More like 3.5
The Lake Villa was an enjoyable read overall, offering a compelling story that, while slow to start, picked up momentum as it progressed. The plot eventually became more engaging, and I found myself invested in the characters and their journeys. However, as a Cambodian and someone highly familiar with Cambodian history, I couldn’t help but feel somewhat distracted by a few factual inaccuracies and misspellings of key Cambodian figures. These errors, unfortunately, affected my enjoyment of the book.
One of the most glaring issues for me was the misspelling of King Norodom Sihanouk’s name as “Siaohouk.” The incorrect spelling stood out every time his name was mentioned, which was a bit jarring.
Another factual error that bothered me was the description of the main character, Collette, arriving in Cambodia via the Port of Kampong Som in 1934. This was problematic because the Port of Kampong Som (also known as Sihanoukville) wasn’t actually opened until 1955. In the 1930s, if Collette had been traveling to Cambodia by ship, she would have had to pass through the Port of Saigon (now Ho Chi Minh City) and then continue by a smaller boat to Phnom Penh. This discrepancy felt like a missed opportunity for the author to better research the historical context and make the setting feel more authentic.
Additionally, the author’s portrayal of Phnom Penh in 1995 didn’t quite capture the atmosphere of that time. The way she described the city felt more like Phnom Penh in the past decade. This mismatch between the historical context and the setting made it harder for me to fully immerse myself in the world the author was trying to create.
Despite these issues, The Lake Villa was still an enjoyable and worthwhile read. The characters were well-developed, and the emotional depth of the story shone through as it progressed. Although the historical inaccuracies and the portrayal of Cambodia didn’t always align with my expectations, the book still managed to captivate me with its charm and heartfelt narrative. For those not as familiar with the history of Cambodia, these issues may not be as noticeable, and they may still find the story to be quite compelling. While it wasn’t a perfect experience for me, The Lake Villa still offers a pleasant and engaging read that’s worth exploring.