own. It reminded me fairytales with curious fae and the even curiouser living nature that housed them.
This book was whimsical and ethereal— mysterious yet inviting. It pulls you in like a siren song but instead of drowning, you come out feeling inspired and perhaps a little bit more alive than before.
I am being dramatic, but how could I not be after reading such a phenomenal book? Alas, I know you didn’t come here for pretty words and flattery, so I’ll also share a detailed and honest review from a critical reader’s perspective.
I like to start with the “negative” first because I believe it important to end on a positive note. While I don’t have much of anything I didn’t like, there are a few things I’d like to note:
Sometimes I got lost in the plot as there was inconsistent pacing. There were areas where it went quite slow but other times perhaps a little too fast and I struggled to keep up— especially with the world building. I think I would have greatly appreciated a bit more world building in order to properly get a lay of the land, especially in regards to the two kingdoms, how they related to human lands, the borders (and what exactly that meant), and the wasteland beyond the borders—or the rippling. (Emily, I am DESPERATE to know what lies beyond the sea!!!). I was so fascinated by this little world that I wished we had gotten more details on it.
Also regarding the end plot, I could see some of it from the very beginning, which is not necessarily a bad thing, especially if the author was not intending it to be a big reveal. Honestly, it was infuriatingly endearing that Iohmar could not see the answers so clearly in front of him.
Lastly, while I liked the play with time, it was off putting to see “the child’s” (don’t want to spoil his name for anyone; names are powerful things you should know) age progression. One moment he was but a wee babe who couldn’t speak and then the next chapter he was suddenly speaking in complete sentences. I got used to it, but it was jarring and his various ages confused me. Perhaps this was the point though, and I make a note of this in my pros section.
Now, onto the positive:
I did not see the ending regarding the Rippling coming, but I felt like it was a good fit. I do wish we had gotten more of that, but I understand it was paired with another big reveal.
I also quite liked how the author played with time and how slowly it moves for Fae. Instead of telling us, however, the author SHOWS us using the life of one particular human who changed everything for Iohmar. (Shoutout to my boy J! Rest in peace, king)
Character dynamics were perfect. I found that I quite liked the point of view of a “man” (disrespectful to call him that to be honest because he is the King of the fae), especially one as strong, yet vulnerable as Iohmar. He frustrated me at times with his inability to be outwardly vulnerable to his closest loved ones, but his growth in that area was clear to see by the end of the book. Plus, we love a “man” who can apologize and own up to his shortcomings.
His relationships with his dad-not-dad, Galen, was quite wholesome which reflected in his relationship with his son. Ultimately the found family of it all is what convinced me to read this story and I was not disappointed. Iohmar was a loving and devoted father.
I also appreciate the subtle romance between Rúnda and Iohmar. It was the perfect touch of romance to aid the story but not take it over, plus, the fact that it was a clean romance that only hinted of a deeper, more adult intimacy was a nice touch. I do wish we’d gotten more backstory on those two however. Are they “permanent mates?” Casual lovers? Married in the fae sense? What does their future look like? Destined to be together for short periods of time? He calls her his “queen” but they rule two separate kingdoms? It was slightly confusing, but sweet all the same.
In truth, I would not mind a prequel story leading up to the fateful day Iohmar discovered the child in the woods. I’d love a deeper look into the world of Latwill and its struggle with the rippling. Of the centuries before “the child” when Iohmar was but a child himself. I’d love to meet his parents, know the war and the sacrifices that had to be made. Of how Iohmar and Rúnda met and how their relationship formed. Of the dynamic of the two kingdoms, and what may lay beyond them. I have so many questions I’d like answered.
But even if these questions are never answered, this book was a wonderful read. I bought it on the Kindle app, but I’m planning of obtaining a physical copy myself. I’d love to have this sitting pretty on my shelf.
What my star ratings means
1 ⭑ I did not like the book or dnf
2 ⭑ it was average
3 ⭑ I liked this book!
4 ⭑ I loved this book!
5 ⭑ This is one of the best books I’ve ever read
This book was whimsical and ethereal— mysterious yet inviting. It pulls you in like a siren song but instead of drowning, you come out feeling inspired and perhaps a little bit more alive than before.
I am being dramatic, but how could I not be after reading such a phenomenal book? Alas, I know you didn’t come here for pretty words and flattery, so I’ll also share a detailed and honest review from a critical reader’s perspective.
I like to start with the “negative” first because I believe it important to end on a positive note. While I don’t have much of anything I didn’t like, there are a few things I’d like to note:
Sometimes I got lost in the plot as there was inconsistent pacing. There were areas where it went quite slow but other times perhaps a little too fast and I struggled to keep up— especially with the world building. I think I would have greatly appreciated a bit more world building in order to properly get a lay of the land, especially in regards to the two kingdoms, how they related to human lands, the borders (and what exactly that meant), and the wasteland beyond the borders—or the rippling. (Emily, I am DESPERATE to know what lies beyond the sea!!!). I was so fascinated by this little world that I wished we had gotten more details on it.
Also regarding the end plot, I could see some of it from the very beginning, which is not necessarily a bad thing, especially if the author was not intending it to be a big reveal. Honestly, it was infuriatingly endearing that Iohmar could not see the answers so clearly in front of him.
Lastly, while I liked the play with time, it was off putting to see “the child’s” (don’t want to spoil his name for anyone; names are powerful things you should know) age progression. One moment he was but a wee babe who couldn’t speak and then the next chapter he was suddenly speaking in complete sentences. I got used to it, but it was jarring and his various ages confused me. Perhaps this was the point though, and I make a note of this in my pros section.
Now, onto the positive:
I did not see the ending regarding the Rippling coming, but I felt like it was a good fit. I do wish we had gotten more of that, but I understand it was paired with another big reveal.
I also quite liked how the author played with time and how slowly it moves for Fae. Instead of telling us, however, the author SHOWS us using the life of one particular human who changed everything for Iohmar. (Shoutout to my boy J! Rest in peace, king)
Character dynamics were perfect. I found that I quite liked the point of view of a “man” (disrespectful to call him that to be honest because he is the King of the fae), especially one as strong, yet vulnerable as Iohmar. He frustrated me at times with his inability to be outwardly vulnerable to his closest loved ones, but his growth in that area was clear to see by the end of the book. Plus, we love a “man” who can apologize and own up to his shortcomings.
His relationships with his dad-not-dad, Galen, was quite wholesome which reflected in his relationship with his son. Ultimately the found family of it all is what convinced me to read this story and I was not disappointed. Iohmar was a loving and devoted father.
I also appreciate the subtle romance between Rúnda and Iohmar. It was the perfect touch of romance to aid the story but not take it over, plus, the fact that it was a clean romance that only hinted of a deeper, more adult intimacy was a nice touch. I do wish we’d gotten more backstory on those two however. Are they “permanent mates?” Casual lovers? Married in the fae sense? What does their future look like? Destined to be together for short periods of time? He calls her his “queen” but they rule two separate kingdoms? It was slightly confusing, but sweet all the same.
In truth, I would not mind a prequel story leading up to the fateful day Iohmar discovered the child in the woods. I’d love a deeper look into the world of Latwill and its struggle with the rippling. Of the centuries before “the child” when Iohmar was but a child himself. I’d love to meet his parents, know the war and the sacrifices that had to be made. Of how Iohmar and Rúnda met and how their relationship formed. Of the dynamic of the two kingdoms, and what may lay beyond them. I have so many questions I’d like answered.
But even if these questions are never answered, this book was a wonderful read. I bought it on the Kindle app, but I’m planning of obtaining a physical copy myself. I’d love to have this sitting pretty on my shelf.
What my star ratings means
1 ⭑ I did not like the book or dnf
2 ⭑ it was average
3 ⭑ I liked this book!
4 ⭑ I loved this book!
5 ⭑ This is one of the best books I’ve ever read
Want to read
July 19, 2024this seems gay but i really can’t tell
February 22, 2024
Finally, a found (haha literally dug out of the ground after being found, or taken from a house like a prize) family book with a happy ending. This book was like a fresh glass of water, and I hadn't realized how badly it had been needed until I finished it and wanted more.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 30, 2023
3/5 stars. Buddy read with a friend. It was fine, but it certainly didn't blow my socks off.
I enjoyed the description of the world. The writing overall is quite flowery and descriptive, but almost to a fault in some cases. Sometimes it was hard to really grasp what was happening and I'd have to reread a page a few times and yet I still couldn't quite figure out what was going on. The fever dreams were even harder to understand. I also struggled to follow the aging of Lor, as it never felt quite clear what size he was because his "actual age" didn't quite match up with normal human growth. It's quite a short book, but the lack of clear understanding of what's happening made it harder to really want to pick it back up and read.
Don't get me wrong, it had some really nice moments. I enjoyed the first spring section of the book quite well. I liked seeing Iohmar grow soft for a human baby, and it was sweet to see him come to care for the child so deeply and ultimately choosing to save him from illness under the tunnels with the woman. And even the story of his missing childhood friend. They were all quite intriguing moments. It certainly peaked my interest at the start.
I also was intrigued in the summer half as well. The mystery of the shadows and the ripplings and their association with the past war really had me wondering what could possibly be happening. While I did enjoy the origin of the shadows, I felt like the ripplings wasn't what I was expecting.
In terms of the ending,
Overall, it wasn't bad, and I did have a good time here and there, but I just felt like it could have been more enjoyable had it been a little less flowery when important information was being provided as it was harder to follow and gauge what was happening and was rather vague.
I enjoyed the description of the world. The writing overall is quite flowery and descriptive, but almost to a fault in some cases. Sometimes it was hard to really grasp what was happening and I'd have to reread a page a few times and yet I still couldn't quite figure out what was going on. The fever dreams were even harder to understand. I also struggled to follow the aging of Lor, as it never felt quite clear what size he was because his "actual age" didn't quite match up with normal human growth. It's quite a short book, but the lack of clear understanding of what's happening made it harder to really want to pick it back up and read.
Don't get me wrong, it had some really nice moments. I enjoyed the first spring section of the book quite well. I liked seeing Iohmar grow soft for a human baby, and it was sweet to see him come to care for the child so deeply and ultimately choosing to save him from illness under the tunnels with the woman. And even the story of his missing childhood friend. They were all quite intriguing moments. It certainly peaked my interest at the start.
I also was intrigued in the summer half as well. The mystery of the shadows and the ripplings and their association with the past war really had me wondering what could possibly be happening. While I did enjoy the origin of the shadows, I felt like the ripplings wasn't what I was expecting.
In terms of the ending,
Overall, it wasn't bad, and I did have a good time here and there, but I just felt like it could have been more enjoyable had it been a little less flowery when important information was being provided as it was harder to follow and gauge what was happening and was rather vague.
October 29, 2022
Under the Earth, Over the Sky
Synopsis: The King beneath the earth does not concern himself with the doings of the humans in the village beyond the border of his realm. But when his crows bring whispers of men nearing his woods, his duty forces investigation. There has been a murder, a rot, poisoning the ground where a woman is buried, and Iohmar finds a child, sickly, small, and destined to the same fate as his mother. Despite his own law, forbidding his fae from luring humans into Latwill, he brings the child back to his mountain. His lands and magic will strengthen the child until he can find a suitable home for it back in the human world. But the trees hold secrets, and shadows lurk deep within the mountain. They whisper of a long forgotten war, carry memories that have long faded, and threaten the human son that Iohmar never intended to love, but now cant stand to lose.
Rating: *****
Review: This story has such a unique way of weaving around your heart. I was so touched by the intimacy on display throughout the book, and the constant internal conflict that Iohmar feels, as a king, a lover and a father. I’m struggling to describe how deeply you can feel these connections as a reader, but it is incredibly well done.
The prose is intoxicating. As I read, it felt like floating into the magic of the woods. The movement and magic in Latwill are vivid and surreal. I appreciated the unique and delicate descriptions, and the original twists on the classic fae legends and lore.
I was so strongly invested throughout this read, from start to finish, just enthralled. There were moments so beautiful that I cried, and there were moments so emotional that it tore my heart. I love it. It is unique, intimate and lovely, a must-read.
Synopsis: The King beneath the earth does not concern himself with the doings of the humans in the village beyond the border of his realm. But when his crows bring whispers of men nearing his woods, his duty forces investigation. There has been a murder, a rot, poisoning the ground where a woman is buried, and Iohmar finds a child, sickly, small, and destined to the same fate as his mother. Despite his own law, forbidding his fae from luring humans into Latwill, he brings the child back to his mountain. His lands and magic will strengthen the child until he can find a suitable home for it back in the human world. But the trees hold secrets, and shadows lurk deep within the mountain. They whisper of a long forgotten war, carry memories that have long faded, and threaten the human son that Iohmar never intended to love, but now cant stand to lose.
Rating: *****
Review: This story has such a unique way of weaving around your heart. I was so touched by the intimacy on display throughout the book, and the constant internal conflict that Iohmar feels, as a king, a lover and a father. I’m struggling to describe how deeply you can feel these connections as a reader, but it is incredibly well done.
The prose is intoxicating. As I read, it felt like floating into the magic of the woods. The movement and magic in Latwill are vivid and surreal. I appreciated the unique and delicate descriptions, and the original twists on the classic fae legends and lore.
I was so strongly invested throughout this read, from start to finish, just enthralled. There were moments so beautiful that I cried, and there were moments so emotional that it tore my heart. I love it. It is unique, intimate and lovely, a must-read.
March 1, 2023
Eh. My overarching thought coming out of reading this. I had high hopes of this book going into it with eh gorgeous cover art and the book jacket summary had me thinking this was going to be a faster paced book with good conflict points while proving an air of mystery to what is causing this sickness of Iohmar. I didn't really find that at all. This book is of a slower pace. The first 50% of the book felt very slow to me with the King watching and interacting with his son, walking the woods and interacting with his subjects. As someone who has no interest in children of my own, I struggled to connect with why he cared so much for a baby he just found. I also didn't see a point in what the book was really about until I hit the 60% mark where the King talks more about the ripples trying to encroach on his land.
Not all of the book was stuff I had trouble connecting with. The world Emily describes is very gorgeous and I could envision myself being in the forest with the sunbeams hitting just right through the trees. I loved the idea of various kingdoms trying to combat the threat of the ripples even if it wasn't as action filled as I imagined. I did feel vaguely happy at the end that a few things were resolved even if it didn't have a big grand conflict at the end like I wanted.
Overall I think someone who enjoys a slower paced book as well as someone who enjoys or connects with kids would most likely enjoy the book better. It just didn't hit the mark for me personally.
Not all of the book was stuff I had trouble connecting with. The world Emily describes is very gorgeous and I could envision myself being in the forest with the sunbeams hitting just right through the trees. I loved the idea of various kingdoms trying to combat the threat of the ripples even if it wasn't as action filled as I imagined. I did feel vaguely happy at the end that a few things were resolved even if it didn't have a big grand conflict at the end like I wanted.
Overall I think someone who enjoys a slower paced book as well as someone who enjoys or connects with kids would most likely enjoy the book better. It just didn't hit the mark for me personally.
September 29, 2022
I received an ARC ebook of Under the Earth, Over the Sky in exchange for an honest view.
Under the Earth, Over the Sky is a character driven found family story with a lot to unpack.
The setting of this heartfelt story takes place in what we would dream of when we think magical fairy forest. I cannot say how much I wanted and needed that. It's simplicity and endearment is one to soothe your heart. And you will need it.
You will chuckle, laugh and cry. I did a couple times so bring some tissues on this adventure following Iohmar through what I see as a battle with mental health and the long term effects of this struggle. It's effects on those closest to him and his unrelenting need to love and protect all.
My heart bleeds for this character. As well as those around him. He's spoken of as a grumpy king but I see you Ms. McCosh. This is a king whom would sacrifice every bit of himself because he loves so fiercely.
The characters from Lor, his adopted son to the tiny branches of the forest that are always reaching for him (at times smothering him with their needs) become a beloved story of duty, love, guilt, grievance, fear and how difficult it is manage so many things that effect all of us so significantly.
I need to get a physical copy. This book hit me hard. More than once I gasped "Oh, my heart"
Under the Earth, Over the Sky is a character driven found family story with a lot to unpack.
The setting of this heartfelt story takes place in what we would dream of when we think magical fairy forest. I cannot say how much I wanted and needed that. It's simplicity and endearment is one to soothe your heart. And you will need it.
You will chuckle, laugh and cry. I did a couple times so bring some tissues on this adventure following Iohmar through what I see as a battle with mental health and the long term effects of this struggle. It's effects on those closest to him and his unrelenting need to love and protect all.
My heart bleeds for this character. As well as those around him. He's spoken of as a grumpy king but I see you Ms. McCosh. This is a king whom would sacrifice every bit of himself because he loves so fiercely.
The characters from Lor, his adopted son to the tiny branches of the forest that are always reaching for him (at times smothering him with their needs) become a beloved story of duty, love, guilt, grievance, fear and how difficult it is manage so many things that effect all of us so significantly.
I need to get a physical copy. This book hit me hard. More than once I gasped "Oh, my heart"
May 30, 2024
2.5 Stars. I know many people love this book, which is evidenced by the average rating as well as individual ratings. But it was just not really for me. The world would be boring if everyone liked the same books, wouldn't it.
What I liked
- The Writing Style
- the general idea of the world, its characters as well as the story
- The overall design of the book, font, length of chapters and structure in general
What I did not like that much or what could have been better in my humble opinion
- to me the world lacked depth, as someone with a generally vivid imagination I found myself struggling to put together a mental image of the world. Some aspects of this world also would have deserved to be more detailed or to be explored within the story at all
- in correlation with the other point, I think the other characters beside Iohmar were rather shallow and lacked depth. But that might be my personal preference.
- the story was very slow. By the time something happened (apart from Iohmar saving Lor, which I consider the foundation or trigger for the actual story) I was about halfway through the book and wondering whether anything will happen at all, which is how the book kind of lost me. Even for a cozy fantasy read, I would have preferred a bit more excitement. I simply wasn't hooked by this book.
What I liked
- The Writing Style
- the general idea of the world, its characters as well as the story
- The overall design of the book, font, length of chapters and structure in general
What I did not like that much or what could have been better in my humble opinion
- to me the world lacked depth, as someone with a generally vivid imagination I found myself struggling to put together a mental image of the world. Some aspects of this world also would have deserved to be more detailed or to be explored within the story at all
- in correlation with the other point, I think the other characters beside Iohmar were rather shallow and lacked depth. But that might be my personal preference.
- the story was very slow. By the time something happened (apart from Iohmar saving Lor, which I consider the foundation or trigger for the actual story) I was about halfway through the book and wondering whether anything will happen at all, which is how the book kind of lost me. Even for a cozy fantasy read, I would have preferred a bit more excitement. I simply wasn't hooked by this book.
December 23, 2022
This book was not exactly what I was expecting, which is always a bit disappointing, but if I had gone into it knowing what it was actually going to be like then I still would have enjoyed it. See, I was expecting it to be more of a cozy, sort of slice-of-life-y father/son bonding book about the trials of raising a baby. However, this book is actually an intricate, lyrical, description of nature and love and magic.
So, if you are looking for a cutesy, raising a baby story, this is not what you are looking for.
But if you are looking to be swept away in magical descriptions with unique fae creatures and cradled in flowery language, then this is exactly what you need.
Read my full review here: https://ohmybookishness.weebly.com/bl...
So, if you are looking for a cutesy, raising a baby story, this is not what you are looking for.
But if you are looking to be swept away in magical descriptions with unique fae creatures and cradled in flowery language, then this is exactly what you need.
Read my full review here: https://ohmybookishness.weebly.com/bl...
September 28, 2024
Ethereal. Otherworldly. Uniquely told.
With a beautifully written writing-style, that captivated me the entire way through the story.
The bonds of father and son, so sweet, and so pure.
I loved the wholesome moments. And the mini mysteries as they slowly unraveled.
Magic leaked from every inch of this world, and it feels alien, inhuman, as if you are truly following in the footsteps of a Fae-King who does not think or act like you or I would.
Almost like an original told Fairytale of its own.
Whimsical and enchanting to it’s core. And I know I am a sucker for such things.
(This year, will be my Fae Era, for books I decide to read)
With a beautifully written writing-style, that captivated me the entire way through the story.
The bonds of father and son, so sweet, and so pure.
I loved the wholesome moments. And the mini mysteries as they slowly unraveled.
Magic leaked from every inch of this world, and it feels alien, inhuman, as if you are truly following in the footsteps of a Fae-King who does not think or act like you or I would.
Almost like an original told Fairytale of its own.
Whimsical and enchanting to it’s core. And I know I am a sucker for such things.
(This year, will be my Fae Era, for books I decide to read)
March 13, 2023
This book was like a warm hug on a rainy day, beautifully written and wonderfully lovable characters. Absolutely fell in love with Iohmar and Lor :)
November 6, 2023
This reminded me of warm afternoons spent in my uncle's study and rummaging through his things and finding an ordinary silly thing that turns to be a hidden treasure 🤗
He runs the backs of his fingers along the babe’s soft cheek. The boy blinks wet eyes, the sobs fading. The beginnings of a smile crinkle his plump face.
For the first time, the boy giggles.
Both hands stop flailing, instead reaching for Iohmar’s jaw. Iohmar blinks. Lowering his head, he lets the boy’s chubby hands pat his cheeks, thump against his horns, and tug the locks of autumn hair spilling over his shoulders. Soft cooing begins. Iohmar blinks again, his eyes hot.
Ridiculous. Fae kings do not cry for a human babe.
Firstly, I must talk about the writing - it is both simple and lyrical, a song without music and words that feel so...so loved that they resemble a dream when uttered. Or at least a far away memory that's become so blurry but still holds that warmth that wraps around you like an old comfortable blanket.
Then there is the world and the characters, both wonderful and soft with much depth that is sometimes left unanswered (which is good!). The way Io absolutely MELTS for his little human foundling is both gutwrenching and heartwarming at the same time! The way he holds and cares for him, the way he openly shows him his feelings and reassures him of his love despite being riddled woth self-doubt and fear is LOVELY, BEAUTIFUL AMAZING (especially when he compares himself to his parents, knowing they would never be as open with their affection due to their position as rulers and despite feeling they wouldn't approve of him, he still DOES IT) 💕
And then there is Runda... Oh my stars, the way she loves is beautiful. Whenever she and Io are together I feel all giggly and soft and it's just... Wholesome. And when Io finally allowed himself the idea of not being a burden, of having the person he loves not be disgusted or disappointed by his physical weakness? And he promised to send his crows for Runda when he is sick and she comes and is with him no matter how long it takes for him to recover? Priceless.
There are so many things I loved about this story but I must also confess that the last 50 or so pages concerning the big unravelling of the shadow/ripplings mystery was just hmm alright? It kinda dragged and I felt it happened too quickly considering the pacing of the story before it (I honestly believed that mystery would be solved much later when Lor grows a bit more but alas).
Oh and that scene when Io remembers how he found his dead father surrounded by his guard and can barely leave his body to continue his fight? And THEN finds his mother gone as well? And fucking goes bezerk but also gently takes the poppies that had sprouted in the place she fell and takes them to the orchad where they still grow to this day? I SOBBED ALRIGHT?! 💔😭
He runs the backs of his fingers along the babe’s soft cheek. The boy blinks wet eyes, the sobs fading. The beginnings of a smile crinkle his plump face.
For the first time, the boy giggles.
Both hands stop flailing, instead reaching for Iohmar’s jaw. Iohmar blinks. Lowering his head, he lets the boy’s chubby hands pat his cheeks, thump against his horns, and tug the locks of autumn hair spilling over his shoulders. Soft cooing begins. Iohmar blinks again, his eyes hot.
Ridiculous. Fae kings do not cry for a human babe.
Firstly, I must talk about the writing - it is both simple and lyrical, a song without music and words that feel so...so loved that they resemble a dream when uttered. Or at least a far away memory that's become so blurry but still holds that warmth that wraps around you like an old comfortable blanket.
Then there is the world and the characters, both wonderful and soft with much depth that is sometimes left unanswered (which is good!). The way Io absolutely MELTS for his little human foundling is both gutwrenching and heartwarming at the same time! The way he holds and cares for him, the way he openly shows him his feelings and reassures him of his love despite being riddled woth self-doubt and fear is LOVELY, BEAUTIFUL AMAZING (especially when he compares himself to his parents, knowing they would never be as open with their affection due to their position as rulers and despite feeling they wouldn't approve of him, he still DOES IT) 💕
And then there is Runda... Oh my stars, the way she loves is beautiful. Whenever she and Io are together I feel all giggly and soft and it's just... Wholesome. And when Io finally allowed himself the idea of not being a burden, of having the person he loves not be disgusted or disappointed by his physical weakness? And he promised to send his crows for Runda when he is sick and she comes and is with him no matter how long it takes for him to recover? Priceless.
There are so many things I loved about this story but I must also confess that the last 50 or so pages concerning the big unravelling of the shadow/ripplings mystery was just hmm alright? It kinda dragged and I felt it happened too quickly considering the pacing of the story before it (I honestly believed that mystery would be solved much later when Lor grows a bit more but alas).
Oh and that scene when Io remembers how he found his dead father surrounded by his guard and can barely leave his body to continue his fight? And THEN finds his mother gone as well? And fucking goes bezerk but also gently takes the poppies that had sprouted in the place she fell and takes them to the orchad where they still grow to this day? I SOBBED ALRIGHT?! 💔😭
Displaying 1 - 30 of 269 reviews