This book follows two Iowa high school wreslters as they seek to win their fourth state chamionships, in the 2004-05 season. Jay Borschel, at 171, who attended Linn-Mar HS, one of the larger schools (3A) around Cedar Rapids; Jay won his first state championship at 103 (the year he suffered his only high school defeat, losing to a longtime club friend in a match earlier that year) and had won his championships at ever increasing weights (125, 152), kind of a rare feat. And Dan LeClere, who comes from a wrestling family; his father was a state qualifier, and is now the assistant coach, his brothers are also known wrestlers though not at Dan’s level of fame. Dan comes from the same county and club system as Jay, but Dan was raised on a farm in the rural north county, and attended North-Linn HS, small 1A school. He won his previous championships at 119, 130, and 140, and is going for 40 again. He had only two losses his whole HS career.
The author does a decent job of introducing the two young wrestlers, Jay and Dan, but it just felt somewhat superficial. Jay appears to fuel himself off of doubt from others, he thrives off of “bulletin board material” of those who doubt him in online forums (often over whether he has bitten off more than he can chew (pun intended) with his huge weight increases. He also uses as fuel the relative disinterest he receives from his own school and community for the most part in his incredible feat of having won three state championships and on course for a fourth, while racking up only one loss in his HS career. Jay mentions how no one shows up to their wrestling team home meets, unlike for the basketball team. A funny symbol of this disinterest was even at the end while a teammate’s (a freshman who also went to state but lost early) front door was decorated by cheerleaders, Jay’s was not; albeit apparently due to an accident in addresses but kind of made Jay’s point. Jay’s story was contrasted well by the author with that of “farm kid” Dan, though, to be honest, while Dan was raised on a farm in rural Linn County, he didn’t exactly seem like a farm kid but just a kid raised there. In Dan’s story he is really overshadowed by his father Doug, who, in addition to his side-hustle jobs (common to small farmers) appears to do all the work on the farm (what is the point of having four sons as a farmer?) as I never read about Dan or the others doing any work. Dan seems more introspective than Jay, his passion and fuel seems to come from a secret spot from within him (I assume). But his community support felt striking compared to Jay’s, especially as the story progressed.
But the above is really all it felt like I got on the personal level about the two wrestlers, Jay and Dan. I felt like I’d have gotten the same reading an SI article. There was more on their programs, coaches, a little background on other wrestlers in their programs and others in the state that year, but again, not much more than you’d get in a news article. Dan’s father Doug, the former state qualifier and current assistant coach at North Linn, was almost the star of the book. His passion was evident as we hear about him still wrestling on his own still in club matches, or ferociously against kids in practice, obsess over Dan, younger son Nick, consider mistakes with a past oldest son who quit the sport (not hard to imagine why) and a youngest son to come, etc… We get some insight into Dan and Jay’s future as they both have committed to wrestling out of state (along with a few other top HS wrestlers in the state), both having felt disinterest from the Hawkeyes, their lifelong dream school (which plays into Jay’s mindset of being doubted by everyone) and where they wrestled when little in an affiliated club.
The flow of the book felt a little disjointed. It felt like we left Jay and Dan as the author talks about wrestling in general and wrestling in Iowa, in a very basic and repetitive manner. A lot of the same clichés are brougt up over and over. It felt at times like the author only knows surface level facts about wrestling or he was just dumbing it down for a broader audience, I really felt this as he tried to do play by play of matches. When he does return to Jay and Dan it felt the same; repetitive, covering the same things about them personally and their families and teammates/coaches and their families as was already covered. And suddenly we are at the state finals and its goes very quick from there. We get very little play by play of Jay or Dan’s matches or what is going through their minds beyond a few lines here and there. Very anticlimactic.
Either those two young men were just super boring, or refused to open up, or the author just couldn’t connect with them. I felt it was the latter, but it doesn’t matter, without it the book felt flat, much of the material felt like filler just to take what could have been a feature magazine story and make it a book. He seemed to connect to the parents and coaches much more, which is understandable, but what he got from that felt irrelevant or again, repetitive. He would have been better served to get more info from the other wrestlers mentioned, those who Jay and Dan faced for example, or teammates, friends at school, etc... Everything seemed to come from coaches and parents, and it felt that way, like commentary from adults who were holding back because they were tallking about teens. But it needed something more to fill it out. It became a real slog to read which shouldn’t have been the case for me with this kind of story.
So, while the topic was very interesting the book is rather mediocre. My gut is a 2.5/5 but I can’t round up someting as miserable to read. On a sidenote, I looked up Jay and Dan’s college records andnthe towns and schools they went to to get a feel, and on Jay’s school’s Wikipedia page there is no mention of him and his feat as a notable alumni; he also went on to win a national championship in college (undefeated that year) and is in the Iowa and the National Wrestling HOF. Yet there are several alumni basketball players listed on the page who I’ve never heard of, kind of fits his story that no one there really cares about wrestling, even in mighty Iowa! I also looked up Dan, he with Jay and the other Iowa defectors returned to Iowa after redshirting at VT, sat out a year per NCAA rules, then wrestled his last three years at Iowa (looks like he may have been plagued by injuries based on how few matches he had). He had a solid career though he missed out on a national championship but was a qualifier his senior year. Good for both of them.