Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Thousands of years ago, small hunting bands crossed the fragile land bridge linking the Eurasian continent to the Americas and discovered a land untouched by humankind. Over the centuries that followed, their descendents spread throughout this land. Bestselling authors and award-winning archaeologists W. Michael Gear and Kathleen O?Neal Gear bring the stories of these first North Americans to life in this magnificent, multi-volume saga. Set five thousand years ago and ranging through what is now Montana, Wyoming, northern Colorado, and Utah, People of the Earth follows the migration of the Uto-Aztecan people south out of Canada. It is the unforgettable tale of a woman torn between two peoples and two dreams, of the two men who love her and the third who must have her, and of the vision given to the peoples long ago by the spirit of the wolf.

608 pages, Paperback

First published February 15, 1992

133 people are currently reading
2013 people want to read

About the author

W. Michael Gear

181 books730 followers
W. Michael Gear was born in Colorado Springs, Colorado, on the twentieth of May, 1955. A fourth generation Colorado native, his family had been involved in hard-rock mining, cattle ranching, and journalism. After his father's death in 1959, Michael's mother received her Master's degree in journalism and began teaching. In 1962 she married Joseph J. Cook, who taught tool and die making, and the family lived in Lakewood, Colorado, until 1968. At that time they moved to Fort Collins so that Joe could pursue his Ph.D.. During those years the family lived in the foothills above Horsetooth Reservoir.

It was there that Mike developed a love of history, anthropology, and motorcycles. They would color his future and fill his imagination for the rest of his life. During summers he volunteered labor on local ranches or at the farm east of Greeley and landed his first real job: picking up trash at the lake and cleaning outhouses. It has been said that his exposure to trash led him into archaeology. We will not speculate about what cleaning the outhouses might have led him to. On his first dig as a professional archaeologist in 1976 he discovered that two thousand year old human trash isn't nearly as obnoxious as the new stuff.

Michael graduated from Fort Collins High School in 1972 and pursued both his Bachelor's (1976) and Master's (1979) degrees at Colorado State University. Upon completion of his Master's - his specialty was in physical anthropology - he went to work for Western Wyoming College in Rock Springs as a field archaeologist.

It was in the winter of 1978 that he wrote his first novel. Irritated by historical inaccuracies in Western fiction, he swore he could do better. He was "taking retirement in installments," archaeology being a seasonal career, in the cabin his great uncle Aubrey had built. One cold January night he read a Western novel about a trail drive in which steers (castrated males) had calves. The historical inaccuracies of the story bothered him all night. The next morning, still incensed, he chunked wood into the stove and hunkered over the typewriter. There, on the mining claim, at nine thousand feet outside of Empire, Colorado he hammered out his first five hundred and fifty page novel. Yes, that first manuscript still exists, but if there is justice in the universe, no one will ever see it. It reads wretchedly - but the historical facts are correct!

Beginning in 1981, Michael, along with two partners, put together his own archaeological consulting company. Pronghorn Anthropological Associates began doing cultural resource management studies in 1982, and, although Michael sold his interest in 1984, to this day the company remains in business in Casper, Wyoming. During the years, Michael has worked throughout the western United States doing archaeological surveys, testing, and mitigation for pipelines, oil wells, power lines, timber sales, and highway construction. He learned the value of strong black coffee, developed a palate for chocolate donuts, and ferreted out every quality Mexican restaurant in eight states. He spent nine months of the year traveling from project to project with his trowel and dig kit, a clapped-out '72 Wonder Blazer, and his boon companion, Tedi, a noble tri-color Sheltie.

That fateful day in November, 1981, was delightfully clear, cold, and still in Laramie, Wyoming. Archaeologists from all over the state had arrived at the University of Wyoming for the annual meetings of the Wyoming Association of Professional Archaeologists. It was there, in the meeting room, way too early after a much too long night, that Mike first laid eyes on the most beautiful woman in the world: Kathleen O'Neal Gear. The BLM State Archaeologist, Ray Leicht, introduced him to the pretty anthropologist and historian, and best of all, Ray invited Mike to lunch with Kathleen. It was the perfect beginning for a long and wondrous relationship.

http://us.macmillan.com/author/wmicha...

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
1,814 (42%)
4 stars
1,446 (33%)
3 stars
853 (19%)
2 stars
122 (2%)
1 star
33 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews
Profile Image for Melissa.
1,324 reviews67 followers
January 13, 2014
The First North Americans series is a prehistoric fiction series written by the husband/wife team of Michael & Kathleen Gear. People of the Earth is the third book in that series, and actually the best one I've read out of the first three.

White Ash was kidnapped as a child from the Earth people by a man of the Sun people. Which was actually ok with her. Her adoptive parents were much nicer than her original family. But hostile tribes are attacking the Sun people now and they are being forced to fight or move South. White Ash also has to deal with the strange dreams she's been having and the unwanted attentions of a man who claims he's been to the camp of the dead. And her only help is in an unlikely, mild mannered man with only one good arm.

Both White Ash and Bad Belly are great characters. They aren't perfect, or even overly strong. They are regular people who have been called out to do something special. Bad Belly especially is inspiring. I like how humble he is and that he has tranquility despite being made fun of. White Ash isn't quite as humble, in fact she's a little neurotic, but she still is much more human than some of the other "almost perfect" characters in the previous books have been.

This whole book is about struggle. Whether it's with inner demons, other tribes, disabilities, and everything else, someone is having a struggle. And the goal is to overcome that. There was a lot of mystical lore and activity going on in this book as well. And I'm still not sure how I feel about that. I know I'd probably prefer a book that's just about the lives of these people during the time period without the magic, but at least it is used to tell a good story. Like the other books, this one does have violence, rape, and other harsh topics.

Definitely the better book out of the first three. They still aren't edge of your seat fantastic, but they're interesting reading. On to book four!

People of the Earth
Copyright 1992
587 pages

Review by M. Reynard 2013

More of my reviews can be found at www.ifithaswords.blogspot.com
Profile Image for Noella.
1,255 reviews77 followers
December 30, 2020
Zeer mooi boek uit deze reeks. De hoofdpersonen zijn Witte Es en Stil Water, en ook Windrenner en Dappere Man zijn belangrijke figuren. Witte Es en Dappere Man zijn Dromers, en staan tegenover elkaar zoals vroeger Wolfdromer en zijn broeder. Er staat Witte Es een zware taak te wachten zo moet het volk van de Zon en het volk van de Aarde samen Dromen, en dat gaat niet zonder dat ze eerst vele gevaren moet overwinnen, in het gezelschap van Stil Water, om dan de ultieme geestelijke strijd aan te gaan met Dappere Man.
Nadat het vorige boek een beetje tegenviel, wist dit verhaal me weer helemaal in de ban te houden en me veel leesplezier te geven.
Profile Image for Mieczyslaw Kasprzyk.
891 reviews148 followers
March 14, 2015

Once again we are taken back through time, to another era of climate change and the movement of whole peoples across the land. The life and death struggle to survive is always the focal point of the "First Americans" series. Once again Power forges a leader to lead the people along the path to new lands and a new life. If there is a degree of predictability in the "First Americans" series then it is easy to forgive. We are drawn into the struggle of a people who are tied to the land but are also constantly struggling to survive. War is not uncommon and the tribes have their great warriors and their disastrous defeats. We are drawn into the tale as we watch "ordinary" people live in peace among their own but then, through the forces unleashed, prove to be more than "ordinary". It takes a strong leader to bind them together and to lead them with vision. As tribes move south, away from starving lands to more fertile grounds, like a set of dominoes being knocked over, change becomes the way forward.
I enjoyed this tale but am a little wary, as always, of the spirit world that is also conjured up. Our true heroes become like Shaolin monks, meditating and losing themselves in the One... and at times what is such an earthy tale, with its love for the land and those that live upon it, loses itself in fantasy.
Profile Image for Julie.
617 reviews3 followers
November 17, 2012
This novel, based on the archeology of authors W. Michael Gear and Kathleen O'Neal Gear as well as others, explores the mythology and relationships between native peoples living 5000 years ago in what is now Montana and Wyoming. I was thoroughly engrossed. Character driven novels enthrall me.
Profile Image for Belinda Vlasbaard.
3,371 reviews101 followers
July 5, 2022
4,25 stars - English Ebook

Quote: White Ash shook her head, the smile on her lips bittersweet. Three years ago things had begun to change. Rumors had circulated down the trail that the other clans were beginning to move south, seeking new territory. The White Clay warriors had strutted among the lodges, thumping their chests, growling threats about what they’d do if the other clans came near.

Then the Black Point clan attacked the camp on the Fat Beaver River and caught everyone by surprise. The White Clay had fled in horrified confusion and come unraveled, splitting into three factions. Defeat after defeat had thinned what remained of their ranks. But the people had never been as desperate as they now were. War visited them again, bringing death and privation. Hunger stalked the camp, reflected in the gaunt faces of the children and elders.

The cold seemed to intensify, rending their bodies with talons of ice. Hope had fled with the ghost of summer.
Hope? How can I hope? What have I done to deserve this? What hope will there be for White Ash? She closed her eyes and shook her head, trying to escape the images in the Dreams. She forced herself to relive the days when she and Wind Runner and Brave Man had laughed and told each other what they hoped for the future.

The sun had been brighter then. The meat racks had bent under the weight of rich red slabs. The White Clay had been whole, powerful. Smiling faces peered at her from the past—faces of people dead or vanished with the breakup of the clan. Faces now as remote as those of her native Earth People.-

Set five thousand years ago and ranging through what is now Montana, Wyoming, northern Colorado, and Utah, People of the Earth follows the migration of the Uto-Aztecan people south out of Canada.

It is the unforgettable tale of a woman torn between two peoples and two dreams, of the two men who love her and the third who must have her, and of the vision given to the peoples long ago by the spirit of the wolf.

Once again we are taken back through time, to another era of climate change and the movement of whole peoples across the land. The life and death struggle to survive is always the focal point of the "First Americans" series.

Once again Power forges a leader to lead the people along the path to new lands and a new life. If there is a degree of predictability in the "First Americans" series then it is easy to forgive. I was drawn into the struggle of a people who are tied to the land but are also constantly struggling to survive.

War is not uncommon and the tribes have their great warriors and their disastrous defeats. We are drawn into the tale as we watch "ordinary" people live in peace among their own but then, through the forces unleashed, prove to be more than "ordinary".

It takes a strong leader to bind them together and to lead them with vision. As tribes move south, away from starving lands to more fertile grounds, like a set of dominoes being knocked over, change becomes the way forward.


I enjoyed this tale but am a little wary, as always, of the spirit world that is also conjured up. Our true heroes become like Shaolin monks, meditating and losing themselves in the One... and at times what is such an earthy tale, with its love for the land and those that live upon it, loses itself in fantasy.
Profile Image for Gabriel Romero.
43 reviews1 follower
October 31, 2018
Uno de los mejores libros en cuanto a la comprensión de las deidades en la época de las migraciones del continente americano, la interacción entre las tribus es un verdadero deleite; el autor tipifica la figura del guerrero de manera muy tradicionalista, sin embargo, el rol del chamán es realmente atractivo por que escapa de los estereotipos, con una combinación de vidente y líder social, moderadamente el traductor de las ideas/propuestas de dichas deidades; cuenta con una historia original y la trama es dinámica.
Profile Image for Theresa.
4,130 reviews16 followers
March 27, 2013
Interesting story about how the plains people spread out. I love the battle of power at the end.
51 reviews
October 1, 2019
Same story. All the females are beautiful with lustrous hair and full breast. Same character over and over.
Profile Image for Libros de warmi. F.
71 reviews1 follower
May 20, 2024
Escrito por antopólogos esta historia supo atraparme. No tanto por el camino que realiza Ceniza Blanca -la heroína- y Aguas Tranquilas -el antihéroe- sino por las descripciones de la vida cotidiana.

Se realizó un excelente trabajo en describir como vivieron las tribus de 5.000 años atrás en América del Norte. Se detalla con precisión la forma de vida, la cosmovisión, la relación con la naturaleza, las batallas y los motivos que los llevaron a la guerra a los antiguos pobladores.

Los nombres de los personajes como Fantasma de Artemisa, Consuelda, Corredor del Viento, Álamo Temblón, Luna Brillante, Hombre Bravo, Mal Vientre, Piedras Cantarinas, entre otros, quedaron repiqueteando dentro mío, como caireles movidos suavemente por la brisa.

Esta es una novela para disfrutar con todos los sentidos. Entre escenas de guerra cinematográficas, caminatas por montañas y planicies, valles con suaves hierbas, crudos inviernos atravesados por tormentas de nieve y veranos ardientes: La tribu de la Tierra se levantará de la mano de una nueva Soñadora.

La novela ofrece varias moralejas o enseñanzas: el respeto y cuidado por la tierra, todo en esta vida es una ilusión, el amor nos hace poderosos, los beneficios de la meditación, la búsqueda de la vida sencilla en armonía con el entorno... pasan como antiguos ecos atravesando generaciones y generaciones de clanes y grupos sociales, están al alcance de todos. ¿Quiénes realmente las escucharán?
Profile Image for Chris Meads.
648 reviews10 followers
January 27, 2018
This is 3rd in the series of North America's Forgotten Past.

The story starts out in the present when a company's bulldozer unearths a skeleton. They decide to hide it because of the ramifications of what it would mean--the shut down of their project and a bunch of dirt diggers taking over.

The past starts with the Earth People who live in the earth, their homes are made of dirt and they collect plants as well as kill game to live on. One little girl seems to be shun by the rest--she dreams. White Ash is told to get water and that is when she is take captive by Sage Ghost-he has dreamed of taking a child since all his children have died.

White Ash has learned the ways of the White Clay and feels love for Brave Man. But something happens to Brave Man--he claims to have run from the Camp of the Dead and now has Power.

Bad Belly is from Round Rock clan and is also not in favor of the group. He only has one good arm and the other is maimed. When his best friend begins to die, his friend tells Bad Belly to search for the dreamer. So Bad Belly leaves and finds White Ash who is the dreamer.

This is the story of the battle between Brave Man and White Ash to bring the new life through the Spiral.

I like reading the history of primitive man especially around the Wyoming and Colorado area.
Profile Image for Abbi.
123 reviews2 followers
Read
November 29, 2022
Got to page 30. Had to stop. It follows the same plot and over used cliches as People of the Wolf.
Profile Image for Natalie.
815 reviews2 followers
June 29, 2020
I have to hand it to the Gears- they do a wonderful job of combining story with history when it comes to Native Americans. They cite dozens of sources and describe a people's day to day life; from the huts they live in to the food they eat, and the clothes they wear. They do all this without getting overly wordy and losing their audience (see: Jane Auel). Their characters are always relatable and real. In this particular novel, we're focusing on the area of what is now Montana, and we're following four main characters; Bad Belly/Still Water, White Ash, Brave Man, and Wind Runner. Their stories and journeys are separate enough that whenever the authors shift character gears, you know exactly who you are following. I really loved White Ash and Still Water's story, and I was encouraged to keep reading mostly because of them. I can't say the same for the tribes and clans in general- there were so many that I lost track of who belonged to which clan, and where they lived, and who their leaders were. I found myself skimming over some of this information, as it wasn't always relevant and important to the main story. The other aspect that I didn't enjoy as much was rather integral to the plot, but I found it hard to reconcile- the dreaming. This is where that magical realism tag comes in. White Ash and Brave Man learn to "dream" and in doing so, see the future, speak with spirits, and see the power running through the world. Honestly, I would really have preferred less of this and more of what actually might have happened all those years ago. Native Americans and their culture is interesting all by itself- you don't need to add in power and magic. This aside, it was an interesting story, if slow at some points. I always feel like I learn something when reading these novels, and I can honestly imagine what the long ago past might have been like. The Gears weave a good story, even if they take some liberties. 3.5, rounded up to 4.
Profile Image for Carol Storm.
Author 28 books240 followers
June 28, 2012
An unforgettable gallery of characters makes this ancient saga of North American Indians come alive.

The year is 5000 B.C. Somewhere in the West, ancient Indian tribes are battline for supremacy, lead by competing "Soul Fliers" or shamans, each with a radically different vision for the ages yet to come in North America.

BRAVE MAN -- the power-mad psychopath, whose twisted Vision leads him to kill and rape while dreaming uncanny prophecies of the untold might of the Aztec Empire!

WHITE ASH -- the mother of the people, a vulnerable young woman who was kidnaped as a child, raped repeatedly by enemy warriors, yet nevertheless has the compassion and love for all living things needed to Dream a new way for all the people.

BAD BELLY -- the lovable, crippled misfit who leaves his home village with his dog Trouble, seeking only a way to belong. Instead he discovers danger, terror, and enduring love beyond his wildest dreams.

WIND RUNNER -- the warrior with a heart of gold, he leaves his clan to make a place among strange tribes, only to face a heart-breaking choice between love and honor.

All of the books in the "People" series are unique and different. This one is special because it is the most mystical of the books. All the stories mention Power, the creative force that shapes all living things and is the source of both good and evil. But in this book Power is actually the main character, and all of the action is defined in terms of concepts like the Spiral and the One.

This was a great book, and I would recommend it to any one who is interested in Native Americans, spiritual quests, underdog heroes, or nature. The brutal rape scenes and the graphic violence make it less appropriate for younger readers, however.
119 reviews12 followers
July 13, 2010
i’ve read a few books in this series and i’d have to say that this one’s my favourites. I liked the perspectives from which the authors presented their characters. it was a kind of pensive, but not seriously so… meaning that there are little tidbits to think over every now and again but these tidbits are by no means the focus of the book, more a backdrop to the story, and they don’t really inspire any intense thought, just more of a lazy sunday afternoon pondering kind of thought. if that makes sense.
i thought the story was well put together. there are several plot lines going on at once, which i enjoy because it gets the mind going a bit, but they all tie in to the overall story which is always nice. i liked the character bad belly. he was a reserved kind of guy, not for timidity but kind of for oddness. i thought him and whatever her name was made an ok couple. She could’ve been stronger, which bugged me at times. i read this a while back so i can’t give any examples but i do recall that i wanted her to be stronger at times. though this is so, she wasn’t exactly weak. she had an inner strength, it just wasn’t as powerful when confronting other people. This was a minor detail though. the plot and characters were well done and the story had a nice flow to it.
overall, worth picking up i’d say.
710 reviews1 follower
October 28, 2019
Each novel has shown a pivotal point in the development of North American societies and provided an important glimpse of what life was life during these periods. Hundreds or thousands of years have passed between each novel, but memories are long, and the histories are passed from one generation to the next; with a few differences between peoples. The 1st novel described the arrival of humans to the continent, the second, the realization that humans can survive off plants just as well as animals and this novel deals with the which vision of the future will be realized and the separation of groups that are the ancestors of the Mayan, Aztec and Incan civilizations and those that stayed in North America. At times brutal, this book had plenty of excitement, along with a great deal of insight into the importance of Dreams to all, and how an injured mind can twist such power to develop a dangerous and brutal cult of personality. Good books, you just have to have some imagination along with an open mind to absorb and understand the cultures.
Profile Image for Beth.
206 reviews30 followers
October 29, 2015
This is the sixth book by W. Michael and Kathleen O'Neal Gear that I've read and the third in the First American's Series. This book did not disappoint me. The Gears story of the early American Indian includes their culture, religious beliefs, food, cooking, and daily life interwoven with a cast of characters and adventure. Each book in the series could stand alone but the underlying theme of respect and reverence for nature threads through out the series. These books show the American Indian as a member of a complex culture with complex beliefs not as Indians are often shown on television. I throughly enjoyed the story and the education
Profile Image for Kimberly  Anderson .
37 reviews4 followers
January 28, 2010
I have not been able to put this series down since I first found it a few months ago. It is written by a husband and wife who are both Archaeologists. They have written a series of books called The First North Americans, as well as each writing their own individual books. Though the stories are mainly fictional, they are supplemented by real archaeological and historical findings and facts. Very intense at moments and really sad at others, overall, an excellent read.
Profile Image for Bryan Richard.
43 reviews
Read
November 14, 2012
A really great book and I enjoyed it completely. It is the 3rd. book in a series. I really enjoy this type of subject matter. It was written by a husband and wife team. (They were both arachaeologists).
Profile Image for Darby.
400 reviews60 followers
March 9, 2008
It was long ago when I read this book but I remember enjoying it. It had war, history, love and suffering. It is good historical fiction series.
Profile Image for Theresa.
8,300 reviews134 followers
October 12, 2023
People of the Earth (North America's Forgotten Past #3)
By: W. Michael Gear, Kathleen O'Neal Gear
Narrated by: Mark Boyett
Length: 23 hrs and 57 mins

Mark Boyett has an amazing way of bringing the story to life, as you listen to his words, you hear the subtle things that you missed when reading the book. Heart mountain stands out much grander than in the book. The Hot Springs at Thermopolis become this hidden gem, and the sideways mountains before the Wind River Basin become magical. The characters motives and ideals stand out remarkably. You see the innate evil in Big Man, the connection to Raven Hunter becomes so real that you are linked back to the original story People of the Wolf, just by his nature evoked by the voice given by Mr. Boyett. Still Water is calmer, soothing, in his tones making the listener question why everyone in the story does not see him as the wonderful man he is. The awe of the one and the circle become more enhanced by the performance.


The story begins with a description of common practice in modern times of project managers wanting to hurry their projects as the consequence of history.

White ash is a dreamer, who is taken by power from her people to allow her to grow up with love and understanding. In an attempt to change the future he strives to change the path of man from harmony to discord. White ash must face her greatest fears, and learn to love in the impossible areas to learn to dream back the people to the spiral and continue the path of Wolf Dreamer, and Fire Dancer.

Bad Belly becomes her husband because is uncommon love and understanding is the only way that White ash will be able to balance the world of the One, and the illusion of the world of man.

Wind Runner a new leader of the people, leaves all his remaining family to be with the woman he loves, only to learn strength and thought and understanding in the arms of another woman.

Brave Man a corrupt man who finds the edge of power and dreams a way of controlling White ash and power to make his own vision of the world.

Sage Ghost a grieving man learns that loss can only strengthen you, and love can only fill you.

Character List:
People of the Earth

Dreamer: White Ash dreamer, as a young girl stolen from herpeople so that she will have the opportunity to dream. She is called the“Mother of the people”.

BadBelly/ Still Water: cousin and friend of white ash,learns to lover her although he does not think well of himself, has a bad armlost to a snake bite.

WindRunner: in the sun people clan her cousin because ofthe man who adopted Whiteash, love interest

BraveMan: a childhood friend changed by power because of ahead wound, is corrupted and false dreamer.

Singingstones: the old dreamer of the earth people, changedhis view of power after touching the wolf bundle.

Wolfdreamer/ fire dancer

Power object : (wolf bundle) (less) [edit]
Jul 24, 20
Profile Image for Lauren.
421 reviews
May 12, 2020
3.5 stars

If I have to say one thing about this book, it’s that it’s really easy to get sucked in. When I started reading it I easily imagined it was the middle of winter 5000 years ago, but when I looked up I realized I was sitting in my living room in the middle of a pandemic. When I finished reading it, it was the middle o summer within the story, and I looked out my window expecting to see sunshine, only to see it snowing and gray. It’s really great if you’re looking looking for a book to escape into to forget everyday life for a while. I would definitely be open to reading other books by these authors.

I think, if it was done right, this could make a great movie. Some things from the plot would have to be cut, but i think cinematically it could be amazing. There are such rich descriptions of the landscape, as well as the descriptions of the dream visions.

The story is told mainly from the point of view of four different characters, although occasionally there’s an occasional switch to the point of view of more minor characters.

White Ash- a girl kidnapped from the Earth People as a child and taken to a clan of the Sun People. Her adoptive father took her on prompting from the Power after he and his wife lost all their children and were unable to have more.

Wind Runner- a warrior of the White Clay clan, a friend of White Ash from her childhood. He is in love with her but cannot marry her because her adoptive father is his uncle, making her his cousin. The rules against incest would not allow them to marry, even though they don’t share blood.

Brave Man- a friend of White Ash and Wind Runner, he too is in love with White Ash. When the clan was attacked by enemy warriors, he is supposedly killed, but he escapes the Camp of the Dead and returns to the living. However, after this he is changed, hearing the voices of Power in his head, although the voices are twisted.

Bad Belly- a member of one of the Earth People clans, he is regarded as useless by the people of his clan as one arm was permanently injured by a rattlesnake. He also tends to question the world around him, why things are the way they are and what makes things like that.

For me, my main issue with the book was that the climax felt sort of anticlimactic. It was built up for 500 something pages but I felt like it went too fast and was over too easily. It didn’t seem like it lived up to the promise of the previous pages.

Other things that are more personal preferences that irritated me include the long chapters and switches in point of view within the chapters. Most of the chapters took around 20-30 minutes to read according to my Kindle. I generally prefer shorter chapters, and I think these chapters could have been split up differently because there are switches in point of view within each chapter. The thing that annoyed me about this was that there was very little indication that this was happening, just some added white space between them. However, if the start of a new point of view fell at the top of the page on the Kindle edition, it was difficult to notice sometimes. Usually when authors switch point of view within a chapter there is some sort of visual marker and I found it irritating that there were none here because I would be reading and suddenly get confused and have to reread a bit to figure out there was a switch in the point of view. I also noticed quote a few typos and mistakes, such as writing smite instead of smile, missing quotation marks and a random apostrophe where it wasn’t needed. Not sure if this happened when the book was converted to the Kindle edition or what happened. That was more of a minor thing, though.

This book is sort of difficult to describe because it is focused so much on the cultures of the native peoples. I liked how there were differences between the Earth People and the Sun People, how they had different languages so they couldn’t communicate with each other and how they had different beliefs and traditions. Even within the Earth People and the Sun People there are different clans who don’t always see eye to eye, which I appreciated because it works against the common perception we tend to have of native peoples, which is that they are all basically the same and can be lumped into one group. I did have a bit of trouble envisioning what the Spiral was as well as First Man’s dream and The One, but I think I got the gist of it.


Spoilers!

What disappointed me most with this book was the climax/ending. I’ve found myself disappointed with the endings of other books I have read recently, so it could be just me. I felt like it went too fast, it was over to easily. White Ash goes into The One and Brave Man follows and gets lost in it and dies. That’s it. There’s not really a real battle of dreams or a back and forth between them. I had a similar complaint of another book I read recently. If it’s built up to this big face off or battle, I want to see that. The other thing that bothered me about the ending was how quickly Pale Raven backed down from her challenge to White Ash. I get that she saw that she was powerful from her confrontation with Brave Man, how White Ash escaped The One and Brave Man didn’t, but I thought that she would continue to fight. She doesn’t seem like the type to easily be cowed or back down, but that’s what she does here. Overall I just felt this whole moment was underwhelming and could have been done differently.

I also expected that because we began the book with a connection to the present day, we would end with one, but that wasn’t the case. Unless this is something that connects to the series as a whole that I’m missing, I almost felt like it wasn’t necessary. I guess it did ask the question of what the native peoples saw in that landscape, why they lived there, which the story answers, but I felt the story could have stood on its own without it.
Profile Image for Katelyn.
260 reviews
October 15, 2019
I'm always enraptured with this series, but hearing it in audio brings it to a whole new level of awareness. I am captivated by the characters and the voice of the reader. Within the first sentences, I'm transported into history and the people become real to me. I am swept up into the malignant mental illness of Brave Man, the gentle love of Still Water, the heartbreak and new love Wind Runner finds, and even the devious scheming of Larkspur.
Profile Image for Katie O'malley.
62 reviews
March 21, 2023
I was absolutely swept away by this story. I felt as if I was actually there among the prehistoric North American tribes. Emotions, tribe dynamics, landscapes, weather, and the characters themselves are described in engrossing detail. I felt as if they were real people.

Unfortunately, I give this three stars instead of four because of the unnecessarily graphic depictions of violence and rape. If this is a sensitive topic for you, I would advise against reading this book.
Profile Image for A.W. Sibley.
Author 11 books3 followers
October 12, 2017
I give the Gear books 5 stars (but for adults only). The raw sex and cruelty of the imaginary prehistoric beast called man is a little rough for younger readers. As an adult reader, I like to follow the authors line of imaginary thought as I read about a supposed advance of the creature called man from 15,000 years ago towards modern man. Excellent read!
29 reviews
September 30, 2022
I enjoyed this better than the first two books. The characters were believable and likeable. I do still get confused by the multiple characters and clans, but it is interesting to see how each of them live. I do not like the rape scenes in each of her books, but at least they are not as explicit as they might be. I do recommend this one, but it makes more sense if you have read the earlier ones.
Profile Image for Dan.
624 reviews10 followers
November 13, 2025
DNF - one attribute of a good novel staying power
no matter if I read it again next year or in 10 years, THE SHIPPING NEWS will always satisfy

North America's Forgotten Peoples, or whatever it's called, is dated; it does not satisfy the 21st century reader; it has no staying power

there are other, better sources of pleasure in the field of historical novels; try one of them
Profile Image for Michael McQueen.
155 reviews3 followers
January 7, 2019
While it took me awhile to get into this story, once I did I was in love!! Incredibly rich writing that makes you feel as if you are experiencing the ways of the natives for yourself. I am very excited to read the rest of this series and HIGHLY recommend it.
Profile Image for Trudi.
18 reviews
May 23, 2020
If you loved Jean M Auel's books you will love these books by W Michal Gear And Kathleen O'Neal Gear. They take you back to prehistoric times. They are extremely well written. They draw you in from the very first page until the end. The 1st book is still my favourite.
Profile Image for Deborah Vos.
12 reviews
April 13, 2022
Prachtige herlezing van een boek uit mijn tienerjaren. De serie begint steeds met een scène uit onze tijd en door het hele boek blijf ik maar denken hoe die verband houdt met het verhaal. Heel mooie personages en spannende gebeurtenissen.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.