I’ve been wanting to up my illustration work lately and have had this book for years, though I’ve never read more than 20 or 30 pages in. It seemed a good enough time and I couldn’t find a sufficient excuse as to why I would (want to) keep putting it off, so I started reading it. I only have the pdf version with me (which is unfortunate as I have the hardcover version in storage back in the States), so I was left trying to read through some poorly scanned pages and lackluster image scans. For those in a similar situation, the Russian version has much MUCH better scans of everything, so you can look at that for the images at the very least. I ended up reading a bit of both languages to get the pages with left out text, but that’s not so relevant to a review of the book itself.
As for the content of the book and how relevant it is in today’s world, I would say that around 75-80% still holds up in the current illustration market. A lot of the compositional tips are amazing and much more useful than what I learned in art school, though the applications listed in the book and some examples just aren’t what would be accepted by publishers or clients today. The portion about forming a layout from various views and then framing it was something that I hadn’t previously learned and was game-changing, in my mind. Loomis likes to go on little rambles about subjects that can leave you (or at least, me) a bit lost in the thick of it all, especially when it comes to color. I think that this may have been partially due to the scan of the book requiring me to think of what some parts would say rather than simply reading, though. Some of the materials used to illustrate are also a bit outdated, though I suppose it’s never bad to consider/learn new techniques.
The part that I would say was least helpful for me was the section dedicated to forming a concept or brainstorming ideas. The method given in the book for this was very much focused on advertising at the time of publication and really doesn’t apply to a lot of what I do currently as an illustrator. That said, it does still apply to brainstorming as a whole and taking yourself out of the bubble that you’ve potentially put yourself into.
I’m sure that there’s more to cover, though that’s all I can think of at the moment. If you can find a copy of this book online or in person, I say pick it up. It’s worth it either way. Also, if you haven’t, check out the other books by Andrew Loomis on Figure Drawing, Head & Hands, etc. The guy was a wealth of knowledge back in the day and a lot of what he said is still incredibly useful today.