It’s a difficult subject mixing diplomacy, commerce, local politics and more vaporous topics such as the perception of Jews in Revolutionary Europe. Unfortunately the author does not prove equal to the task. Most egregious is the total absence of anything resembling commercial history which is a problem considering the book is meant to be about a successful family of traders and bankers. Crucially a slightly broader point of view could have replaced the Bacris in the (very) complex and fast moving environment of the Maghribi Jews in the Age of Empires.
Numerous mistakes can be spotted along the way: no Algiers’ wheat did not constitute fourth fifth of Marseilles’ grain imports, no the “Moors” are not the recent Spanish exiles (the Moriscos) but the Kabyle “tribesmen” from the countryside, etc. Worse, the author often suddenly utters unsupported conclusions and the reader is left wondering whether he hasn’t missed a chapter or two.
However, the most problematic aspect of the book is the almost automatic association of Western practices (singularly the English ones) with modernity while the Maghribi (Jews and Muslims alike) are just unable to understand the modern world and to adapt to its ruthless impersonal efficiency.
And it’s a mess from a literary perspective. Not even pleasant to read. Which overall is a shame as the subject was well chosen and clear efforts have been expanded to offer a Europe-wide perspective with the point of view of Spain, Danemark and the Netherlands being presented.