I'm not a book double dipper; tunnel vision for one book is typically more my style. But as I find it, "Middlemarch" is 800 pages and I need a palate cleanser (or two), and the Holy Spirit faithfully led me to this book at the exact time I needed it! Praise the Lord.
I feel like the providence of God's timing in this book deeply influenced how much I valued it. This was a book gifted to me by my dear university pastor as a graduation present :) It has traveled with me home to home over the last four years—Toronto to Akron to Memphis and finally NYC! Although it has stood on my shelf all these years, I did not feel compelled to read it until the morning of a church-organized street evangelism event—an event I have fondly and consistently enjoyed over the past year. It was on the train, en route to the event, that I read the first chapter on pragmatic evangelism. Oof. I was extremely excited to GO (hehe), but found myself on autopilot as my partner and I walked around the city sharing the gospel and praying for our neighbors.
As I reflected afterward, I realized pragmatism had dulled me. I had gotten used to “doing evangelism” in a way that elevates success and method over the heart of it all - a faithfulness to the Great Comission for the glory of Jesus. I love Mack’s shift from asking, “What works?” to “Who are we to be as evangelists?” This reorientation moves us away from a
programmatic approach to a personal and identity anchoring. I want to be an evangelist who is more concerned with faithfulness in sharing Christ clearly than I am with “results.”
For years I’ve felt a slight kicking feeling whenever people throw around the phrase “This is the gospel!” so flippantly. The Holy Spirit has given me a growing discernment for when people are actually sharing the gospel versus merely naming its implications. I love that Mack writes about the dangers of “adding” and “subtracting” from the gospel story—and the effects these distortions have. For example, Mack says that “subtracting” from the gospel could look like minimizing the true weight of sin. Mack writes, “It [when we omit the weight of sin in the gospel story] makes for weak disciples of Jesus. People who have a weak view of their own sin, for example, will carry a weak view of grace and love.”
“Human additions to the gospel rob God of His rightful glory.” And a lot of this, I think, comes from a place of pride (at least for me it does). For me to assume that I know how to “fit” the gospel to other people’s life contexts is silly!
The Guarding the Gospel chapter was so interesting! I love 2 Timothy 2:2, where Paul talks about the faithfulness of generation to generation passing on the gospel—it encourages me in my own disciple-making. Mack takes this verse and shows the importance of guarding the gospel from generation to generation by preaching it in its fullest dignity and truth. Then he shows the consequences when it is not handled with dignity and truth using this sobering progression:
The gospel is accepted (generation 1) → the gospel is assumed (generation 2) → the gospel is confused (generation 3) → the gospel is lost (generation 4).
Considering the culture around me—both secular and within the church—I feel like we are on the precipice of generation 2: the gospel is assumed. Again, whenever I hear friends or even pastors toss around the phrase “This is the gospel!” so carelessly, it worries me!! It makes me think: we are in generation 2. And that’s something I should be praying over more intentionally. It also convicts me to solidify my own understanding of the gospel.
Also—can I just say—I really appreciate a bullet point list in a book. My Gen Z attention span can’t always retain or unpack sprawling theological dense exposition, so Mack’s lists on conversion markers, how to love your church, and the final chapter—the manifesto—were clear and easy to receive!
In the “Take Action” section of the final chapter, Mack urges readers to spend time with new believers—not only to help them grow in their faith, but also because new believers are often still closely connected to nonbelieving friends, creating natural opportunities for further ministry. The conviction hit me like a cartoon anvil—straight to the head. Honestly, this book pulled back the curtain on a lot of my pride (which feels like a recurring theme the Lord is shouting in my life right now!!).
My church has been preaching that church life—service, community groups, the cozy Sunday rhythms—is the huddle, not the game. And I must admit, I love the huddle. I thrive in the huddle! Maybe even prefer it to the game itself! Lately, I’ve been wrestling with where my “game” actually is. Beyond the beautiful people of NYC, I think it might be my newer believer friends—the ones I often hold at a distance. Not out of anything malicious, but out of a desire to stay in the comfort zone of those who are already “equally yoked.” Praying for a softer heart and a deeper humility—for the courage to draw near to friends who are just beginning their journey with Jesus.
My final sub-point is one of adoration: specifically, a love for the church! I’ve always loved church, though the reasoning behind that affection has evolved (and I would like to think has matured) over the years. At first, I loved being around people who looked like me, ate like me, talked like me. Then I loved it as a space where I felt known, loved, and seen. And now—I am challenged by it. Church has always been a spiritual home and a formative force. Over the past year, I’ve come to more fully grasp the value of the church in relation to the Great Commission. Mack states it simply: “The church does not exist as a way to fulfill us; it demonstrates the truth of Christ to a watching world.” It's in the unity of the body that non-believers witness the true love of Christ. A love that is sacrificial, forgiving, gentle, and a reflection of Christ's heart for His people!
One star off because I think Mack threw in some phrases that felt like sweeping theological generalizations—with big jumps and even bigger assumptions in between. I understand this book is about evangelism and would’ve been much, much longer had he dwelled on all the intricacies of repentance or the layers of what it means to find joy in the Lord—but still, worth noting. Might not be the best read for a new believer. Also, I didn’t love some of his anecdotes—I can’t pinpoint exactly why, but a few felt a little too... tidy?
All in all: This book convicted and clarified. It calls me out of autopilot and into the deep end—where evangelism is not a tactic but a life. It reminded me of the weight of the gospel, the necessity of guarding it, and the beauty of sharing it with others—not as a strategy, but as an identity rooted in Christ.
Random quotes dump:
- "We never get beyond the gospel in our Christian life to something more advanced. The gospel is not the first step in a stairway of truthsl rather, it is more like the hub in a wheel of truth. The gospel is not just the A-B-C's but the A to Z of Christianity. The gospel is not just the minimum reuqired doctrine necessary to enter the kingdom, but the way we make all progress in the kingdom." - Tim Keller
- "Caring for others represents the gospel, it upholds the gospel, it points to the gospel, it's an implication of the gospel, but it is not the gospel, and it is not equal to the gospel." I think the first three words can be replaced with many things and thats when we get careless with "This is the gospel" statements.
- Fear of God > fear of man ---> leads us to Godly boldness
- On wordly love: "Sentimental loves gives up truth, and universal love gives up justice, me - centered love gives up sacrifice."
Thank you Max for this book!