What do you think?
Rate this book
Tragic Mountains: The Hmong, the Americans, and the Secret Wars for Laos, 1942-1992
Jane Hamilton-Merritt, Nobel-nominated scholar and photojournalist, has followed the plight of the Hmong and the war in Indochina since the 1960s. The staunchest of allies, the Hmong sided with the Americans against the North Vietnamese and were foot soldiers in the brutal secret war for Laos. Since the war, abandoned by their American allies, the Hmong have been subjected to a campaign of genocide by the North Vietnamese, including the use of chemical weapons. Tragic Mountains moves from the big picture of international diplomacy and power politics to the small villages and heroic engagements in the Lao jungle. It is a story of courage, brutality, heroism, betrayal, resilience, and hope.
584 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1993
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews
Read
December 12, 2018This is your basic everyday story of mountain folk roped in to a CIA covert war and left to fend for themselves afterwards, with added opium.
The author was a journalist, maybe still is - and much of the book is constructed from interviews she had with various people - she is plainly interested in this story, her account closes with writing to U.S congresspersons and Senators trying to prevent forced 'voluntary' repatriations from refuge camps in Thailand to Laos.
As you might expect from a journalist's book it is chatty and a mass of anecdotes, arranged to form a continuous narrative. Until the end of the book she is entirely self-effacing, although she was active as a journalist in the region during the Vietnam war it is unclear how much time she spent then in Laos, in the introduction she mentions that U.S personnel were not helpful or forthcoming, unlike in Vietnam, so it may be that most of her contacts and personal involvement began only after 1975 when formally the informal war ended. None of this matters much aside from that readers may want to salt some of want she recounts particularly reported dialogue or precise seeming details about weapons and the like.
She opens with a depiction of the Hmong as American types, or at least as sharing homely American values, apart from their habit of cultivating opium, in which they paid taxes to the French and used as a cure-all for the stresses,strains and injuries arising from this earthly life, and I suppose also their tradition of embroidery, the young men allegedly having a keen appreciation of needlework skills and would marry the most able seamstresses, also polygamy which was to become a sticking point later. It comes across as an appeal to the audience and no doubt this is no simple story but a campaigning book.
Anyhow the Hmong, she says were a simple minority group in Laos, upland farmers, who had drifted into the country from China in the not very distant past. They were divided into a handful of clans, were animists in contrast to the Buddhist majority in Laos, they spoke their own language, they made their own flintlock muskets, the women folk wore necklaces made from silver French colonial coins, the Hmong were mostly excluded from education and generally looked down upon as the Indochinese equivalents of Hill-billies. Towards the end of WWII a handful of French soldiers engaged some Hmong in insurgent warfare against the Japanese with considerable success, although the Hmong generally only bothered to turn up and fight if they thought they'd win, not realising at this stage that in modern organised total warfare it is the taking part, not the winning, that counts.
All these stories go back to the Japanese invasion / personally extended invitation to join the Asian co-prosperity sphere, and the breakdown of colonial authority.
As the USA gets involved in fighting in Vietnam they notice that supplies are being moved into South Vietnam through Laos along what is called the Ho Che Min trail and in a move to disrupt this a CIA operative turns up among the Hmong calls himself Colonel Billy and asks if they want to fight communists if he provides the guns. His offer apparently is enthusiastically welcomed. Presumably there was a little more to it than that, but that is more or less how it comes across here. ' Colonel Billy's' conception is that this should be an entirely covert operation and essentially guerilla warfare, he is later accused of running the whole affair out of his trouser pocket to which he can only assent as that is where he kept his note book with all the details he needed to recall. A key part of his conception is to minimise official US involvement since, similarly to as is argued in Understanding Vietnam he felt the US presence was self-destructive as it ended with large numbers of monolingual people in air-conditioned facilities with a huge logistical tail writing reports on the welfare of Americans in South-East Asia rather than actually engaging with the people whose hearts and minds they needed to win. Eventually this 'Colonel Billy' was pushed out, partly it seems because he wasn't spending enough money and didn't have a big enough office, at least that is how it comes across.
After his departure the conception changes to using the Hmong as a substitute for regular infantry forces. By this time twenty thousand or more Hmong are under arms led by General Vang Pao - formally an officer in the Lao army. He was something of a big chief, his eventual five marriages linked him to several clans and his charisma (getting back to Max Weber here) won him a substantial following, helpfully the author tells us he was opposed to the opium trade. The US were providing 'covert' air support from bases in Thailand and units of the Thai army were also occasionally involved. Vang Pao pushed for air power under his own control to which end a handful of Hmong were trained as pilots, unfortunately as they all tended to be short the control panels had to be altered and the trainees were given thick cushions so that they could see out of the windows.
Air power was a critical element in supplying and fighting in this tropical mountainous region, all the more so as Vang Pao withdrew into the mountains to fight from more defensible/ inaccessible areas, this led to the construction of various bizarre dirt and log runways, sometimes with dog legs, occasionally cantilevered over mountainsides and so on. The fighting led to considerable social change, since the Hmong had moved from the Highlands to the mountains they were dependant on food supplies. Due to casualties they recruited boys to fight - the basic rule was, similar to fairgrounds, that you had to be at least as tall as the weapon you were intending to use, some girls were trained as nurses, there was an effort to provide elementary schooling, and soldiers were paid cash money.
All things come to an end. In this case in 1975. A small number of Hmong were flown out of the country. General Vang Pao managed, after divorcing most of his wives, to get to the USA where he got a mortgage to buy a farm in Montana though eventually he drifted to California, he died in 2011. Reasonably the Hmong feared reprisals as Vietnam friendly forces took over Laos and tens of thousands fled into Thailand. in the late 1970s various chemical weapons were used on Hmong populations while others were imprisoned, and sent to labour camps. Naturally after decades of fighting there was no particular shortage of people who had been involved in the war or in working with the US.
The refuges as one might expect were in a jolly position - it is best to avoid being on the loosing side of any war, but because it was officially covert and still worse, the CIA had lost, the USA didn't want to know, perhaps in part didn't even know - which is were this book comes in as Agitprop. When the book ends the Thais are increasingly unsupportive hosts of the 25,000 odd refugees, there are some thousands of Hmong in the USA, the USA is angling towards normalisation of relations with Laos despite their human rights record and there are ongoing attempts to enforce the voluntary repatriation of refugees.
All in all it is a decent work of campaigning journalism but for the absence of apparent success or a road map to a bearable future. On the downside it has a tendency to flop into stories of who spilled whiskey over themselves one New Year's Eve, equally some may feel that CIA operatives engaging in Animist ceremonies to bind parties together for common action is a difficult basis to build lasting American policy on. For me the author was overly fussed about Vietnamese violations of the Geneva accords in regard to Laotian neutrality when according to her account the US were equally in violation, I couldn't help suspect that if challenged on this her answer would be 'Mommy, they started it!'.
I wondered if one could go along with the subtext of the narrative that the Hmong were victims of the Cold war roped in as proxies in order to avoid a head to head nuclear confrontation between the Soviets and the USA, or if the Hmong made use of US weapons and air support to continue traditional rivalries in a more modern fashion. I suppose either way it doesn't matter much to the resulting mess, people who play with sharp knives often have fewer fingers.
The author was a journalist, maybe still is - and much of the book is constructed from interviews she had with various people - she is plainly interested in this story, her account closes with writing to U.S congresspersons and Senators trying to prevent forced 'voluntary' repatriations from refuge camps in Thailand to Laos.
As you might expect from a journalist's book it is chatty and a mass of anecdotes, arranged to form a continuous narrative. Until the end of the book she is entirely self-effacing, although she was active as a journalist in the region during the Vietnam war it is unclear how much time she spent then in Laos, in the introduction she mentions that U.S personnel were not helpful or forthcoming, unlike in Vietnam, so it may be that most of her contacts and personal involvement began only after 1975 when formally the informal war ended. None of this matters much aside from that readers may want to salt some of want she recounts particularly reported dialogue or precise seeming details about weapons and the like.
She opens with a depiction of the Hmong as American types, or at least as sharing homely American values, apart from their habit of cultivating opium, in which they paid taxes to the French and used as a cure-all for the stresses,strains and injuries arising from this earthly life, and I suppose also their tradition of embroidery, the young men allegedly having a keen appreciation of needlework skills and would marry the most able seamstresses, also polygamy which was to become a sticking point later. It comes across as an appeal to the audience and no doubt this is no simple story but a campaigning book.
Anyhow the Hmong, she says were a simple minority group in Laos, upland farmers, who had drifted into the country from China in the not very distant past. They were divided into a handful of clans, were animists in contrast to the Buddhist majority in Laos, they spoke their own language, they made their own flintlock muskets, the women folk wore necklaces made from silver French colonial coins, the Hmong were mostly excluded from education and generally looked down upon as the Indochinese equivalents of Hill-billies. Towards the end of WWII a handful of French soldiers engaged some Hmong in insurgent warfare against the Japanese with considerable success, although the Hmong generally only bothered to turn up and fight if they thought they'd win, not realising at this stage that in modern organised total warfare it is the taking part, not the winning, that counts.
All these stories go back to the Japanese invasion / personally extended invitation to join the Asian co-prosperity sphere, and the breakdown of colonial authority.
As the USA gets involved in fighting in Vietnam they notice that supplies are being moved into South Vietnam through Laos along what is called the Ho Che Min trail and in a move to disrupt this a CIA operative turns up among the Hmong calls himself Colonel Billy and asks if they want to fight communists if he provides the guns. His offer apparently is enthusiastically welcomed. Presumably there was a little more to it than that, but that is more or less how it comes across here. ' Colonel Billy's' conception is that this should be an entirely covert operation and essentially guerilla warfare, he is later accused of running the whole affair out of his trouser pocket to which he can only assent as that is where he kept his note book with all the details he needed to recall. A key part of his conception is to minimise official US involvement since, similarly to as is argued in Understanding Vietnam he felt the US presence was self-destructive as it ended with large numbers of monolingual people in air-conditioned facilities with a huge logistical tail writing reports on the welfare of Americans in South-East Asia rather than actually engaging with the people whose hearts and minds they needed to win. Eventually this 'Colonel Billy' was pushed out, partly it seems because he wasn't spending enough money and didn't have a big enough office, at least that is how it comes across.
After his departure the conception changes to using the Hmong as a substitute for regular infantry forces. By this time twenty thousand or more Hmong are under arms led by General Vang Pao - formally an officer in the Lao army. He was something of a big chief, his eventual five marriages linked him to several clans and his charisma (getting back to Max Weber here) won him a substantial following, helpfully the author tells us he was opposed to the opium trade. The US were providing 'covert' air support from bases in Thailand and units of the Thai army were also occasionally involved. Vang Pao pushed for air power under his own control to which end a handful of Hmong were trained as pilots, unfortunately as they all tended to be short the control panels had to be altered and the trainees were given thick cushions so that they could see out of the windows.
Air power was a critical element in supplying and fighting in this tropical mountainous region, all the more so as Vang Pao withdrew into the mountains to fight from more defensible/ inaccessible areas, this led to the construction of various bizarre dirt and log runways, sometimes with dog legs, occasionally cantilevered over mountainsides and so on. The fighting led to considerable social change, since the Hmong had moved from the Highlands to the mountains they were dependant on food supplies. Due to casualties they recruited boys to fight - the basic rule was, similar to fairgrounds, that you had to be at least as tall as the weapon you were intending to use, some girls were trained as nurses, there was an effort to provide elementary schooling, and soldiers were paid cash money.
All things come to an end. In this case in 1975. A small number of Hmong were flown out of the country. General Vang Pao managed, after divorcing most of his wives, to get to the USA where he got a mortgage to buy a farm in Montana though eventually he drifted to California, he died in 2011. Reasonably the Hmong feared reprisals as Vietnam friendly forces took over Laos and tens of thousands fled into Thailand. in the late 1970s various chemical weapons were used on Hmong populations while others were imprisoned, and sent to labour camps. Naturally after decades of fighting there was no particular shortage of people who had been involved in the war or in working with the US.
The refuges as one might expect were in a jolly position - it is best to avoid being on the loosing side of any war, but because it was officially covert and still worse, the CIA had lost, the USA didn't want to know, perhaps in part didn't even know - which is were this book comes in as Agitprop. When the book ends the Thais are increasingly unsupportive hosts of the 25,000 odd refugees, there are some thousands of Hmong in the USA, the USA is angling towards normalisation of relations with Laos despite their human rights record and there are ongoing attempts to enforce the voluntary repatriation of refugees.
All in all it is a decent work of campaigning journalism but for the absence of apparent success or a road map to a bearable future. On the downside it has a tendency to flop into stories of who spilled whiskey over themselves one New Year's Eve, equally some may feel that CIA operatives engaging in Animist ceremonies to bind parties together for common action is a difficult basis to build lasting American policy on. For me the author was overly fussed about Vietnamese violations of the Geneva accords in regard to Laotian neutrality when according to her account the US were equally in violation, I couldn't help suspect that if challenged on this her answer would be 'Mommy, they started it!'.
I wondered if one could go along with the subtext of the narrative that the Hmong were victims of the Cold war roped in as proxies in order to avoid a head to head nuclear confrontation between the Soviets and the USA, or if the Hmong made use of US weapons and air support to continue traditional rivalries in a more modern fashion. I suppose either way it doesn't matter much to the resulting mess, people who play with sharp knives often have fewer fingers.
Read
February 13, 2010This book is very personal to me since it is the story of my parents and grandparents. To some, it may seem like just a tragedy or something that happened long ago. But in my parents' house, it's a story that's still told with a lot of sorrow and heartache. The book covers a lot of information about the Vietnam War that most people aren't aware of. Some part can be brutal.
March 14, 2022
A rich, well-written and mostly well-researched work, if quirky. It feels very journalistic for a book from an academic publisher.
Hamilton-Merritt covers the sacrifices the Hmong made in the war, and the suffering they endured after the communists won. She definitely has a passion and sympathy for their story, and identifies strongly with them; the book is certainly not always written in a detached, scholarly tone, if that’s what you’re looking for. Also, Hamilton-Merritt played a role in the charge that the communists used chemical weapons in Laos. This claim came under scrutiny when she made it, and much of the book is a defense of her allegations. She ably covers how other Lao peoples often viewed the Hmong as collaborators with the French and then with the Americans. The narrative transitions smoothly from setting to setting.
The latter half of the book, however, seems a little unorganized and gives you the impression that Hamilton-Merritt lost some of her interest toward the end. The level of detail sometimes seems excessive. The research seems mostly based on interviews. There also could have been some more analysis of why the Hmong joined the American side (or why some Hmong joined the communists, a topic that she almost completely ignores), and how it complicated America’s alliance with the Lao government, and on the Hmong’s relations with other groups in Laos. Her portrait of the Hmong people often feels like caricature. Hamilton-Merritt also blames the Americans for betraying the Hmong, but doesn’t provide a lot of coverage of specific actions by America’s wartime leaders. She often repeats what US embassy officials said at the time, but doesn’t really analyze these statements. She seems to style herself as the Hmong’s leading advocate, but you don’t really learn that much about the group.
Much of the book deals with Vang Pao. Hamilton-Merritt’s coverage of him verges on hero worship, and in this version of history the general never makes any mistakes. She insists that Vang Pao wasn’t complicit in the regional drug trade, and mostly ignores the role played by opium in the Hmong economy and society. When she covers Vang Pao’s life in the US, she skips over his shady financial dealings. She also seems supportive of the postwar Hmong resistance movements in Laos, but doesn’t cover how they affected life there (or how Vang Pao funded them by basically demanding money from other Hmong refugees in America)
Sometimes Hamilton-Merritt includes lengthy conversations, even though she wasn’t present during them. She also tries to get into the minds and emotional states of the many of the people involved in the story一一even when they’re people she didn’t interview. When describing the origins of the CIA’s alliance with the Hmong, Hamilton-Merritt refers to a “Colonel Billy.” From reading the book’s description of him, you can tell this is Bill Lair, but for some reason he’s never named.
Other parts could have been explained better. Harry Aderholt is introduced in the narrative as “the officer in charge of the Tibetan airlift.” Some readers may be familiar with this operation, but Hamilton-Merritt never bothers describing it. On the lack of American armed intervention at Dien Bien Phu in 1954, she writes “Perhaps the US decided it could not undertake such a mission without the approval of its major ally, Britain, which refused to change its policy of nonintervention in Indochina.” There is no discussion of the debate on US intervention at this stage of the war, or the documentary record that explains some of this.
There’s a few errors as well. At one point she writes that the CIA was successful in their paramilitary operations until Laos. Apparently, she hasn’t looked much at previous examples of abortive Agency projects like Tibet, Indonesia, or Cuba. Clarence Abadie is called “Aberdee” at one point. Harry Aderholt’s unit is called the “1095th Operational Evaluation Training Group,” even though it was the 1045 Operations, Evaluation and Training Group. Hamilton-Merritt writes that during the Geneva Conference of 1962, Kennedy “created the Green Berets” (they were formed in 1952) She also repeats the story that the North Vietnamese walked out of the Paris talks because they balked at Thieu’s demand for changes, and that Nixon then bombed them to bring them back to the table. These bombing plans, however, were discussed before these snags developed, and were executed because Nixon wanted to convince Thieu of his sincerity so that South Vietnam would agree to an armistice.
The book is valuable for the Hmong perspective, for sure, and the narrative is engaging, but as an actual history it has its shortcomings. You should definitely supplement this with other books on the topic.
Hamilton-Merritt covers the sacrifices the Hmong made in the war, and the suffering they endured after the communists won. She definitely has a passion and sympathy for their story, and identifies strongly with them; the book is certainly not always written in a detached, scholarly tone, if that’s what you’re looking for. Also, Hamilton-Merritt played a role in the charge that the communists used chemical weapons in Laos. This claim came under scrutiny when she made it, and much of the book is a defense of her allegations. She ably covers how other Lao peoples often viewed the Hmong as collaborators with the French and then with the Americans. The narrative transitions smoothly from setting to setting.
The latter half of the book, however, seems a little unorganized and gives you the impression that Hamilton-Merritt lost some of her interest toward the end. The level of detail sometimes seems excessive. The research seems mostly based on interviews. There also could have been some more analysis of why the Hmong joined the American side (or why some Hmong joined the communists, a topic that she almost completely ignores), and how it complicated America’s alliance with the Lao government, and on the Hmong’s relations with other groups in Laos. Her portrait of the Hmong people often feels like caricature. Hamilton-Merritt also blames the Americans for betraying the Hmong, but doesn’t provide a lot of coverage of specific actions by America’s wartime leaders. She often repeats what US embassy officials said at the time, but doesn’t really analyze these statements. She seems to style herself as the Hmong’s leading advocate, but you don’t really learn that much about the group.
Much of the book deals with Vang Pao. Hamilton-Merritt’s coverage of him verges on hero worship, and in this version of history the general never makes any mistakes. She insists that Vang Pao wasn’t complicit in the regional drug trade, and mostly ignores the role played by opium in the Hmong economy and society. When she covers Vang Pao’s life in the US, she skips over his shady financial dealings. She also seems supportive of the postwar Hmong resistance movements in Laos, but doesn’t cover how they affected life there (or how Vang Pao funded them by basically demanding money from other Hmong refugees in America)
Sometimes Hamilton-Merritt includes lengthy conversations, even though she wasn’t present during them. She also tries to get into the minds and emotional states of the many of the people involved in the story一一even when they’re people she didn’t interview. When describing the origins of the CIA’s alliance with the Hmong, Hamilton-Merritt refers to a “Colonel Billy.” From reading the book’s description of him, you can tell this is Bill Lair, but for some reason he’s never named.
Other parts could have been explained better. Harry Aderholt is introduced in the narrative as “the officer in charge of the Tibetan airlift.” Some readers may be familiar with this operation, but Hamilton-Merritt never bothers describing it. On the lack of American armed intervention at Dien Bien Phu in 1954, she writes “Perhaps the US decided it could not undertake such a mission without the approval of its major ally, Britain, which refused to change its policy of nonintervention in Indochina.” There is no discussion of the debate on US intervention at this stage of the war, or the documentary record that explains some of this.
There’s a few errors as well. At one point she writes that the CIA was successful in their paramilitary operations until Laos. Apparently, she hasn’t looked much at previous examples of abortive Agency projects like Tibet, Indonesia, or Cuba. Clarence Abadie is called “Aberdee” at one point. Harry Aderholt’s unit is called the “1095th Operational Evaluation Training Group,” even though it was the 1045 Operations, Evaluation and Training Group. Hamilton-Merritt writes that during the Geneva Conference of 1962, Kennedy “created the Green Berets” (they were formed in 1952) She also repeats the story that the North Vietnamese walked out of the Paris talks because they balked at Thieu’s demand for changes, and that Nixon then bombed them to bring them back to the table. These bombing plans, however, were discussed before these snags developed, and were executed because Nixon wanted to convince Thieu of his sincerity so that South Vietnam would agree to an armistice.
The book is valuable for the Hmong perspective, for sure, and the narrative is engaging, but as an actual history it has its shortcomings. You should definitely supplement this with other books on the topic.
December 29, 2017
A sometimes overly sympathetic look at the Hmong people of Laos and what happened to them during and immediately after the "Secret War" in Laos. (Vang Pao, for instance, while being a remarkable guerrilla leader did have his faults and did often succumb to his vanity.) The Hmong story, I hasten to add, is actually a sympathetic story overall. So it is acceptable that their side of things is given a primacy here, whereas in other histories of the conflict, the Hmong are often underappreciated, at best, or unappreciated, at worst. The fact is that they were tenacious fighters and committed to the land, Laos, when other Lao peoples did not have the will to fight the North Vietnamese. It should be mentioned, however, that not all Hmong fought against the Communists and with covert American forces. Some served on the other side and have reaped great honors in contemporary Laos for their commitment to the communist cause.
An important part of the story that also is much neglected is how the Hmong fled Laos after the end of the war in 1975. Many ended up in refugee camps in Thailand, where life was far from easy and almost all faced the threat of death while trying to cross the Mekong to get to Thailand. That the Hmong survived their ordeal is admirable. And their later success, when they came to the United States, is still a story in progress.
An important part of the story that also is much neglected is how the Hmong fled Laos after the end of the war in 1975. Many ended up in refugee camps in Thailand, where life was far from easy and almost all faced the threat of death while trying to cross the Mekong to get to Thailand. That the Hmong survived their ordeal is admirable. And their later success, when they came to the United States, is still a story in progress.
August 6, 2013
Important information about an aspect of the so called Vietnam War that most Americans know nothing about. The author spent time as a journalist during in the war, and witnessed many events she describes. She also played a role in getting recognition - or at least, attempting, for some of the people who were involved in the "secret war" in Laos. This explains why the tone of her narrative comes across as shrill, given that she was writing for a purpose and amidst an ongoing crisis. So this doesn't read like a typical academic treatise, it rather as a journalistic exposé.
October 4, 2008
How could I express my gratitude...it tells the facts of why Hmong people are here in USA, how so many of us are here, whether we wanted to or not.
March 6, 2026
This book (masterpiece/text book) fills me with feelings of immense sadness and immense indignation. I had tears but more often I shook my head in anger and disbelief.
To my “spare” son, I’m so glad your big brother pulled little you out of the Mekong River and saved you from drowning. ❤️
To my “spare” son, I’m so glad your big brother pulled little you out of the Mekong River and saved you from drowning. ❤️
January 15, 2021
This book tells an important Hmong history, but it is basically told from General Vang Pao's perspective, and thus misses some important points.
October 10, 2016
This year President Obama became the first American president in office to visit Laos and acknowledge the role the U.S. played there during the Vietnam War. The Ho Chi Minh trail ran through Laos, the Americans ran many secret bombings against the Viet Minh from there. They mostly worked with an ethnic minority called the Hmong whom they trained and encouraged in guerrilla warfare. There was no official agreement between the Hmongs and the U.S. so when the U.S. pulled out many of the Hmong were left behind and seemingly forgotten. They were killed or disappeared when the communists took over in Laos without any concern shown by u.s. policy-makers. Some of the Hmong top fighters did emigrate to the U.S. but the general public knows nothing about them and how closely they worked with and helped the u.s. If anything they were vilified in the media as public sentiment turned against the war, the u.s. military and politicians.
This is the only book I've come across that tells this story. The author does take a side, though. She is clearly advocating for the Hmong.
Makes me want to finish The Pentagon Papers.
For an unrelated take on the Hmong: The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman
This is the only book I've come across that tells this story. The author does take a side, though. She is clearly advocating for the Hmong.
Makes me want to finish The Pentagon Papers.
For an unrelated take on the Hmong: The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman
July 11, 2008
I didn't finish this book. I think it was because it's summer that I'm just not in the mood for nonfiction. Particularly on a subject which I at least know something about already, and seemed a bit not seeing the forest for the trees. Fascinating information on the role of the Hmong in Laos, though. The author of Hmong! The CIA's Secret Army seems to have used information verbatim from this book.
December 14, 2013
canceled
October 16, 2013
Highly recommend to anyone interested in the truth of the ruin of Laos and its people.
January 11, 2017
Read in college and got this much fatso. I don't know if it was in this book or somewhere else but I'm recalling something about Korean soldiers being involved or sent. I could be erred.
March 13, 2016
The last few chapters are absolutely heartbreaking. I need some time to process.
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews