This book has a good idea, but it’s delivered with such a chaotic execution that it made me assume this MUST be from a first-time author who doesn’t know how to tell a story. I’d be willing to cut her some slack and maybe give this 3 stars if this WAS her first book. But apparently it’s not! Apparently this mess comes from an experienced writer!
It’s an RH omegaverse, and the plot is exactly what the title says: the omega’s name is Havoc, and one of the alphas in her pack cornered her, kept her trapped in a room for a few months, and abused her, so she killed him. The other alphas in the pack had no idea that the evil one even found their omega, kept her from the rest of them, had her imprisoned (or that he was evil). So, they don’t trust Havoc and they think SHE’S the problem and the evil one (since they think she killed their pack brother randomly, for no reason).
That's a good concept! This has the potential to be angsty. But the way that this story unfolds is chaotic. So the angst didn’t land. It took me into 20% in to even feel like I had a lay of the land – who was who. This pack has some very specific dynamics: 2 of the guys are in an MM relationship within it. One guy is in danger of losing his “alpha aura,” (a bit of worldbuilding that is poorly explained). The only likeable guy (Bane) is an outcast in his own pack, and his pack brothers know very little about him even after living with him for YEARS. This isn’t clear why for a long time.
All of these things are revealed too slowly – not in a way that feels deliberate, like this plot is unfolding like a mystery. More like, this author does not know how to share all this information about the characters with the reader. If this was a series, it might be okay that the characters are established slowly. But for a standalone, the characters need to be established sooner, so that the reader can sit back and enjoy it, rather than being like, "Wait, who is who, and what's going on?" quite far into the story.
The story begins AFTER Havoc has killed the evil one, when she’s living with her pack of alphas and they’re trying to decide what to do with her. There are SO MANY italicized flashbacks to her time with the evil one before his death. Not only was this annoying, but it felt like a very amateur writing style. This story should have started earlier in the timeline, instead of doing all the italicized flashbacks. (We even get italicized flashbacks to the guys pasts too at some points - and it adds nothing to the story to give us the info in this way, and makes it feel even choppier).
Havoc doesn’t have much of a personality beyond being a doormat for the mean guy, being scared, and behaving irrationally. For a long time, when the guys ask her why she killed their pack brother, she gives them different answers. So, they think she’s manipulative. It’s hard to blame them! Even if she thinks they won’t believe the truth, why doesn’t she try telling it, and stick to her story so that it becomes clear she’s not lying? I don’t need a heroine to behave perfectly. But I DO need to understand her behavior. And Havoc’s behavior is just erratic.
It also gets tedious because even after they find out their dead pack mate was evil, they keep finding things out that he did and being all, “No way! Surely he couldn’t have done that!” These guys are kind of dumb, and not in a fun way.
The worldbuilding is muddled and incoherent. Usually in omegaverse stories, the world is the same as our real world, except that there are alphas, omegas, etc. Or sometimes, the worlds are more sci-fi. When an author doesn’t establish what kind of setting this is right away, I have no idea what to even picture, and it’s hard for me to get into a book. This one was very muddled. It seems to be set in the real world, but it also had supernatural elements – one of the guys is a seer, and one is losing his “alpha aura,” and it’s not really fleshed out what these things mean.
There's even simple stuff that's hard to picture - like, where the guys live is described as a house at one point, but later it suddenly has an elevator that neighbors are in, and it's an apartment. What?
There are also a lot of concepts that are revealed too late. Like, it’s supposed to be an angsty and dramatic moment when it’s revealed that one guy is a “rogue.” But it’s so unclear what being a “rogue” means in the context of this world. So, it just ended up being an info-dump of exposition about what that means. Why weren’t we told what a “rogue” is in this world sooner, so that we could feel the angst of that moment? The story is FILLED with stuff like that.
The writing itself is fine. There are even some interesting concepts in this that I haven't seen in other omegaverse reads. But this feels like a story that REALLY needed to be put through another draft or two. If it had been, it could have been good.