What do you think?
Rate this book
Harry Bosch #7
Más oscuro que la noche
Harry Bosch participa como testigo en un juicio en el que se acusa a un director de cine del asesinato de una actriz. Mientras tanto, el ya retirado agente del FBI, Terry McCaleb, investiga un homicidio complejo. Su primer examen del escenario del crimen le lleva en pos de un asesino metódico con un gusto por los rituales y la venganza: junto al cadáver de la víctima han sido halladas la figura de una lechuza y un extraño mensaje en latín. A medida que McCaleb desentraña las claves de este escabroso asesinato, Bosch cobra mayor protagonismo en el juicio del que está pendiente toda la ciudad de Los Ángeles. Sorprendentemente, las piezas de uno y otro rompecabezas empiezan a solaparse.
448 pages, Paperback
First published November 8, 2000
5684 people are currently reading
12178 people want to read
About the author
Michael Connelly
380 books35.1k followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads' database with this name. See this thread for more information.
Michael Connelly decided to become a writer after discovering the books of Raymond Chandler while attending the University of Florida. Once he decided on this direction he chose a major in journalism and a minor in creative writing — a curriculum in which one of his teachers was novelist Harry Crews.
After graduating in 1980, Connelly worked at newspapers in Daytona Beach and Fort Lauderdale, Florida, primarily specializing in the crime beat. In Fort Lauderdale he wrote about police and crime during the height of the murder and violence wave that rolled over South Florida during the so-called cocaine wars. In 1986, he and two other reporters spent several months interviewing survivors of a major airline crash. They wrote a magazine story on the crash and the survivors which was later short-listed for the Pulitzer Prize for feature writing. The magazine story also moved Connelly into the upper levels of journalism, landing him a job as a crime reporter for the Los Angeles Times, one of the largest papers in the country, and bringing him to the city of which his literary hero, Chandler, had written.
After three years on the crime beat in L.A., Connelly began writing his first novel to feature LAPD Detective Hieronymus Bosch. The novel, The Black Echo, based in part on a true crime that had occurred in Los Angeles, was published in 1992 and won the Edgar Award for Best First Novel by the Mystery Writers of America. Connelly has followed that up with over 30 more novels.
Over eighty million copies of Connelly’s books have sold worldwide and he has been translated into forty-five foreign languages. He has won the Edgar Award, Anthony Award, Macavity Award, Los Angeles Times Best Mystery/Thriller Award, Shamus Award, Dilys Award, Nero Award, Barry Award, Audie Award, Ridley Award, Maltese Falcon Award (Japan), .38 Caliber Award (France), Grand Prix Award (France), Premio Bancarella Award (Italy), and the Pepe Carvalho award (Spain) .
Michael was the President of the Mystery Writers of America organization in 2003 and 2004. In addition to his literary work, Michael is one of the producers and writers of the TV show, “Bosch,” which is streaming on Amazon Prime Video.
Michael lives with his family in Los Angeles and Tampa, Florida.
Michael Connelly decided to become a writer after discovering the books of Raymond Chandler while attending the University of Florida. Once he decided on this direction he chose a major in journalism and a minor in creative writing — a curriculum in which one of his teachers was novelist Harry Crews.
After graduating in 1980, Connelly worked at newspapers in Daytona Beach and Fort Lauderdale, Florida, primarily specializing in the crime beat. In Fort Lauderdale he wrote about police and crime during the height of the murder and violence wave that rolled over South Florida during the so-called cocaine wars. In 1986, he and two other reporters spent several months interviewing survivors of a major airline crash. They wrote a magazine story on the crash and the survivors which was later short-listed for the Pulitzer Prize for feature writing. The magazine story also moved Connelly into the upper levels of journalism, landing him a job as a crime reporter for the Los Angeles Times, one of the largest papers in the country, and bringing him to the city of which his literary hero, Chandler, had written.
After three years on the crime beat in L.A., Connelly began writing his first novel to feature LAPD Detective Hieronymus Bosch. The novel, The Black Echo, based in part on a true crime that had occurred in Los Angeles, was published in 1992 and won the Edgar Award for Best First Novel by the Mystery Writers of America. Connelly has followed that up with over 30 more novels.
Over eighty million copies of Connelly’s books have sold worldwide and he has been translated into forty-five foreign languages. He has won the Edgar Award, Anthony Award, Macavity Award, Los Angeles Times Best Mystery/Thriller Award, Shamus Award, Dilys Award, Nero Award, Barry Award, Audie Award, Ridley Award, Maltese Falcon Award (Japan), .38 Caliber Award (France), Grand Prix Award (France), Premio Bancarella Award (Italy), and the Pepe Carvalho award (Spain) .
Michael was the President of the Mystery Writers of America organization in 2003 and 2004. In addition to his literary work, Michael is one of the producers and writers of the TV show, “Bosch,” which is streaming on Amazon Prime Video.
Michael lives with his family in Los Angeles and Tampa, Florida.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,719 reviews
October 16, 2017
In this book, published in 2001, Michael Connelly brings together three of the characters he had previously used as lead protagonists: former FBI agent, Terry McCaleb from Blood Work, journalist Jack McEvoy from The Poet, and L.A. Homicide Detective Harry Bosch, whom Connelly had featured in several novels up to that point. McEvoy plays a relatively minor role here, while Bosch and McCaleb are center stage.
As the book opens, Bosch is assisting the prosecution in a high-profile Hollywood murder trial. A movie director is charged with murdering a young actress and then attempting to make the killing look like an accidental death. Bosch was the lead detective on the case and made the arrest.
As the case unfolds in court, L. A. County Sheriff's detective Jaye Winston seeks out Terry McCaleb, looking for help on a case that has dead-ended. McCaleb, who was forced to retire after having a heart transplant, is now living quietly, running a charter fishing boat, and carving out a life with his new wife, their daughter, and his adopted son. But he hasn't lost the drive and the curiosity that once made him a leading FBI profiler.
Winston's case involves a scumbag named Edward Gunn who was once arrested by Harry Bosch for the murder of a prostitute. Gunn managed to beat the charge and has now been found murdered in a ritualistic fashion. Winston's case is going nowhere and she fears that this may be a serial killer who will be targeting victims after Gunn. She appeals to McCaleb who had worked with her previously, to look at the evidence and offer an opinion.
Well, in for a penny....
The reader understands immediately, even if Winston doesn't, that once this case gets its hooks into McCaleb, it's not going to let go. Civilian or not, and whether anyone wants him to or not, McCaleb will wind up in the middle of it. And the deeper McCaleb digs into the case, the more the evidence leads him in the direction of a startling suspect.
Meanwhile, the trial in which Bosch is involved is having its ups and downs. Just when it appears that the prosecution team has pretty much nailed the case against the cocky director, things seems to take a bad turn. And as the case seems to be hanging by a thread, McCaleb's investigation intrudes into it, with potentially dire consequences for everyone involved.
This is another very good novel from Michael Connelly. Caleb and Bosch make a very interesting pairing and the plot takes one surprising twist after another. One might argue that the ending is a little forced, but that's a small complaint, and this is another story from Connelly that kept me turning the pages well into the night. An easy four stars.
As the book opens, Bosch is assisting the prosecution in a high-profile Hollywood murder trial. A movie director is charged with murdering a young actress and then attempting to make the killing look like an accidental death. Bosch was the lead detective on the case and made the arrest.
As the case unfolds in court, L. A. County Sheriff's detective Jaye Winston seeks out Terry McCaleb, looking for help on a case that has dead-ended. McCaleb, who was forced to retire after having a heart transplant, is now living quietly, running a charter fishing boat, and carving out a life with his new wife, their daughter, and his adopted son. But he hasn't lost the drive and the curiosity that once made him a leading FBI profiler.
Winston's case involves a scumbag named Edward Gunn who was once arrested by Harry Bosch for the murder of a prostitute. Gunn managed to beat the charge and has now been found murdered in a ritualistic fashion. Winston's case is going nowhere and she fears that this may be a serial killer who will be targeting victims after Gunn. She appeals to McCaleb who had worked with her previously, to look at the evidence and offer an opinion.
Well, in for a penny....
The reader understands immediately, even if Winston doesn't, that once this case gets its hooks into McCaleb, it's not going to let go. Civilian or not, and whether anyone wants him to or not, McCaleb will wind up in the middle of it. And the deeper McCaleb digs into the case, the more the evidence leads him in the direction of a startling suspect.
Meanwhile, the trial in which Bosch is involved is having its ups and downs. Just when it appears that the prosecution team has pretty much nailed the case against the cocky director, things seems to take a bad turn. And as the case seems to be hanging by a thread, McCaleb's investigation intrudes into it, with potentially dire consequences for everyone involved.
This is another very good novel from Michael Connelly. Caleb and Bosch make a very interesting pairing and the plot takes one surprising twist after another. One might argue that the ending is a little forced, but that's a small complaint, and this is another story from Connelly that kept me turning the pages well into the night. An easy four stars.
December 1, 2015
I started this knowing that it was Harry Bosch #7 but not knowing it was also Terry McCaleb #2. So not having read Terry McCaleb #1 I may have missed some of the overall goodness of the book. However I got enough to give it four easy stars. I have to admit I did not like McCaleb at all and this may be because I did not already know him. He drew his outrageous assumptions about people based on ridiculously tiny facts and generally just pottered around being a nuisance. Harry on the other hand dealt with his issues head on and I loved the way he kept popping up mysteriously just when he was needed. This was an easy book to read. I finished it in one day and am now looking forward to the next one/
November 19, 2024
Harry Bosch, #7; Harry Bosch Universe, #10: sees three Connelly headliners interact! Former FBI profiler Terry McCaleb is asked to investigate the murder of a man who previously 'got off' a serous crime; he is aided by crime reporter Jack McAvoy as their prime target is testifying at a glamourous all-eyes-on-us trial of a Hollywood big-wig accused of murder. The suspect is Bosch!!
As ever a very well put together read, but a big minus is the idea that somonis as experienced McCaleb so easily came to the assumption/profile that Bosch was his man. This is still such a great universe, in this volume alone I recognised at least 12 characters from this constructed reality :) A 7 out of 12, Three Stars from me.
Lb>2024 read
As ever a very well put together read, but a big minus is the idea that somonis as experienced McCaleb so easily came to the assumption/profile that Bosch was his man. This is still such a great universe, in this volume alone I recognised at least 12 characters from this constructed reality :) A 7 out of 12, Three Stars from me.
Lb>2024 read
December 1, 2018
I have not read the first (and only other) Terry McCaleb book, Blood Work, and honestly, I probably never will. He is the reason I am annoyed with this dud of a book tainting what is otherwise a rock solid series. This cross-over book features characters from three of Connelly's series (serieses? serii?): Obviously Harry Bosch, Jack McEvoy from The Poet and The Scarecrow, and Terry McLame-o.
Jack had a walk-on role with a few lines, but really was just there as a "Oh, hey! That's that guy from that other book!" name recognition Easter egg. He could be replaced by literally anyone else and the story would be unchanged.
Unfortunately, Terry McBlah has a starring role, and this book is more of his story than a Bosch story. Which is... fine. It's fine. If I ever do a re-read of this series, I'll just skip this dud.
Anyway, let's get to the point here. Terry McWhatever is SUPPOSEDLY a professional, prestigious, retired FBI profiler recovering from a heart transplant and apparently a lobotomy and personalityectomy, and he's looped into a case that has the lead not-Bosch detective stumped, and as soon as I saw that the lead detective was not Bosch, I knew where this was going, and was not wrong. Mr. Expert Profiler Man is led precisely by the nose to the conclusion that veteran detective Bosch is the killer, because the crime scene was staged with imagery and symbolism literally taken from Hieronymus Bosch's (the painter) artwork.
FYI: My cat makes a better profiler than Terry McDerpface. The guy is so unimportant, such a non-entity in his own book that even the Goodreads book description of some editions can't bother getting his name right. It lists his first name as "Terrence", but he's actually a "Terrell". I find this amusing. (As a GR Librarian, I did attempt to edit it but I'm not sure if it took, and honestly, don't care that much. Let him be Terrence or whatever if the GR gods will it.)
Anyway, Terrence McClam doesn't even make a good investigator, let alone a trained profiler. His style is more of a "I got a square piece of evidence here, how do I cram it into the triangular hole of the 'gut instinct' theory I literally was fed by the killer's misdirection?" method than "Let's look at the evidence and see where it actually takes us" method. Literally as soon as the painter Bosch was mentioned, Tryhard McFailure stopped investigating the case and started fitting the investigation around Bosch the detective.
Obviously Bosch is a flawed and imperfect man, and that is why he is compelling and interesting and his series didn't stop at a duology, Twobook McWho. But a sadistic killer he is not. There's never a single doubt in my mind on this point, no matter how hard TERRENCE tried to force it all to fit. And it was so frustrating that he tried so hard to make it fit. Being forced to watch him "work" this case was exhausting to my eyes because they kept trying to roll out of my skull every 2 minutes or so as the logical leaps and fallacies abounded.
I'm going to do you all a favor and copy Turdy McGee's profile of Bosch (which should be a red flag, because he's shouldn't be profiling a PERSON in the first place), in its entirety, so you can understand how expert he is at this:
Damn this was... not great.
Profiling is hard. I say this as an expert. WRITING a compelling story about profiling is probably just as hard, because not only do you have to get into the killer's head and understand motivations that may be incomprehensible (not that this was, at ALL. Sheesh, so transparent.), but then you have to weave that into a compelling and suspenseful narrative with believable characters and plot and pacing and dialogue and everything.
And it just didn't hit the mark for me on most of those points. I felt like the whole plot was too convenient, too try-hard. It felt forced and stilted. Every scene Terry was in felt awkward to me. His dialogue was so formal, he was so... boringly wholesome, with his "I see God in my baby daughter's eyes" shit. Gag. His relationship with his wife was eye-rollingly pathetic. Oh, tell me more about how she was totally fine with you coming out of retirement to investigate a murder that mattered to HER - and even more recently after heart surgery... but NOW that she's your wife and the mother of your god-eyed baby, she's gone all mother hen about you working THIS case, clucking about how dangerous it is, and how scared she is, and blah blah blah. Stereotypical "concerned wife" bullshit, and irritating as hell.
And ugh - Tweedle McDee correcting his 10? 12? year old step-son Raymond when he said "yeah" with "You mean 'yes'?" every time made me want to stab him in the face. Dude, don't be a dick. He's a kid, and you're a fucking stick in the mud. Get over yourself.
Ugh... so much to dislike in this book. I sincerely hope this is the last I ever see of Troopy McCrawdad.
The ONLY saving grace to this book was that Bosch was in it. In all the ways that Typo McSnooze failed as a character, Bosch doesn't. He's got a supporting role in this book, but his sections were the highlight of the story for me. I love his nuance, I feel like I get his jadedness, and identify with his disgust with a system that fails in its duty to carry out fair and blind justice more often than not. I understand him, I think. And I root for him. Even when he fucks up, badly, I still feel like he's on the right side of things, and I can understand why he does what he does, even if I can't condone it.
So, Bosch is why this is getting 2 stars instead of an otherwise well-earned 1 star.
And now, back to our regularly scheduled Bosch series... Please? :D
Jack had a walk-on role with a few lines, but really was just there as a "Oh, hey! That's that guy from that other book!" name recognition Easter egg. He could be replaced by literally anyone else and the story would be unchanged.
Unfortunately, Terry McBlah has a starring role, and this book is more of his story than a Bosch story. Which is... fine. It's fine. If I ever do a re-read of this series, I'll just skip this dud.
Anyway, let's get to the point here. Terry McWhatever is SUPPOSEDLY a professional, prestigious, retired FBI profiler recovering from a heart transplant and apparently a lobotomy and personalityectomy, and he's looped into a case that has the lead not-Bosch detective stumped, and as soon as I saw that the lead detective was not Bosch, I knew where this was going, and was not wrong. Mr. Expert Profiler Man is led precisely by the nose to the conclusion that veteran detective Bosch is the killer, because the crime scene was staged with imagery and symbolism literally taken from Hieronymus Bosch's (the painter) artwork.
FYI: My cat makes a better profiler than Terry McDerpface. The guy is so unimportant, such a non-entity in his own book that even the Goodreads book description of some editions can't bother getting his name right. It lists his first name as "Terrence", but he's actually a "Terrell". I find this amusing. (As a GR Librarian, I did attempt to edit it but I'm not sure if it took, and honestly, don't care that much. Let him be Terrence or whatever if the GR gods will it.)
Anyway, Terrence McClam doesn't even make a good investigator, let alone a trained profiler. His style is more of a "I got a square piece of evidence here, how do I cram it into the triangular hole of the 'gut instinct' theory I literally was fed by the killer's misdirection?" method than "Let's look at the evidence and see where it actually takes us" method. Literally as soon as the painter Bosch was mentioned, Tryhard McFailure stopped investigating the case and started fitting the investigation around Bosch the detective.
Obviously Bosch is a flawed and imperfect man, and that is why he is compelling and interesting and his series didn't stop at a duology, Twobook McWho. But a sadistic killer he is not. There's never a single doubt in my mind on this point, no matter how hard TERRENCE tried to force it all to fit. And it was so frustrating that he tried so hard to make it fit. Being forced to watch him "work" this case was exhausting to my eyes because they kept trying to roll out of my skull every 2 minutes or so as the logical leaps and fallacies abounded.
I'm going to do you all a favor and copy Turdy McGee's profile of Bosch (which should be a red flag, because he's shouldn't be profiling a PERSON in the first place), in its entirety, so you can understand how expert he is at this:
SUSPECT: BoschThis, friends, is not a profile. I'm no expert, but I've seen many seasons of Criminal Minds, and therefore I am an expert, and a profile should be formed around the traits that a killer may likely possess to have committed the crime at hand, and should be used to help narrow down a suspect pool. It should NOT be a bunch of disparate thoughts and observations and out-of-context comments centered on and used against a single person who all-too-conveniently fits the theory that you're trying to square-peg-round-hole together.
Institutional - youth hall, Vietnam, LAPD
Outsider - Alienation
Obsessive-compulsive
Eyes - lost, loss
Mission man - avenging angel
the big wheel always turning - nobody walks away
what goes around comes around
alcohol
divorce - wife? why?
alienation/obsession
mother
cases
justice system - "bullshit"
carriers of the plague
guilt?
Harry = Hieronymus
owl = evil
evil = Gunn
death of evil = release stressors
paintings - demons - devils - evil
darkness and light - the edge
punishment
mother - justice - Gunn
God's hand - police - Bosch
punishment = God's work
A darkness more than night - Bosch
Damn this was... not great.
Profiling is hard. I say this as an expert. WRITING a compelling story about profiling is probably just as hard, because not only do you have to get into the killer's head and understand motivations that may be incomprehensible (not that this was, at ALL. Sheesh, so transparent.), but then you have to weave that into a compelling and suspenseful narrative with believable characters and plot and pacing and dialogue and everything.
And it just didn't hit the mark for me on most of those points. I felt like the whole plot was too convenient, too try-hard. It felt forced and stilted. Every scene Terry was in felt awkward to me. His dialogue was so formal, he was so... boringly wholesome, with his "I see God in my baby daughter's eyes" shit. Gag. His relationship with his wife was eye-rollingly pathetic. Oh, tell me more about how she was totally fine with you coming out of retirement to investigate a murder that mattered to HER - and even more recently after heart surgery... but NOW that she's your wife and the mother of your god-eyed baby, she's gone all mother hen about you working THIS case, clucking about how dangerous it is, and how scared she is, and blah blah blah. Stereotypical "concerned wife" bullshit, and irritating as hell.
And ugh - Tweedle McDee correcting his 10? 12? year old step-son Raymond when he said "yeah" with "You mean 'yes'?" every time made me want to stab him in the face. Dude, don't be a dick. He's a kid, and you're a fucking stick in the mud. Get over yourself.
Ugh... so much to dislike in this book. I sincerely hope this is the last I ever see of Troopy McCrawdad.
The ONLY saving grace to this book was that Bosch was in it. In all the ways that Typo McSnooze failed as a character, Bosch doesn't. He's got a supporting role in this book, but his sections were the highlight of the story for me. I love his nuance, I feel like I get his jadedness, and identify with his disgust with a system that fails in its duty to carry out fair and blind justice more often than not. I understand him, I think. And I root for him. Even when he fucks up, badly, I still feel like he's on the right side of things, and I can understand why he does what he does, even if I can't condone it.
So, Bosch is why this is getting 2 stars instead of an otherwise well-earned 1 star.
And now, back to our regularly scheduled Bosch series... Please? :D
September 10, 2021
This 9th book in the 'Bosch Universe' pairs two popular Michael Connelly characters: Harry Bosch and Terry McCaleb. The book can be read as a standalone.
*****
Harry Bosch is a detective in the Los Angeles Police Department who almost always closes his cases, but is usually on the wrong side of his superiors.
Terry McCaleb is a former FBI profiler who - after a heart transplant - moved to Catalina Island with his wife, stepson, and baby girl. Terry now runs a charter fishing business and tries to avoid stress.
As the story opens Terry is contacted by Sheriff's Deputy Jaye Winston, who asks him to have a quick look at the file of a puzzling murder case. The victim is an alleged killer named Edward Gunn, who was trussed up and murdered in a horrific fashion. Terry is reluctant to get involved - and strongly discouraged by his wife - but is drawn into the investigation anyway.
In the meantime, Harry Bosch is the main witness at the murder trial of David Storey, a Hollywood director accused of murdering a young woman. In court Harry describes the evidence against Storey AND says that - when no one else was around - Storey admitted he killed the girl and boasted he'd get away with it.
A scandal involving Harry would negate his testimony against Storey, and it looks like one is about to break thanks to Terry McCaleb. When Terry studies the scene-of-crime photos in the Edward Gunn murder file he observes deliberate symbols that remind him of a painting by 17th century Dutch artist Hieronymus Bosch, called 'The Garden of Earthly Delights.'
The Garden of Earthly Delights
As it happens Hieronymus Bosch happens to be Harry's given name, and Terry puts two and two together to make five. He tells Deputy Winston he thinks Bosch killed the trussed up victim. Oh no.....say it ain't so!! 😕
As things play out Harry's old partner Kizmin Rider is tricked into talking about him; information is leaked to reporter Jack McAvoy; Terry's life is endangered; and surprising secrets come to light.
A good deal of the novel is composed of courtroom scenes, with witnesses being questioned and cross-examined, lawyers maneuvering to influence the jury, and so on. Courtroom drama is one of Connelly's favorite tropes, and I always enjoy it, but he goes a bit overboard in this book.....and it slows down the story.
Still, I'd recommend the book to mystery readers, especially Harry Bosch fans.
You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot....
November 13, 2024
5★
“As he looked down at the murder book in his hands he felt a sharp thrill as well as the familiar rising of dread and guilt. McCaleb knew it was time to go back to the darkness. To explore it and know it. To find his way through it. He nodded, though he was alone now. It was in acknowledgment that he had waited a long time for this moment.”
Ah, back in the safe hands of Michael Connelly with Harry Bosch. Oh, wait. This is Terry McCaleb, isn’t it? Yes, a retired detective with a new heart and a new baby. He lives on a quiet island and runs a charter fishing business with a partner. Excellent for recovery.
So what’s he doing with a murder book? He was at home, on the island, sitting on the back deck of his house with Graciela and baby Cielo, looking out over the bay, when someone appeared driving a rented golf cart up the steep hill to their house. It really is a quietly isolated place.
“Sheriff’s detective Jaye Winston smiled when she saw the child in his arms. It was genuine, but at the same time it was the distracted smile of someone who wasn’t there to admire a new baby. McCaleb knew the thick green binder she carried in one hand and the videocassette in the other meant Winston was there on business. Death business.”
His wife and baby make themselves scarce and McCaleb waits for an explanation. She has brought a green binder of information – the murder book – and a video. She tells him she thinks it might be a serial killer, in which case she needs to hurry, and McCaleb is the best profiler she knows. She needs him.
“‘When they took out your heart, they didn’t take out what makes you tick, know what I mean?’”
He knows, and now he’s reading through the evidence and viewing the tape and completely hooked – of course. But what about Bosch?
Bosch is completely immersed as part of the prosecution of a case against a particularly influential, arrogant man, who sits and sketches during his trial while photos of the murder scene of a beautiful, strangled young woman are shown to the jury and many onlookers. This is West Hollywood, and this is another O.J.-type trial.
The connection with McCaleb (although they’ve met before) is that the victim in McCaleb’s murder case was the nasty perpetrator from a previous Bosch case, but the guy wasn’t convicted, and Bosch has been bitter about it ever since. It is known that he keeps track of the guy.
This is two excellent stories in one: Bosch for the prosecution against David Storey, whose trial is being widely televised, putting Bosch in the public eye; then Bosch becoming a possible – even, leading – suspect in McCaleb’s case.
As always, while the crimes and investigations are detailed and interesting, it’s the people and what Connelly reveals about their characters – shortcomings, sacrifices, and heroics – that stand out. The crimes are heinous, but he doesn’t dwell on the grisly blood and guts other than to make it clear what’s happened.
Such a good series!
Below are my reviews of the earlier Harry Bosch books.
(#1) My review of The Black Echo
(#2) My review of The Black Ice
(#3) My review of The Concrete Blonde
(#4) My review of The Last Coyote
(#5) My review of Trunk Music
(#6) My review of Angels Flight
“As he looked down at the murder book in his hands he felt a sharp thrill as well as the familiar rising of dread and guilt. McCaleb knew it was time to go back to the darkness. To explore it and know it. To find his way through it. He nodded, though he was alone now. It was in acknowledgment that he had waited a long time for this moment.”
Ah, back in the safe hands of Michael Connelly with Harry Bosch. Oh, wait. This is Terry McCaleb, isn’t it? Yes, a retired detective with a new heart and a new baby. He lives on a quiet island and runs a charter fishing business with a partner. Excellent for recovery.
So what’s he doing with a murder book? He was at home, on the island, sitting on the back deck of his house with Graciela and baby Cielo, looking out over the bay, when someone appeared driving a rented golf cart up the steep hill to their house. It really is a quietly isolated place.
“Sheriff’s detective Jaye Winston smiled when she saw the child in his arms. It was genuine, but at the same time it was the distracted smile of someone who wasn’t there to admire a new baby. McCaleb knew the thick green binder she carried in one hand and the videocassette in the other meant Winston was there on business. Death business.”
His wife and baby make themselves scarce and McCaleb waits for an explanation. She has brought a green binder of information – the murder book – and a video. She tells him she thinks it might be a serial killer, in which case she needs to hurry, and McCaleb is the best profiler she knows. She needs him.
“‘When they took out your heart, they didn’t take out what makes you tick, know what I mean?’”
He knows, and now he’s reading through the evidence and viewing the tape and completely hooked – of course. But what about Bosch?
Bosch is completely immersed as part of the prosecution of a case against a particularly influential, arrogant man, who sits and sketches during his trial while photos of the murder scene of a beautiful, strangled young woman are shown to the jury and many onlookers. This is West Hollywood, and this is another O.J.-type trial.
The connection with McCaleb (although they’ve met before) is that the victim in McCaleb’s murder case was the nasty perpetrator from a previous Bosch case, but the guy wasn’t convicted, and Bosch has been bitter about it ever since. It is known that he keeps track of the guy.
This is two excellent stories in one: Bosch for the prosecution against David Storey, whose trial is being widely televised, putting Bosch in the public eye; then Bosch becoming a possible – even, leading – suspect in McCaleb’s case.
As always, while the crimes and investigations are detailed and interesting, it’s the people and what Connelly reveals about their characters – shortcomings, sacrifices, and heroics – that stand out. The crimes are heinous, but he doesn’t dwell on the grisly blood and guts other than to make it clear what’s happened.
Such a good series!
Below are my reviews of the earlier Harry Bosch books.
(#1) My review of The Black Echo
(#2) My review of The Black Ice
(#3) My review of The Concrete Blonde
(#4) My review of The Last Coyote
(#5) My review of Trunk Music
(#6) My review of Angels Flight
May 27, 2022
4/5 Estrellas
Nos adentramos en la parte más oscura de Harry Bosch. ¿Después de tanto tiempo luchando contra el crimen, se habrá pasado al lado oscuro nuestro detective? ¿Habrá sucumbido a sus demonios? ¿Habrá decidido utilizar la guerra sucia para combatir a sus enemigos?
Embarcado en un importante y mediático juicio contra un conocido cineasta, las alarmas y los indicios contra Harry empiezan a saltar. El encargado de desvelarlos será uno de los personajes importantes que irá apareciendo en distintos libros del autor a lo largo de los años, el ex-agente del FBI, Terry McCaleb. Antiguo compañero y porque no, amigo, de Harry, se embarca en una complicada investigación a título personal (está retirado), donde las cosas no son lo que parecen....o si. Tendréis que leerlo y sacar vuestras propias conclusiones.
Rigor judicial, más que policial, en esta entrega. Trama equilibrada y bien hilvanada, con su dosis de incertidumbre final. Quizá le falta un poco de chispa en algunos momentos, aunque yo, personalmente, no necesito grandes giros para engancharme a la historia. Sólido y fiable Connelly, no defrauda. Seguiremos con él, poco a poco.
Nos adentramos en la parte más oscura de Harry Bosch. ¿Después de tanto tiempo luchando contra el crimen, se habrá pasado al lado oscuro nuestro detective? ¿Habrá sucumbido a sus demonios? ¿Habrá decidido utilizar la guerra sucia para combatir a sus enemigos?
Embarcado en un importante y mediático juicio contra un conocido cineasta, las alarmas y los indicios contra Harry empiezan a saltar. El encargado de desvelarlos será uno de los personajes importantes que irá apareciendo en distintos libros del autor a lo largo de los años, el ex-agente del FBI, Terry McCaleb. Antiguo compañero y porque no, amigo, de Harry, se embarca en una complicada investigación a título personal (está retirado), donde las cosas no son lo que parecen....o si. Tendréis que leerlo y sacar vuestras propias conclusiones.
Rigor judicial, más que policial, en esta entrega. Trama equilibrada y bien hilvanada, con su dosis de incertidumbre final. Quizá le falta un poco de chispa en algunos momentos, aunque yo, personalmente, no necesito grandes giros para engancharme a la historia. Sólido y fiable Connelly, no defrauda. Seguiremos con él, poco a poco.
August 26, 2025
Bosch, as a man, grows ever deeper and darker!
When the LAPD run into a brick wall solving a bizarre murder, sheriff's detective, Jay Winston, asks her friend Terry McCaleb, a retired FBI agent recently recovered from a heart transplant, to help them out by polishing up his psychological profiling skills and putting them back to work on their stalled case. Edward Gunn, a small-time LA hood involved with the murder of a prostitute was himself found tied, gagged and strangled. McCaleb is convinced that the key to finding Gunn's murderer rests with two bizarre clues - the statue of an owl found in the room with Gunn and the inscription on the tape binding his mouth, "Cave Cave Deus Videt" or "Beware, Beware, God Sees" translated from a version of Latin spoken around the time of the Renaissance.
McCaleb started his search for details on Gunn's murder with an interview of detective Harry Bosch. Bosch, who had been assigned the case of the prostitute's murder and was certain that Gunn had been the killer, was apparently one of the last people to see Gunn alive. But Bosch can only find time to give McCaleb the most cursory of interviews. His time and his mind are fully occupied as the star witness in the very high profile prosecution of David Storey. Storey, a fabulously wealthy Hollywood producer, is on trial for the sex slaying of a young actress. He's alleged to have strangled her during a bout of rough sex and then staged the scene to make her death look like a case of accidental auto-erotic asphyxia.
It's that bizarre owl that's the centerpiece of McCaleb's investigative efforts. Author Connelly leads McCaleb (and this fascinated reader) on a magnificent journey through "A Garden of Earthly Delights", as it were - a fabulously informative sidebar on the paintings of sixteenth century Dutch Renaissance painter, Hieronymus Bosch. It isn't long before McCaleb and Winston have Harry Bosch in their sights as their sole suspect in Gunn's murder. They've got it figured as Bosch meting out frontier justice because he couldn't corral Gunn within the framework of the legitimate legal system.
A DARKNESS MORE THAN NIGHT is unquestionably the darkest and most complex story yet in the ever growing Harry Bosch canon. Connelly skillfully weaves the story of Gunn's murder into the tale of David Storey's trial for murder and brings both stories to a superb conclusion. But for all the complexity and brilliance of the plot that Connelly has devised, it is really the growing, ever deepening and ever darkening character of Harry Bosch that takes centre stage in this particular play. From his earliest appearance in THE BLACK ECHO as a shell-shocked Vietnam War tunnel rat returning to an ungrateful country to his suspension for pushing his supervisor through the glass window of his office, Connelly continues to make Bosch an ever-deepening mystery. Maverick, loner, cowboy, sinner, saint, psycho ... all of the above? How are we to know?
A superb addition to the Harry Bosch series. Highly recommended.
Paul Weiss
When the LAPD run into a brick wall solving a bizarre murder, sheriff's detective, Jay Winston, asks her friend Terry McCaleb, a retired FBI agent recently recovered from a heart transplant, to help them out by polishing up his psychological profiling skills and putting them back to work on their stalled case. Edward Gunn, a small-time LA hood involved with the murder of a prostitute was himself found tied, gagged and strangled. McCaleb is convinced that the key to finding Gunn's murderer rests with two bizarre clues - the statue of an owl found in the room with Gunn and the inscription on the tape binding his mouth, "Cave Cave Deus Videt" or "Beware, Beware, God Sees" translated from a version of Latin spoken around the time of the Renaissance.
McCaleb started his search for details on Gunn's murder with an interview of detective Harry Bosch. Bosch, who had been assigned the case of the prostitute's murder and was certain that Gunn had been the killer, was apparently one of the last people to see Gunn alive. But Bosch can only find time to give McCaleb the most cursory of interviews. His time and his mind are fully occupied as the star witness in the very high profile prosecution of David Storey. Storey, a fabulously wealthy Hollywood producer, is on trial for the sex slaying of a young actress. He's alleged to have strangled her during a bout of rough sex and then staged the scene to make her death look like a case of accidental auto-erotic asphyxia.
It's that bizarre owl that's the centerpiece of McCaleb's investigative efforts. Author Connelly leads McCaleb (and this fascinated reader) on a magnificent journey through "A Garden of Earthly Delights", as it were - a fabulously informative sidebar on the paintings of sixteenth century Dutch Renaissance painter, Hieronymus Bosch. It isn't long before McCaleb and Winston have Harry Bosch in their sights as their sole suspect in Gunn's murder. They've got it figured as Bosch meting out frontier justice because he couldn't corral Gunn within the framework of the legitimate legal system.
A DARKNESS MORE THAN NIGHT is unquestionably the darkest and most complex story yet in the ever growing Harry Bosch canon. Connelly skillfully weaves the story of Gunn's murder into the tale of David Storey's trial for murder and brings both stories to a superb conclusion. But for all the complexity and brilliance of the plot that Connelly has devised, it is really the growing, ever deepening and ever darkening character of Harry Bosch that takes centre stage in this particular play. From his earliest appearance in THE BLACK ECHO as a shell-shocked Vietnam War tunnel rat returning to an ungrateful country to his suspension for pushing his supervisor through the glass window of his office, Connelly continues to make Bosch an ever-deepening mystery. Maverick, loner, cowboy, sinner, saint, psycho ... all of the above? How are we to know?
A superb addition to the Harry Bosch series. Highly recommended.
Paul Weiss
August 13, 2024
“The streets were dark with something more than night.” – Raymond Chandler, Author, 1950
Carching up…
I am re-visiting an old novel I read quite some time ago of Connelly’s and now bringing my review to Goodreads.
It is 2001. A dark case calls for the return of profiler, Terry McCaleb, first seen in Blood Work, who has created a new life for himself. We will also see LA Homicide Detective Harry Bosch. McCaleb and Bosch have been good friends for about 12 years.
This case is complicated and intriguing to McCaleb, and in many ways, it appears to implicate Bosch. Especially since the victim and Bosch had an antagonistic past relationship.
Could Bosch have been responsible for his death?
In the meantime, Bosch, is currently involved in a high-profile murder trial. He is a principal witness under attack. When he realizes that he is being suspected of murder by McCaleb, in the case he has been working, Bosch challenges him with the statement, “you missed something.” But what?
Does someone have something against Bosch? And why?
“Bosch didn’t smile. He didn’t blink. He didn’t do anything but hold the stare.”
In true fashion it typically comes down to the Bosch stare. Connelly provides an excellent police procedural and courtroom drama that keeps pages turning at a classic thrilling pace. Reminding readers not only of early Bosch but of earlier characters we have come to appreciate, too.
Carching up…
I am re-visiting an old novel I read quite some time ago of Connelly’s and now bringing my review to Goodreads.
It is 2001. A dark case calls for the return of profiler, Terry McCaleb, first seen in Blood Work, who has created a new life for himself. We will also see LA Homicide Detective Harry Bosch. McCaleb and Bosch have been good friends for about 12 years.
This case is complicated and intriguing to McCaleb, and in many ways, it appears to implicate Bosch. Especially since the victim and Bosch had an antagonistic past relationship.
Could Bosch have been responsible for his death?
In the meantime, Bosch, is currently involved in a high-profile murder trial. He is a principal witness under attack. When he realizes that he is being suspected of murder by McCaleb, in the case he has been working, Bosch challenges him with the statement, “you missed something.” But what?
Does someone have something against Bosch? And why?
“Bosch didn’t smile. He didn’t blink. He didn’t do anything but hold the stare.”
In true fashion it typically comes down to the Bosch stare. Connelly provides an excellent police procedural and courtroom drama that keeps pages turning at a classic thrilling pace. Reminding readers not only of early Bosch but of earlier characters we have come to appreciate, too.
August 14, 2016
You get two character focuses in one in this story. It really serves you well to have read Blood Work first to get a good sense of Terry McCaleb. I believe it made a difference in my enjoyment. While this is the 7th book in the Harry Bosch series, it's the 8th in that universe and the second in the Terry McCaleb series.
For a large part of the story, McCaleb and Bosch are operating independently until their worlds connect. Terry believes Harry is behind the murder of Edward Gunn because aspects of the crime scene seem to provide a connection. What makes this story compelling are the contrasts of the investigative styles of these two men. Both have really good instincts but their approaches couldn't be more different.
I wasn't all that happy with the narrator of the story, particularly his interpretation of Harry. In all fairness, I'm an ingrained Dick Hill fan so he had a steep hill to climb. Otherwise it was okay but I'm glad to see a change with the next book.
This is another fascinating chapter of the Harry Bosch world with the added bonus of Terry McCaleb. While the ending left me a bit adrift, it seemed fitting for both men.
For a large part of the story, McCaleb and Bosch are operating independently until their worlds connect. Terry believes Harry is behind the murder of Edward Gunn because aspects of the crime scene seem to provide a connection. What makes this story compelling are the contrasts of the investigative styles of these two men. Both have really good instincts but their approaches couldn't be more different.
I wasn't all that happy with the narrator of the story, particularly his interpretation of Harry. In all fairness, I'm an ingrained Dick Hill fan so he had a steep hill to climb. Otherwise it was okay but I'm glad to see a change with the next book.
This is another fascinating chapter of the Harry Bosch world with the added bonus of Terry McCaleb. While the ending left me a bit adrift, it seemed fitting for both men.
September 24, 2024
My 109th read of the year. Another Harry Bosch that had been on the Amazon tv series. Super read. Harry profiled by an ex FBI profiler Terry McCabe as a possible murder suspect. Hollywood film producer in dock for murder, Owls and a lot of art history of Bosch the painter. What more could you ask for? Also a good memory of seeing Bosch’s paintings at the Prado.
Luckily I have many more Harry Bosch’s to read in 2022👍
Luckily I have many more Harry Bosch’s to read in 2022👍
December 11, 2023
Actual rating is 3.5 stars.
This is part of a series but can be read as a stand alone. In this one a suspect in a crime from years ago is found murdered. Terry McCaleb is called in to profile the case and he zeroes in on Harry Bosch.
I had a hard time getting into this book at first. The reason is that I would argue that this is a McCaleb book instead of a Bosch book. McCaleb has a previous book written from this author. At the beginning I thought the author was just trying to introduce this character to readers so we would seek out the other book. But slowly this book finally won me over. I do applaud the author for attempting to make our hero the culprit even if we knew there was no way this was true. While the investigation is going on Bosch is a witness in a court case. This is the secondary plot. I liked this plot but it was not overly enthralling. I read these books for more of the thrill and the police investigation and not the court drama. Eventually these two plots intersect and when this happens I was engaged in this novel. The ending was terrific especially the exchange between the two characters.
This is one of the times when it is a story of two halves. The first half was not really doing it for me. We get the point of view of McCaleb and I kept on saying I am reading a Bosch book not a McCaleb book. I also don't think McCaleb is the most enthralling character and I will not seek out his book. When the second half happens is when I was invested in the book. The tide turned towards the real culprit and that is when this book reminded me of why I am enjoying this series so much.
This is part of a series but can be read as a stand alone. In this one a suspect in a crime from years ago is found murdered. Terry McCaleb is called in to profile the case and he zeroes in on Harry Bosch.
I had a hard time getting into this book at first. The reason is that I would argue that this is a McCaleb book instead of a Bosch book. McCaleb has a previous book written from this author. At the beginning I thought the author was just trying to introduce this character to readers so we would seek out the other book. But slowly this book finally won me over. I do applaud the author for attempting to make our hero the culprit even if we knew there was no way this was true. While the investigation is going on Bosch is a witness in a court case. This is the secondary plot. I liked this plot but it was not overly enthralling. I read these books for more of the thrill and the police investigation and not the court drama. Eventually these two plots intersect and when this happens I was engaged in this novel. The ending was terrific especially the exchange between the two characters.
This is one of the times when it is a story of two halves. The first half was not really doing it for me. We get the point of view of McCaleb and I kept on saying I am reading a Bosch book not a McCaleb book. I also don't think McCaleb is the most enthralling character and I will not seek out his book. When the second half happens is when I was invested in the book. The tide turned towards the real culprit and that is when this book reminded me of why I am enjoying this series so much.
July 14, 2023
Not that crazy about the McCaleb character.
January 4, 2025
"A Darkness More Than Night" is Michael Connelly at the top of his game. It's his most suspenseful, entertaining, and philosophical book yet that I have read, and it pits Connelly's beloved police detective, Harry Bosch, in a fascinating new predicament: murder suspect.
Reprising his role from Connelly's previous novel "Blood Work" (one that I haven't read yet but saw the Clint Eastwood film adaptation), retired FBI profiler Terry McCaleb is asked to "consult" on the ghastly murder of an L.A. low-life, someone the world won't miss and that many people were glad to see dead. Unfortunately, the homicide detectives working the scene felt that the level of atrocity of the murder screams serial killer, and they want to stop the unsub from doing it again. Jaye Winston, the Sheriff's detective working the case, has a history with McCaleb and knows that he could offer some valuable insight.
Almost immediately, McCaleb strikes upon a clue that links one of his old friends from the L.A.P.D., Harry Bosch, who is busy playing witness for the prosecution against David Storey, a rich filmmaker accused of killing a young actress. During a candid and unrecorded conversation, Storey admitted to Bosch that he did it and that he was going to get away with it.
What follows is typical Connelly: a plot that is suspense-driven and full of twists and turns. Along with the pulse-pounding police procedural and action, there is the philosophical aspect, as McCaleb examines the dark psyche of his friend Bosch. Everyone knows Bosch has a dark side---they've all encountered it at least once---but could the very thing that drives Bosch to being an exceptional cop also turn him into an "avenging angel"-style serial murderer?
Readers will also enjoy the extended cameo of Jack McEvoy, Connelly's protagonist from his novel "The Poet", whose presence plays a significant role in this story.
Reprising his role from Connelly's previous novel "Blood Work" (one that I haven't read yet but saw the Clint Eastwood film adaptation), retired FBI profiler Terry McCaleb is asked to "consult" on the ghastly murder of an L.A. low-life, someone the world won't miss and that many people were glad to see dead. Unfortunately, the homicide detectives working the scene felt that the level of atrocity of the murder screams serial killer, and they want to stop the unsub from doing it again. Jaye Winston, the Sheriff's detective working the case, has a history with McCaleb and knows that he could offer some valuable insight.
Almost immediately, McCaleb strikes upon a clue that links one of his old friends from the L.A.P.D., Harry Bosch, who is busy playing witness for the prosecution against David Storey, a rich filmmaker accused of killing a young actress. During a candid and unrecorded conversation, Storey admitted to Bosch that he did it and that he was going to get away with it.
What follows is typical Connelly: a plot that is suspense-driven and full of twists and turns. Along with the pulse-pounding police procedural and action, there is the philosophical aspect, as McCaleb examines the dark psyche of his friend Bosch. Everyone knows Bosch has a dark side---they've all encountered it at least once---but could the very thing that drives Bosch to being an exceptional cop also turn him into an "avenging angel"-style serial murderer?
Readers will also enjoy the extended cameo of Jack McEvoy, Connelly's protagonist from his novel "The Poet", whose presence plays a significant role in this story.
January 24, 2025
В този роман Конъли е събрал трима свои и мои любимци - Тери Маккейлъб, Хари Бош и Джак Макавой.
Бившият агент на ФБР Тери Маккейлъб се опитва да си изгради нормален живот след трансплантация на сърце и напускането на службите. Но не е лесно да загърбиш миналото и когато при бившия криминален профайлър идва за помощ полицайка със сложен случай на убийство с ритуални мотиви, той няма как да откаже. А всички улики водят към голямото зло…
Хари свири втора цигулка, но има голямо соло към края на книгата.
А Джак, Джак всички го използват, всеки за собствените си цели.
Отлична криминална история, препоръчвам!
Бившият агент на ФБР Тери Маккейлъб се опитва да си изгради нормален живот след трансплантация на сърце и напускането на службите. Но не е лесно да загърбиш миналото и когато при бившия криминален профайлър идва за помощ полицайка със сложен случай на убийство с ритуални мотиви, той няма как да откаже. А всички улики водят към голямото зло…
Хари свири втора цигулка, но има голямо соло към края на книгата.
А Джак, Джак всички го използват, всеки за собствените си цели.
Отлична криминална история, препоръчвам!
May 21, 2016
I'm close to giving this 5 stars. It was a perfect storm in so many ways & it makes me very glad that I read the books in published order, not by series. Not only does Connelly bring many of his characters together, but he does it in such a perfect, real way. We start off following Terry McCaleb & see a lot of Harry Bosch. Jack McEvoy has a small, but good part. Cassie Black doesn't make an appearance, but there is a nod to her as well.
The plot was as twisty as ever, but the end... wow. Just wow. I like Bosch even better now. He's a miserable SOB in a lot of ways, but he's a smart one.
The plot was as twisty as ever, but the end... wow. Just wow. I like Bosch even better now. He's a miserable SOB in a lot of ways, but he's a smart one.
September 17, 2025
An entertaining trial was worked into the novel along with a connected murder investigation. But the Rules of Evidence seem to be nonexistent in this genre. Detective Harry Bosch testified to practically the whole prosecution’s case, including the coroner’s conclusions as to the cause of death as well as his partner’s observations without objection.
October 8, 2015
8.5/10
Surprise, surprise, another top notch book by Michael Connolly. Man, is this guy predictable. I bet he sits there thinking about writing a terrible book and then just laughs it off as it’s easier to come up with a stonking effort. No change with this one. There was a slim hope for me at the start though with a split narrative and one of the leads being from the only Connolly book I have disliked (“Blood Work”). Then Connolly ramps things up to 11 and pushes what could have been a tedious read into the usual top notch affair.
As this is a Bosch novel things don’t really get going until Bosch turns up, but do they get turned up! In quite a role reversal to the usual Bosch novels, Bosch is on the back foot and not the lead investigator. He’s a star witness at a trial and is actually being investigated by an ex-FBI agent after some murders point suspiciously towards Harry Bosch and a hidden vigilante.
Connolly has to be the best writer of courtroom scenes (I’d be happy for any other recommendations)? Whenever Bosch or Haller are in the courtroom I could literally read from start to finish. The tension and excitement are really ramped up and that is exactly what happens here. All the courtroom scenes make up for the slow start in this one.
Not one to start the series off with but definitely one to advance it. I’m glad I read the standalone “Blood Work” before reading this (even if I disliked it) as the main characters from that are in this one and there are some things that happen in that which influence this book. Not essentially, but advisory. Yet again though, Connolly reminds me why he is one of my top “go to” authors with a great novel. Looking forward to the next one.
If you like this try: “Lincoln Lawyer” by Michael Connolly
Surprise, surprise, another top notch book by Michael Connolly. Man, is this guy predictable. I bet he sits there thinking about writing a terrible book and then just laughs it off as it’s easier to come up with a stonking effort. No change with this one. There was a slim hope for me at the start though with a split narrative and one of the leads being from the only Connolly book I have disliked (“Blood Work”). Then Connolly ramps things up to 11 and pushes what could have been a tedious read into the usual top notch affair.
As this is a Bosch novel things don’t really get going until Bosch turns up, but do they get turned up! In quite a role reversal to the usual Bosch novels, Bosch is on the back foot and not the lead investigator. He’s a star witness at a trial and is actually being investigated by an ex-FBI agent after some murders point suspiciously towards Harry Bosch and a hidden vigilante.
Connolly has to be the best writer of courtroom scenes (I’d be happy for any other recommendations)? Whenever Bosch or Haller are in the courtroom I could literally read from start to finish. The tension and excitement are really ramped up and that is exactly what happens here. All the courtroom scenes make up for the slow start in this one.
Not one to start the series off with but definitely one to advance it. I’m glad I read the standalone “Blood Work” before reading this (even if I disliked it) as the main characters from that are in this one and there are some things that happen in that which influence this book. Not essentially, but advisory. Yet again though, Connolly reminds me why he is one of my top “go to” authors with a great novel. Looking forward to the next one.
If you like this try: “Lincoln Lawyer” by Michael Connolly
March 12, 2023
I fell asleep while listening and was woken up by suspenseful music, which was a bit disorientating and creepy! This was a download via Overdrive, perhaps the music is a signal for the end of the disc on the original CD disc version, as the music appeared at intervals.
I was surprised and delighted by the inclusion of the art of Hieronymus Bosch, which I am familiar with through art class. I also happen to own a jigsaw puzzle version of The Garden of Earthly Delights, one of Bosch's paintings that is referred to in this book!
As well as art, religion also appears in this volume and one passage that chilled me is:
"God's work was never done. When a killer was out there using His name as part of the imprint of his crime there often meant there would be more crime. It was said in the bureau profiling offices that God's killers never stopped of their own volition. They had to be stopped."
It was interesting to read about how in the past the bureau and to an extent the police department were divided into two groups when officers chose to join a church to impress their deputy chief, a lay preacher, in the hopes of increasing their odds of promotion, or just receive better assignments. "It was like the saints and the sinners - two distinct groups. The born again and the born against."
Michael Connelly writes thoughtfully about homicide detectives that they "were usually of two kinds, those who saw their jobs as a skill or craft, and those who saw it as a mission in life."
A discourse follows on what motivates homicide detectives: "For some it would seem as almost a game to prove they were better, smarter, more cunning than their quarry. Others saw themselves as being speakers for the dead. There was a sacred bond cast between victim and cop that formed at the crime scene and could not be severed."
The conclusion is that they make the best, most committed detectives leaving no stone unturned and overcoming obstacles along the way, as they seek to discover the perpetrators of the cruelest crimes. They walk a tightrope over the dark abyss.
This is a suspenseful, thoughtful and satisfying read.
I was surprised and delighted by the inclusion of the art of Hieronymus Bosch, which I am familiar with through art class. I also happen to own a jigsaw puzzle version of The Garden of Earthly Delights, one of Bosch's paintings that is referred to in this book!
As well as art, religion also appears in this volume and one passage that chilled me is:
"God's work was never done. When a killer was out there using His name as part of the imprint of his crime there often meant there would be more crime. It was said in the bureau profiling offices that God's killers never stopped of their own volition. They had to be stopped."
It was interesting to read about how in the past the bureau and to an extent the police department were divided into two groups when officers chose to join a church to impress their deputy chief, a lay preacher, in the hopes of increasing their odds of promotion, or just receive better assignments. "It was like the saints and the sinners - two distinct groups. The born again and the born against."
Michael Connelly writes thoughtfully about homicide detectives that they "were usually of two kinds, those who saw their jobs as a skill or craft, and those who saw it as a mission in life."
A discourse follows on what motivates homicide detectives: "For some it would seem as almost a game to prove they were better, smarter, more cunning than their quarry. Others saw themselves as being speakers for the dead. There was a sacred bond cast between victim and cop that formed at the crime scene and could not be severed."
The conclusion is that they make the best, most committed detectives leaving no stone unturned and overcoming obstacles along the way, as they seek to discover the perpetrators of the cruelest crimes. They walk a tightrope over the dark abyss.
This is a suspenseful, thoughtful and satisfying read.
July 21, 2017
A Darkness More Than Light is Connelly’s seventh Harry Bosch novel, first published in 2001. It actually brings together a number of Connelly’s recurring characters. In addition to Homicide Detective Bosch, it features FBI profiler Terry McCaleb, and newspaperman Jack McEvoy. I listened to the audio version. Although the entire Bosch series is terrific, this book felt a bit more disjointed than some of the others and perhaps it was the flipping back and forth between Bosch and McCaleb’s viewpoints that took away some of the gusto of this book.
Here, McCaleb is a retired FBI profiler, living an idyllic life on Catalina Island with his wife and newborn daughter. Occasionally, his old contacts bring him cases and her Deputy Winston brings him a file with clues that point to Harry Bosch, particularly a signature at the murder of the painter Hieronymus Bosch. Bosch meanwhile is working on an unrelated case of a high-profile Hollywood celebrity being tried for a murder where the victim’s body was set up to look like auto- asphysixiation.
The book flips back and forth between the two stories until, of course, at some point, they coalesce. The shocking part of the book is McCaleb suspecting Bosch of losing it and turning to the dark side, committing murder of a man Bosch thought got away with it years earlier and has been following ever since.\
Not the best of the Bosch series, but still, as they all are, a worthwhile read (or listen). Connelly combines police investigative work with courtroom scenes and really does a great job of portraying both.
Here, McCaleb is a retired FBI profiler, living an idyllic life on Catalina Island with his wife and newborn daughter. Occasionally, his old contacts bring him cases and her Deputy Winston brings him a file with clues that point to Harry Bosch, particularly a signature at the murder of the painter Hieronymus Bosch. Bosch meanwhile is working on an unrelated case of a high-profile Hollywood celebrity being tried for a murder where the victim’s body was set up to look like auto- asphysixiation.
The book flips back and forth between the two stories until, of course, at some point, they coalesce. The shocking part of the book is McCaleb suspecting Bosch of losing it and turning to the dark side, committing murder of a man Bosch thought got away with it years earlier and has been following ever since.\
Not the best of the Bosch series, but still, as they all are, a worthwhile read (or listen). Connelly combines police investigative work with courtroom scenes and really does a great job of portraying both.
August 26, 2019
** Continuing my read and review of Michael Connelly’s Detective Bosch series **
Connelly’s 10th book and 7th outing with Bosch - “A Darkness More than Light” - was published back in 2001 before cell-phones and social media played a key role in police work. Detective Hieronymus “Harry” Bosch is a Vietnam war veteran and a twenty-year police officer serving in the Los Angeles, California police department. Harry was previously a star in the Robbery/Homicide division, working out of the LA city headquarters. However, Harry’s bad habit of fighting the formal structure of the police department and especially those in leadership positions has had him demoted to the Hollywood detective squad.
Although this book is labeled a “Bosch” book, that is not completely true. It has dual protagonists. This time out Harry shares the stage with Terry McCaleb, ex-FBI profiler, and the lead character in Connelly’s previous book, “Blood Work”. Terry and Graciela Rivers, whose sister provided him with his heart replacement, have married. They have a baby daughter, Cielo, and Terry runs a fishing charter off Catalina island.
The book begins with sheriff's deputy, Jaye Winston, bringing Terry a current murder case file that scares her deeply. It involves a gruesome murder with bizarre and dark artistic elements that makes her think a serial killer may be at work. Jaye asks Terry to look over the case file and let her know his thoughts because the police are getting nowhere on it. However, the trouble begins after Terry performs his analysis and the clues point him towards a certain police officer that he knows from a previous investigation before retiring – LAPD’s own Harry Bosch.
As for Harry, he is in the middle of a criminal trial involving an arrogant movie director charged with murdering an actress during sex, and then staging her death afterwards to make it look like a suicide. While Terry investigates Bosch for murder, Harry is busy testifying in court as the investigation team’s leading officer in a highly public case that includes the full frenzy of the Hollywood media following his every move. One of those media members includes, Jack McEvoy, the primary character from another prior Connelly novel, “The Poet.” Jack spends time with both Harry and Terry trying to get the inside scoop on a criminal story.
As Terry’s investigation into Bosch builds into an elaborate situation using historical art and ritualistic murder, uncovered clues seem to mysteriously overlap in strange ways with Bosch’s own movie director court case. As another surprising revelation unfolds, the two cases begin to pull McCaleb and Bosch into each other’s crosshairs in a dangerous game of cat and mouse and life and death.
Like most of Connelly’s previous books, this one takes place over a period of about a week or so. The two primary plotlines – McCaleb’s murder investigation and Bosch’s court trial – are both told in a fast-paced, rhythmic style that grabs you from the beginning and demands no less than your full attention. Connelly’s prior experience as a journalist feeds into his straight-forward cadence and style. There are no wasted words and his descriptions are crisp and fresh. Connelly moves back and forth between the two plots smoothly and effortlessly, making you feel like you are standing there right next to Harry and Terry each step of the way. You can smell Harry’s menthol cigarettes and taste Terry’s 27 pills being swallowed twice a day.
I especially enjoyed the interactions between Harry Bosch and Terry McCaleb. It would have been easy for Connelly to make them a super-team, working together like Batman and Superman to rid Los Angeles of evil psycho serial killers. They could have been the best of partners. However, Connelly truly understands what drives and motivates these two characters, including the inner-strengths that drive them to deal with the darkness of chasing killers and weaknesses that keep them from being real team players. Bosch and McCaleb are independent spirits, who by nature, must work alone to do what they do best. It is what creates great conflict between them and Connelly knows just how best to bring them together, using their differing personal philosophies to drive conflict between their methodologies and approaches.
As I continually describe in my Connelly related reviews, there are so many strengths that he displays as a writer. He is a master of plotting, characters, and setting – mixing each one together in a winning synergistic style of his own. Connelly’s plotting is tighter than a steel drum. He unfolds McCaleb’s investigation and Bosh’s court case in a methodical, no-nonsense, just the facts Mam, focus that demands and keeps our full attention, and catches us off-guard with well-placed twists and turns along the way. In addition, he uses the greater Los Angeles setting and locations to breathe vibrant life and energy into his story, adding an extra depth to the story.
Overall, Connelly delivers another splendid winner. He uses this book to bring together several returning characters in a creative and conflict filled thriller that consistently delivers an exceptional reading experience. It is incredible to me that somehow each of his novels (even without Bosch) continue to get better and raise the bar of the mystery / detective / crime fiction genre.
For me, it is really beginning to be hard to pick one of his books over another. They are all really that good. I cannot wait to open the cover of the next one and start reading again…
Connelly’s 10th book and 7th outing with Bosch - “A Darkness More than Light” - was published back in 2001 before cell-phones and social media played a key role in police work. Detective Hieronymus “Harry” Bosch is a Vietnam war veteran and a twenty-year police officer serving in the Los Angeles, California police department. Harry was previously a star in the Robbery/Homicide division, working out of the LA city headquarters. However, Harry’s bad habit of fighting the formal structure of the police department and especially those in leadership positions has had him demoted to the Hollywood detective squad.
Although this book is labeled a “Bosch” book, that is not completely true. It has dual protagonists. This time out Harry shares the stage with Terry McCaleb, ex-FBI profiler, and the lead character in Connelly’s previous book, “Blood Work”. Terry and Graciela Rivers, whose sister provided him with his heart replacement, have married. They have a baby daughter, Cielo, and Terry runs a fishing charter off Catalina island.
The book begins with sheriff's deputy, Jaye Winston, bringing Terry a current murder case file that scares her deeply. It involves a gruesome murder with bizarre and dark artistic elements that makes her think a serial killer may be at work. Jaye asks Terry to look over the case file and let her know his thoughts because the police are getting nowhere on it. However, the trouble begins after Terry performs his analysis and the clues point him towards a certain police officer that he knows from a previous investigation before retiring – LAPD’s own Harry Bosch.
As for Harry, he is in the middle of a criminal trial involving an arrogant movie director charged with murdering an actress during sex, and then staging her death afterwards to make it look like a suicide. While Terry investigates Bosch for murder, Harry is busy testifying in court as the investigation team’s leading officer in a highly public case that includes the full frenzy of the Hollywood media following his every move. One of those media members includes, Jack McEvoy, the primary character from another prior Connelly novel, “The Poet.” Jack spends time with both Harry and Terry trying to get the inside scoop on a criminal story.
As Terry’s investigation into Bosch builds into an elaborate situation using historical art and ritualistic murder, uncovered clues seem to mysteriously overlap in strange ways with Bosch’s own movie director court case. As another surprising revelation unfolds, the two cases begin to pull McCaleb and Bosch into each other’s crosshairs in a dangerous game of cat and mouse and life and death.
Like most of Connelly’s previous books, this one takes place over a period of about a week or so. The two primary plotlines – McCaleb’s murder investigation and Bosch’s court trial – are both told in a fast-paced, rhythmic style that grabs you from the beginning and demands no less than your full attention. Connelly’s prior experience as a journalist feeds into his straight-forward cadence and style. There are no wasted words and his descriptions are crisp and fresh. Connelly moves back and forth between the two plots smoothly and effortlessly, making you feel like you are standing there right next to Harry and Terry each step of the way. You can smell Harry’s menthol cigarettes and taste Terry’s 27 pills being swallowed twice a day.
I especially enjoyed the interactions between Harry Bosch and Terry McCaleb. It would have been easy for Connelly to make them a super-team, working together like Batman and Superman to rid Los Angeles of evil psycho serial killers. They could have been the best of partners. However, Connelly truly understands what drives and motivates these two characters, including the inner-strengths that drive them to deal with the darkness of chasing killers and weaknesses that keep them from being real team players. Bosch and McCaleb are independent spirits, who by nature, must work alone to do what they do best. It is what creates great conflict between them and Connelly knows just how best to bring them together, using their differing personal philosophies to drive conflict between their methodologies and approaches.
As I continually describe in my Connelly related reviews, there are so many strengths that he displays as a writer. He is a master of plotting, characters, and setting – mixing each one together in a winning synergistic style of his own. Connelly’s plotting is tighter than a steel drum. He unfolds McCaleb’s investigation and Bosh’s court case in a methodical, no-nonsense, just the facts Mam, focus that demands and keeps our full attention, and catches us off-guard with well-placed twists and turns along the way. In addition, he uses the greater Los Angeles setting and locations to breathe vibrant life and energy into his story, adding an extra depth to the story.
Overall, Connelly delivers another splendid winner. He uses this book to bring together several returning characters in a creative and conflict filled thriller that consistently delivers an exceptional reading experience. It is incredible to me that somehow each of his novels (even without Bosch) continue to get better and raise the bar of the mystery / detective / crime fiction genre.
For me, it is really beginning to be hard to pick one of his books over another. They are all really that good. I cannot wait to open the cover of the next one and start reading again…
December 9, 2018
I loved A Darkness More Than Night.
First off, it is narrated mostly from Terry McCaleb's perspective. This change in perspective did a lot to shake the slightly monotonous feeling I was getting from binge reading Harry Bosch.
Secondly, Harry Bosch comes across as the antagonist for the majority of the story. This, again, helped in making the story much more interesting, especially seeing Bosch from a different perspective. In fact, I think this might be the first story where the book is actually way better than the prime video series. The video series shows us what Bosch is up to right from the beginning while the book keeps this as a mystery right till the end.
But, on the flip side, this is more of a Terry McCaleb novel than it is a Harry Bosch. At best, it is equal billing.
First off, it is narrated mostly from Terry McCaleb's perspective. This change in perspective did a lot to shake the slightly monotonous feeling I was getting from binge reading Harry Bosch.
Secondly, Harry Bosch comes across as the antagonist for the majority of the story. This, again, helped in making the story much more interesting, especially seeing Bosch from a different perspective. In fact, I think this might be the first story where the book is actually way better than the prime video series. The video series shows us what Bosch is up to right from the beginning while the book keeps this as a mystery right till the end.
But, on the flip side, this is more of a Terry McCaleb novel than it is a Harry Bosch. At best, it is equal billing.
June 2, 2024
Interesting concept. A Harry Bosch book where Harry isn’t the main character. Still, a solid mystery and great crime procedural.
Unfortunately for me, this one was super close to the third season of Amazon’s Bosch series. Not nearly as suspenseful or fun to read when you know how it will end.
I did feel toward the end that Harry is heading to a cross roads. Maybe that’s why Connelly gives a view of him through the lens of another (albeit retired) cop.
(Reviewed 6/23/18)
PS— I went thru a major Bosch binge pre-Covid and then watched the (Amazon?) series… I was so frustrated by the blending of books that I couldn’t read them anymore… I gotta right that wrong soon!! 😎
Unfortunately for me, this one was super close to the third season of Amazon’s Bosch series. Not nearly as suspenseful or fun to read when you know how it will end.
I did feel toward the end that Harry is heading to a cross roads. Maybe that’s why Connelly gives a view of him through the lens of another (albeit retired) cop.
(Reviewed 6/23/18)
PS— I went thru a major Bosch binge pre-Covid and then watched the (Amazon?) series… I was so frustrated by the blending of books that I couldn’t read them anymore… I gotta right that wrong soon!! 😎
January 20, 2019
“The monster goes back into the darkness from which it came.”
This novel brings together three of Connelly's protagonists. Harry Bosch, Terry McCaleb (Blood Work),and Jack McEvoy (The Poet). McEvoy only has a few brief appearances in the story. The story opens with Bosch visiting a lowlife named Edward Gunn in jail. Bosch has a standing request in with all of the watch commanders ... whenever Gunn is picked up they are to call Bosch. He once arrested Gunn for the murder of a prostitute but Gunn was released on a technicality. Bosch hasn't forgotten it and can't let it go. It is New Year's Eve and Gunn is too drunk to even talk to. This encounter sets the stage for the interaction between Terry McCaleb and Harry Bosch that is the basis for the story to follow.
Harry is assisting the prosecution in a high-profile Hollywood murder trial. A movie director, David Storey, is charged with murdering a young actress and trying to make it look like an accident. Harry was the lead detective and made the arrest. Storey boasted to Harry that he was God and couldn't be touched.
While Harry is involved with the latest celebrity trial L. A. County Sheriff detective Jaye Winston visits Terry McCaleb, the former FBI profiler who retired after a heart transplant. Edward Gunn was found dead in his apartment on New Year's Day. A ritualistic murder. The case has hit a dead end but Winston is afraid she may have a serial killer on her hand and Gunn's murder is only the first. McCaleb is now living quietly, running a charter fishing boat with his new wife, adopted son and daughter. Winston had worked with McCaleb previously and she wants his help in putting together a profile of Gunn's killer. Just look at the case documentation and give her a profile. McCaleb may be retired but as he starts working on a profile he becomes hooked and can't let it go.
As McCaleb works on his profile he learns of the connection between Edward Gunn and Harry Bosch. He also discovers that the ritualistic murder scene resembles a painting by Hieronymous Bosch. McCaleb soon realizes that the profile points to Harry Bosch. How far would Harry go to see that Edward Gunn did not get away with murdering the prostitute?
As the story unfolds the reader will find a connection between the murder of Edward Gunn and the David Storey trial. What is the connection? Bosch and McCaleb may be the good guys but they deal with monsters. They are human and they have flaws. How does working with the worst humanity has to offer affect them?
"You don’t go into the darkness without the darkness going into you."
This novel brings together three of Connelly's protagonists. Harry Bosch, Terry McCaleb (Blood Work),and Jack McEvoy (The Poet). McEvoy only has a few brief appearances in the story. The story opens with Bosch visiting a lowlife named Edward Gunn in jail. Bosch has a standing request in with all of the watch commanders ... whenever Gunn is picked up they are to call Bosch. He once arrested Gunn for the murder of a prostitute but Gunn was released on a technicality. Bosch hasn't forgotten it and can't let it go. It is New Year's Eve and Gunn is too drunk to even talk to. This encounter sets the stage for the interaction between Terry McCaleb and Harry Bosch that is the basis for the story to follow.
Harry is assisting the prosecution in a high-profile Hollywood murder trial. A movie director, David Storey, is charged with murdering a young actress and trying to make it look like an accident. Harry was the lead detective and made the arrest. Storey boasted to Harry that he was God and couldn't be touched.
While Harry is involved with the latest celebrity trial L. A. County Sheriff detective Jaye Winston visits Terry McCaleb, the former FBI profiler who retired after a heart transplant. Edward Gunn was found dead in his apartment on New Year's Day. A ritualistic murder. The case has hit a dead end but Winston is afraid she may have a serial killer on her hand and Gunn's murder is only the first. McCaleb is now living quietly, running a charter fishing boat with his new wife, adopted son and daughter. Winston had worked with McCaleb previously and she wants his help in putting together a profile of Gunn's killer. Just look at the case documentation and give her a profile. McCaleb may be retired but as he starts working on a profile he becomes hooked and can't let it go.
As McCaleb works on his profile he learns of the connection between Edward Gunn and Harry Bosch. He also discovers that the ritualistic murder scene resembles a painting by Hieronymous Bosch. McCaleb soon realizes that the profile points to Harry Bosch. How far would Harry go to see that Edward Gunn did not get away with murdering the prostitute?
As the story unfolds the reader will find a connection between the murder of Edward Gunn and the David Storey trial. What is the connection? Bosch and McCaleb may be the good guys but they deal with monsters. They are human and they have flaws. How does working with the worst humanity has to offer affect them?
"You don’t go into the darkness without the darkness going into you."
February 6, 2017
Ehh. This one I did not feel at all. The book went back and forth between Terry McCaleb's POV (way too much of him) and then Harry Bosch. Since the book is set up as Terry trying to tie Bosch into a murder of a man that was Bosch's suspect in a prior case, I just couldn't work up the energy to it. The flow was bad in this one too since it kept jumping back and forth. One of my friend's told me that I should have read "Blood Work" first to get a better sense of Terry, but since I had a ton of books I went through like candy this weekend, I was not going to circle back to figure out a character who I found to be a big pain the butt through almost the entire book.
Terry is called in to investigate a possible connection between Harry Bosch and the murder of Edward Gunn. Terry is called in by an old friend, Jaye Winston. She wants Terry's help in figuring out who could have murdered Gunn in a scene that calls upon a famous painting by an artist many readers will know from reading this series. At this point, I would have said this was some straight up obvious set-up, but we have to muddle through things with Terry as he realizes that maybe Bosch has turned a corner into being a murderer.
Bosch is up as a witness for the prosecution in the trial of David Storey. Storey is charged with murdering his lover and making it look like a suicide. According to Bosch, Storey confesses, but also says Bosch won't be able to prove it. So the book flip flops between Terry's investigation of Bosch, and Bosch's testimony in court.
The book only improves when we have Bosch's POV chapters. Connelly has Bosch locked down. And now we get why most of his chapters it felt like Bosch was holding a little back here and there. We don't get to see until the end what our Bosch has up his sleeves. And when we see how these two men's current cases tie together, I may have said "oh come on" out loud.
I really thought that Terry's supposed insight into Bosch was weak as anything. Also I didn't like the whole thing really being about Bosch going into the judge and jury. The POV of Terry of Bosch had Bosch just being really close to going around the bend. And also these guys (Bosch and McCaleb) has to be freaking clairvoyant to be able to figure out how the criminal trial case was tied up into the murder of Gunn. There was way too many plot holes with the whole book.
Secondary characters don't really get developed in this one. I assume some of these people popped up in "Blood Work." We have Terry's disapproving wife who just, no. I didn't like her or get her at all. She was just kind of there weeping and being negative all of the time since she doesn't want Terry to be involved in profiling anymore.
The dialogue during all of the courtroom scenes was great. I wish more of that was included in the Bosch series. We get to see how Bosch is on a stand and how his notes are crucial to key evidence during a murder trial.
The flow didn't work very well in this one. All in all, this felt like two books smashed together. I wish Connelly had kept McCaleb investigating Bosch with no back and forths between the two men, or just had Bosch being the main POV with no POV of McCaleb.
The setting of the book felt a bit disjointed. We have McCaleb away on an island and coming back and forth to LA to analyze Bosch. Bosch in court. And then McCaleb on his boat. I think those were the major settings besides a bar or two. This really didn't feel much like a Bosch book.
The ending was definitely a what the heck just happened moment. I still don't get everything that went down in this case.
Terry is called in to investigate a possible connection between Harry Bosch and the murder of Edward Gunn. Terry is called in by an old friend, Jaye Winston. She wants Terry's help in figuring out who could have murdered Gunn in a scene that calls upon a famous painting by an artist many readers will know from reading this series. At this point, I would have said this was some straight up obvious set-up, but we have to muddle through things with Terry as he realizes that maybe Bosch has turned a corner into being a murderer.
Bosch is up as a witness for the prosecution in the trial of David Storey. Storey is charged with murdering his lover and making it look like a suicide. According to Bosch, Storey confesses, but also says Bosch won't be able to prove it. So the book flip flops between Terry's investigation of Bosch, and Bosch's testimony in court.
The book only improves when we have Bosch's POV chapters. Connelly has Bosch locked down. And now we get why most of his chapters it felt like Bosch was holding a little back here and there. We don't get to see until the end what our Bosch has up his sleeves. And when we see how these two men's current cases tie together, I may have said "oh come on" out loud.
I really thought that Terry's supposed insight into Bosch was weak as anything. Also I didn't like the whole thing really being about Bosch going into the judge and jury. The POV of Terry of Bosch had Bosch just being really close to going around the bend. And also these guys (Bosch and McCaleb) has to be freaking clairvoyant to be able to figure out how the criminal trial case was tied up into the murder of Gunn. There was way too many plot holes with the whole book.
Secondary characters don't really get developed in this one. I assume some of these people popped up in "Blood Work." We have Terry's disapproving wife who just, no. I didn't like her or get her at all. She was just kind of there weeping and being negative all of the time since she doesn't want Terry to be involved in profiling anymore.
The dialogue during all of the courtroom scenes was great. I wish more of that was included in the Bosch series. We get to see how Bosch is on a stand and how his notes are crucial to key evidence during a murder trial.
The flow didn't work very well in this one. All in all, this felt like two books smashed together. I wish Connelly had kept McCaleb investigating Bosch with no back and forths between the two men, or just had Bosch being the main POV with no POV of McCaleb.
The setting of the book felt a bit disjointed. We have McCaleb away on an island and coming back and forth to LA to analyze Bosch. Bosch in court. And then McCaleb on his boat. I think those were the major settings besides a bar or two. This really didn't feel much like a Bosch book.
The ending was definitely a what the heck just happened moment. I still don't get everything that went down in this case.
July 15, 2025
Amazing as usual. Terry McCaleb was someone new to me.
July 12, 2014
This book was not as much about Harry Bosch as I expected when I bought it, it is also about Terry McCaleb former FBI profiler. And he is also directly responisble for Harry's involvement in the main story which is a unsolved ritualistic murder on a person that had killed someone but was allowed to walk free. After having had heart surgery and having started a new life complete with wife and bay daughter he gets called upon by an old friend from the force with the question if he can look into a case just as a service for old times sake. However Terry becomes involved into the search of a killer. And as his investigation continues to signs start to point to a certain LA detective.
The second storyline is about a courtcase against a bigshot Hollywood producer who had the guts to admit to Bosch he had killed somebody but would get away with it. The courtcase's star-witness is Harry Bosch.
In a sense this book has 2 storylines both are about Harry Bosch, and you get to know more about him, his history as quite a few books together. And Harry remains a fascinating character.
Connelly does write very good and kind of pulls his readers into the tales he weaves. My wife concluded that the book must be a good one as I would grab any break in my responsibilities as a moment to read, even if she does not share my taste in literature.
Once again a well worth visit in the universe of Bosch and friends.
The second storyline is about a courtcase against a bigshot Hollywood producer who had the guts to admit to Bosch he had killed somebody but would get away with it. The courtcase's star-witness is Harry Bosch.
In a sense this book has 2 storylines both are about Harry Bosch, and you get to know more about him, his history as quite a few books together. And Harry remains a fascinating character.
Connelly does write very good and kind of pulls his readers into the tales he weaves. My wife concluded that the book must be a good one as I would grab any break in my responsibilities as a moment to read, even if she does not share my taste in literature.
Once again a well worth visit in the universe of Bosch and friends.
April 19, 2019
I really, really disliked this book. The pacing was bad, the rhythm of the writing did not seem like Connelly at all. The plot was poorly constructed and abusive to the reader's intelligence. In short, a mess.
After reading about 40% of the book, becoming more and more frustrated and irritated - especially the court scenes, and scenes between McCaleb and Winston - I finally decided I had had enough. Ugh.
I skipped to the last three chapters and started from there. The gory details are, of course, recounted even though "you would have read them" in such a way that I did not feel I had really missed much.
And finally, the end scenes between McCaleb and Bosch were crap.
Sorry, but I hated this book.
After reading about 40% of the book, becoming more and more frustrated and irritated - especially the court scenes, and scenes between McCaleb and Winston - I finally decided I had had enough. Ugh.
I skipped to the last three chapters and started from there. The gory details are, of course, recounted even though "you would have read them" in such a way that I did not feel I had really missed much.
And finally, the end scenes between McCaleb and Bosch were crap.
Sorry, but I hated this book.
January 20, 2023
This story revolves around McCaleb doing a profile of who murdered a suspect of a murder in a grisly manner. Harry is in court trying to put away a Hollywood celebrity called David Storey for the murder of a woman.
As always very easy to read and with a few surprises with Rudy Tafero a retired cop Harry worked helping Storey get off the charges. The use of owls as portents of evil in Hieronymus Bosch paintings as clues was entertaining.
SPOILERS AHEAD
The ending with Harry saving McCaleb from Tafero and his brother was timely. McCaleb figuring out that Harry all the time knew he was being set up as a murder suspect was a nice twist. An entertaining read.
As always very easy to read and with a few surprises with Rudy Tafero a retired cop Harry worked helping Storey get off the charges. The use of owls as portents of evil in Hieronymus Bosch paintings as clues was entertaining.
SPOILERS AHEAD
The ending with Harry saving McCaleb from Tafero and his brother was timely. McCaleb figuring out that Harry all the time knew he was being set up as a murder suspect was a nice twist. An entertaining read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 6, 2011
3 ½ stars. I had a few complaints, but the series is so good that I’m glad I read it, and I’m on to the next.
STORY BRIEF:
Two stories are being told interspersed. Gunn was found murdered in his home in an elaborate method patterned after a scene from a painting. Detective Jaye Winston is in charge of the investigation which has stalled. She asks retired FBI profiler McCaleb to help her.
The second story is a murder trial. A wealthy movie director Storey is charged with murdering an actress and making it appear as a suicide. Bosch is the arresting officer and star witness in the trial. Storey bragged to Bosch that he killed her and that he would get away with it. The confession was not on tape so it’s Storey’s word against Bosch’s.
REVIEWER’S OPINION:
As I’ve said before, I’m enjoying this series. This is book 7 in the Harry Bosch series. As I finish one, I go right on to the next one. I’m doing them all as audiobooks, which might mean something. This one is not typical Bosch because the main detective work is being done by McCaleb, not Bosch. We are in McCaleb’s mind through most of the story. It was good, but I prefer Bosch as the main investigator, not McCaleb. This book is also listed as book 2 in the Terry McCaleb series. This could be read as a stand-alone, but I recommend reading it after McCaleb’s first book “Blood Work.”
Things I did not like:
The murder trial story was mostly being done through trial testimony. This resulted in a “telling” feel rather than “showing.” So it wasn’t the best way to hear a story, but it was ok. I viewed this as a supporting story to the McCabe investigation.
I wish the author had spelled out things more clearly at the end. McCaleb accuses Bosch of knowing something and doing things without telling McCaleb. Bosch subtly acknowledged this, but as the reader I wanted more specifics. I wanted to know exactly what Bosch knew, how he knew it, and what he did. The overall story and resolution were good, but I didn’t like having to make assumptions.
To avoid a spoiler I’m going to be vague here. I didn’t see the logic of why McCaleb thought Gunn’s murderer was X. The murder scene was made to look like a painting that many people owned copies of or had seen. So why did he suspect one of these people as a murderer? My immediate reaction was this could be a set up or a frame, but McCaleb didn’t consider that. The reason I like this series is because McCaleb and Bosch are smarter than I am, but that wasn’t happening here. McCaleb’s conclusion as to X being a suspect should have been better justified.
NARRATORS:
I did not like the narrator Richard M. Davidson. His interpretation of some characters came out too arrogant and negative somehow. McCaleb and Bosch weren’t as enjoyable because of this interpretation. It made me realize how wonderful Dick Hill was who did the first six books. My biggest problem with Dick Hill was his effeminate gay guy voice for some of the female characters. He did that in the early books, but not in the later books. So he improved. In this book, Richard Davidson used a deep super-gravely bass voice for Bosch which didn’t feel right to me. In another scene Buddy was saying something in a “pleading whining voice” (author’s words), but the narrator used an almost arrogant tone for that phrase.
DATA:
Unabridged audiobook length: 12 hrs and 33 mins. Narrator: Richard M. Davidson. Swearing language: strong but not frequently used. Sexual content: none. Setting: 2000 mostly Los Angeles, California, plus nearby Catalina Island. Book Copyright: 2001. Genre: crime mystery. Ending: The bad guys lose.
STORY BRIEF:
Two stories are being told interspersed. Gunn was found murdered in his home in an elaborate method patterned after a scene from a painting. Detective Jaye Winston is in charge of the investigation which has stalled. She asks retired FBI profiler McCaleb to help her.
The second story is a murder trial. A wealthy movie director Storey is charged with murdering an actress and making it appear as a suicide. Bosch is the arresting officer and star witness in the trial. Storey bragged to Bosch that he killed her and that he would get away with it. The confession was not on tape so it’s Storey’s word against Bosch’s.
REVIEWER’S OPINION:
As I’ve said before, I’m enjoying this series. This is book 7 in the Harry Bosch series. As I finish one, I go right on to the next one. I’m doing them all as audiobooks, which might mean something. This one is not typical Bosch because the main detective work is being done by McCaleb, not Bosch. We are in McCaleb’s mind through most of the story. It was good, but I prefer Bosch as the main investigator, not McCaleb. This book is also listed as book 2 in the Terry McCaleb series. This could be read as a stand-alone, but I recommend reading it after McCaleb’s first book “Blood Work.”
Things I did not like:
The murder trial story was mostly being done through trial testimony. This resulted in a “telling” feel rather than “showing.” So it wasn’t the best way to hear a story, but it was ok. I viewed this as a supporting story to the McCabe investigation.
I wish the author had spelled out things more clearly at the end. McCaleb accuses Bosch of knowing something and doing things without telling McCaleb. Bosch subtly acknowledged this, but as the reader I wanted more specifics. I wanted to know exactly what Bosch knew, how he knew it, and what he did. The overall story and resolution were good, but I didn’t like having to make assumptions.
To avoid a spoiler I’m going to be vague here. I didn’t see the logic of why McCaleb thought Gunn’s murderer was X. The murder scene was made to look like a painting that many people owned copies of or had seen. So why did he suspect one of these people as a murderer? My immediate reaction was this could be a set up or a frame, but McCaleb didn’t consider that. The reason I like this series is because McCaleb and Bosch are smarter than I am, but that wasn’t happening here. McCaleb’s conclusion as to X being a suspect should have been better justified.
NARRATORS:
I did not like the narrator Richard M. Davidson. His interpretation of some characters came out too arrogant and negative somehow. McCaleb and Bosch weren’t as enjoyable because of this interpretation. It made me realize how wonderful Dick Hill was who did the first six books. My biggest problem with Dick Hill was his effeminate gay guy voice for some of the female characters. He did that in the early books, but not in the later books. So he improved. In this book, Richard Davidson used a deep super-gravely bass voice for Bosch which didn’t feel right to me. In another scene Buddy was saying something in a “pleading whining voice” (author’s words), but the narrator used an almost arrogant tone for that phrase.
DATA:
Unabridged audiobook length: 12 hrs and 33 mins. Narrator: Richard M. Davidson. Swearing language: strong but not frequently used. Sexual content: none. Setting: 2000 mostly Los Angeles, California, plus nearby Catalina Island. Book Copyright: 2001. Genre: crime mystery. Ending: The bad guys lose.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 2,719 reviews