I am tempted to downgrade my score based on the “type” of book this is, but I won’t do it.
First of all, I was constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop, for the abuse of fat people that happens even in “empowering” books. It never came. Though the fat character, Holly, isn’t exactly a paragon of fat representation, the book still realistically addresses that:
-losing weight is hard, miserable, and not worth it for most people
-being fat was never the problem, the treatment of Holly by those who preyed on her insecurities was
-you can be fat and still be a successful business owner and good friend
While there is quite a bit of negative talk aimed at Holly for her size, both from others and her own mind, it was far less triggering than other (again, “empowering”) books with fat protagonists. Harbison did not opine at length about her “fleshy thighs” or otherwise dwell on her body to a sadistic extent. Now, Holly was clearly wearing straight sizes and only lost 20 pounds, which means she isn’t a true representation of the experience of many fat people, but for a non-activist book that’s over a decade old, it’s pretty impressive.
I also thought Harrison did a pretty good job in explaining Lexi’s motivations without making you feel so sorry for her as to be saccharine. She kept Lexi in the complex grey on area of having truly hurt both Nicola and Holly, and being kind of a jerk to those around her, but having it come from a place of genuine pain and fear. Needing change, but worthy of redemption.
Finally, I was kind of disappointed to see a whole storyline about an actress getting a nose job without ONE mention of Jennifer Grey!!! Or maybe Nicola was supposed to *be* Jennifer Grey? Nicola’s story wrapped up a bit fancifully, but it was enjoyable to read nonetheless.
There are elements of the book that stretched reality enough to notice the light coming through, like the 4 month engagement, and the somewhat lame build up denouement (which was ultimately more interesting). Overall, more sensitive and nuanced than many of the books in this particular sub-category of “women’s” literature.