Prompted by students’ mounting interest in issues of racial justice and new Supreme Court caselaw in various realms of evidence law, this Edition presents the familiar student-friendly textbook, now with these the casebook’s focus on issues of racial justice, including the use of rap lyrics against criminal defendants, evidence of racist beliefs of police officers accused of wrongdoing, and the ambiguity of evidence of flight when young men of color run from the police;Presents and digests the latest Supreme Court caselaw, including Peña-Rogriguez v. Colorado (2017), Ohio v. Clark (2015) and Hemphill v. New York (2022);Fully incorporates the latest amendments to the Federal Rules of Evidence and looks ahead to several proposed amendments likely to become law soon, especially concerning illustrative aids and expert testimony;Surveys the latest reports and caselaw to assess the current validity of a range of forensic techniques;Presents new cases and problems throughout, while retaining tried-and-true teaching tools, however old, that have shown no sign of wear. As with past editions, this new text addresses the intricacies of evidence law in a way students will find both engaging and(more...)
This book was so hard to put down! Every section left me wanting more cases and rules to learn but the textbook can only be so dense. I particularly liked the part where Ms. Gray made multiple lovers *disappear* to claim their insurance benefits, while also rendering them unavailable as witnesses to testify against her at trial (U.S. v. Gray). This taught me a lot about hearsay (among other things). I can’t wait to see what the fifth edition brings!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
this is the best textbook i’ve had in law school. fisher does an exceptional job explaining the concepts and cases that supplement the FRE. i wish he could write all of my textbooks.
This book IS the best law text I've had in law school. From the substance to the layout to the multitude of hypotheticals, I was continually impressed (and grateful) at the way it broke down complex topics in simple, learnable terms. Because Fisher's textbook is so useful, Evidence is the first class in law school I haven't felt the need to drop eighty dollars on a hornbook.
If I ever have the chance to meet Prof. Fisher, I will hug him for it.
The authors include most of my "wants" from a legal textbook: includes important/interesting/abridged cases, clearly and plainly explains the context, includes the language of the rule of evidence when appropriate, keeps the reader oriented within the broader topic, and, of course, provides plenty of really good practice problems. Dare I say I had fun (?!) applying my knowledge and intuition to the practice problems.
Could really use a new edition, as some sections are clearly outdated (e.g. this edition predated marriage equality via Obergefell v. Hodges, so the marital privilege section is longer than it needs to be).
That's a small nitpick, though. This book is good enough that I'll probably reread sections of this book in the future if I need a refresher.
I am strongly in favor of the format of this book generally and thought it covered the topic well. That said, there were two things about this book I did not like. (1) The use of hypos is great, but they are often put before the rules, which I strongly dislike because it requires going back and forth, and it also has you guessing at the questions on your first pass. (2) The articles are great, but they sometimes get too into the weeds over high-level scholarly debate. This book is really for an introduction to the rules of evidence, and these end up being long-winded tangents.
definitely one of those subjects that every attorney should take in lawyer school--the course will more than likely be dull and the abstractions may not signify until one encounters the problem for real as a litigator. this text was a sufficiently useful guide.