This could have been a good story, but instead it was a case of a good idea poorly executed. Storm Roemer leaves her home for a teaching job in Cheyenne, to get over a broken heart. The man who broke it, Wade Magallan, is being what's sometimes called a "noble idiot". On the verge of proposing to Storm, he gets a letter from his brother that's a real game changer, and he then decides he's "gotta be cruel to be kind", so he dumps Storm, as if she hadn't meant much to him at all. He'd rather hurt her and let her think he's a womanizing jerk, which he assumes will be less painful than what's really going on, when he should have been honest and then they could have made decisions together. Never assume you know what's best for anyone, ask them instead!
Storm copes with her heartbreak by concentrating on her teaching career, keeping interested men at arm's length, while Wade hides his sorrow by acting footloose and fancy-free, though his latest bedmate is hoping to tie him down. The Storm comes back.
After that, Wade sure becomes a contradiction in terms. He wants to do the right thing and stay away from Storm, yet he can't bring himself to do that. He acts like he cares one minute, then treats her crummy the next. He determines to keep her at arms length, then seduces her. He regrets what happened, leads her to believe it meant nothing, then does the same thing again. after sleeping with her, he acts like it was just sex, then acts like he really cares, then tells her there's no future for them. He has a good reason to believe she's be better off without him, then risks getting her pregnant, as there was no mention of him withdrawing or using a condom (yes, they had them back then). So what the heck?????? What's with this contradictory guy, anyhow? If he really wanted to do the right thing, he never would have lead Storm on, slept with her, then made her feel it didn't mean anything, and that he was still carrying on with his bad rep girlfriend, who was hostile to Storm. You want to take Wade by the shoulders and shake him until his teeth rattle!!
I won't give away the reason why Wade does what he does, but it was something that could have be resolved before and went on too damn long. If it weren't for the secondary love story, between Storm's friend Becky and Rafe, the whole thing would just be redundant.
Moral of the story: tell the truth, no matter what, and trust in the person you love. Above all: DON'T BE A NOBLE IDIOT!