✰ 3.25 stars ✰
“A farmhouse over a hundred years old could be the perfect spot for a ghost. If she got lucky, this summer might actually be exciting.
Maybe she’d find her own “heart-stopping haunting.”
With a title like Field of Screams, I was actually expecting it to be a little bit more on the horror-spooky side, but Wendy Parris' debut middle-grade novel leaned more towards a ghost story-mystery than having the creepy factor rise out of me. And it's not a bad thing - just a little bit different than what I had expected - so, whatever reason why it didn't get a higher rating is definitely my own fault.
It was still written with a lot of feeling for the characters - a lot of care was taken into outlining the history of family past, but the present seemed to have suffered, in the process. Rebecca's frustrations with her mother, her loneliness of being a new girl on the block, her sadness over the missed years of not getting to know her father were realistically portrayed. I liked how the ghostly element was revealed and handled and how it was tied into the characters' actions, culminating in an intensely high-action-packed final scene that connected all the missing clues together.
I also enjoyed Rebecca's candidness - she loved the paranormal and she made no excuses for it. She had a deep love for her father and knowing that he, too shared an interest in it, brought her closer to him - even after his death. I enjoyed the few side characters that were introduced that were a catalyst for many of her investigative actions. The dialogue was engaging and the atmospheric vibe of the Iowa cornstalks and the uneasiness of something lurking and waiting and watching was tangible.
However, even if it is a children's story - the vibe of fear did not translate well off page. The focus became so much more so on finding out the truth behind Rebecca's ties to the spooky manor, that I felt underwhelmed at the end. Also, it did end in a rather happy note - without any real villain, that also made for a rather disappointing end.
Honestly, I feel that the title and cover promised something a lot scarier, but became a bit more of a coming-of-age story for a young girl, where she experiences new challenges at making new friendships, and new understandings at how she can be a better daughter to her mother - knowing that she's not the only one who was affected by the loss of her father. There's nothing wrong with that - just something I wasn't quite prepared for - even if I'm not the target audience. So, if you set aside my own grievance with feeling misled, than this was a solid entertaining read that young children who are in the mood for a light-hearted fun spook of a mystery, than this will certainly fit their palette. 👍🏻👍🏻