I was looking forward to this one because I remember this is one that I read quite a bit in my teen years. You can tell by how worn my copy is. Well - the good news it's much better than most of Nixon's other novels. The bad news is that... it was kind of boring and I had a hard time getting into it.
This is a sequel to The Dark and Deadly pool, and all the wonderful characters are back. Mary Elizabeth is fun, and while the klutziness is kind of an annoyingly trope-ish way to give an otherwise perfect heroine some faults, she's easily the most likably heroine we've had.
Pretty much all the side characters are back -- Tina, Lamar, Detective Jarvis, and the setting of the hotel. Even the love interest, Fran, remains being an all around fun guy (unlike so many of the dudes Nixon puts in her novels.) All great characters, again, easily the best batch of characters we've had -- which may be one reason why Nixon decided to have another go with the characters.
Look - the premise is a lot of fun, too. There's a mystery weekend at the hotel, and then someone really dies in a haunted room. Everything about this book screams like a wonderful fun time. And maybe at age 12 I did enjoy it.
The problem is that the mystery is incredibly dull. While Nixon avoids a lot of her long standing tropes (were there any besides this being Texas?), the downside is that lacks any kind of tension or intriguing mystery. The mystery weekend is a cool plot framing, but I seems kind of clumsily shoehorned in. And the unraveling of the real mystery is that interesting at all -- the motive is exceedingly vague and boring, and there really aren't clues to follow, just a bunch of assumptions that, more or less, turn out to be right.
At least there's a bit of a ghost story tied into it -- but it's also not really fleshed out to really hold any weight.
Ug, c'mon, Joan, you know how to have a good premise - why is it squandered??
That said - this still remains one of her better overall novels...
Rating: 3.25 Stars