I liked it, but was disappointed with the focus on service learning at the expense of other forms of public writing. I understand and respect PM's experience with service learning, and strongly agree with her critique of institutionalized s-l programs as well as her repeated warnings about misrepresenting the community's needs and their voices. The message of the book, however -- taking the writing classes to the streets -- can be further engaged with a larger appreciation of socio-environmental forces (she alludes to these, I know) such as discussed in Welch's _Living Room_ while simultaneously addressing other public rhetorics in more detail and discussion, such as those briefly mentioned in chapter 1 -- ethnography, community literacy projects, etc. I like her verve.