Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

‫مكان‬

Rate this book
عناوين القصص العربية بترتيب الكتاب:هليوبوليسإيناس محمد علي التركيثورة سرونرمين فاروق صبريشمس يقيننادين بدراويمحرز العفريت والشيخ جميلمحمد محمود زقزوقفجر آخرأدهم سيد حسنيننكاح الجماعةكمال أحمد الفاروشيشهبة بسيونيالحجرشريف الهراويإيثاكاإيناس محمد علي التركي

92 pages, Kindle Edition

First published February 1, 2014

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Moataz Mohamed

4 books650 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (18%)
4 stars
8 (21%)
3 stars
16 (42%)
2 stars
3 (7%)
1 star
4 (10%)
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
Profile Image for Moataz Mohamed.
Author 4 books650 followers
February 6, 2014
As a reader, I pride myself of having every shred of liberty I might have the thought of to criticize any piece of work I happen to read. I like to be straight-forward and clear, even if my critic was harsh or uncommon.
But as a contributing writer in this book, I find it a bit and a tad hard to criticize other fellow writers in our mutual production.
So, I'll prefer to talk in general, and not criticize every single one of the short-stories in the book.

The book is a good-read. Some of the stories can really take you adrift to other dreamy realms where pains and sorrows and hopes are all born and diminished. But there were other stories that made my eye-brows rise up wondering how come they had a place inside this book.
I liked the English section mush more than the Arabic one. Only two or three Arabic stories were, in my opinion, of high, or above average, quality. But the English section had only one or two stories at most that were ordinary.
Again, that's my opinion as a reader and an amateur critic based on the art of writing and the aroma of the feelings delivered amongst words.

The final thing I'd like to note is, I curse the EDITOR to the darkest and deepest pits of Hades. He almost did NO WORK whatsoever on Editing the book. I only pray, if this book is destined to have other prints, that it gets proper editing first. Editing work by someone who can really read, and takes the effort of reading. Amen.
Profile Image for Nada Sobhi.
Author 3 books223 followers
February 10, 2014
Makan is collection of 18 short stories, selected from a total of 90 pieces written in both English and Arabic. It is the product of the Makan Writing Award, which is a sub-project of The Forgotten Writers Foundation.

‘Makan’ means ‘place’ in Arabic. Writers had to write about one – or two – of three places in Egypt. These places were: The Baron’s Palace in Heliopolis, Cairo; the Hussein neighbourhood in Old Cairo; and Qayet Bay Castle (Fortress) in Alexandria.

I found the English pieces to be far more exciting and imaginative than the Arabic ones. I don’t like stories where I’m spellbound at the beginning then confused at the ending; this is how I felt with many of the Arabic pieces.

Another piece that has potential but didn’t make it to five stars was “Shams Yaqeen”. It earned 3 to 3.5 stars but I didn’t like that it was long with an abrupt ending – I don’t mind length if the ending will wow me or leave me happy or thinking about it.

Below are my favourite pieces; those that I gave an overall 4.5 or 5 stars. (They’re not written in any particular order)

• A Trip through the Eyes of Brahma by Dina Korayem
• The Sabil of Every Lost Love by Rana Kamaly
• The Incense Live by Nariman Mohamed Eid
• The Sanctuary of Unforgotten Memories by Moataz Muhammed Ibrahim Muhammed
• Al-Hagar (The Stone) by Sherif El-Harawy (Arabic piece)
• Fagr Aakhar (Another Dawn) by Adham Sayed Hussein (Arabic piece)
Profile Image for Nouran Gamal.
185 reviews78 followers
April 16, 2014
Ok first off i am not a writer or a critic but here's my opinion as a reader so kindly accept it openheartdly..

هبدأ بالقصص العربى لأن دول اللي قريتهم الاول:
عجبنى قصص قصر البارون وقلعة قايتباى... ولم تعجبنى أى من قصص الحسين بالمره.. كانوا يخوفوا الصراحة وحسيت ان الحسين هو مكان مرعب مليان جن وعفاريت! محستش بروح المكان الحقيقيه.. ممكن تكون الكتابة مبدعة بس انا كقارئ معجبنيش القصص.
الجزء العربى عامة يغلب عليه الكآبة وجو رعب او احباط.. مش عارفة ليه!.. بس تقريبا الجيل كله بقا محبط ومكتأب .. عموما الكتاب كله تجربه لذيذه ومشروع جديد وفيه مواهب فعلا
وقصص القلعة خلتنى نفسي اروح اسكندرية اوي!
I could almost feel the sea breeze and smell its scent and for that i thank the talented writers
من الكتاب المفضلين لدى فى هذا الجزء: إيناس محمد على.. اسلوبها فى الكتابه يشد.. "هليوبوليس" دخلتنى ف جو تانى وفعل حسيت بروح منطقتى ((هليوبوليس)) ونرمين فاروق قصتها مختلفة و "creative" .. أما هبه بسيونى ف قصتها "وشيش" هى أكثر عمل عجبنى فى الجزء العربى.

As for the english stories:
My favorite one is dina's "a trip through the eyes of brahma" it was very well written, simple & catchy, creative and had a nice message.
I also liked "giant ants" kinda scary but new.. (the whole book has got some weird imagination but very cool actually) and "in search of a stone" by Yosra was "finally" a story that captures the true spirit of Al-Hussein.. i felt the urge to actually go and visit the place.. may be buy me a stone too!
Also "the aftermath of life altering encounters" was very well written and i liked the story very much.

Overall i give that collection 7/10 and nice work all
Profile Image for Mahmoud Haggui.
225 reviews59 followers
April 9, 2016
الكتاب عبارة عن مجموعة من القصص القصيرة للكتاب الشباب عن مواضيع محددة : حى الحسين، قصر البارون إمبان و قلعة قايتباى. تم إختيار تماثية عشر قصة قصيرة من لجنة التحكيم فى مسابقة مكان بالتعاون مع مكتبة "ديوان". بعض القصص قد إتخذت منحنى كلاسيكى و بعضها إتخذ من الرومانسية منهج فى سرد التاريخ. بالإضافة إلى أن الكتاب لا يقدم جديد و لكن لا يسعنا إلى التصفيق للمحاولات الجادة للنهوض بالكتابة الأدبية البعيدة عن الإسفاف و الإبتذال.
Profile Image for Ranim Ayman.
116 reviews11 followers
October 20, 2014
الكتاب ده بالنسبة لي أنا ورضوي في عمرو بوك استور وأنا بزق رضوي تشتريه
وطلعنا في الاخر ورضوي معاها الكتاب
ولما لقيته قلت دي ساين واشتريته .. أنا بحب رضوي طارق

الكتاب حلو علشان بيتكلم عن اماكن حلوة .. كان فيه قصص حلوة وقصص سوبر ويرد فضلت لخد ما خلصته بقرأه بس كل يوم وانا راجعة من الكلية بس توقف فجاة وبعدان لقيته امبارح فخلصته : )
Profile Image for Nermeen Wahid.
161 reviews
April 10, 2020
فكرة الكتاب جميلة والقصص رائعة.
وحبيت انه نصه عربي ونصه انجلش.
وفيه قصص حسيت ان كُتّابها دول هيبقوا كُتّاب محترمين جدا بجد، ولو لقيت ليهم اي اعمال تانية هقرأها.
Profile Image for Noha Basiouny.
572 reviews262 followers
November 18, 2018
مجموعة قصصية فائزة في مسابقة للكتابة تضم معالم مصر التاريخية.. بعضها كان عن قصر البارون ، قصة عن مسجد الحسين وقصتين عن قلعة قايتباي. الكتاب يضم القصص بالعربية والإنجليزية.

قصص ضعيفة لم يعلق بذهني أياً منها بعدما انتهيت من قراءة الصفحة الأخيرة.
Profile Image for Mona.
40 reviews19 followers
April 18, 2014
I applaud the efforts exerted to make this book and the way it gives young people a way to present their talents and encourage them to do something that they love even if they don't get paid for it. Despite some typos in both the English and Arabic texts, there were some good ideas, some predictable ones but mainly good idea by The Forgotten Writers Foundation to try and promote similar projects to provide people from different backgrounds and ages to let their imaginations run wild
Profile Image for Mohamed Atef.
37 reviews
June 12, 2015
افضل القصص العربية: شمس يقين - ثورة سرو - ايثاكا.
From the english: The aftermath of life altering encounters - The Darker side of the moon - Empain Alive
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews