When Mesa High closes, more than half its students transfer to Tabb. Bummed about the disruption in her social life and her dwindling chances of landing Homecoming Queen in a school where no one knows her, Jessica Hart is grateful that, at least, most of her friends transferred with her. When Alice and Polly McCoy decide to throw a party, half Tabb students and half Mesa, so everyone can get to know each other, Jessica thinks it’s a great idea. The party ends with a body on the ground. The police ruled it a suicide–but they were wrong. Trigger warnings: death, parent death, suicide mention, violence, eye horror, blood, guns, drowning, racism, misogyny, fat-shaming, bullying, depression.
As always with books I love, I feel like I’m not doing them justice when I review them. This series really hinges on the characters, so if you don’t like them, there’s almost no chance of liking it. That being said, the cast of Final Friends are some of my favorite Pike characters of all time. He often begins with stock-like characters: Yes, Clair Hilrey is the characteristic stuck-up cheerleader, Bill Skater the not-too-bright quarterback, and Jessica Hart is well-meaning but privileged, but I think he takes them in interesting and often unexpected directions. Michael Olsen has more kindness and depth than the stereotypical brilliant over-achiever, Alice McCoy is ethereal and troubled without edging into manic pixie dreamgirl territory, and Sara Cantrell is entirely her own brand of spunk and sass. Sara fighting with Russ Desmond is one of my favorite YA ships, and I found myself laughing out loud a couple times. I also like that Pike attempts to work in characters of color in this series with Nick, an African American teenager from inner city L.A., and Maria, a sweet but quiet girl from El Salvador. Keep in mind, however, that this book is more than twenty years old, and the representation isn’t flawless. Like the others, they sometimes edge into stereotypes, and there are a handful of references that a sensitivity reader in the present day would probably revise. Sara also fat-shames Polly more than once, which isn’t necessary or funny.
The majority of this book is given over to these characters: getting to know them, them getting to know each other as the Mesa students navigate the social order of Tabb, and seeing how they relate to one another. As an ensemble cast, it works extremely well, and there’s plenty of mixed tension and small jealousies to create problems later on. We need to know these characters and know them well for the story to work, but the thriller aspect of it doesn’t really ramp up until the last fifty pages, where the eponymous party takes place. There’s a high creep factor when Pike sets up what’s basically a locked room murder, and since all the main characters are still present at the end of the party, they’re all suspects. In the meantime, it’s becoming clear that he’s laid the groundwork for a number of other, smaller mysteries: What happened to Russ’s ax? Who tampered with the votes for the school elections? Who exactly is Alice’s weird boyfriend, Clark? And, of course, who would have the motive to commit this particular murder? However, the novel isn’t at all high on closure, since the murder has only just happened near the book’s end, with no time to unravel any of these mysteries. In hindsight, I’m a little surprised to see it published as three separate books, since it seems to work best as a whole. (Perhaps in a few years I’ll read the Until the End omnibus to see if I’m right about that.)
I review regularly at brightbeautifulthings.tumblr.com.