A disappointing and deeply flawed book. It is profoundly ironic that a primary proponent of redemptive analogies considers Islam to be "the great exception." The book contains little insight and less "objectivity." Taking September 11 as his north star, Richardson propounds an unhelpful array of fallacious arguments, failing to see that the problems of money, sex, and power are fundamentally human problems, not Islamic. There is an enemy but it is not Islam. I wish Richardson had found a way to navigate into the good news of God's kingdom, cutting through the murky waters of our discourse, sailing into a Jesus filled future characterized faith, hope, and most of all love, even for the "enemy."