What do you think?
Rate this book


258 pages, Hardcover
First published March 23, 2010
I have to say that the second half of the book was better than the first. The first part seemed clumsy to me--like the author was playing at being a writer and alternately wasn't that into it or was trying too hard. The prose just did not flow. The characters lacked dimension. I was also bothered by the fact that she had two kids fighting over who got to be Smurfette and have the Smurf doll while playing in 1971. The Smurfs didn't make it to the States until 1981! I thought the author could have done some research to see what toy may have actually been popular in the US (or at least in production) in 1971.
Anyway, the story had a good hook, but it just didn't come together well. I was also disappointed that the "big revelation" at the end of the book (literally on the last page) was obvious to me on page 38. There were also some plausibility issues in the plot (well, for me it centered mostly around identity/legal issues; I don't want to give anything away). I think the second half was better than the first because she finally started to reveal some information that made it interesting (and, she seemed to hit more of a rhythm as a writer and find a comfort level in her prose that was lacking in the first half). However, it wasn't clear if it was Justin remembering things or just the author relaying what happened (if it was the former, then he sure did suddenly have his memory open like a floodgate, whereas for a year he was getting little trickles). It was as if in the first half she was so intent on making things mysterious that she didn't really have anything happen in any depth so she didn't accidentally give things away.
This review may sound a bit harsh, but I don't mean it to be. It was a good book, and I give a lot of credit to someone who tries to make a cohesive, comprehensible story out of a relatively complex storyline. It just was not a great book. It did remind me quite a bit of The Memory Keeper's Daughter--secrets kept, trying to give your kids what you didn't have and thinking you are doing well by them when really you're messing them up anyway, etc.