The premise of the book sounded interesting, so I requested the book and added it to my NetGalley’s list to read. After all, not much attention gets paid to the more problematic bodily functions, such as flatulence or vomit.
I thought the chapter on mucus was quite enlightening, as I hadn’t really given it much consideration through my studies of human anatomy and physiology, and I learned a lot.
What is depressing is that, as of this writing in May of 2025, the current United States administration seems hell bent on destroying any advantage America has in scientific advancements, so I read the chapter realizing that the investigation detailed in the chapter might already be discontinued.
If I have any complaints about the book, it’s that the author feels it necessary to take pages upon pages of one aspect of a subject and literally beat it to death. For example, in the chapter on semen, there is an extensive and rather boring discussion of a Reddit “subreddit” on Fapping.
Reddit can be described as a social media platform with subreddits serving as forums dedicated to one subject. I’m not a prude by any means, but after a few pages of the discussion on fapping, I got the gist and basically skimmed the rest.
Also, on the chapter dedicated to Milk, specifically breast milk, the author meanders into a long story about a woman who was reselling baby formula. I remember there was a major problem with the availability of baby formula, but honestly, the whole discussion of the rise and fall of Alicia Tondreau-Leve could have been distilled down to a few paragraphs, not the multiple pages that were dedicated to the subject.
I did like reading the author’s adventures with ayahuasca, as I had heard quite a bit about it but hadn’t delved into the matter. As with other portions of the book, this section did go on a bit long, but I was interested, which makes me think that my concerns above about the meanderings of the chapters on milk and semen might be of interest to others, despite my feeling that it went on too long.
I do have mixed feelings about “Earthly Materials: Journeys Through Our Bodies' Emissions, Excretions, and Disintegrations,” as I felt the author could have concentrated more on the subjects he was writing about rather than taking all those side trips. There were also times when the author used terms that were not adequately explained, such as “xanthinuria”—a disease where the body cannot break down xanthine (for a more detailed explanation, Google is your friend)—and this makes it difficult to recommend this book to a more lay audience.
In general, I did enjoy reading the book, though I often found myself skipping through the many side stories that I felt really didn’t enhance the subject. Someone who is interested in the various subjects covered may get something valuable out of the book; others may find it a wee bit tedious.
3.5/5 stars
[Thank you to NetGalley and the author for the advanced ebook copy in exchange for my honest and objective opinion, which I have given here.]