Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Chaos Magic #2

Pretentious

Rate this book
Double, double toil, I’m in so much trouble.
Fire burn, and cauldron crumble...


Pepper O’Malley, headmistress… No, no that’s not it.
Keymaster, yes I am the keymaster… No that isn’t quite it either. I think I’m getting close.
Peace keeper! That’s the one.

New Peacekeeper of the Philadelphia region, and I’ve already fallen prey to one slimy criminal that remains elusive. Pulling myself out of his terror trap might just be my greatest accomplishment. At least for the afternoon.

While terror continues to…well, terrorize the city, witches show up on my doorstep with a bogus job and more curiosity than their familiars. They want something from me, I just haven’t figured out what it is yet. I better figure it out soon, because it’s not just my life on the line anymore.

Five very stubborn, very delicious males refuse to leave my side.
Unfortunately, they aren’t afraid to put their life on the line for me.

I just have to make sure that never happens.
As it is, the Fates have other plans.Please This series, 'Eternal Legacies,' is a 'Why Choose' romance saga, where the protagonist may have multiple love interests without having to choose just one. For detailed content warnings and further information, please visit Elle Lincoln (dot) come to ensure the best reading experience tailored to your preferences.

376 pages, Kindle Edition

Published January 3, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Elle Lincoln

67 books251 followers
Elle Lincoln is a paranormal romance author known for obsessive heroes, sharp-tongued heroines, and slow-burning tension that keeps readers up past midnight. With over 40 novels published since 2019, she writes dark, emotionally charged romance layered with found family, dangerous devotion, and magic that lingers long after the final page.

She lives in Pennsylvania with her children and an ever-growing collection of pets. When she’s not writing, she follows her intuition—trusting the stories that arrive in the quiet hours.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
192 (50%)
4 stars
124 (32%)
3 stars
44 (11%)
2 stars
13 (3%)
1 star
7 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
Profile Image for Laura (lady_h_reads).
865 reviews377 followers
December 28, 2022
4.5/5
I really enjoyed reading Pretentious. This book has a ton of action, from Pepper waking up from her drug-induced terror dream to that absolutely k!ller of a cliffhanger ending. Several sneaky twists keep you on your toes, and some hard truths are revealed.

This book is a bit darker than Psychotic as Pepper deals with her shadow man stalker who wants to claim her and a coven of witches who wants to take her powers.

I loved that the spice level was ratcheted up from the previous book with lots of playtime with Jasper and Nikko, who are developing a relationship of their own. Pepper is also mending the broken relations with the druid twins, her fated mates who rejected her years before, and exploring her attraction to Bo, the demon librarian. With the increased s3x scenes, there is MM and some kn!fe play.

That cliffhanger… You may want to throw your kindle across the room and/or say some choice words; I am 100% with you. Book three cannot get here fast enough.
5 reviews
January 4, 2023
it was okay

Cons:

It absolutely drives me insane that Pepper is supposed to be this badass witch that trained with the Amazons, and worked to bring criminals down with the police but all she does the entire book is become a damsel in distress. It’s like she found out she was a chaos witch (which is supposed to make her stronger) and now she can no longer do for herself at all. And how many times is she going to have the truth forced out of her via truth serum before she , as a chaos witch, figures out a work around. She doesn’t even stand up for herself against her harem. I expected at least a little groveling from the twins!! I had such high hopes for a stronger FMC

Pros

I really love the writing style and the world building. I have not read any of the other fates mates series but I like that the other characters appear in each other’s stories. It definitely helps build a picture of the community in my mind.

Will I read the next installment? Maybe. 🤷🏽‍♀️
357 reviews2 followers
January 12, 2023
Not going to wait

What a mess this story is. It simply doesn't hold together. Blurred characters, unclear motivations for MC. World building is practically nonexistent. Meh what a disappointing read
Profile Image for Amanda Crossland.
1,306 reviews12 followers
January 10, 2023
Slower than I’d like

Even though the book started off with a boom I found the pace slowed a bit. I did like it. I felt the fmc feelings and actions were all normal after everything she went through, and then the guys called her out at the end, telling her if it was anyone else other than her in danger, she would run headfirst into it. That gave her the courage to go to the lock in. I’m on the fence because hello the witches have been nothing but pains in her behind. Yet she brefriends a few. I love Dede. Jasper I’m on the fence. I did Not like how he treated her in the first book. This one he treated her better but he still needs to do some grovelling. I don’t understand how she was built up to be this all power chaos witch, who can’t contain her magic. Then forms a familiar bond with her Royal Pixie friend, which increased her magic even more. Then stalker enters the picture and it’s like she’s a human with no magic. Scared. I dunno, I think the first book built her bad a$$ character up so much, it’s like she lost her mojo. Don’t get me wrong, it was still entertaining but I hope the next book helps bring back her lady balls. She’s a bit whiney in this book. Loved the multiple povs. Can’t wait for the next.
Profile Image for Alexis.
68 reviews15 followers
January 4, 2023
That cliff hanger!
How dare you Elle!!

Book 2 starts where 1 ended. Pepper is in her "dream" only she doesn't know.
This book is more Pepper ignoring what is happening but also admitting to herself that she can no longer bury her head in the ground and hope for the best. Her men are basically forcing her to confront everything head on. Including their relationships.

I didn't feel like she made the twins suffer enough. Basically said, ok, we can try and basically forget what you did and said I wasn't enough. Not to mention only coming back AFTER knowing she is a witch..with their betrothed in tow!
Wanted to hate her...but I couldn't.

Jasper...I need him. Toss the rest. I want him....kittens and fruit snacks!!!!!
Bo...um..Kinda want to smack him with a ruler.
Nikoo...I wasn't sure in book 1..but book 2 he gained some attention and I started to have faith...UNTIL THE END...faith lost!
Also..Slenderman...I feel like he isn't actually bad...just isn't sure how to correctly go about things.
Profile Image for Annie (_anniereadsbooks).
238 reviews25 followers
January 4, 2023
I really enjoyed this book! my favorite thing about Elle is how creative she is with her stories and Peppers series is super creative and interesting. I can honestly say I have no clue where the story is going but i am loving this ride!

Peppers harem is one of my favorite she’s written so far. I feel so many emotions with these guys along with Pepper. i’m so glad that Connor and Donovan’s rejection didn’t drag out and that these men are front and center in her life again.

I seriously am sitting here trying to figure out WHO Slenderman/terror man is. but he is such an amazing villain! and these witches! i cannot wait to see what role they play in Peppers life. I would also like to give a huge shout out to my other favorite character this series, Dede. I need her to have her own story and that NO harm will come to Dede this series. she is a true ride or die for life.

highly recommend this series and all of Elle’s back list!
Profile Image for Kira Leavens.
208 reviews7 followers
September 21, 2023
Character growth?

After reading a few reviews I was worried about the groveling aspect and character growth of our fmc going in. I really feel the author did a good job growing the various relationships this book. The fmc does not jump into bed with the guys. She only has reached that level with the two guys who were pretty solid in book one. So while we may not get a sobbing apology for being idiots, we get adult logic and discussions. And a lot of avoidance. I think more will be coming in the conversations with these relationships in book three. Our girl has had a lot going on.
Profile Image for Mary Ann.
658 reviews14 followers
January 2, 2023
Love this world. Happy see Peppers finally getting he men. But well can't be that easy or what a short book it would be. The potion still affects the bond. She has a terror inducing
creature terrorizing her and PA.
Sabina and the girls pop in and oh surprise when the babies arrive!
Nikko the only human has made a decision on how to be immortal that was a great addition to this tale.
The witches won't give up to get pepper in their coven. But something big happens with that at the end to CLIFFHANGER us good!
Profile Image for Heather.
134 reviews
January 4, 2023
Waiting

The fact I have to wait a while eleven months to find it what happens, is slightly irritating.
But, gah! I am in love with this series. Pepper and her men go so well together! They are just the right amount of possessive, sweet, and psycho. I adore Peppers charcater and have from the first book. She is not annoying as an FMC, which is a huge plus. Although she doesn't really know much, she doesn't act all damsel in distress either.

I can't wait to see what happens in book 3!
Profile Image for Whitney Walston.
257 reviews1 follower
May 12, 2024
the twins got off easy

The story is getting really good. There is some progress on the mate front and that’s all fine and great and I’m happy to see her acknowledge her love for them. I do think the twins got off too easy and I definitely don’t see how that problem can be solved yet. They are gonna have to face the music in Ireland eventually. The reason they gave for leaving is still crappy IMO and hasn’t been properly addressed and I hope the author does so or else I won’t ever really warm up to the twins.
10 reviews
December 8, 2024
I do like the writing style of this author in general, the first book had me hooked!
Unfortunately this one almost DNF at around 65% and had to force myself to read the whole thing, which is usually not an issue for me at all. After the first book, the series seemed to have so much potential, but it feels like the initially strong, badass FMC just disappeared and was replaced with your typical helpless-heroine-who-cannot-get-anything-done-without-the-MMCs. Will not be reading the rest of the series after also checking the reviews/ trigger warnings from the community on that.

Profile Image for Felicia's Review.
2,434 reviews39 followers
January 2, 2023
Pepper's story continues and man so much information and so many twist! I think Pepper might be my favorite right now. With her men who are not her men being around her things start to happen. We get find out more of her magic and history with the guys. Also stalker man has up his game and not in a good way. I'm waiting to see how this turns out before I label him as no good for her. But we will see. This does leave off with what the heck ending and I cant wait for book 3.
Profile Image for Bigred6126.
1,389 reviews3 followers
January 3, 2023
This is full of intrigue and there's some nasty things that happen but Pepper's story is moving right along. I love how the guys are really coming together and she's starting to drop her barriers. The cliffhanger is crazy. I'm excited to read the next book. The first one was good, this one is even better. I can't wait to see what happens next.
I received an ARC and I'm voluntarily leaving an honest review.
1,172 reviews8 followers
January 2, 2023
Pretentious by Elle Lincoln is the second book in the Chaos Magic series. We're still with Pepper and her guys. I really enjoy watching Pepper beat the baddies that are trying to get her. Lots of action. Lots of smexy time. No bullying. Some TW to look out for. There's a serious cliffhanger. I can not wait for book three.
19 reviews
January 5, 2023
Strong by Weak

To read that a FMC is supposed to be strong on her on but isn't is a disappointment. So a hasten who left can find back and because of hormones she falls into them like nothing happened. I really tried to stick with this series but this last cliffhanger causes me to let go and release from this series.
6,559 reviews24 followers
January 7, 2023
This is a continuation of Pepper's story and it is getting even more creative. It is an engaging read that kept me hooked and not knowing what was going to happen will of the twists. We get to learn more about Pepper's magic and get more backstory. I am really liking Pepper's guys and definitely have a favorite or two.
Profile Image for Jacquie Stolz.
583 reviews
January 6, 2023
Pepper is awesome

Love this story, be sure to read Psychotic first or you'll be a bit lost. I like seeing sneak peeks of the cousins lives. I'm curious about the big bad guy. Also loving the growing relationship in the guys. Anxious to see what happens next 😬.
Profile Image for 4foxsake.
894 reviews14 followers
January 7, 2023
chicken Rex.

I am scarred and don’t know if I’ll ever be able to eat bbq again. 🤣

Love this series! Pepper is def my favorite so far. I hope the angst isn’t too bad in the next book because I want the tide to turn for her.
208 reviews2 followers
January 12, 2023
Love Elles books

I love Elles books. This one and series is so good. But ugh a cliffy lol. To be expected tho cause there will be another thank god.
Pepper and her men are delicious. Cant wait to see what happens next.
Profile Image for Savannah Brown.
Author 19 books4 followers
March 8, 2025
Confused

So, to start I don't even know where to start. Mfc is not as strong as is made out to be. I hate how these men walk all over her! Loved the previous books in this World. Not loving Peppers story!
Profile Image for BobbiJo.
951 reviews
October 11, 2025
So much heartbreak

So much pain and heartbreak in book two as Pepper is hunted and tortured by the big bad.

Her relationships grown more though and it’s sweet, until the cliffhanger in this book… I’m officially mad at one of her mates.
Profile Image for Vega Starlight.
166 reviews1 follower
Did Not Finish
August 31, 2026
DNF as I got info about a surprise trope in next book. Ruined my mood. Should have investigated a bit more. Nothing wrong with the story so far though (except questionable males that undermine the fmc)
Profile Image for literaryobsessed_.
539 reviews5 followers
December 27, 2022
I love this series and these characters, Elle continues to write a collection of amazing stories with killer cliff hangers. Cant wait to see what happens in the next book.
6 reviews
January 4, 2023
Elle does it every time. This book is amazing. Once you start you can not put this book down. The cliff hanger at the end definitely leaves you wanting more but it is well worth it.
Profile Image for Fiona DeBono.
153 reviews1 follower
January 6, 2023
Love love love

I got hooked with Sabina and was anxiously awaiting Peppers story and so far it did not disappoint!! I seriously can't wait for more.
Profile Image for Margie .
538 reviews2 followers
January 27, 2023
No

No I will not wait a whole year to read such a gory book. The plot and characters were very good, but I don't intend to start the whole series over just to get t the ending.
Profile Image for Sheila Ryals.
2,845 reviews14 followers
February 16, 2023
😻

Now, that is what I call a horrid ending. Seriously I really really did not like that freaking cliffhanger. Guess things are just bleak now,.,
Profile Image for Wisp42.
2,391 reviews1 follower
July 16, 2023
urban

This ends in a cliffhanger. The faded mates still aren’t mates. The villain is the same as the last book and still as vague ever.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews