The genesis of the United States Constitution was built upon centuries of tyranny inflicted by treacherous kings and highly centralized government. In many cases, this authority had to be challenged directly in order for liberty to thrive. As a result, the Constitution was born from a laborious and exhaustive understanding of the British experience that the founders lived under and observed.
In Compact of the Republic, David Benner aims to prove that the Constitution did not impose a nationalist, powerful central government, and was not ratified by “one people.” Instead, the Constitution was a multi-party compact set up by the states, where the states were the masters of their own creation. The states built the federal government, and did not intend for their creation to rule over them.
Compact of the Republic promises to become the standard argument for the compact view of the union, and throws a wrench into the wheel of contemporary legal thought.
In Compact of the Republic, historian David Benner:
*Contends that representatives were made aware that power could be resumed by the states after acts of federal overreach and usurpation *Explores the historical foundation behind the Bill of Rights, and traces the limitations on government to malevolent actions of kings *Proves the Constitution acknowledges the states in the plural, as a collection of societies with varied interests *Reveals that the “elastic clauses” were clearly explained and leave no room for modern reinterpretation *Explains how the federal judiciary now overturns state laws that they have no discretion over, to the contrary of its original scope of power *Describes how Thomas Jefferson and James Madison believed that unconstitutional federal laws had to be opposed, nullified, and obstructed by the states *Illustrates that ratification was only secured by convincing opponents of the Constitution that the document would produce a weak general government with limited, enumerated powers
I was a Political Science major at one of the countries top universities, and I learned more from this book than I did in a year of studying constitutional law. This is one of the best arguments for nullification and return to the original intent of the constitution i have read. Highly recommend for any patriotic citizen or history buff.
Hope you enjoyed Compact of the Republic! It was certainly a great joy to write. If you liked the content within, you will most certainly like my podcast and website.
This book is an excellent guide on the Founders intentions, their disagreements, and the result of an out of control Federal Government. Mr. Benner has written a worthwhile read that points out how the United States has become a Plutocracy and ways of restraining Federal overreach. His inclusion of important historical documents at the end was a nice gesture.
I cannot recommend this book strongly enough. If you think you understand the Constitution of the United States, read this book. If you want to understand the Constitution of the United States from the viewpoint of the people who wrote it and ratified it, read this book.
Very well researched, with excellent notes and documentation as well as reprinting key documents including Magna Carta, the English Bill of Rights, the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution.
Anyone interested in the history of how the US Constitution came into existence, was authorized and how it was understood then should read this book. Very focused, well-written and just plain solid.