'Conjuring the Witch' delivers exactly what it says: a Christian community brings rage and blood down on its own head. The book is an easy read, well-written, with very nice descriptions of nature, emotions, and small town life. There's some atmosphere, some unexpected twists, but nothing to write home about. It follows the standard pattern of a binary, self-conflicted voice: Men and Women, Husbands and Wives. The children don't have a say, since they're there to just reproduce their parents' mentality; the religious dissenting voice is, as it often is in such narratives, that of a timid yet intelligent female; the voice of authority belongs to the Father. Rather predictably, the figure of the Witch (in all senses) raises her head, reveals the injustices, and brings everything to an explosive (and ambiguous) ending.
This is the classic struggle between male and female for power, dressed as salvation through submission to an external authority vs salvation through oneself. It's been exhaustively treated in philosophy as the debate between Kant and Sartre (the author goes for a standard 20th century solution, namely, Nietzche's - irrational rage and blood.) The irony is that this is a classic male (typically Western, white) preoccupation, one easy to identify with - as a male. It's all about who has control and the rights to others' pleasure.
The author has some brilliant insights into family and what drives the submissive housewife; unfortunately, these insights do not drive the narrative. Instead, we get endless takes on the urbanite's unfocused mental state (NIcole's) that go nowhere (until, all of a sudden, we reach the final pages, and with no explanation they do!) The witch seemed, to me, just a metaphor for resentment, drawing on never actually defined resources - a deus ex machina sort of solution to all the troubles of this book. But this is precisely how such narratives work: reproducing the old struggles, back and forth to the point of exhaustion.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.