What do you think?
Rate this book
Their Babygirl
She’s everything I’ve ever wanted in a babygirl. The problem? She’s my best friend’s girl.
He’s tasked me with watching over her..
I can’t fall in love. But he’s only stringing her along.
I’m supposed to only… watch her.
But I have an idea. A crazy idea.
We could share her.
Maybe together we can be everything she needs.
Maybe together we can have it all.
He’s tasked me with watching over her..
I can’t fall in love. But he’s only stringing her along.
I’m supposed to only… watch her.
But I have an idea. A crazy idea.
We could share her.
Maybe together we can be everything she needs.
Maybe together we can have it all.
189 pages, Kindle Edition
Published January 10, 2023
261 people are currently reading
348 people want to read
About the author
Rory Reynolds
45 books331 followersRory Reynolds is a stay-at-home mom of two little monsters. She's a ravenous reader of romance and firmly believes that you can never have too many book boyfriends.
She writes feisty heroines, alpha heroes, and panty drenching smut with happily ever afters.
Sign up to my newsletter for a special gift: https://dl.bookfunnel.com/i2ehnjkchq
BookBub: https://www.bookbub.com/profile/rory-...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/authorroryre...
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/roryreynold...
She writes feisty heroines, alpha heroes, and panty drenching smut with happily ever afters.
Sign up to my newsletter for a special gift: https://dl.bookfunnel.com/i2ehnjkchq
BookBub: https://www.bookbub.com/profile/rory-...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/authorroryre...
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/roryreynold...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
January 15, 2023
This book was so delicious and broke my heart into tiny pieces. Rory did a amazing job in her first 3some hehe.
Mia and Cody had some history already but they were alittle toxic I really wanted Cody to grovel more during the book and Mia to make him work harder. That was my only ugh lol. There relationship was on and off again that made Mia finally say enough was enough and made her path towards a new home and into Trevor's arms which is funny since Cody and Trev are friends and work together. Cody just didn't know how badly Trevor wanted Mia.
Until she cut off ties with Cody he started to act right. The relationship was rocky alot. But when the three decided to make it a MFM things were abit better until a bomb was dropped and let's I wish Tervor kicked Cody butt a time or 2.
Low angst, no ow/om drama, no cheating, tiny drama, sexy times, no virgins
Recommend-yes
Cover-⭐️⭐️⭐️
Heat level-🌶🌶🌶
Slowinsta
Age gap
Push away from H
MFM
Sharing
Daddy kink
Praise kink
Anal/sex play
No condom
Hea
Epilogue
Mia and Cody had some history already but they were alittle toxic I really wanted Cody to grovel more during the book and Mia to make him work harder. That was my only ugh lol. There relationship was on and off again that made Mia finally say enough was enough and made her path towards a new home and into Trevor's arms which is funny since Cody and Trev are friends and work together. Cody just didn't know how badly Trevor wanted Mia.
Until she cut off ties with Cody he started to act right. The relationship was rocky alot. But when the three decided to make it a MFM things were abit better until a bomb was dropped and let's I wish Tervor kicked Cody butt a time or 2.
Low angst, no ow/om drama, no cheating, tiny drama, sexy times, no virgins
Recommend-yes
Cover-⭐️⭐️⭐️
Heat level-🌶🌶🌶
Slowinsta
Age gap
Push away from H
MFM
Sharing
Daddy kink
Praise kink
Anal/sex play
No condom
Hea
Epilogue
January 21, 2023
This one missed the mark for me.
Cody and Mia have a complicated relationship. Deciding she’s done with being left behind, she moves out and accepts a position hoping it will give her a fresh start. She didn’t expect to be attracted to her new boss. Trevor is tired of his best friend stringing along the woman of his dreams so he takes their relationship in his own hands.
Honestly, I really liked the idea of this book. Mia and Trevor are adorable and legit perfect for the other. Cody.. he’s walked out on Mia so many times and she just accepts him back without any form of groveling. The worst part is that he knows she’ll always forgive him and he abuses that knowledge. I was honestly waiting for him to bail yet again and Mia just roll over and accept it… again.
Cody and Mia have a complicated relationship. Deciding she’s done with being left behind, she moves out and accepts a position hoping it will give her a fresh start. She didn’t expect to be attracted to her new boss. Trevor is tired of his best friend stringing along the woman of his dreams so he takes their relationship in his own hands.
Honestly, I really liked the idea of this book. Mia and Trevor are adorable and legit perfect for the other. Cody.. he’s walked out on Mia so many times and she just accepts him back without any form of groveling. The worst part is that he knows she’ll always forgive him and he abuses that knowledge. I was honestly waiting for him to bail yet again and Mia just roll over and accept it… again.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 15, 2023
Cody is an ass. Trevor is probably a stalker. Mia is a bit of a doormat.
A handful of pages more could have at least given us some scenes that make Mia forgiving Cody believable.
The story isn’t terrible, but it definitely could have been better.
A handful of pages more could have at least given us some scenes that make Mia forgiving Cody believable.
The story isn’t terrible, but it definitely could have been better.
June 27, 2023
Skip this one.
This is super middle of the road. Its a MFM romance that had potential. Mia was dating Cody but he left and she took a new job with Travis. Travis has been obsessed with her and wants to take care of her. Cody turns out to be friends and business partners with Travis. Travis wants to share Mia. They do. Then Mia ends up pregnant. And Cody leaves. Like it just feels like this was extremely surface level and the spice was extremely short.
This is super middle of the road. Its a MFM romance that had potential. Mia was dating Cody but he left and she took a new job with Travis. Travis has been obsessed with her and wants to take care of her. Cody turns out to be friends and business partners with Travis. Travis wants to share Mia. They do. Then Mia ends up pregnant. And Cody leaves. Like it just feels like this was extremely surface level and the spice was extremely short.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 2, 2023
OK: managed to get to Ch 7, but...just couldn't continue.
Mia Grace has been "house-sitting" for Cody Turner for 5 yrs; she has a crush; he fucks her every time he turns up, then he disappears with no explanation.
So - Mia has a job offer (Office Manager in a BIG security organisation) so she takes the job.
Enter Trevor Brooks - CEO.
He makes sure she has the penthouse apartment next door to him (bc he knew she needed somewhere to live after moving across country) - he also has the hots for her.
And then the reasoning....
Trevor & Cody are partners in this security organisation (Trevor doing the Admin; Cody doing the assignments) with Trevor tasked with "looking after" Mia when Cody is absent.
Now that Trevor has the 'upper hand' (aka looking after Mia (hahaha!!)) he offers to share with Cody when he returns early from an assignment...
Then For Fucks Sake - Mia 'accepts' their explantion/s; forgives Cody; then agrees to a menage...
And that's only by Chapter SIX!!
So - No, no, pretty NO! Both Trevor & Cody are lying; Mia is a fucking doormat & doesn't deserve either men.
I possibly need to hide this - but I don't think I will :)
Mia Grace has been "house-sitting" for Cody Turner for 5 yrs; she has a crush; he fucks her every time he turns up, then he disappears with no explanation.
So - Mia has a job offer (Office Manager in a BIG security organisation) so she takes the job.
Enter Trevor Brooks - CEO.
He makes sure she has the penthouse apartment next door to him (bc he knew she needed somewhere to live after moving across country) - he also has the hots for her.
And then the reasoning....
Trevor & Cody are partners in this security organisation (Trevor doing the Admin; Cody doing the assignments) with Trevor tasked with "looking after" Mia when Cody is absent.
Now that Trevor has the 'upper hand' (aka looking after Mia (hahaha!!)) he offers to share with Cody when he returns early from an assignment...
Then For Fucks Sake - Mia 'accepts' their explantion/s; forgives Cody; then agrees to a menage...
And that's only by Chapter SIX!!
So - No, no, pretty NO! Both Trevor & Cody are lying; Mia is a fucking doormat & doesn't deserve either men.
I possibly need to hide this - but I don't think I will :)
February 6, 2023
enjoyable read but could have been more
I uhmmed and aahed over how many stars this would receive from me and it was a close call between 3 and 4 stars.
I loved the premise of the story - the idea of falling for your best friends girl and wanting her or part of her for yourself was a great one and worked well with the characters.
The reason I marked this down in the end were the following:
Mia’s forgiveness of Cody every time - I understand loving somebody and wanting to forgive them but his attitude and behaviour were disgusting at times and Mia just accepted his apology every time making her seem like a bit of a doormat.
Lack of character development - I would have liked to know more about how Cody and Mia met, more about Cody and Trevor’s past and relationship
Apart from terms of endearment like princess and baby girl there was very little of the whole daddy dom/sub relationship dynamic shown to us which I’d have expected more of given the title.
I uhmmed and aahed over how many stars this would receive from me and it was a close call between 3 and 4 stars.
I loved the premise of the story - the idea of falling for your best friends girl and wanting her or part of her for yourself was a great one and worked well with the characters.
The reason I marked this down in the end were the following:
Mia’s forgiveness of Cody every time - I understand loving somebody and wanting to forgive them but his attitude and behaviour were disgusting at times and Mia just accepted his apology every time making her seem like a bit of a doormat.
Lack of character development - I would have liked to know more about how Cody and Mia met, more about Cody and Trevor’s past and relationship
Apart from terms of endearment like princess and baby girl there was very little of the whole daddy dom/sub relationship dynamic shown to us which I’d have expected more of given the title.
July 1, 2023
good story but wanted more
3.5 stars
I devoured this story in one afternoon. I loved the premise of the girl falling for her lover and his best friend but there were two things missing that dropped it from 4 stars to 3.5 (and again it’s a gooood and spicy story)… I thought it started almost in the middle of a story. There was a whole back story of the characters that we were missing and I was craving more of it. If we had that it would have definitely up’ed the rating. And the heroine forgave one hero way to quickly without any explanation.
I will say though if you’re looking for quick reads to help the lazy afternoons pass- check out this author. I will definitely be looking into her backlist.
3.5 stars
I devoured this story in one afternoon. I loved the premise of the girl falling for her lover and his best friend but there were two things missing that dropped it from 4 stars to 3.5 (and again it’s a gooood and spicy story)… I thought it started almost in the middle of a story. There was a whole back story of the characters that we were missing and I was craving more of it. If we had that it would have definitely up’ed the rating. And the heroine forgave one hero way to quickly without any explanation.
I will say though if you’re looking for quick reads to help the lazy afternoons pass- check out this author. I will definitely be looking into her backlist.
February 11, 2023
DNF at 69% after really wanting to DNF around 50%
Sadly I just couldn’t connect with any of the characters. Mia just seemed like a doormat. Cody had no real redemption or depth before he was forgiven for being a tool for years - we didn’t even get a real explanation or backstory for why he acted how he did. Trevor seemed sweet, albeit a bit stalker-y. I think Mia and Trevor could have had a cute story, but the elements Cody brought to the story were just too frustrating for me. The accidental pregnancy trope is not one that I enjoy so that was the final blow. I’m typically a fan of Ms. Reynolds’s insta-love DDLG works, this one just missed the mark for me.
Sadly I just couldn’t connect with any of the characters. Mia just seemed like a doormat. Cody had no real redemption or depth before he was forgiven for being a tool for years - we didn’t even get a real explanation or backstory for why he acted how he did. Trevor seemed sweet, albeit a bit stalker-y. I think Mia and Trevor could have had a cute story, but the elements Cody brought to the story were just too frustrating for me. The accidental pregnancy trope is not one that I enjoy so that was the final blow. I’m typically a fan of Ms. Reynolds’s insta-love DDLG works, this one just missed the mark for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 17, 2024
i really tried to like this one
I usually love Rory Reynolds’ books, but I just couldn’t with this one. FMC Mia is a complete doormat and it just made me sick.
Cooperation between the guys: 5 of 5 ⭐️
Writing: 5 of 5 ⭐️
Strength of FMC: negative 20 of 5 ⭐️
Necessity of grovel from MMC (Cody): 250 of 5 stars ⭐️
Amount of grovel from MMC (Cody): negative 250 of 5 stars ⭐️
Awesomeness of the other MMC (Trevor): 4 of 5 ⭐️ - he would have gotten 5 except he lets Cody continue to be a @*%#!
Other pertinent info: ménage, not RH and the baby/daddy dynamic is sugar daddy not age play
I usually love Rory Reynolds’ books, but I just couldn’t with this one. FMC Mia is a complete doormat and it just made me sick.
Cooperation between the guys: 5 of 5 ⭐️
Writing: 5 of 5 ⭐️
Strength of FMC: negative 20 of 5 ⭐️
Necessity of grovel from MMC (Cody): 250 of 5 stars ⭐️
Amount of grovel from MMC (Cody): negative 250 of 5 stars ⭐️
Awesomeness of the other MMC (Trevor): 4 of 5 ⭐️ - he would have gotten 5 except he lets Cody continue to be a @*%#!
Other pertinent info: ménage, not RH and the baby/daddy dynamic is sugar daddy not age play
February 1, 2023
A beautiful story
Absolutely loved this story. It took hold of me from the start right to the very end. Although i had to feel sorry for Mia, because in the beggining Cody i felt was such a douch bag doing what he was doing. But then Mia did the right thing and took another job with free accommodation. Her boss Trevor was sexy as, but then after a few days she discovered that Cody worked for Trevor as well. Now she had two men, or does she,? when the crunch comes to the crunch will Cody stay?
A very good read, well worth the five stars.
Absolutely loved this story. It took hold of me from the start right to the very end. Although i had to feel sorry for Mia, because in the beggining Cody i felt was such a douch bag doing what he was doing. But then Mia did the right thing and took another job with free accommodation. Her boss Trevor was sexy as, but then after a few days she discovered that Cody worked for Trevor as well. Now she had two men, or does she,? when the crunch comes to the crunch will Cody stay?
A very good read, well worth the five stars.
January 12, 2023
Mia and Cody have history but then Trevor wants her too.
Steamy, dramatic and romantic. Great story with sensitive, involving characters that evolve as the story progresses.
Cody and Trevor are hot handsome alpha men who want their girl. Several issues were needing to be worked through before these three could make a go of it but all worked out in the end.
Great book and worth the read.
This was an ARC and this is my honest review.
Steamy, dramatic and romantic. Great story with sensitive, involving characters that evolve as the story progresses.
Cody and Trevor are hot handsome alpha men who want their girl. Several issues were needing to be worked through before these three could make a go of it but all worked out in the end.
Great book and worth the read.
This was an ARC and this is my honest review.
July 1, 2023
mia and cody have a on and off relationship with each other. they fuck and cody always leave making mia feel empty afterwards. being sick of it she moves out of his apartment and gets a new job with housing. her new boss trevor turns out to be cody's best friend.
i didnt really like this book. mia always forgave cody. she ended up being pregnant with cody's and he walked out on her again. in the end they all patched up. MFM. she has a baby girl
i didnt really like this book. mia always forgave cody. she ended up being pregnant with cody's and he walked out on her again. in the end they all patched up. MFM. she has a baby girl
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 3, 2023
get you in the feels
This book got me. It has some serious emotion. Very well written story with a female lead character that gets the short end of the stick until the tide changes. Overwhelmed, and confused when her world implodes she takes a chance on unconventional love and its a beautiful story. This is a spicy romance with Hea and multiple partners. Couldn’t put it down.
This book got me. It has some serious emotion. Very well written story with a female lead character that gets the short end of the stick until the tide changes. Overwhelmed, and confused when her world implodes she takes a chance on unconventional love and its a beautiful story. This is a spicy romance with Hea and multiple partners. Couldn’t put it down.
January 18, 2023
Their Babygirl
A good story by Rory Reynolds. Mia has finally had enough of Cody's here then gone style. She leaves for a different job only to discover......well, read the book to find out what happens.
I only saw a couple of errors, excellent in that department. It is a hot, sweet romance!
A good story by Rory Reynolds. Mia has finally had enough of Cody's here then gone style. She leaves for a different job only to discover......well, read the book to find out what happens.
I only saw a couple of errors, excellent in that department. It is a hot, sweet romance!
January 19, 2023
I really liked this book! It had a lot of Action and steamy stuff.
Cody has been a love and leave in the morning kind of guy and Mia just can’t do that any longer.
This is where this book takes off into the upper stratosphere! With two guys making her heart do flip flops!
There is also an additional bonus epilogue available. What’s not to like?
I reviewed an advanced copy of this book
Cody has been a love and leave in the morning kind of guy and Mia just can’t do that any longer.
This is where this book takes off into the upper stratosphere! With two guys making her heart do flip flops!
There is also an additional bonus epilogue available. What’s not to like?
I reviewed an advanced copy of this book
May 25, 2024
All the YES!!
So "Why Choose" is my favorite trope. And this book delivered that in a quick, steamy and glorious way. I loved the characters and the storyline. I LOVED the spice 😘👌 If you're looking for a quick read (I finished it in one evening, I couldn't put it down!), spicy and well-executed Why Choose romance, read this book!!
So "Why Choose" is my favorite trope. And this book delivered that in a quick, steamy and glorious way. I loved the characters and the storyline. I LOVED the spice 😘👌 If you're looking for a quick read (I finished it in one evening, I couldn't put it down!), spicy and well-executed Why Choose romance, read this book!!
June 16, 2024
I loved Mia and Trevor together. However, Cody was a jerk and should have had to grovel at least a little bit. HE ACCUSSES MIA OF CHEATING WHEN THEU FIND OUT SHE IS PREGNANT AND THEN LEAVES. AND SHE JUST LET'S HIM COME BACK. If it wasn't for Trevor, I would have DNFed this book when she took hom back the first time
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 15, 2023
Cute Read
What cute read, when you have a boyfriend who comes in for a quickie then leaves to being hired for a great job, only to find out its the same company the boyfriend works at. Lots of cute things happen in this book.
What cute read, when you have a boyfriend who comes in for a quickie then leaves to being hired for a great job, only to find out its the same company the boyfriend works at. Lots of cute things happen in this book.
April 14, 2023
Honestly, I knew pretty quickly I was going to dnf this book. After a few chapters I skipped to the end, disliked the last few chapters enough that I didn't bother to go back and read the rest of the story. Sometimes a book just doesn't click.
July 3, 2023
Really Good
I have to say I loved this book. I think the characters were great (though Mia was a little too forgiving in my opinion). One man is a flight risk and the other is a mild daddy Dom, what's not to love?
So good!!
I have to say I loved this book. I think the characters were great (though Mia was a little too forgiving in my opinion). One man is a flight risk and the other is a mild daddy Dom, what's not to love?
So good!!
July 4, 2023
This is a menage, not RH. The plot is not the worst I've seen but I didn't like how wishy washy the MCs are and the fact that they're all walking red flags. I do feel like the story could've been better.
July 16, 2023
Get rid of Cody and this could have been a way better book with a higher rating bc that man child was ridiculous and did not deserve to be given so many chances
Trevor however was amazing and the only reason I kept reading lol
3/5 stars
Trevor however was amazing and the only reason I kept reading lol
3/5 stars
August 22, 2023
No se que esperaba pero nada de eso tuvo. La idea NO es mala PERO no hay plot, no hay conflicto todo sucede natural y se resuelve sólo, no tiene sentido.
Beneficios? Fue una descarga gratuita del Stuff Your Kindle Day (?
Beneficios? Fue una descarga gratuita del Stuff Your Kindle Day (?
March 29, 2024
Story 2.5⭐️ Spice 2.5🌶️
I love MFM and Daddy Dom (with no age play) so I really had high hopes for this…but it fell short, big time. Cody should have been kicked out of her life years ago, he is 100% toxic. And Trevor is stalker creepy. The whole situation is absurd.
I love MFM and Daddy Dom (with no age play) so I really had high hopes for this…but it fell short, big time. Cody should have been kicked out of her life years ago, he is 100% toxic. And Trevor is stalker creepy. The whole situation is absurd.
January 15, 2023
Emotional read
I enjoyed this book! Interesting story of these 3 coming together and a steamy relationship. Also an emotional ride towards a HEA. Kept me engaged to the end.
I enjoyed this book! Interesting story of these 3 coming together and a steamy relationship. Also an emotional ride towards a HEA. Kept me engaged to the end.
March 14, 2023
4.5 stars
Want to read
July 1, 2023🎁 FREE on Amazon today (7/1/2023)! 🎁
July 15, 2023
Hot and steamy
Very hot and steamy story from the very beginning. Quick read, and full of all the naughty things you crave in this type of book.
Very hot and steamy story from the very beginning. Quick read, and full of all the naughty things you crave in this type of book.
August 1, 2023
Ugh this book. Honestly not a good one for me. I liked Trevor, hated Cody… I just couldn’t get into it.
August 5, 2023
Cody walks out on her, f that.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews