Natsuki’s moving things along just fine with Kobayakawa and she might even be okay with it! Keiichi feels like nobody understands his kink, which is probably his own fault. Then the school festival is pretty fun, plus a lot of short stories and unrelated stuff.
Brief volume results in brief synopsis. This is, literally, two chapters of actual plot plus three one-shots, one of which has absolutely nothing to do with the series in question. It’s okay, but not what I wanted, which was more of the main story.
This series is, frankly, very roguish. You know you shouldn’t like it as much as you do, but you just can’t help yourself. At least that has been my impression of it. It’s genuinely well written, if very much of its time, and has a zip to its dialogue that I haven’t felt since the delightful I’ll Win You Over, Sempai!.
The friendship between our male leads is a ton of fun and everything I said in the first volume holds true here - they are so goofy together and supportive, yet wholly unsupportive at the same time. They make such a unique team, which really comes through in the first side story.
There’s a lot of focus on Keiichi and his S&M lifestyle this time out, which is a bit of a double-edged sword. On the one side, it’s nice to see him being honest with himself about what he wants from a partner and, even while playing him for laughs, he’s not shamed by the story proper.
But, and this is the but of it all, there’s no nuance to this version of BDSM. Like, I don’t need 50 Shades of Grayscale here, and he at least screens the girl who confesses to him, but there’s being yourself and there’s being nothing but your kinks. Sure, it’s a comedy, but it could do better (or I could lighten up, maybe both).
And Keiichi is better than that, sometimes. He’s incredibly good at sports and his struggles with loneliness are the focal point of a surprisingly poignant first chapter that addresses the very real ‘my friends all have girlfriends and I don’t’ scenario.
The other big problem is Tomoya and Mari’s interactions, which are currently so vicious that I definitely think we’re being set up for the godawful ‘fixable lesbian’ trope (yes, she might be bi, yes, this may be a smokescreen, yes, this is a fluffy gag book, but it’s not how she’s portrayed). Mari is absolutely fixated on Kobayakawa, and hates guys. I’m expecting that second point to get handwaved away via Tomoya and it’s pretty irritating. Prove me wrong, manga.
Toss in some real old-school cross dressing shame and you’ve got something that definitely feels like it was written before a decade of any progress whatsoever in terms of its politics. It’s only fair you know what you’re in for. And I am more annoyed for the person who will be annoyed by it. I recognize what I’m getting into here, but I can see somebody else getting really ticked off. Yet, if you can see past all that, there’s actually a really great book buried under all that baggage.
The school festival is a desperate attempt by Natsuki to get a festival date with Kobayakawa, generally thwarted by everything that can possibly go wrong. To say nothing of Tsuyoshi’s plans with his actual girlfriend, Yukiko, which accidentally got screwed over by Natsuki before things even started.
How the Natsuki scenario plays out is genuinely sweet, with an assist from his friends, and it shows the heart this story can have when it isn’t being a gag book. Kobayakawa may be very emotionally blunted, but her heart is ridiculously on her sleeve and I really came around on her this time out. She and Natsuki are adorable together.
This is helped by the other one-shot, which is a food excursion for Kobayakawa and Mari that ends up bringing in Yukiko for an all-girls episode that shows that this story also works with just the three female leads. Yes, Anna is being ultra-possessive, but Yukiko’s high energy persona makes such a fun compliment to the others. The goofball imaginary scenarios don’t hurt either.
If there’s one thing I struggle with, it’s really good books that are incredibly hard to recommend. I think this is, by and large, a very fun little series that has a lot of potential to be even better. Yet it’s also hamstrung by some of its choices.
3 stars - if you accept the time it was written and some attitudes that it brings with it as a result, this is an easy 4 stars. But, since it’s not something I can wholeheartedly recommend, it will likely stay at 3 for its entire run.