I really can't believe the average rating was only three stars. This book brings together dozens of principle-based lessons I've heard, and provides excellent, practical applications that can help us overcome our pesky setbacks. It helps identify all the things we do that keep us from living a more meaningful life. The cure is as simple as making one life-changing decision. I believe she is right, as I have read stories of many great people and they've usually had a defining moment where they decided the kind of person they wanted to be, and then avoided deviating from that decision.
Last month, I had the pleasure of hearing Judith Wright speak on her pet topic of soft addictions. It's a curious topic--we all know what addictions are, and we know they're bad. But "soft addictions"? Intriguing, and her demo reel shows it, with a lineup of major media appearances from all over the country. I went home with her books, The Soft Addiction Solution and The One Decision in my bag, curious about what Ms. Wright might have to say about my self-confessed ability to watch entirely too much television.
Her definition, to begin: Soft addictions are those seemingly harmless habits--like overshopping, overeating, watching too much TV, surfing the Internet, gossiping, procrastinating--that actually keep us from the life we want. Whether we realize it or not, our soft addiction cost us money, rob us of time, numb us from our feelings, mute our consciousness and drain our energy.
She points out that while we all have these habits, what defines a "soft addiction" is the frequently and use of the habit. Watching a program we enjoy on TV--that's OK. Surfing idly for hours to escape reality or to zone out after a busy day--hmm, what are you trying to escape from, and does it actually help?
The definition was intriguing and an interesting way of looking at some of the less-than-healthy routines some of us have set up in our lives that end up robbing us of time and energy we could be spending on pursuing the hopes, dreams and activities that we truly value--no argument there. And the coinage of "soft addiction" is truly brilliant; "soft" makes the term a bit easier to admit and own up to and "addiction" has that connotation of negative feedback loop that detracts from our lives.
And there is a lot of value in simply identifying which parts of our lives and daily routines aren't feeding our purposes and our stated goals and values--you guys know how strongly I believe in goal-setting based on our stated values so that our everyday lives reflect what we value in life. So sure, I'm going to be a fan of any type of self-reflection that could help keep one on track and aligned with one's values.
I will say that the usefulness seems to stop there; with respect to ridding oneself of these soft addictions and making "the one decision," I'd recommend going out and investing in a copy of Everyday Zen: Love and Work, by Charlotte Joko Beck, which is a deeper and more cogent explanation of integrating love, life and work. The philosophy of making one powerful decision to live life a certain way is a strong one, but Ms. Wright's explanations seem vaguely positive and zen-ish without going more deeply into zen philosophy. Or any philosophy; the whole transition process seems to come across as the stale "make a decision to be positive and your life will change" without any solid philosophy behind it. Her solution of "just make a decision and change" seems to fall a bit flat for me, and it seems she continually almost espouses zen philosophies but skims over them rather shallowly.
So skim Wright's book to dig out your own soft addictions, and then go read Beck's excellent (and extremely readable treatise) on Zen to really put it into practice and opt to live meaningfully on a daily basis.
I met this woman randomly in Chicago after she was a guest on a Chicago radio talk show and left the Tribune building. Her publicist gave me a free copy and I figured I must need to read this. My Life Coach who is from Minneapolis couldn't believe I had met Judyth and was very familiar with her. How many soft addictions do I have? The sum of them just might total at least one hard addiction.
According to this book we all have some soft addiction or another, and they become problems when they keep us from living more full and abundant lives. I really like the premise of the book, though I don't agree with everything the author says.
For the first 75 pages, my reaction was that this book was utter bullshit. No human in the world has ever thought of this strategy on their own, and yet, if we follow her advice, every one of us will be able to improve our lives. We can feel fulfilled and be successful in everything, in all spheres of our lives, despite the fact that there are a limited number of hours in the day, and a limited amount of energy and attention that we have. And it’s all written in the language of hype that self-help transform-your-life books seem to love.
But then I started to look for the underlying truths behind the hype. And it seems to boil down to mindfulness. Identify those places where you’re “zoning out”, and, well, don’t. Her “One Decision” is essentially like a mantra, that you can repeat to yourself as a reminder to look for the way to engage mindfully with your life. So, I guess if you like the idea of miracle cures, and enjoy being swept along by exciting language, maybe you’ll use this book to make a shift in your life. It really did not resonate with me. At best, if I squinted I could see where it was talking about the same concepts that seem better addressed in other sources.
There were a number of things that annoyed me in this book. Cutesy terms such as "stinking thinking", "MORE-sels", and "alive-lines" (rather than deadlines). Lots of weight-loss talk. Toss-off comments about dating "high quality women" or "better quality men” (we’re rating the quality of our fellow human beings now?). Several mentions of "oversleeping" as a soft addiction, or an example of the wrong sort of thing to want more of your life, without any recognition of the fact that chronic sleep deprivation is rampant in our society, and many people literally do need more sleep in their lives, for physical as well as mental health. Not to mention that the very idea of a “One Decision” is off-putting or intimidating to someone with perfectionistic tendencies who knows they won’t get it “right” on the first try. Bonus: the very last inspirational quote in the book is from Ayn Rand, a certified asshole.
On the other hand, there were some really good points. I appreciated how she several times assigned movie-watching to illustrate her ideas. She would give the title of a movie, and suggest being alert to whatever particular topic, while watching it. It’s often easier to see patterns in other people’s behavior than our own, and getting some practice in identifying these patterns might help when we then look at our own behavior. Also, the workbook section of the book is excellent. I did not actually attempt to do any of the workbook exercises, because as I mentioned the book didn’t resonate with me that strongly. But there seemed to be a lot of very specific assignments to help the reader put her ideas into action, where most books leave that part completely up to you. At the very least, even just reading through the workbook section provided a sort of summary review of her main topics.
I have to be honest, this book didn’t capture me right away. I almost gave up on it but I’m so glad I didn’t! This was an excellent book! I have really shifted my views on my life and habits and gave me some concrete information to use to help improve my life. I highly recommend it.
Great concept, but the writing was kind of all over the place. Very repetitive, lots of platitudes. Just...meh. But the idea of becoming aware of soft addictions we all secretly hate like binging Netflix and never having silence and wasting time ...Very helpful for that.
I really wanted to like this book...the concept rang so true for me. I found it dissolved into a self-actualizing mess pretty quickly and I got tired of reading about my life of MORE (all caps). Ugh.
A great book that brings together many life changing principles in a way you can grasp. However the first 90 pages I found unwieldy - which is why I think it is nit rated as well here as the book should be. If you stick to it by page 93 (chapter 5) the book really takes off. Chapter 6 is a masterful exposition of how to see past our soft addictions to reveal our deep inner yearnings. This then powers you to reveal your vision - and then in my case at least, to reveal the ONE Question that drove me, spoken of at the books beginning.
It reads like a typical self-help book but goes a bit further. She forces you to look at your life from a quality stand point. She encourages you to form a ONE DECISION & life by it. Mine is corny: "I live a conscious life, I value myself & am always genuine." It's helped me to say "no" to things that don't add quality to my life.
The thesis (many of us have "soft addictions") is fine and perceptive/insightful. But there the usefulness ends. As "solutions" go, there is effectively none in the book (besides "stop doing it"). One of the few books I've actually abandoned in frustration — it's just full of stories with the basic plot "Person X decided to improve her life and did so", with nothing actually useful to the reader.
This is a fantastic book about how to make your life full of MORE. More fun, more love, more intimacy. We do this by doing LESS of all the stupid crap: watching too much TV, eating, shopping, gossiping, procrastinating, fill in your addiction here.... Very helpful and practical advice.