Rating the entire series 4-stars and reviewing as a series here.
Going into the weekend, I looked at the books in my Kindle library and couldn't bring myself to read any of them. They were too long, or too dark, or too serious. I wanted something I could zip through without a care for it being over with too soon. I was really in the mood for a paranormal academy RH book and Exemplar Hall has been on my TBR forever.
The series definitely fit the niche I was craving. It was addictive enough that I started Friday evening and got through all five books by Sunday evening. And I enjoyed every minute.
First of all, our FMC, Jesse is so much fun. Her sarcasm is always on point. She's never mean, but she's no pushover either. She's not like other girls, but not "not like other girls". Meaning, while she's nearly a carbon copy of her twin brother, with mostly tomboy traits, like a penchant for repairing machines and extreme sports, she doesn't even seem to realize that her interests are outside of the female norm and never compares herself to other girls. To be fair, I'm not sure if she's ever met a female under age of 40, but you get the idea. The point is, she's uniquely qualified to pull off the secret girl trope. And I freaking love the secret girl trope.
What Jesse loves most in the world is her twin brother Wyatt. When mercenaries abduct him right in front of her and drag him through a magical portal, all she knows is that they were taking him to a placed called Exemplar Hall. Her only clue to finding him is the school Welcome packet back at their apartment. With the help of her longtime crush/occasional FWB Maverick and her estranged father, Jesse arrives at the school grounds posing as Wyatt. She has four days to locate him in the wilderness during the Hunger Games-style admissions trial and get him back to the portal before he's taken into "The Vault" and lost to her forever. The best laid plans...
Needless to say, Jesse and Wyatt do not escape through a portal, and both begin their journey at Exemplar Hall. When the school dean and the magi counsel realize that a female was capable of entering where no female had ever entered before (because no female has ever had magic before), they instruct her to continue her ruse of posing as a boy. Can't have the boys distracted and all that. Luckily, Jesse is over 6' tall and has a buzz cut, because she manages to pull it off for quite a while.
Aside from Jesse, it was the main storyline that kept me on the hook. Our girl is at the center of a hurricane. All she wants to do is be with her brother and learn to channel magic she never even knew existed, but she's forced to conceal her gender at all times. The dean is obsessed with using the twins unique powers for political gain while another powerful family wants to use her as a brood mare. There are the bullies who cast magical attacks when her back is turned, and the bullies who call her Plus One based on a misguided rumor, and the outright attempted murder. There's the constant rejection from her long-time crush who can't be seen with her in public without it jeopardizing his life's mission and then there's the vampire professor who accidentally bonded to her and is now privy to her every emotion. On top of all that is the fact that the magi world's most reviled "traitor", the leader of the Resistance, just happens to be Jesse and Wyatt's father.
So yeah, there's so much going on that it's hard to put these books down.
The romance is okay but nothing to write home about. River is wonderful and an absolute rock for Jesse. Jack is a cutie pie genius who can't believe that anybody would want him. Maverick is sexy but also an asshole a lot of the time, and I can't even remember the professor's name despite finishing this last night. For the most part, these are some pretty good book boyfriends.
I think my issue is the complete lack of passion. I'm not saying there isn't spice, because there's plenty of it. And I'm not saying the spice is poorly written. It's just...there is no sexual tension. I love when an author uses physiological responses in a way that gives ME butterflies. I love all the little things that add up to a couple crossing over from platonic to something more, like standing too close, accidental touches and glancing at each others' mouths. These are my favorite parts of a Romance novel.
Over the course of the series eight distinct sexual relationships develop between Jesse and her four boyfriends, but instead of eight delicious seductions, or kisses that surprise both parties, we get dry negotiations:
MMC1: I'm DTF if you are.
MMC2: Yes, I'm also DTF. Should we kiss or something?
It's not only wasted opportunity, but it's BORING!
So anyway, read this series if you like fast-paced intricate plots where the characters barely get a chance to breathe before the next disaster arises.
Skip it if push-pull sexual tension is something that's important to you.