BREAKING NEWS Urshall United FC owner dies at Drew Castle
Details are sketchy at this stage, but it is believed businessman Ben Rhodes (38) was found dead in his bathroom at the king’s Scottish home by his twin brother Max, where the pair were guests at a shooting party hosted by Lord Frederick Astley (39), brother of Lady Beatrice (36). The cause of Mr Rhodes’ death is not known, but he started receiving death threats from football fans after his controversial takeover of the club and had recently employed his own personal security. How unlucky can a girl get? Is fate playing a cruel trick on her for boorish Detective Chief Inspector Richard Fitzwilliam to be the only person who can get to the snowed-in castle to investigate Ben Rhodes’s death? And with no other external resources available to him, he now needs her, her smart dog, and her best friends’ help to catch the killer. Can they put their issues behind them and work together to find the murderer before the weather improves and the perpetrator is free to leave?
Another page-turning cozy British whodunnit with a hint of humour from author Helen Golden.
Helen Golden spins crimes that are charmingly British, delightfully deadly, and served with a twist of humour.
With quirky characters, clever red herrings, and plots that keep the pages turning, she’s the author of the much-loved A Right Royal Cozy Investigation series, following Lady Beatrice and her friends—including one clever little dog—as they uncover secrets hidden in country houses and royal palaces. Her new historical mystery series, The Duchess of Stortford Mysteries, is set in Victorian England and introduces an equally curious sleuth from Lady Beatrice’s own family tree—where murders are solved over cups of tea, whispered gossip, and overheard conversations in drawing rooms and grand estates.
Helen lives in a quintessential English village in Lincolnshire with her husband, stepdaughter, and a menagerie of pets—including a dog, several cats, a tortoise, and far too many fish.
If you love clever puzzles, charming settings, and sleuths with spark, her books are waiting for you.
Very enjoyable contemporary cozy mystery with a completely fictional English royal family. I think it could have been a little shorter, but I really enjoyed the investigative part, and the characters' personal stories captivated me right away.
I chose this book for the cute cover with the little white dog, as I was craving mystery and lightheartedness. After a couple of chapters, I seriously considered giving it up...but luckily I didn't, and I'm happy to say that the story and characters, after my silly first impression, completely captivated me.
THE PLOT may seem obvious, one of the usual clichés: a party inside a castle, a heavy snowfall and the guests get stranded there, a murder, and since the roads are impassable, only the "grumpy but handsome and charming" policeman, who is staying at a friend's house nearby, can reach the castle on foot. The lady of the castle is not only the granddaughter of a fictional king, but she also regularly stumbles upon unexpected murders and throws herself into amateur investigations along with her best friends and her dog. Obviously, the relationship between the policeman and the lady is tense (mutual attraction and sexual tension? ...huh...). ________________
But I say : it's not just the plot that makes a story interesting, it's above all how it's told!
I think the book could have been a little shorter, but I also realize that many of the dialogues I might have deleted, and many of the descriptions of every little gesture and thought of the speakers (which sometimes made me snort with impatience), actually contributed greatly to making me imagine the setting and getting to know each character closely, especially the four or five main ones (two protagonists, two co-protagonists, and the dog). The same goes for the secondary characters, both recurring and new.
__ WELL-DRAWN CHARACTERS __ The story's "heroes" are all likeable, and each has a well-defined personality:
_The gruff, yet charming, and ultimately caring, as well as intelligent and highly professional Detective Inspector Fitzwilliam.
_ The beautiful and brilliant young widow, Lady Beatrice, always curious and enterprising, proud and deluded that she no longer wants anything to do with handsome and charming bachelors.
_ Her best friends: Simon Lattimore, a writer and former policeman, poised and full of common sense, and his fiancé Perry Juke, a jokester always ready to joke and laugh, but also to support every idea, no matter how daring, of Lady Beatrice.
_ The suspected secret agent Lord Frederick Astley, Lady B.'s brother, and his equally mysterious but friendly and charming collaborators.
_ The cute, almost omnipresent dog doesn't do much except act like a dog, but it's her greedy and curious nature that will help her uncover an important clue! I'd call her a very respectable character who brings warmth and color to the story.
Marginal characters and potential villains, as well as the castle staff, have less visibility in the story, but the detective's questioning is enough to make us formulate a precise opinion about them.
___ LIVELY AND FUNNY DIALOGUES___ The dialogues between the main characters reveal the bond that unites them. Affection, humorous quips, sulks, and thoughts of return-game enliven the entire story.
___ THE MYSTERY INVESTIGATION and THE AUTHOR'S CLEVERNESS __ Between an overheard conversation and a good interrogation, clues emerge, which like small crumbs, on the one hand satisfy readers who feel they are advancing the investigation at the same pace as the "good guys," and on the other, pique their curiosity, pushing them to turn page after page to learn more.
The author's real cleverness was to pepper the entire story with many other small subplots filled with mysteries and romantic connections.
Even though this is installment #6 in the series, this is easy readable as a standalone. In fact I never found myself disoriented by the characters' personal life stories. Each situation is well-drawn, giving the reader a glimpse of what happened before and introducing new elements that won't be fully resolved in this book, satisfying the reader but also leaving them wanting to read the next volume(s) in the series, and read the books before this one.
The solution to the main mystery is easily understood thanks to the emphasis placed on certain descriptions and impressions (even initial ones), but this is a classic case where one can say "it's not the destination that matters, but the journey" ( if you know what I mean ).
The story even continues for many chapters even after the murderer has been framed, because the murder case and the investigation are merely "false central themes." The real lifeblood of the story is the personal subplots.
CLEAN LANGUAGE and GOOD HUMOR. WOULD I RECOMMEND IT? Definitely, if you like cozy mysteries and want some lightheartedness and a touch of clean romance.
Thanks for reading my opinion and sorry for any errors you may find in my text, English is not my native language.
Barbara’s rating: 4.5 out of 5 Stars Series: A Right Royal Cozy Investigation #4 Publication Date: 5/31/23 Period: Contemporary Number of Pages: 315
What do you call a book that has a member of the royal family, an interior designer, a popular crime writer, a gruff policeman, and the cutest little dog you’ve ever met? Delightfully entertaining, witty, engrossing, and suspenseful, that’s what. The characters are wonderfully crafted and their personal dynamic will keep you grinning – even when the going gets serious.
Lady Beatrice and Perry Juke, her business partner and best friend, have undertaken the re-design of several of the bedrooms at Drew Castle, the king’s Scottish home. Perry’s partner in life, Simon Lattimore, also agreed to accompany them as long as he could get the quiet time he needed to work on his next book. That all goes well until a death occurs – in the middle of a blizzard – where they are snowed in and totally isolated. Well, almost totally isolated. It seems Lady Bea’s frenemy, Detective Chief Inspector Richard Fitzwilliam is visiting friends close by and is able to make the trek to the castle.
The victim is a guest at the shooting party hosted by Lady Bea’s brother, Fred – and because they are snowed in, they know the murderer has to be a member of the shooting party or one of the staff. It definitely doesn’t make anyone feel all warm and fuzzy to know they are trapped inside the castle walls with a murderer. Who among them could have wanted the young man dead?
It seems there are many reasons to want the young man dead – and more than one person at the castle who might have a reason to do it – but did they? If so, which one was it? You might be surprised – and you might not. You’ll just have to read the book to see. Of course, as always, Daisy, Lady Bea’s West Highland Terrier, sniffs out an all-important clue and helps to save the day.
While this book is part of a series, it can easily be read as a standalone. However, if you want to really understand the dynamic between the character and much of their backstories, you’ll want to read at least the first book in the series.
This is a witty and entertaining book filled with characters you’ll quickly come to love. You’ll also wonder if there is going to be a romantic relationship at some point between Fitzwilliam and Lady Bea. We already have one lovely romance between Perry and his partner Simon – but I’d like to see Lady Bea and Fitzwilliam find a loving relationship as well – whether it is with each other or someone else. I just simply need a romance to go along with my mystery.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
A Dead Herring is the fifth in the endearing A Right Royal Cozy Investigation series. Author Helen Golden clearly writes with heart and pluck which is a good thing as she says there is more to come!
Quirky Lady Beatrice defies royal convention with her inveigling, poking around and amateur sleuthing. Deep down her more staid family members are both horrified and but I believe secretly tickled. A body is found (you can't throw a brick without hitting one when Lady Bea is in the vicinity!) and luckily family friend Detective Chief Inspector Richard Fitzwilliam is dining with Bea's family at Drew Castle when notified of a death. Murder aside, there are also arresting subplots and banter galore. There is no shortage of love interests, either.
The first chapter is a humdinger! No gradual easing in which is fabulous. The resolution is wonderfully satisfying and the pace in between is brisk. A snowed-in castle? Count me in! I've visited scores and scores of castles and had no problem envisioning the story as it unfolded. Daisy is a little breath of fresh air. I like that the main characters aren't twenty-somethings, enjoyed the exaggerated pearl-clutching moments and drooled over food mentions.
My sincere thank you for providing me with a free review copy of this fun escapist book. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This was a fun mystery A winter storm strands everyone and then we have a body and a house full of suspects.. Great twist at the end. There's another mystery going on with her husband who died 15 years ago. I'm wondering how that will play out. Will definitely read the next one. Definitely recommend this series!.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
“A Dead Herring“ by Helen Golden is a true Cozy Mystery. Well written, very entertaining and it keeps you guessing until the end. As well the interplay between the various characters continues from book to book getting more interesting each time.
I can’t resist this series, loving both the characters and the plotlines. This author knows how to keep me invested in her stories and I have to admit I’m hooked. Of course, Daisy steals the limelight as usual, closely followed by Perry, but this story also sees a thawing in the relationship between Lady Beatrice and DCI Fitzwilliam… despite the weather and the fact that neither of them appear to want to run into the other. Methinks the Lady and the DCI doth protest too much 😉
A Dead Herring puts the “cosy” into cosy mystery with its wintry setting that almost insists upon lots of tasty food and hot chocolatey drinks as Lord Fred’s (Bea’s brother) shooting party gets underway. Lady Bea is refurbishing rooms Drew Castle with her business partner, Perry Juke while Simon Lattimore, Perry’s partner and a former high-ranking police officer turned author is working on his latest novel. She is obliged, as part of her royal duties, to mingle with her brother’s guests, but the shooting event is not for her… that is until the mystery of a dead guest turns things on its head. It seems murder and mystery are never too far away for Lady Bea, and despite several warnings from DCI Fitzwilliam to not get involved, she can’t resist a challenge, especially if it involves getting one over the frosty DCI.
Imagine her surprise when the Detective Chief Inspector turns up unexpectedly at the castle to take over the case, and even more unusual is his willingness to seek out her help in solving this crime before the snow melts and the guess-cum-suspects are able to leave. Time is of the essence. Can they work together or will the frisson between them turn to the inevitable friction of their previous encounters?
There’s a huge amount of humour in these stories, courtesy of Daisy and Perry in the main, but also more revelations about Lady Beatrice’s husband’s death some fifteen years ago: a mystery that keeps on giving. The bond between the main characters – Bea, Perry & Simon – is an endearing as ever, and looks to become even more enchanting. More insight into Lord Fred’s life adds nuance and intrigue to the plot, and Daisy steals the show… and hearts of everyone. Well, maybe not of the killer, but everyone else.
Great fun, well-paced and structured, with a “just one more chapter” quality that held my attention throughout, and has left me eagerly waiting the next book.
The fifth book in the Right Royal Cosy Investigation Mystery series. A Dead Herring is another great read I couldn't wait to get stuck into!
Helen Golden's series is a stand-out one due to every book being as engaging and just as much fun to read as the previous one. I always look forward to returning to the characters. Each and every one is colourful, vivid, and so unique. Each and every book keeps me intrigued. Five books in, and I'm still raring to read another.
This time, the setting is Drew Castle in Scotland, and it's an intriguing case in what almost turns into a locked room mystery. As soon as I pick one of these books up, I know I won't be moving anytime soon! The story has fantastic pacing, which transports me into Lady Bea's world. I was again gutted by the time I turned the last page and had to leave them all again. A plot that's complex enough to keep you guessing along with a setting that I can picture does keep me hooked. I love this series and will be happy to return to the next book! I love Lady Bea and Daisy!! Thanks to Rachel's Random Resources and Helen Golden for the copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
A really good story! The introduction plunges straight into the plot, welcoming familiar faces, including Daisy, the dog, who takes a liking to Fitzwilliam, whose job it is to protect the Royal family. The castle and snowy setting provide the chill factor as suspects and motives arise following an unexpected murder. The pace of the plot moves quickly keeping us gripped as we follow the progress of the investigation, and also the relationship between Bea and Fitzwilliam. It is not long before they clash again! Bea's hasty reaction is to investigate alone, with the help of friends Simon and Perry. The trio discover a lead to the identity of the killer, which adds further thrilling and unexpected twists, but it is up to Fitzwilliam to protect one of the group as he faces the killer! Daisy has important canine information to communicate and is, for me, the hero! Brilliant! So looking forward to the next story. I would recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good cosy murder mystery.
I received an advanced readers copy from the author in exchange for an honest review. Nice take on the golden age of mysteries closed room murder, with limited suspects who can neither come or go because of a tremendous snow storm! Our intrepid PAIRS investigator Fitzwilliam just happens to be nearby! A true cozy mystery in my books. Only quibble Lady Beatrice seems a little off side figuring she has the right to be included in everything related to the events surrounding the murder. I found her a bit tedious at times how easily her nose got out of joint. Nice to have past mysteries have some added clarity (other facts uncovered as to what happened to Bea’s husband when he died years before). What does Bea’s brother Fred do for a job?? For the author - you may have heard already - page 270, a paragraph that is past tense and should be present tense (mortgage not mortgaged) another descriptor in the paragraph also needs tense update and a typo on the word Surrey:) Daisy of course found the missing clue which pulled it all together!
Helen Golden has done it again! She has created a story that has kept me guessing until the end. I only recently found this series and have loved it since I started the first book. I received a ARC of A Dead Herring, which is the latest in the series of Lady Bea, a royal in her own right, trying to solve a murder in her own backyard. This time the action takes place at Drew Castle in Scotland. Add in a hunting party, a blizzard, possible spies, and her very best friends Simon and Perry and we have the makings for a real "locked room" mystery. The addition of Det Insp Fitzwilliam adds an element of romance and this tale just keeps you glued to your seat. I love the progression in the relationship between Bea and Fitzwilliam and Simon and Perry are always enjoyable. Definitely a keeper.
The story starts with the discovered body on the 10th, then leads up to the events from seven days earlier before resuming the investigation for the next few days. Going back seven days gives a nice overview of the characters' relationships and how they interact, predominantly following Bea's point of view. The setting is modern but the characters are amicable and formal, even during the twists and turns of revealed secrets. This is a cosy whodunnit mystery that readers can solve alongside the characters, who are all featured at the back of the book.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This series features the Royal Family, specifically the king's granddaughter Lady Beatrice, and a member of the Royal protection squad Inspector Fitzwilliam. I haven't read the previous entries but was given enough background to figure out that Bea and Fitzwilliam have often clashed over her investigative efforts.
This time around evidently Fitzwilliam is trying a new tack: he invites Bea to participate in the investigation and mostly solicits her opinions. But Bea is prickly, a bit entitled, and impatient. And Fitzwilliam can be imperious and brusque and is not particularly tactful, so there are some fireworks.
The story is set in one of the royal residences where Bea's brother has hosted a shooting weekend. One of his guests invites his twin brother, and then he is found dead in the bath. This is particularly troublesome because the victim had been receiving threats after his disputed purchase of a football club and actually had a bodyguard with him.
Several guests had a bad history with the victim and there is not a shortage of suspects. The clashes between the two main characters and the royal setting give this mystery a different twist. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Chief Inspector Richard Fitzwilliam needs Lady Beatrice a amateur sleuth, her dog and her best friends to help investigate the death of Ben Rhodes death at Drew Castle. He had been found dead in his bathroom by his twin bother Max who had been there at the shooting party hosted by Lord Fredrick Astley. There is a lot of suspense and mayhem to make this a very exciting read. I received this book free and leave a honest review. I recommend this book to other readers.
Love this series and the continuing characters. Here’s hoping that the mystery that has been running in the background of the series gets sorted out in the next book, but if it takes another book or two to solve that will be fun to continue the stories of the main characters. Just be warned, do not read these books is you are hungry as the food descriptions are all too tempting.
Another fun addition to this series. It’s nice to see Lady Bea and Fitzwilliam being more friendly and working together.
My only complaint is Lady Bea seems a bit entitled at times in her desire to be included and the constant reference to Perry Juke’s full name, but those are minor quibbles. It’s an entertaining series and a great take on cozy British mysteries!
I received a free copy for review from the author. The review is purely my own opinion.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I had been interested in this series of books for a while, so I was excited to read this one.
This filled my craving for a cosy mystery, and it was a light, entertaining read. I found it sophisticated, and at the same time, quite humorous. I think I would read another one.
Thank you to Booksirens and the author for a free copy to review.
Prepare to clear your calendar before picking up "A Dead Herring"! This murder mystery will take you on a thrilling ride you never saw coming. With its intricate web of characters and an abundance of compelling motives, this book keeps you guessing until the very end. Get ready to be hooked!
I received an ARC copy in exchange for my honest review.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily. Lady Bea and Fitzwilliam are back and this time are trapped by a snow storm in a Scottish castle. Love the characters and the mystery.
I love the interplay between Fitz and Bea. These stories are so good. Shamefully for me. And laudable for the author, I did not have it figured out right away. Good job!
I love this series. It’s very quick to read, and I enjoy getting to follow the characters on these adventures. Daisy is hilarious, though her loyalty to Lady Beatrice is lacking, or is it….maybe she knows something Lady Bea doesn’t. I can hardly wait for the next book. Thank you Helen Golden.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I’m truly enjoying this series..modern day cozy mystery! Characters are well designed and I imagine they will be around for more mysteries in the future.
While the mystery itself stands alone, I would recommend reading in order for more in depth information about the relationships between the main characters. Many past encounters are referenced and their reactions to each other are based on past history. That being said if you like English country manners, royals and house parties and a murder mystery mixed in you’ll enjoy this book. I found the characters relatable for all that there were many royals among them and the setting charming. The plot was complex and kept you guessing right along with our investigators. At times some of the sayings and dialogue were a bit unusual to me but that might just be the difference between reading British English and American English. Other than that I enjoyed the story very much and will be downloading some previous entries in the series!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Book Sirens gave me the opportunity to read an ARC of A Dead Herring by Helen Golden, the fourth book of a series called A Right Royal Cozy Investigation, in return for an honest review.
Having thoroughly enjoyed the first three books as well as the prequel, I was looking forward to immersing myself into this book and was not at all disappointed. The same characters that played such an important role in the earlier books are present again in this one: Lady Beatrice, niece to the King of England, a rather persistent would-be detective; Perry Juke, her capable and hilarious assistant; Simon Lattimore, Perry’s partner who is a former CID police officer turned crime writer and amateur chef; DCI Richard Fitzwilliam, the policeman, charged with protecting the Royal family, who secretly seems to have a crush on Lady Bea and of course, Daisy, the West Highland white terrier, who is a sleuth all on her own and adored by everyone!
It is a true cosy mystery, where in the middle of winter one of the guests at the King’s home in Scotland is found dead in his bath and Fitzwilliam happens to be spending holiday time just about a mile from the castle, so he gets called in to solve the crime.
It is a fast-pacing read, relating the progress of the investigation, as well as the development of the relationship between Lady Bea and Fitzwilliam. Of course, Daisy is the one to save the day, with her ability to find the missing clue. The storyline is well-developed and I could really connect with all of the characters.
The book gets a well-deserved four stars (if I could have given 4.5, I would have) and I will certainly read the upcoming fifth book of the series.
I’ve had The Windsor Knot on my tbr for a while now and I imagine it’s going to be a bit like this book, full of royal references and grandeur with a murder mystery thrown in.
This is book 5 in the series but I found it a great standalone, I’m sure there is plenty to learn from the others but as an introduction to the series, I found this fab. I enjoyed the storyline, lots of characters to get to grips with and try to find out whodunnit. I didn’t get it until late on, which is the best sign of a good novel. I did however get a bit fed up with “oh my giddy aunt” towards the end, I’m sure there’s more than one saying posh/Royals use in a sticky situation!
"The Dead Herring" by Helen Golden is a captivating and humor-filled British whodunnit that keeps readers hooked from beginning to end. Set against the backdrop of a snowed-in castle and a mysterious death, this cozy mystery introduces an unlikely duo tasked with unraveling a murder that becomes increasingly complex.
When businessman Ben Rhodes is found dead in the bathroom of his brother's Scottish home, Detective Chief Inspector Richard Fitzwilliam becomes the only person who can access the snowed-in castle to investigate the case. Unluckily for him, fate pairs him up with an unexpected partner— Lady Beatrice, her clever dog - Daisy, and her loyal friends. Together, they must put aside their differences and work together to catch the killer before they can escape with the impending thaw.
Helen Golden's writing seamlessly blends suspense, humor, and a classic British charm that will delight fans of cozy mysteries. The author weaves a web of intrigue and keeps readers guessing with each page turn. From the eccentric cast of characters to the atmospheric setting, every element of the story adds depth and richness to the mystery.
Lady Beatrice, is a relatable and endearing character whose wit and determination shine throughout the narrative. As the plot unfolds, readers are drawn into her world, rooting for her and her companions as they navigate the twists and turns of the investigation. The interactions between the characters are engaging, laced with humor and occasional tensions that add an extra layer of intrigue to the story.
Golden's ability to balance lighthearted moments with the gravity of the murder mystery is commendable. The clever blend of humor and suspense creates a unique reading experience that keeps readers entertained while maintaining the sense of urgency and intrigue necessary for a satisfying whodunnit.
The wintry setting of the snowed-in castle adds an additional layer of atmosphere to the story, enhancing the sense of isolation and raising the stakes for our intrepid investigators. Golden's descriptive prose brings the setting to life, immersing readers in the chilling environment and heightening the tension.
"The Dead Herring" is an enjoyable and well-crafted mystery that will appeal to fans of the genre. Helen Golden's skillful storytelling, sprinkled with humor and charm, keeps readers engaged and guessing until the very end. If you're looking for a cozy mystery with a touch of British flair, this book is an excellent choice.
In conclusion, "The Dead Herring" is a delightful and page-turning whodunnit that combines suspense, humor, and a cast of memorable characters. Helen Golden's mastery of the genre shines through in this engaging mystery, making it a must-read for cozy mystery enthusiasts seeking a clever and entertaining read.
A Dead Herring, the fifth installment in the A Right Royal Cozy Investigation series by Helen Golden, delivers a captivating and humorous British cozy whodunit that will keep readers eagerly turning the pages. This book skillfully weaves together an engaging mystery, witty dialogue, and the endearing dynamic between Lady Beatrice and Detective Chief Inspector Richard Fitzwilliam.
The story revolves around the suspicious death of businessman Ben Rhodes during a shooting party at Drew Castle. Lady Beatrice, an amateur sleuth, finds herself snowed in at the castle alongside DCI Fitzwilliam, who reluctantly relies on her help to solve the case. Despite their differences and past issues, they must set aside their conflicts and work together to catch the killer before they can escape.
Helen Golden's writing style is delightful, with a perfect balance of intrigue and humor. The witty banter between Lady Beatrice and DCI Fitzwilliam adds an entertaining layer to the narrative, creating an engaging and enjoyable reading experience. The author expertly crafts the mystery, providing readers with twists and turns that will keep them guessing until the very end.
One of the highlights of A Dead Herring is its well-developed characters. Lady Beatrice shines as a determined and resourceful amateur detective, while DCI Fitzwilliam brings a sense of skepticism and professionalism to the investigation. The supporting cast, including Lady Beatrice's smart dog and her loyal friends, adds depth and charm to the story.
Golden's ability to transport readers to a snowed-in castle in Scotland adds an atmospheric touch to the narrative. The descriptions are vivid and immersive, immersing readers in the cozy and quintessentially British setting.
Overall, A Dead Herring is a page-turning cozy mystery that blends contemporary elements with British charm. Helen Golden's engaging storytelling, delightful characters, and clever dialogue make this book a must-read for fans of the genre. With its perfect blend of humor and intrigue, readers won't be able to put down this captivating whodunit until the very last page.