Third reread: August 2025
***4.0 rating***
same rating. I have been binging hockey romance this month idk🤷♀️
Second reread: August 2023
***4.0 rating***
Upon my initial reading of Iced Out a year ago, it immediately captured my interest and, as evidenced by my original review, I found great enjoyment in it with only a minor quibble. The decision to revisit it was prompted by the recent release of "Caught Stealing," the second book in the series, and my somewhat forgetful memory necessitating a refresher on the events of the inaugural book.
I am genuinely pleased that I opted for a second reading, as it granted me a deeper appreciation for the characters and their journeys. The dynamic between Oak and Quinn, which commenced with enmity, gradually evolved into a charged undercurrent of sexual tension that grew increasingly palpable. My initial encounter with this narrative left me a tad vexed by the frequency of the intimate scenes and the way in which Oak shouldered unjust blame for Braxton's actions, despite Braxton being the instigator who initially manipulated Quinn's drug test. However, with the benefit of revisiting the text, these concerns waned, replaced by a profound captivation with the evolving passion and intricate bond between Oakley and Quinton.
Though these two protagonists embarked on their journey as adversaries on and off the ice, a transformative encounter at a fraternity gathering acted as a catalyst for their gradual metamorphosis. Their connection, initially borne out of antagonism with added perks, deepened substantially as they spent more time in each other's presence. This progression saw the transformation of animosity into desire, and that desire blossoming into a profound love. The evolution of their relationship was a narrative delight, a testament to C.E. Ricci's skill in crafting their connection.
"Oak" and "Quinn," as they've affectionately come to be known, are a precious pairing. Their emotional evolution, from their tumultuous beginnings to the tender love they share, is a captivating narrative thread that resonates profoundly with readers.
If you haven't read this yet, you should! And by doing so you can expect:
-Enemies with Benefits
-Rival Teammates
-Enemies to Lovers
-College Sports
-Opposites Attract
- Secretive Relationship
- Many delicious spicy moments 😏
-Hockey for my hockey lovers
I am excited to read book 2. I know my boy Holden is gonna be involved in some love shenanigans, so looking forward to it!
_______________________________
***3.75 rating***
"I’m about to cross Michigan Avenue when a hand lands on my forearm, halting me in my tracks. There’s not even a second for me to register what is happening when Quinton reels me back into him, and without hesitation, drags me in for a kiss. The second kiss of the day, but this is entirely different than the first."
Iced Out is an enemies-to-lovers story centered around hockey at Leighton University. Oakley and Quinton have it out for one another, enemies on ice and off the ice, or so it seems. The feud started way back in high school. Quinton cannot stand the golden boy of hockey, Oakley, and his legacy ties to the sport. While the less hostile party, Oakley cannot stand Quinton's jabs at his family ties to the sport or Quinton's hot temper that aggravates just about everybody.
Both guys think they never have to see each other again after high school, wrong! Somehow fate has them ending up at the same university and on the same hockey team, a sport which they both love no matter how much they "hate" each other that is the one thing they seem to have in common. Due to their "beef" in high school, no love is lost between our boys. Golden boy Oakley has the team wrapped around his finger but not the coach, even though that is his uncle. Unfortunately, an injury leaves Oakley's position as captain on hiatus. Quinton is instead the interim captain. This certainly adds fuel to the fire and their so-called feud. The team isn't happy about having Quinton as captain, but when circumstances change and our supposed "enemies" hook up at a party unexpectedly, things begin to change for Quinton and Oakley, both off the ice and on the ice.
Attraction, lust, and other feelings are developed between these hockey players, and the supposed "beef" is put to a halt. Quinton and Oakley navigate their new sexual relationship and begin to develop romantic feelings for one another. While Oakley is a self-assured gay man, this new relationship for Quinton is life-changing and his first relationship with a man. It's a new discovery of his sexuality, something he welcomes and cherishes. Quinton and Oakley become "Quin" and "Oak" the more time they spend together and the more time they get to know one another on a deeper level. While the reason this "fling" began was sort of stupid, I couldn't help but enjoy the change in their relationship. Oak and Quin were very sweet and cute together. As a reader, I loved when they confided in each other, especially when Quin told Oak about his complicated relationship with his parents and their lack of support for his passion (hockey). I empathized with Quin and felt his loneliness as a reader. His only friend seemed to be his roommate Haynes. So, when he got with Oak, a bit of that loneliness seemed to fade away. I also enjoyed how affectionate they were with each other out of the blue, like their unexpected hugs, kisses, and cuddling. There were many sex scenes, but I found their non-sexual moments together more powerful and romantic. I also loved how thoughtful Oak was with Quin; he made sure to include him in his family and listened to him when Quin didn't have a shoulder to lean on. As you can see, they had many sweet and meaningful moments together outside of the sex, and as a reader, I appreciated that. However, I did not like the dramatic moment in the book, or in other words, the "betrayal." It wasn't really Oak's fault tbh, and I thought Quin's reaction, while understandable, was a bit much. He could have handled it better. Oak didn't need to grovel as much as we see him do in the book to win Quin back.
One issue I have with the enemies-to-lovers trope is that it continues for a while but quickly fades away when the main characters get together. This makes it less appealing to the reader, and sure the author tells us why they "hate" each other, but the supposed "hate" felt more like a dislike, and honestly, "the beef" was kind of dumb. It's very forgettable and ineffective for the author's trope. The ending, again like other books I have read recently, was rushed and boring; I wanted something more believable and less hallmark. Idk. This was overall a decent read; I enjoyed it much more than the other book I have read by this author (Dare You or whatever it's called). If you like this author's work, I think you will definitely enjoy this one.