Few Unitarian Universalists (UUs), lay or ordained, know much about Universalist theology. A related problem is that few UUs know much about Universalist history or culture, which is relevant because Universalist theology was shaped by Universalist experience. With the loss of Universalist perspective, our combined Unitarian Universalist religious movement is being impoverished. Universalism was different from Unitarianism. It originated among laypeople, not clergy. It drew on the experience of a less privileged social class. Its message was more radical, its scope was larger, and its taproot went deeper into the heart. This book presents all of Universalism’s distinctive ideas and make clear their relationships to each other. It uses a variety of approaches—essays, details from the author’s biography, anecdotes, laments, meditations, excerpts from other writers, even jokes.
A HISTORICAL AND DOCTRINAL GUIDE TO THE ‘UNIVERSALIST’ SIDE OF UNITARIAN UNIVERSALISTS
Richard Trudeau is minister emeritus of the Unitarian Universalist Church of Weymoutn, Massachusetts; he is also a professor emeritus of Stonehill College.
He wrote in the ‘Letter to the Reader’ of this 2009 book, “Few Unitarian Universalists (UUs), lay or ordained, know much about Universalist theology… ‘Universalism’ is often reduced to the idea that God is love, or that one should be open to insights from world religions, or that one should pay attention to the heart as well as the head. All such reductions are misleading… A related problem is that few UUs know much about Universalist history or culture. This is relevant because Universalist theology was shaped by Universalist experience.
“With the loss of Universalist perspective, our combined Unitarian Universalist religious movement is being impoverished. Universalism was different from Unitarianism. It originated among laypeople, not clergy. It drew on the experience of a less privileged social class. Its message was more radical, its scope was larger, and its taproot went deeper into the heart. I have tried to present all of Universalism’s distinctive ideas and make clear their relationships to each other…” (Pg. v-vi)
He adds in the Supplement, “In 1960-1961, when the Unitarian and Universalist denominations combined, the Universalists---less prosperous, less educated, less confident, and outnumbered five to one---were afraid of being swallowed up. For a while it looked as if their fears were justified. Both Universalist seminaries were closed. The Universalist Service Committee was dissolved (and ‘Universalist’ spliced into the name of the Unitarian Service Committee). And in town after town, once the Universalist church had gamely changed its name to ‘Unitarian Universalist’ church, people started calling it ‘the Unitarian Church.’ ‘There are no more Universalists,’ one man said. ‘We’re all Unitarians now.’” (Pg. vii)
“Unitarianism was about freedom, reason, and tolerance. Universalism held those values too, but emphasized what it called ‘the supreme worth of every human personality.’ God loves everybody, Universalists said. God’s love is universal. This central Universalist sentiment has become the defining characteristic of our combined movement. Some of us may say we’re ‘Unitarians,’ but we’re ‘Unitarian UNIVERSALISTS.’” (Pg. vii-viii)
He observes, “The UU movement needs renewal? I think it does, and I’d like to offer three reasons why. First, in 1961, when the denominations joined forces, there were a total of 151,557 adult UUs. Forty years later, there [was only] … a net gain of less than 4%. Meanwhile the population of North America went up something like 50%, so as a percentage of the population, we actually declined considerably in forty years. To me, that’s a symptom of a need for renewal. Second, there’s a lot of talk about ‘spirituality’ in UU churches… I interpret [this] … as a sign of a deep-seated hunger on the part of members of our congregations, and therefore as another symptom of a need for renewal. Third, a great many members of UU congregations are intolerant of Christianity. Some of these people are Jews, but most are traumatized former Christians… they are angry with Christianity because they have been hurt by it… Intolerance of Christianity is a wound at the heart of our movement, and to me, it is a third symptom of a need for renewal.” (Pg. 20-21)
He notes, “Some say that Unitarian Universalism is the gateway from Methodism to golf. I think there's a lot of truth to that. Regularly people come to our churches, are encouraged to turn their backs on their former religions and then, not finding much to stay for, leave---sometimes for another church but often, for the Sunday paper or Sunday golf. We don’t encourage people to confront their religious pasts, we enable people to deny their pasts… As a consequence, we fail to help them reappropriate spiritual resources that, in combination with the UU perspective, would be of great value to them.” (Pg. 27)
He suggests, “A majority of Unitarian Universalists---including a majority of our ministers---have unresolved conflicts with Christianity. There is a need, therefore, to talk about Christianity. We need to take it apart, distinguish its varieties, jettison what is not useful, and keep what is. We need to do this, but mostly we do not.” (Pg. 33)
He reports that “Tolstoy was inspired by the writings of Universalist minister Adin Ballou, with whom Tolstoy corresponded, at the end of Ballou’s life. Adin Ballou, a distant cousin of Universalist leader Hosea Ballou, was born in 1803… He was a pacifist, socialist, abolitionist, and founder of the utopian community of Hopedale, Massachusetts.” (Pg. 47)
He includes a quotation from ‘The Battle for Christmas,’ by Stephen Ninssenbaum: “With the turn of the 19th century, the re-appropriation of Christmas [by Protestants in New England] took on a concerted form---a move to hold church services on December 25. This move was led by both evangelicals and liberals. In the forefront of the evangelicals were the Universalists. Largely a rural sect, Universalists openly celebrated Christmas from the earliest stages of their existence in New England… In the early 19th century it was this denomination that proselytized for Christmas more actively than any other. The Unitarians were close behind. Compared with Universalists, Unitarians were genteel, and (for all their theological liberalism) more socially conservative. Unitarians were calling for the public observance of Christmas by about [1810]… in the hope that their own observance might help to purge the holiday of its associations with seasonal excess and disorder.” (Pg. 51-52)
Under the heading, 'Universalists Leading the Way: Women’s Ordination,’ he reports, “a historical marker … explains ‘Universalist Olympia Brown, second woman to achieve full ministerial standing in any denomination in the United States, served here 1864-69.’ (The first such woman, Lydia Ann Jenkins, was Universalist, too.)” (Pg. 53)
He recounts, “In 1861, Universalists were one of America’s largest denominations, many times larger than the Unitarian denomination. But by 1961, Universalists had shrunk to a tiny denomination, outnumbered by the always-small Unitarian denomination five to one. One reason for Universalism’s decline was that its distinctiveness was blurred when other denominations began to downplay hellfire and emphasize God’s love. Churchgoers made a calculation: ‘Why should I go to the Universalist church when I can go to another, more socially prominent church, where the theological message is practically the same?’” (Pg. 54-55)
He reports, “In speaking of early Universalism in America, I will focus on the year 1780. As with Unitarians in 1815, Universalists hadn’t yet organized as a denomination and were just beginning to accept the Universalist name (also bestowed by opponents). But they knew who they were and what the issues were. In 1780, the Revolutionary War was still unresolved. There was no United States. There was no President. The Universalists accepted the Calvinist idea of God as an absolute monarch who is experienced mostly through nature, and on whom we are totally dependent, every moment of our lives.” (Pg. 77-78)
He concludes, “UU spirituality is, at bottom, Universalist spirituality, though this is muddied by lingering messages from Unitarianism. Is the reason for doing good is to be happy, as in Universalism, or to develop yourself into an okay person, as in Unitarianism? Is humanity a community of moral equals, as in Universalism, or morally stratified, as in Unitarianism?” (Pg. 83)
This book will be of great interest to anyone studying the origins, history, and doctrines of Universalism.
1) Universalist history is ignored or downplayed as we talk about UU history and theology 2) We should lean into the Universalist focus on Christianity as a source of language, practice, and theology in UU spaces 3) The best UU theology is drawn from the Universalist tradition, rather than the elitist, humanist, detranscendent Unitarian tradition
If you are interested in learning about Universalist or Unitarian basic Theology, this is a good place to start. Easy to read and does not try to shove one way of thinking and doing down your throat.
Really helped clarify the differences between Unitarianism and Universalism. Easy to understand without being childish or condescending. Glad to know more about the denomination, and how accepting it is.
This was a really interesting book for those interested in getting some backstory about the Universalist heritage of Unitarian Universalism. It was very accessible and easy to read!
Thought provoking and informative. These ideas apply to the larger question of religion’s place in a liberal society. A lot of folks think they can just walk away from their past experience, and just take up golf. It’s not so easy. This book takes an honest look at the larger questions behind moral development I. Society and how to tackle the process more honestly. And more joyously.
I really enjoyed his take on early universalism as, I found the idea class differences fascinating. At times though I feels he detracts from our Unitarian brothers and sisters. I do agree that we as UU people can learn from our Universalist forebears and do a better job of outreaching to people and communities with different SES and who may take a more traditional approach to Jesus in a liberal religious framework.
I read this to help me understand my significant other's church, Unitarian Universalism. This book explains the differences between Unitarianism and Universalism, which used to be two different and separated entities, and eventually merged. It is an excellent book, and well written. His understanding of the Bible is my own.
Having been a UU for over 10 years, this book explained quite a bit of the confusion about Unitarian and Universalism.
Excellent explanation on Universalism. The kindle version,however, is full of grammatical errors. I'd love to take the time to edit them. Now when member tell me what our congregation needs is more universalism, I understand.