Booklist (December 15, 2003 (Vol. 100, No. 8))
PreS-K. When a family of mice goes sledding, little sister Biddy is a fearful of sliding down the big hill. After she has conquered it, though, she wants to go again and again. Like its companion volume Picnic (1984, 2003), this originally wordless picture book has been republished in a larger edition with a simple text. The illustrations have been repainted and significantly enlarged, enhancing their beauty and making their details more accessible to children in story hours. Those who enjoy wordless picture books can always ignore the text, but the addition of a few words ("The road is icy"or "Bitty is scared") on each double-page spread will complete the reading experience for the many parents and caregivers who like to know what to say when they turn the page and for the many children who enjoy hearing the same words with each picture every time.
Horn Book (Fall 2004)
In this companion to the wordless Picnic, the mouse family goes sledding. McCully's drawings are so clever, and the story unfolds in such a logical way, that even the smallest children can follow the action. As did the new edition of Picnic, this new larger format edition has unfortunately, and inexplicably, added words.
School Library Journal (January 1, 2004)
PreS-K-First published as a wordless picture book in 1985, First Snow is back with a brief text, enhanced illustrations, and a larger trim size. The extended mouse family from McCully's Picnic (1984, both HarperCollins) piles into an old red pickup truck and heads out for a day of winter frolicking. They ice skate, build a snowman, and go sledding. The littlest mouse, Bitty, isn't so sure she wants to go down the hill by herself, but once she gathers up her courage there's no stopping her. This new edition has brighter, deeper colors, but the artwork is essentially the same as in the original. Most of the text consists of bits of dialogue and short descriptions of the action. This addition seems unnecessary as the book still works well without words. Full of exuberance and excitement, both versions are perfect for winter storytimes and one-on-one sharing.-Wendy Woodfill, Hennepin County Library, Minnetonka, MN Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.