#litlife192021 An Ancient Greek or Roman Work OR Finish a Book You Started But Never Finished
Trying to classically educate my kids, I began reading this on two different occasions in the past, only to give up. I finally got through the entire book this year, but not before my son, to whom I assigned it for lit. The arrangement of the myths feels a bit scattered or arbitrary to me, and thus I couldn't give it a 5-star rating. I feel that the children's D'aulaire's Greek Myths does a better job at (sort of) chronologically or thematically arranging the myths so that they stick in your mind. But I really appreciate that Bulfinch attempted to cut out some of the themes that aren't helpful to developing Christian affections, meanwhile including all myths that will be most referenced in classical literature, and trying to tell them in a delightful way. Here's what he says:
"Having chosen mythology as connected with literature for our province, we have endeavoured to omit nothing which the reader of elegant literature is likely to find occasion for. Such stories and parts of stories as are offensive to pure taste and good morals are not given. But such stories are not often referred to, and if they occasionally should be, the English reader need feel no mortification in confessing his ignorance of them. Our book is not for the learned, nor for the theologian, nor for the philosopher, but for the reader of English literature, of either sex, who wishes to comprehend the allusions so frequently made by public speakers, lecturers, essayists, and poets, and those which occur in polite conversation."
And here is what Graves says in his foreword:
"Bulfinch was at pains to tone down the brutally frank original details of some myths (for example the one about Osiris's dismemberment) and omit incidents unsuitable for young ears and eyes, such as the Argonauts' experiences on the Island of Lemnos...) ...His main object was to provide a key to the classical references found in the educated poets of his day--such as.... And, indeed, as a source of quotation Bulfinch has long ranked with the Bible, Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress, Tennysons's Idylls of the King, Lamb's Tales form Shakespeare, and Milton's Paradise Lost, especially among those who have had no classical schooling."