The Common Man, by Maurice Manning, is a book you have to read with people you know. Another pair of eyes helps with thick symbolism, and another smile makes a nice poem nicer. I enjoyed almost all of the poems in this book, and I would recommend it to other people.
In most poems, Manning’s language looks deceptively common. He writes in a way that sounds like a ramble, as if the poet is speaking directly to the reader. He tells stories about people who are “ordinary:” ironically, the stories are as un-ordinary as they come. Here’s an example from the poem “For the Last Time, No, I’m Not the Rabbit Man.”
“… Why, he’s got
More rabbits than sense, and they’ve all got names
From the books of the Good Book and because
There’s more rabbits than books he’s doubled up,
So there’s a fat rabbit he calls
Ecclesiastes the Second, and such
as that.” (3-9)
This story is great. I myself have never known a man with 67+ rabbits, which is probably the reason the poet decided to tell me about one. Manning’s skillful writing and broad imagination has filled the book with stories like these: stories that are simply entertaining.
Don’t let the rambling or the humor fool you. The poems are also full of unexpected depth. In another poem, titled “The Old Clodhopper’s Aubade,” the poet describes a girl he thinks is amazing, comparing her eyes to bluebirds, and lamenting the lonely shadow he keeps in his head. But the poet, by mistake, has gotten her eye color wrong.
“Yore nature’s strange, she said, and sighed.
Besides my eyes ain’t blue, they’re green.
With that, she closed them tight, her eyes,
and the sun-ball hung his hat behind
the sky. The happiness I’d known
so little of had left a mark
to let me know I knew it less,
and, by God, that turned my nature dark.” (33-40)
It’s an amusing predicament, and at the same time, it’s a reflection on self-centeredness. As soon as the poet’s love contradicts his fantasies, the sun seems to disappear behind the clouds. The last sentence, which is more poetic than any previous praise of bluebird eyes, talks about how much his ignorance of his proclaimed source of happiness has struck him.
It is good to mention, lastly, that the book includes plenty of mature themes. The story in “Ars Poetica Shaggy and Brown,” for example, talks about a suicide. Another example is the poem “Hey, Sidewinder,” which tells the story of a man who discovers his wife was cheating. By killing the man, he drew the wrath of the man’s brothers, so he leaves his wife tied naked to a bedpost and escapes town dressed like a woman. Such scenes are never written in a graphic or demeaning way.