Typical Anne Perry mystery, maybe a little drier than most.
As always, I enjoyed the glimpse into Victorian England.
I enjoyed the scenes with the home life of Thomas & Charlotte Pitt. Sometimes, they feel more like Anne Perry's other characters to me from her other series, William and Hester Monk. I did like Tellman's character and the growth in his character arc, and Gracie and her final input into the mystery as well, and even Balantyne and Cornwallis. Well done.
Anne Perry did well describing the desperation that the blackmail victims felt, and I'd agree that many people just want to believe something sensational rather than trying to discern the truth about someone.
I remember telling that to my then-gradeschool-aged child who had been accused of eating soup at her desk out of her lunchbox. She was horrified that anyone would think she had done such a thing, and hadn't even brought soup to school, and couldn't understand why people wouldn't believe her or why the other students would pick on her for something she hadn't even done - something more absurd and not morally wrong. I told her they wanted to believe it because it was more interesting than believing the truth.
The same theme encompasses this book, where the blackmailer threatens to tell people, not what the victims have truly done, but something more interesting and more condemning, knowing that most people would believe it, and it would ruin them just the same.
I did not figure out whodunit. There were too many suspects for the blackmailing for me to keep them all straight. I did, however, consider this one who mentioned something someone else had said. I wasn't sure whether those words were really coming from the other person. But I didn't continue down that train of thought far enough to be sure. I'm not convinced we had enough information to be sure. I did not guess the murderer, and I know we didn't have enough information for that one.
I did know how the blackmail victims were all related, and SPOILER ... I did know most of what was happening at the orphanage. I felt like Perry tried to confuse and distract us with so many facts about all the blackmail victims, but really, there weren't many alternatives listed outright in determining those two pieces of the mystery - how the victims were linked, and why the money was so odd, that they had too few orphans, not too many.
One of the other reviewers mentioned that the flowers - tulips and lilacs - were out of season. I noticed that, too. When I came across reading them, I thought, "Hey, wait! Wasn't this taking place in the heat of summer?" Tulips and lilacs are spring flowers, April around here, but I don't know when they bloom in England.
Favorite quotes:
"What kind of friend makes their support conditional upon knowing everything that will happen, and that there will be no unpleasant surprises and absolutely no inconvenience, embarrassment or cost?"
"A great many friends. But none of the best. This loyalty must run both ways. One does not allow friends to walk unknowingly into danger or unpleasantness, nor require of them a pledge, even unspoken, whose costs you know and they do not."
"How did anyone endure having children and watching them grow up, make mistakes, get hurt, perhaps even be destroyed, suffer pain that was worse, more inexplicable than death?"
"And to be a really good commander, you must be loved ... that is what inspires a crew of men to go beyond their duty, beyond even what can be expected of them, to dare, to sacrifice, and to achieve what to a lesser crew, with the same ship, would be impossible."
"Perhaps when all is said and done a quiet conscience is the greatest possession, but a good name in the eyes of others is second." There might be other things I might list as higher - being loved and forgiven, among them - but I would agree that living with a good conscience is of greater worth than a good reputation, but that we do care what others think.