*don't you hate when you type up a whole, detailed review, and then you hit the wrong button right before finishing it, and the whole thing just disappears?*
This book is difficult for me to review. I run the risk of sounding ignorant and condescending whether I praise these stories for being gritty and realistic (my ignorance on the topic of modern Native American life and culture was a primary motivation for me reading this book.) or I complain about them being so depressing and dark. (I have to say; I'm not sure that the editor has much more connection to these stories than I do, though...odd that all the authors are Natives, but the editor is not...) So I will just say that the stories seemed realistic, based on what I know of people, especially people living tough lives in hard situations. I can't say I enjoyed a lot of the stories, precisely because they were dark and sometimes tragic and hopeless. But they were well written and interesting, and I'm not sorry I read them.
by author:
Joy Harjo--a very sad story, with vividly depicted characters. I was horrified at how casually they referred to sexual abuse and assualt, not to make it less horrible, but simply because it was so common in their lives. I enjoyed the story, though, appreciated the underlying notes of hope, and found myself hoping against hope the teens could break free from the cycle and make something more of their lives than what they'd been given.
Sherman Alexie--He's the one author with a name I easily recognized, and based on this story, I see why. I found the juxtaposition of his father's hippie adventures and link to music as interesting as his alcoholism and life choices were sad. beautifully told, even if sad, and at least there was an underlying core of love in this story.
Cynthia Leitich Smith--a brief but interesting story from the perspective of a Native American who doesn't look the part, and the aggravations and frustrations of that fact. It was a pleasant little story.
Richard Van Camp--I hated this story precisely because it was so well written (and seemed so realistic and believable). Also because it reminded me of a friend I have who continues to make poor choices and ends up paying for them. This story was incredibly vivid, with a skillfully drawn main character, leaving me feeling the resolution to the story all the more keenly.
Linda Hogan--I felt like Crow himself was a metaphor for the entire family depicted in this story. bittersweet: love struggling to overcome the odds, and not always winning.
Joseph Bruchac--One of my favorite of these stories, less depressing, more subtle and magical and hopeful. I loved the imagery once I understood what was going on.
Louise Erdrich--I really liked this story at first. The characters were interesting, vivid even with minimal description, and so was the setting. I especially found the inter-relationship of the Catholic church with the protagonists interesting. but then the story took a turn that I found gross and creepy, if I understood it correctly, and I lost all enjoyment of the story. Weird and gross, despite a promising start.
Greg Sarris--Another very vivid story, all the more so because of the tragic and seemingly inescapable world the main character and her family seem caught in. So sad, all the more so because I have a friend who is a Native American from this exact town, and it gives me a little more insight into her past and perhaps why she makes some of the choices she does. I found myself hoping so very hard, just like with Joy Harjo's story, that the two young girls would find a way out of the vicious cycle and make something better of their lives, not just keep repeating a sad (and poisonous) past. like Harjo's story, there was also an element of escapism/ fantasy for the characters, in almost a delusional creepy way. I guess that's what coping mechanisms can look like, though.
Lee Francis--This story felt younger than the other stories, but no less sweet, charming, and hopeful for it. I also enjoyed the story within the story about Spider. I appreciated that one story, at least, could depict the re-emergence of Native American culture, especially among the youth.
Susan Power--I loved the allusion to the Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. I always wanted to find a doorway through my closet too. Although this story also had elements of escapist imagination, the character still managed to be more hopeful than other stories, a smart girl who didn't let other people's opinions weigh her down, with sadness or bitterness, and who was true to herself (and her love of books--a girl after my own heart). There was, of course, the themes common in these stories--loss, struggle, grief--but the main character this time seemed to have more hope in her life, or more determination, or more imagination, or maybe all of the above.