Even though it is apparent that Ruskin wrote this book under the belief that girls could handle the study of geology, his whole attitude towards all of the girls in his class was very degrading. They had questions, and he merely teased answers or complained that he was too cross today to answer any of them. Besides which, he told all of the girls that their only aim in life is to want to dance, sew, and cook—basically just look pretty and be of use. I do not quite understand his reasoning, for if he truly believes this why has he written a book about geology for girls?
Also far too often he interposes his own political and religious viewpoints, which are not founded in anything but his opinion rather than any biblical truth. He will say something based on one verse, which he twists to fit his opinion, and disregard other verses, which speak Truth against Ruskin’s falseness.
The only thing good I’ve taken out of this book was the story in the beginning about the valley of diamonds and the singing serpents, but even that was explained away in the notes at the end, which I did not take kindly too. There were also a few fresh ideas scattered here and there, but overall the book was too condescending.