Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

New American Bible Commentary, Old Testament Set #14

Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs

Rate this book
THE NEW AMERICAN COMMENTARY is for the minister or Bible student who wants to understand and expound the Scriptures. Notable features include:* commentary based on THE NEW INTERNATIONAL VERSION;* the NIV text printed in the body of the commentary;* sound scholarly methodology that reflects capable research in the original languages;* interpretation that emphasizes the theological unity of each book and of Scripture as a whole;* readable and applicable exposition.

448 pages, Hardcover

First published June 11, 1993

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Duane A. Garrett

33 books60 followers
Duane A. Garrett is John R. Sampey Professor of Old Testament Interpretation at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. He has served on the faculty at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, Bethel Seminary, Canadian Southern Baptist Seminary, Mid-America Baptist Seminary, and Korea Baptist Seminary. He has authored numerous books, including Song of Songs in the Word Biblical Commentary, A Modern Grammar for Classical Hebrew, Angels and the New Spirituality, Authority and Interpretation, and Hosea and Joel in the New American Commentary. He is the general editor of The Archaeology Study Bible (Zondervan).

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
43 (45%)
4 stars
25 (26%)
3 stars
22 (23%)
2 stars
5 (5%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews
Profile Image for Jimmy Reagan.
918 reviews68 followers
June 24, 2017
Here’s the pastor’s choice for the three challenging books of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Solomon. In near 450 pages respected scholar Duane Garrett gives what most want: a succinct, weighty, and helpful commentary on these books that will likely be preached from less than many others.

Garrett begins with an Introduction on Proverbs. He starts with a general discussion of Wisdom in the Ancient Near East and transitions into Israelite Wisdom. He provides a lengthy section describing all the proverb classifications scholars have come up with. That subject is more interesting to scholars than pastors, but he explains it well. He also covers the varying opinions on structure. In discussing authorship and date, he wades through the varying conclusions to reach conservative conclusions.

The commentary is good, but he spends time defining classification of every proverb. My only criticism of this book is that the commentary on Proverbs needs to be about 25% longer if a revision is ever done.

Garrett does a fine Introduction on Ecclesiastes as well. Since so few scholars believe Solomon could have written it, he has a lot to wade through to reach conservative conclusions. This was my favorite Introduction of the three. He sees an evangelistic purpose to the book.

The commentary on Ecclesiastes is well done and especially enlightening.

He turns out another careful Introduction on the Song. I can’t agree with his conclusion that it’s only a discussion of human love, but he lays out the differing viewpoints well. The other introductory issues are laid out with equal thoroughness. Garrett went on to write a large, major exegetical commentary on the Song in WBC. The commentary here is once again quite helpful.

This book is the perfect volume for these three books for pastors or teachers. I highly recommend it!

I received this book free from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Profile Image for Michael Boling.
423 reviews33 followers
June 20, 2014
Quality commentary series are tools in the bible scholar’s chest that will find repeated use over the course of their engagement with Scripture. The New American Commentary series from B&H Academic is rapidly becoming a favorite series of commentaries that I find myself using as a go to resource. Dr. Duane Garrett’s excellent volume in this series on Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs is definitely no exception.

As is the standard fare for most worthwhile commentaries, Garrett provides the reader with valuable insight into Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs. Background information necessary to properly understand issues such as authorship, time of writing, genre, purpose, main characters, and the approach of scholars throughout the years to some of the more difficult elements of the text are all addressed in great detail by Garrett prior to exegeting the actual text. For instance when addressing the book of Proverbs, Garrett aptly outlines the similarities and differences between Proverbs as wisdom literature compared to other works of the same genre in the Ancient Near East (ANE). Garrett adroitly notes the various forms of wisdom, patters of wisdom literature, and important rhetorical devices found throughout Proverbs.

In addressing background issues related to Ecclesiastes, Garrett notes the wide range of interpretative positions taken on the underlying message of that book. He notes “the interpretation of this book is anything but unified” which is clearly evidenced by the approach taken in the past by the Reformers and Puritans, namely that the author of Ecclesiastes efforted to demonstrate the futility of this present world in juxtaposition to that of eternity, as opposed to more current positions taken by scholars such as the message being one of pessimism, a declaration of joy, the tension of life, a work of apologetics, existentialism, reflections for the wise, or simply a discussion of creation and the fall of man.

The variety of interpretations taken by scholars is arguably most notable with the Song of Songs. Garrett expertly discusses the numerous interpretative positions taken through the years on this book which greatly impact how one exegetes the purpose and message of the Song of Songs. Garrett does an excellent job of examining each position, noting the pros and cons of each while along the way suggesting what I believe to be the proper approach with this book, that of the Song of Songs being a literal love song that demonstrates both the proper biblical approach to love between man and woman and also the love relationship between God and His people.

Garrett provides a helpful outline of each book under examination prior to engaging the actual text. Outlines are very useful tools for understanding the overarching issue being addressed in a particular section of a book in Scripture. Additionally, they also enable the reader to grasp how the individual parts of that specific book relate to the overall message presented by the biblical author. This is an excellent backdrop to the exegesis Garrett provides, allowing the reader to have a clear understanding of what they are about to spend their time studying.

The analysis of the texts of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs provided by Garrett is quite excellent. I found very little if anything to quibble over. Furthermore, the numerous footnotes found throughout this book provided even more in-depth study and engagement of important issues Garrett discusses in his exegesis. Footnotes should never be overlooked by the reader, in particular when it comes to bible commentaries. In this particular commentary, Garrett often uses the footnotes to elaborate on word meanings, issues that often are of great importance when trying to understand the point being made in a certain passage.

As one who has been studying the Song of Songs in recent weeks, I found the engagement of that book by Garrett to be especially helpful. He approaches the text in short pieces, taking the needed time to walk the reader through the text in question with a useful combination of scholarship and accessibility. The Song of Songs uses a variety of images to relay the beautiful message found in this book. An example of this is the description by the Shulammite woman of her love being a king. Garrett notes “She calls him a king, but this is not to be understood literally; rather it is the language of love. Going to his chambers implies that the wedding night is meant.” Such excellent insight will help the reader navigate a book like the Song of Songs properly, ensuring the message of this book is not lost in the numerous poetic devices used in this beautiful love poem.

I highly recommend this commentary by Dr. Garrett for Bible College or Seminary students, pastors, and even the layman who wants to have a valuable tool for personal Bible study. This work is scholarly yet not overly complicated and will provide the serious Bible student the means to more fully understand the books of Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs over the course of personal Bible study on these books specifically or perhaps in relation to specific topics addressed within these important texts.

I received this book for free from B&H Academic for this review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 : “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
Profile Image for Landon Coleman.
Author 5 books16 followers
April 10, 2023
I had Dr. Garrett as an Old Testament professor at Southern Seminary. He is a godly man, and a great scholar. I have used this commentary on sermons in the book of Proverbs, and I recently used the section on Ecclesiastes. If you are working through the wisdom literature, this commentary is a good, thorough, verse-by-verse resource for your preparation.
Profile Image for Christopher.
16 reviews2 followers
January 19, 2013
Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs is a well-researched and thorough examination of these three books of wisdom literature by Duane A. Garrett, professor of Old Testament Interpretation at The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.

Proverbs

Garret spends a significant amount of time introducing integral information necessary for a full understanding of the book. He provides historical context, with an introduction to wisdom literature in the Ancient Near East (ANE), and how Israelite wisdom literature fit into the general literature of the day.

Garrett explores the seeming lack of structure in Proverbs, explaining the relative “order and disorder” of Proverbs 10:1-24:23, and introducing the collection style with which he categorizes the parables; that is, organizing parables into collections was a common practice in ANE wisdom literature. Garret also concludes that Proverbs is older than traditionally thought, ascribing the majority of it to the Solomonic monarchy under Solomon’s prompting.

An in-depth verse-by-verse summary is undertaken, explaining in detail the purpose of each proverb, the collection it falls under, and any other pertinent details.

Ecclesiastes

As with Proverbs, Garrett provides an in-depth introduction to Ecclesiastes, before moving onto a verse-by-verse analysis. He examines the arguments for Solomonic and non-Solomonic authorship, concluding that the book is probably postexilic. Therefore Solomon is not the author, despite what may be inferred from Eccl. 1:1. Garrett then describes the structure and style of the book; that it was most likely written by a single author; and that there is debate whether Ecclesiastes is “unstructured verbal meanderings” or whether a logical structure is present.

A thorough verse-by-verse analysis of the book is undertaken with a strong focus on the correct use of language.

Song of Songs

Providing background for the book, Garrett makes a case that Song of Song was written in the Solomonic period, most likely penned by Solomon himself. Garrett explains the array of interpretations that have been applied to Song of Songs, ultimately concluding it is simply a love song; a single, unified work. He vehemently discourages any sort of allegorical interpretation, explaining that it can only be seen as Christocentric in the same way that Proverbs and Deuteronomy are.

As with Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, Garrett does a thorough verse-by-verse analysis, separating it on the basis of vocal parts: soprano, tenor, and chorus; where the soprano is the female, the tenor is the male, and the chorus are the friends.

Throughout the book, Garrett interacts with various theologians and scholars who have also explored these books. In doing so, he provides a well-rounded analysis of the book. I appreciated seeing what other scholars had to say on the issue, and Garrett does well with his critique, explaining their strengths and weaknesses and leaving no doubt about his conclusions.

Prior to reading the book, my knowledge of these biblical books was elementary, so I have little in terms of comparison. That said, I appreciate the extensive introductions and outlines he provides for each of the books. Once into the verse-by-verse analysis, Garrett builds on the foundational context he has established in the introduction and continues to interact with the thoughts of other scholars. Garrett also provides strong focus on the Hebrew, where he highlights any ambiguous or contentious sections, explaining his rational and reasoning.

As with all commentaries, it must be read with an understanding of the author’s background. Being a conservative theologian, as indicated in the author’s preface by his views on homosexuality, Garrett’s analysis and conclusions must be examined through that lens. This does not reduce its value, but remains an important consideration when reading. I found this book to be quite enlightening and it will quickly become a staple in study and sermon preparation on these three biblical books.
Profile Image for Bret James Stewart.
Author 9 books5 followers
August 22, 2015
This commentary is based upon the NIV version of the Bible. It is as good as most commentaries on the market. As commentaries provide additional detail and comments about the text, it is recommended that more than one commentary be used when studying biblical material. Each author is going to have his own focus and presuppositions such as denominational stances that will impact the premises made. This particular commentary deals mostly with the individual verses of these books, which seems somewhat unusual as most of the commentaries I have read deal with thought units or segments of the book in question. Garrett’s verse-by-verse approach might be slightly superior to the other method as each verse receives treatment rather than being passed over or addressed as part of a selection of related verses.

The commentary assumes that this reference book will be used in teaching and preaching, so it is slanted toward this purpose. The book focuses upon the unity of the individual books of the Bible as well as the canon as a whole, which results in the author demonstrating the same. Further, the book is constructed with a conservative exegetical style with an evangelical and applicational bent.

Garrett focuses upon the timeless aspects of the biblical wisdom literature of these books. Wisdom literature is some of the more difficult portions of Scripture, and I think the author treats the material accurately. The introductory material to the controversial Song of Songs is a notable feature of this book, and I recommend it for this alone. As I mentioned above, Garrett tends to focus upon application, which is not my favourite approach. Still, I like this commentary. The only thing I would have preferred was it be based upon the KJV, though I understand and the choices behind utilizing the NIV. I highly recommend this commentary. I will be reading more of the series.
Displaying 1 - 6 of 6 reviews